← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/342/2009allowed

Jyoti v. Mohit

2015-05-12Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Bench- 49 pages

  

      

     





   

                   !" !#" !$%&'!(!)"* +%,&-!#!.+#"!&/)" !&/'!*"0 !*    

  1









 1 



  

     

''#/!2!&-3" !&/*(/**4,+5" !.!"/"/+)%)&!#!6"/+)7+5 " !/)&%4##/4'!6"8.#43/)'5+#&/2+#6!+)" !'#+%)&+56#%!,"3 4)&&!*!#"/+)" !4..!,,4)"9/5!3+"/ 4*.#!5!##!&" !.#!*!)"4..!4, 4'4/)*" !# %*-4)&



))%"* !,," !42!#(!)"/)" !.!"/"/+)5/,!&-34..!,,4)"3+"/ /*" 4"" !4..!,,4)"4)&" !#!*.+)&!)"9!#!)+"-,!**!&9/" 4)36 /,&+%" +5" !/#(4##/4'!" 4""++:.,46!+) ;

<  !#!*.+)&!)" /*%)6,!

4)&4%)"%*!&"+&!(4)&&+9#35#+(" !4..!,,4)"4)& !#.4#!)"*4*" !3 9!#!)+"*4"/*5/!&9/" " !&+9#3'/2!)4"" !"/(!+5(4##/4'!  !3 (4,"#!4"!&" !4..!,,4)"5+#)+"'/2/)''+,&6 4/)"+" !(+" !#4)&4%)"+5 " !#!*.+)&!)"'+,&#/)'"+" !%)6,!+5" !#!*.+)&!)"4)&'+,&!4##/)'*"+ " !*/*"!#*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"

 ,,+5" !("+#"%#!&" !4..!,,4)"5+#)+" -#/)'/)'  ,%=%#3  64#  4)&  64*  4(+%)"  "+  " !  "%)!  +5   ,46*    !

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

%!"+. 3*/64,4)&(!)"4,"+#"%#!'/2!)-3" ! #!*.+)&!)"4)& /*54(/,3(!(-!#*" !4..!,,4)"5!,,/,,/)" !(+)" +5 %)!A4)&94*4&(/""!&"+4=+*./"4, %#'4+)+)7  A

%#/)'" 4".!#/+&" !#!*.+)&!)")!2!#64#!&5+# !#  !#!*.+)&!)"4,*+ %*!&"+" #!4"!)"+:/,, !#-#+" !#- /)42   )7 ;

A9 !)" !

4..!,,4)"#!5%*!&"+466!&!"+" !&!(4)&+5,46*5#+( !#54" !#" ! #!*.+)&!)"6#!4"!&4*6!)!4)&*"4#"!&-!4"/)' !#  !)* !* +%"!&5+# !,.)!/' -+%#*64(!4)&#!*6%!& !#5+#(" !6,%"6 !*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"

 !  #!*.+)&!)"  4,*+  &!*!#"!&  " !  4..!,,4)"  +)  7 ;

A  9/" +%"  4)3 #!4*+)4-,!!=6%*!

6#/(/)4,64*!%)&!#!6"/+)B8AB;774)&;  94*4,*+5/,!&-3" !4..!,,4)"4'4/)*"" !#!*.+)&!)"  42/)'" %* 4,,!'!&" !4..!,,4)"*+%' "5+#&/2+#6!+)" !'#+%)&+56#%!,"34)& &!*!#"/+)

 !#!*.+)&!)" 42/)'6+)"#+2!#"!&" !4,,!'4"/+)*,!2!,,!& 4'4/)*" /(-3" !4..!,,4)"6+)"!)&!&/) /*9#/""!)*"4"!(!)"" 4")+ &+9#394*&!(4)&!&)+#94*/"'/2!)"+ /(/)(4##/4'! !&!)/!&"+

7 42!#!-%:!&" !4..!,,4)"+# !#54(/,3(!(-!#*5+#)+"-#/)'/)',%=%#3 64#4)&64* "+" !"%)!+5,46*  )7 ;

A" !4..!,,4)"4)& !# -#+" !#"%#)!& /(+%"5#+( /*(4"#/(+)/4, +(! +%#54(/,3(!(-!#*+5 " !#!*.+)&!)"9!#!5+%)&/))+6!)"-3" !.+,/6!4)&4*4#!*%,"+59 /6  )+6 4,,4)94*,4/&4*4'4/)*"" +*!(!(-!#*/)" ! #!'/*"!#!&4"" !

