M/S New Shakti Rice Mill. v. Food Corporation Of India And Others
!"# !$%&%"'( )) *&!+,- . %%$!%// )))))! % %"'!0 1!0&2& ""3"04"0 %"'"#'3% '3" -!0& )))))!&4"'3!' & ( 5 6), , , 777
!
"# $"
%& ''''
, ,8)
( %) )* !)!) +, -!. " "# / ( 0 12
&
# + .!)!)-!
0" - " $"# *3) # % &
!)# " ###
" # # " /
#
$"1 /(
(
$"( # !)!)-! !4 )5 !)!) +, - 6 " #.
0 " "
" " # # " 2"!)!)
7
-
# 8
& 9 " 0
%) )* !)!) +, -!.
/( 0+/(0. #" - #
" :
- # -
(;0
7" /(0 $"
"# - "
)% ) !)!) " (;0
"#/(0" 6&
)% ) !)!) , -< /(0 # # - " # "
#" - ###
" -7
" 6 1 /(0
)& ) !)!)+, -&. +:./(0:
$"(
(;0 - # " /0:""#(;0
- # #" -
!)!)-!
" 7 -
(
= "
# "
-
(;0 0 /0:
"#(;0 >
# "
"#(;0 #(;0 #"
%) )* !)!)+, -!., /
"# "# ## #" / ""#/(0
%) )* !)!) +, -!. -
9
#
" $ ? "
"# 7 # 2"!)!) # " 4-5 7 9 #
" # (
" #
#"
@ " $ #"
!+/(0." 7(;0 /0:!3 )* !) 3
(;0 !< )* !) *" # +." /(0 $"
/1 +/1.
+
."
" - "7 A -!+"2/3'" /%.! "- 9!
':;2&%'!&&3! /%'<+% - -!4! % %"'!02'/!&&% &%'9"/9!=!' %' -! & %3= !0"#=%& 440"40% %"'"#& "$."# -!%&$/! 0!3)5
" ( 4 ) !)!) " - B
!
" # $ % & '
! ( )
> &
(* *
"*"* +, - ."/0' 1 0 0,& 0 ! ) ' 23#"*"* "
0 4
&
& &
0
4
5 #
4 "6 *
"*
+, - 7 / "8
"
"*
&
4 # 9( .
'
# :& 5 # &
9+/ .
% &3 . 2 "*"*"*"
0' &
; ; &
&<<&
# . & , & ;10 4&& 5 !
"'
# $ % & 4 && '
5 # &$ &
0 !
" *(
* "*"* +, - .(/ & & = & $ ' && ! )0' &
&&
% & #0 &&
?
' & 0 !
"' ! )
' ' & & 0'
# '' &
,% "9
* "*"* > /(0 !% ) !)!) :
7 # "#/(0
= "# - # !5 ) !)!) "#1( /(
(
" # !)!)-! " %) )* !)!)+, -!.
C "
%&# 7
!* ) !)!)
( #
!)!)-! # 7"# - ", # ( # " "-
B
. &?.
% & 3 . 2"*"*"
>
- ' # .
%
& ' &&
23#"*"*"
' +
.
03 0.
0.# @.,1 1/ 73 ;0 & ;&
3 # && & A &
---------------------------------- ---------------------------------- B C &
% - 0 &
- B --------------- --------------- --------------- --------------- --------------- --------------- --------------- --------------- B >& &'
& & & &
; & && + A & .
%/
;'
@ ' & ;
+/ ; 0
% B >& 010#
&,0.
%
B , & &&
> &
5 &&
& 0 & & . & , && &
------------------------ ------------------------
B ,& 0
' , &- & &
& $
& B &' 0
& && 2"*"*"
"
& & **D & & 2 0 1 & +- A & 23#/ & ;
+/ & ; & $
3 D & $ 23#0& 3 D @ & ;
0 A & 0
30''
&& 2"*
"*0 &3 . ;7 0 (
*9 "*"* @ $ -
! 7.
+6E;"**9/"*
;
*E( *E6 *( *8 "*"* ' F "D0
& 0 & !& 3 & 2"*"*"
: 7 3;C 7 3 & & & '
& '
' & &
. '&& & & & + && /0 & '
. '&
' & & - ' & 0 &3 & &
&
' % 0
.
%.
4+ &
..4/ .
%3 4+
&.
%3 4/ ='0
&
& 10
+/
. 0 & &
+/0 A & ; +/0
& & % !& & +/
& ' ' ;. ; ;3&; 0
& 453#& 3 & :
+3#3:/7 +37/8 '
458** &G &G 45 #;453#3:7 '
&
' ' 4 & & ' 4
& 45#0 30' ' 4 0& & % & ?