/)*"4)6!+5" !54" !#+5" !4..!,,4)"

 !#!*.+)&!)"&!)/!&" !4,,!'4"/+) " 4" !.#!**%#/>!&" !4..!,,4)""+-#/)'4*%(+5,46*5+#/)2!*"(!)"/) 6+(.4)3 "/**%-(/""!&-3" !#!*.+)&!)"" 4"" !4..!,,4)" 4* )+"(4&!+%"464*!5+#&/2+#6!



 !"#/4, +%#"  42/)'5#4(!&" !/**%!4*"+ 9 !" !#" ! 4..!,,4)"94*!)"/",!&"+4&!6#!!+5&/2+#6!+)" !'#+%)&*4*(!)"/+)!&/) " !.!"/"/+)!=4(/)!&" !4..!,,4)"4*4)& !#54" !#4,&!2/)' 4* +)" !*/&!+5" !4..!,,4)"4)&" !#!*.+)&!)"4* #!"%#)!&4 5/)&/)'" 4"" !4..!,,4)"54/,!&"+!*"4-,/* " !4,,!'!&6#%!,"36+((/""!& -3" !#!*.+)&!)"



 !546"#!(4/)*" 4"" !(4##/4'!-!"9!!)" !4..!,,4)"4)& " !#!*.+)&!)"94**+,!()/>!&+) ;

<  "/*" !4&(/""!&64*!+5 -+"  " !  .4#"/!*  " 4"  " !  4..!,,4)"  4)&  " !  #!*.+)&!)"  *"4#"!&  ,/2/)' *!.4#4"!,3  5#+(  7 ;

A  +)94#&*  "  /*  "+  -!  )+"!&  " 4"  )+  *!#/+%* 4,,!'4"/+)+5&!*!#"/+)94*(4&!/)" !.!"/"/+)-3" !4..!,,4)" )546")+ 4#'%(!)"94*4&24)6!&-3" !6+%)*!,5+#" !4..!,,4)"4*#!'4#&*" !.,!4 +5&!*!#"/+)(4&!-3" !#!*.+)&!)"

!4,*+9!)"" #+%' " !!)"/#!

!2/&!)6!+5" !4..!,,4)"4*9!,,4*" !!2/&!)6!+54)& )+%# 6+)*/&!#!&2/!9" !#!/*)+*!#/+%*6 4#'!4*4'4/)*"" !#!*.+)&!)"" 4" !

B &!*!#"!&  " !  4..!,,4)"9/5!  9/"  4)  /)"!)"/+)  "+  .%"  4)  !)&  "+  " ! (4"#/(+)/4,#!,4"/+)* /.

 !#!5+#!9! 42!)+ !*/"4"/+)"+6+)6,%&!" 4" " !4..!,,4)"54/,!&"+.#+2!" !.,!4+5&!*!#"/+)4*+)!+5" !'#+%)&*5+# &/2+#6!  -3  .%""/)'  5+#"  )!6!**4#3  .,!4&/)'*  4)&  4,*+  -3  4&&%6/)' *4"/*546"+#3!2/&!)6!

;

 !.+"!)"/4,.,!4*!"%.-3" !4..!,,4)"/*" 4"" !#!*.+)&!)" *%-$!6"!&" !4..!,,4)""+6#%!,"3)+"+),3-3&!(4)&/)'&+9#3-%"4,*+-3 .#!**%#/)' !#"+-#/)'(+)!3 " 4*4,*+-!!)4,,!'!&" 4"* !94*-!4"!) *!2!#!,3-3" !#!*.+)&!)"

<

)" +#+%' *64))/)'+5" !!2/&!)6!+54)&9! 5/)&" 4"-+" +5" !( 42!*.+:!)/)+)!2+/6!" 4"" !#!*.+)&!)"" +%' )+"&!(4)&!&4)3&+9#34"" !"/(!+5(4##/4'!(4&!4&!(4)&+5,%=%#3 64#4)&64* 4(+%)"+5,46*  4*64"!'+#/64,,3&!.+*!&" 4"* !

#!6!/2!&*!2!#!-!4"/)'*4"" ! 4)&*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"5+#* ! 4&)+" -#+%' "64* 4*&!(4)&!&-3" !#!*.+)&!)"

 !64(!+%"9/" 4*.!6/5/6 /)6/&!)"" 4""++:.,46!+)7 ;

A9 !)* !94*-!4"!)%.-36#!4"/)'4 *6!)!-3" !#!*.+)&!)"4** !#!5%*!&"+6+(.,39/" " !&!(4)&+5 ,46*5#+( !#54" !#

#%!/"/*" 4"/*)+)!+" !#" 4)" !54" !#+5  !