;!> & ; & & 4 ' '
; ' & # ,
&0 0'
& & & &
'
0 ' & & &
3 ; ; &
(0)08 9 $ & && ' 1 $ & &
&0 ' & 3 & & 3 ' $ $ & ' . 730 73 &&
"*D
;& & - & 3 ; 3 & 51 7 30 ' & &
B;; % &
' & & ' #., '
B;; % &
& 3 ' &
'
,
& ; @ 3 $ .
% A & & 1#
@ &, +74 / ;
& &
& & & &
7 & & ;
& 9(6 "
*E *(0 ! "89E"89
"
*E *90! "E"("E"6 * *
*90! "E9 "E9" *
"**90 ! "E6( "* *E "* *0! "99*9 *
*E "* (0! "
* "
* ( *E
( ! ("8" (* *E
(
73' & ; ;4;7 ,
.
%# '& ' &0
'
#.,'&
'
& , & ; $ & ; &
& , %2. & +
B;; % ;/ ' 1#;,;3 ; &
B & , & &&
B , & 3 # . , 1 3 +3/ .
%3 4 0 &
1
"
# , B , ' &
& 0
, B $ %9% :
!;:+-%$- ";!$"=4/! !3 : 3 "!)!) " ! "!)!) # +.
!% "!)!) 0
!< "!)!) !3 "!)!) #+. # . 1# ' -
------------------------------------
!&;& ; ; 0 ; ; ; & ' B ,
( 8H "
& $ &
; **D 0 +/ ; $ ; ' 0 &;& 7 23#"* " ( "* ( 60 &' & & 1
1
' ;
&0 & ' % = I.
% = = ; '
& 0 ' ;3& ' ;
;&&;; 3
&' 0 & ; & ;&0
;&
' &' 0
! & &
& && +/ ' ;
+/;
+/;&&+/ & ; +/0 & &
. & && %
$ '
& 0 && & && 0 1#+' /0 ' & && +/ ' ;
+/;
+/;&&+/ & $ ' &
&
> ; ; &
&<<& ;
;
# . & , ; & ;1 ' 4&& ='0 & ' +/0 A & & & & ' &0 & & '
%
& & ;17; ;, & . &' ! & . , 10 &
1
&' & ; &
,3+/' +/ & ' $ ' '&
&<<& && &
+/
; ='0&0 '&
&<<& &&
&
0 &
' **D && # '
%
&
3 '& '
?
&
' &0 0
' &
'
& & 4 ;&
' 0 ' 4 ;&
0 #,71,:# ,
'
0
& &
&; ;& '
' & +7B .! "*)() "* 93;7% # .
% / 0 1#
! B +/ 3 '
&+/
& +/
;
$ & ' 1
? % & J+475/ ; .1, ;&- +/
&
&
+/ &
& ' ;
& &@ & 0 &
& &0 ' &
&
& ; &&
' & & & &'
& & & &%
- 2
0 &
0 & & &';
/ A B +/ , & ,
,0& &
&
+. +., & %
' &
& 0 0 0 ' & & & & &
+. &0
23# "*
"* *D &
--------------------- ---------------------
@
, . 3 '
&
A & 0 "
3 &-& & % &
"
, &
73 ' ' & && & & ;
& 0 &
& &
,
& ,
' 1#
&' .#1# .#1#
------------------ -------------------> @ # 7 !)!)-!
# 2"!)!) 6
# # " +&.
( +<.#"#
# ( +3. # D "
# # " "#1 (
( +!<. #
A
# #" # #
"# 1 (
/(07$ #
%) )* !)!) +, -!. 1 / E (
+1/(.1 D66 # !)!)-! "#
(;0 !< )* !) * #
# $"/1
" - 8 "7 D!4 !
!) *+, -3. - # " 6 3+ . # # D D" "FF D -#
"
/(0 - " /(0
"
- C
"
%) )* !)!)+, -!. 6 -
# !)!)-! #7
" # 0
- #9 #" "7 " #"
"#/(0 #
7
67"# $"1 /(
(
" @ # 1 (
# ( # 6
1 (
" & 1 (
1 /(0 1 2
+1 2. $" ;
11/ +1
#1 /.
( ) #
# 1 (
2 9 #"
"7 "#1 (
# -
6 #" D "
%) )* !)!)+, -!.
0 ( "$ 7 "#
#
1( - "
"#1( # -
!)!)-! - "
# 1
: ( !< # 6( - # !)!)-! # -
#
# $ "# < ( 0
/"%) )* !)!) +, -!. "# /(0 "9 !% ) !)!) "#/(0!5 ) !)!) "#1 (/(
(
# "" @
( "71 (
7 # 6
@# 7
# 2"!)!) 7#"# - # 9 # # 3 # " !5 ) !)!) "# 1 (/(
(
#
0 "
%) )* !)!) +, -!. "9
!% ) !)!) "# +:. /(0 : 2
$"!5 ) !)!) "#1(/ (
(
# # - # # !)!)-! D
" "
, , )) &2'% G 7D ?D G: " ?D