/)6/&!)"  +5  6#%!,"3  *.+:!)  "+  -3    4&  "4:!)  .,46!  +),3  4"  !# (4"#/(+)/4, +(!

 !4..!,,4)" 4*6+(!+%"9/" (4,"#!4"(!)"(!"!& +%""+ !#-3" !#!*.+)&!)"4)& /*54(/,3(!(-!#* "/*+),3" !54(/,3 (!(-!#*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"9 +9+%,& 42!-!!).#!*!)"/)" !(4"#/(+)/4, +(!

9 +94*/)5+#(!&+5" !*!/)6/&!)"*-3 !#&4%' "!#45"!#* !

 ,!5"" !(4"#/(+)/4, +(! 4&*.+:!)4-+%"4,," +*!/)6/&!)"*4*&!"4/,!& -3 !#&4%' "!# /*!2/&!)6!$%*"6+##+-+#4"!*" !!2/&!)6!+5

!4#)!&6+%)*!,4..!4#/)'5+#" !4..!,,4)"9+%,&*%-(/"" 4" /)*./"!+5" !546"" 4")+)!/' -+%#94*!=4(/)!&" !!2/&!)6!+5 4)&.#+2!*" !.,!4+5" !4..!,,4)"" 4"* !94**%-$!6"!&"+6#%!,"3



 ,!4#)!&6+%)*!,5+#" !#!*.+)&!)"6+)"!)&!&" 4" )+)!=4(/)4"/+)+5+)!+5" !)!/' -+%#*9 +4,,!'!&,3*!.4#4"!&" ! 4..!,,4)"5#+(" !6,%"6 !*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"9 !)" !,4""!#6#!4"!&4*6!)! +%"*/&!" ! +%*!" #+9*&+%-"+)" !/)"!#!*"!&2!#*/+)+54)&



"/*4)+#(4,.#46"/6!" 4"" !)!/' -+%#*+5" ! %*-4)& 42!4 )4"%#4,6+((+).#+.!)*/"3"+*%..+#"" !2!#*/+)+5" ! %*-4)& 5"!#4,, " !9/5! 4*6+(!4,," !9435#+( !#.4#!)"4, +%*!"+*!"",!/)" ! (4"#/(+)/4, +%*!

 56+%#*!" !4..!,,4)"* +%,& 42!!=4(/)!&+)!+5 " !)!/' -+%#*9 +*!.4#4"!&" !#!*.+)&!)"5#+(" !6,%"6 !*+54..!,,4)"

%"/)+%#6+)*/&!#!&2/!9" !6+'!)"!2/&!)6!+54)&/*)+" )!%"#4,/>!&-3)+)!=4(/)4"/+)+5+)!+5" !)!/' -+%#*



"  94*  *%-(/""!&  -3  ,!4#)!&  6+%)*!,  4..!4#/)'  5+#  " ! #!*.+)&!)"" 4" 4*64"!'+#/64,,34&(/""!&" 4"5+#4-+%"3!4#9 !) * !,/2!&9/" " !#!*.+)&!)")!2!# 4&* !(4&!46+(.,4/)""+ !# .4#!)"*  +%)*!,5+#" !4..!,,4)"9+%,&6+%)"!#" !4-+2!*"4"!(!)"(4&! -3,!4#)!&6+%)*!,4..!4#/)'5+#" !#!*.+)&!)"4)&*%-(/"" 4"4*.+%*! 9+%,&(4:!4)4""!(.""+*42!" !(4##/4'!4*4)36+(.,4/)"4*4'4/)*"" ! +" !#*.+%*!4)&54(/,3(!(-!#*(43&!4,4&!4" -,+9"+" !(4"#/(+)/4, ,/5!

; 7

9/5!/)4))&/4)*!"%.9+%,&&!5/)/"!,394/"5+#" !" /)'* "+*!"",!&+9)  !9+%,&)+"4,*+" /):/)"!#(*+5* 4#/)'" !4'+)39/" !#.4#!)"*4*" !3(43'!".!#"%#-!& %#" !#*%6 * 4#/)'(43!)&4)'!# !#(4#/"4,,/5!

 "4)3#4"!* !9+%,&)+"4..#+46 " !.+,/6!9/" 4 6+(.,4/)"/) !# 4)&%),!*** !"4:!*45/)4,&!6/*/+)"+.4#"943*  )&!# *%6 .#46"/64,6/#6%(*"4)6!*9!64))+".#!*%(!" 4"" !4..!,,4)" 4&)+" 6 +*!)"+,+&'!4)36+(.,4/)"4*4'4/)*"" !#!*.+)&!)"4,,!'/)'6#%!,"3 4)& 4#4**(!)"4"" ! 4)&*+5 !# %*-4)&4)& /*54(/,3(!(-!#*4*" !#! 94*)+*%6 +66%##!)6!/)" !(4"#/(+)/4, +%*! B

 !"#/4, +%#"9 /,!&/*(/**/)'" !.!"/"/+)5+#&/2+#6!5/,!& -3" !4..!,,4)"(4&!4)+-*!#24"/+)" 4"4,&!2/)' 54" !#+5" ! 4..!,,4)"&!.+*!&&%#/)'" !6+%#*!+56#+**!=4(/)4"/+)" 4"" !.4#!)"* 4)&+" !##!,4"/2!*+5" !#!*.+)&!)")!2!#&!(4)&!&4)3&+9#34#"/6,!*+# (+)!35#+( /(&/#!6",3   !4#)!&6+%)*!,4..!4#/)'5+#" !#!*.+)&!)"

#!5!##/)'"+" !4-+2!+-*!#24"/+)+5" !"#/4, +%#"9+%,&*%-(/"" 4"/"94* " !4&(/""!&64*!+5" !54" !#+5" !4..!,,4)"" 4")+&!(4)&+5&+9#3 4#"/6,!*+#(+)!394*(4&!-3" !#!*.+)&!)"



 !!)"/#!!2/&!)6!+594*" +#+%' ,3#!4&-3%*  "

4..!4#*" 4"4C%!*"/+)94*.%""+4*"+9 !" !#4)3&!(4)&+5&+9#3 94*(4&!5#+( /(&/#!6",3!/" !#-3.4#!)"*+#+" !##!,4"/2!*+5" ! #!*.+)&!)""+9 /6  !#!*.+)&!&" 4"" !3 4&)+"&!(4)&!&4)3&+9#3 &/#!6",35#+( /(

;

"/*)+"" !64*!+5" !4..!,,4)"" 4"4)3&!(4)&+5&+9#394* &/#!6",3(4&!5#+( !#54" !#   !#!5+#!" !4-+2!&!.+*/"/+)+5

< 64))+"-!6+)*"#%!&" 4"4&(/""!&" 4")+&!(4)&+5&+9#34#"/6,!94* (4&!-3" !.4#!)"*+#" !#!,4"/2!*+5" !#!*.+)&!)"  !4**!#"/+)(4&!

-394*" 4")+&/#!6"&!(4)&94*(4&!-3" !.4#!)"*4)&#!,4"/2!*+5 " !#!*.+)&!)"

<

 !"#/4, +%#"4,*+(4&!4)+-*!#24"/+)" 4"" !4..!,,4)" 4& )+"6 +*!)"+,+&'!4)36+(.,4/)"&%#/)'+)!3!4#.!#/+&* !,/2!&9/" " ! #!*.+)&!)"

*4,#!4&3+-*!#2!&-3%*" !4..!,,4)" 4&94/"!&.4"/!)",3 $%*""+*42!" !(4##/4'!

+9+(4)9+%,&#%* "+" !.4#!)"*+#"+" ! .+,/6!*"4"/+)4"" !#/*:+5 !#(4#/"4,,/5! A

"/*4)4&(/""!&.+*/"/+)" 4"46#/(/)4,64*!%)&!#!6"/+) B8AB;774)&; 94*,4%)6 !&-3" !4..!,,4)"" #+%'  !# 54" !# +(!+5" !#!,4"/2!*9!#!'/2!)46,!4)6 /"!2!)&%#/)'" !6+%#*! +5/)2!*"/'4"/+)-3" !.+,/6!/)4*(%6 4*)+6 4,,4)94*,4/&4*4'4/)*" " !(   !+" !#466%*!&/)6,%&/)'" !#!*.+)&!)"546!&"#/4,-!5+#!" ! 6+(.!"!)""#/4, +%#"

 !6#/(/)4,64*!!)&!&/)46C%/""4,  !4..!,,4)"

4*9!,,4*" !"4"!.#!5!##!&4)4..!4,4''#/!2!&-3" !"#/4, +%#"

 !

4..!,,4"! +%#"4,*+6+)5/#(!&" !46C%/""4,#!6+#&!&-3" !"#/4, +%#"

8

)  " !  4-+2!  546"*  4)&  6/#6%(*"4)6!*  ,!4#)!&  6+%)*!, 4..!4#/)'5+#" !#!*.+)&!)"9+%,&*%-(/"" 4"4,,!'!&&!(4)&+5&+9#3 *%-$!6"/)'4..!,,4)""+6#%!,"34)& 4#4**(!)"&+!*)+" 42!4)3,!'*"+ *"4)&%.+)  /2/,64*!*4#!&!6/&!&-4*!&+)" !.#!.+)&!#4)6!+5!2/&!)6! 4&&%6!&-3" !.4#"/!*6+)6!#)!&D9 !#!4*46#/(/)4,64*!/*&!6/&!&-4*!& +)" !!2/&!)6!9 /6 9+%,&'+"+!*"4-,/* -!3+)&#!4*+)4-,!&+%-"" ! 6 4#'!*5#4(!&4*4'4/)*"" !466%*!& "(43-!464*!9 !#!" !4..!,,4)"

A 6+%,&  )+"  !*"4-,/*  " !  6 4#'!*  4'4/)*"  " !  #!*.+)&!)"  4)&  /*  54(/,3 (!(-!#*-!3+)&#!4*+)4-,!&+%-"

%"" !!2/&!)6!4&&%6!&-3 !#4)& !#54" !#-!5+#!" !"#/4, +%#"/)" !.!"/"/+)6,4/(/)'4&!6#!!+5&/2+#6! !*"4-,/* !*" !6+)"!)"/+)+5" !4..!,,4)"" 4"" !#! 4&-!!)6#%!,"34)& 4#4**(!)"6+((/""!&-3" !#!*.+)&!)"



56+%#*!,!4#)!&6+%)*!,5+#" !4..!,,4)"#!5!##/)'"+" ! &!6/*/+)+5" !+)E-,!%.#!(! +%#"/)

  

  

*%-(/""!&" 4"/5" !(4##/4'! 4*-#+:!)&+9) -!3+)&#!.4/#+#/)+" !#9+#&*" !(4##/4'! 4*/##!"#/!24-,3-#+:!)&+9) 4&!6#!!+5&/2+#6!64)-!'#4)"!&-3" ! +%#"



)

        !"4)& 4,*+/)" !,4"!*"64*!/)       #!"$%& '  ()(/" 4*-!!)64"!'+#/64,,3 !,&" 4"/"/*+),3" !+)E-,!%.#!(!

+%#"9 /6  4*'+".,!)4#3.+9!#*%)&!##"/6,!B+5" ! +)*"/"%"/+)+5 )&/4"+.4**4&!6#!!5+#&/2+#6!/)+#&!#"+&+6+(.,!"!$%*"/6!/)464*! .!)&/)'-!5+#!/"

+/'  +%#"+#" ! /2/, +%#" 4*" !.+9!#"+'#4)"

*%6  4  #!,/!5  -3 /)2+:/)'  " !  &+6"#/)!  +5  /##!"#/!24-,!  -#!4:  &+9)  +5 (4##/4'!



)+%#6+)*/&!#!&2/!9" !"#/4, +%#" 4*(/*#!4&" !!)"/#!

!2/&!)6!  4)&  6+(!  "+  4  9#+)'  6+)6,%*/+)  " 4"  " !  4..!,,4)"  4*  )+" !*"4-,/* !&" !6#%!,"34,,!'!&4*4'4/)*"" !#!*.+)&!)"  !4#!+5" !

6+)*/&!#!&  2/!9 " 4"  " ! 4..!,,4)"  4*  !*"4-,/* !& " #+%' 6+'!)"  4)& #!,/4-,!!2/&!)6!" 4"* !94**%-$!6"!&"+6#%!,"34)& 4#4**(!)"4)&" 4" " !#!5+#!* !/*!)"/",!&"+4&!6#!!+5&/2+#6! +)*!C%!)",3" !/(.%')!&

8 $%&'!(!)"*"4)&**!"4*/&!4)&" !4..!4,/*4,,+9!&4)&" !(4##/4'! -!"9!!)" !.4#"/!*/*&/**+,2!&-3'#4)"/)'4&!6#!!+5&/2+#6!/)542+%#+5 " !  4..!,,4)"  4)&  4'4/)*"  " !  #!*.+)&!)"   !6#!!  * !!"  -!  .#!.4#!& 466+#&/)',3

7

 !#!* 4,,-!)++#&!#4*"+6+*"*

 !   "

# 43 !  "

%,4"/ #