Jaspal Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others


 

       

 

 !

" "#$ %&'&    

 

  



   ! " 

  

  

() % *+,-. (&/012
.10(.1)(2)30(  *+,-. (1&/012
.1034
*".(3)0( #$%$&'(

# ")#*+,,'')-#.-/0123-'$42#')$5$'*'*2&$#%

# -&*&0$#*&+)/# /,&6-7

# %),&$$'*&+)/0123-'$42##$%52&0$&'2

10(.1)(2)30(  5/&  

()-!

  

%5#-:$042#/7:')$;$-#&$032,&%$;42#')$5-#'*$%/')$.-*& 3-%$* $ 
 

*%5#$52&$04#2.<   =/'2'20-:*'%$;4-&0*% '->$&,52&72-#042#)$-#*&+

&$  24  ')$  325$'*'*2&$#%  *&  ')$  *&%'-&'  ?#*'  5$'*'*2&/  *%  ')$ 5;-*&'*44*&

  
      

?)*3)?-%*&%'*','$0 -+-*&%'')$0$4$&0-&'%')$#$*&/?)2-#$)2?$1$#&2'*.5;$-0$0-%5-#':#$ %52&0$&'%/*&')$*&%'-&'?#*'5$'*'*2&

@

)$#$;*$43;-*.$0*&')$%-*0%,*'?-%42#')$#$&0*'*2&24- 0$3#$$245$#.-&$&'5#2)*7*'2#:*&6,&3'*2&-+-*&%'')$0$4$&0-&'%')$#$*&/42# ')$#$7:%/  ')$*#%  &2'  ,&0$#'->*&+  -&:  32&%'#,3'*2&  -3'*1*'*$%  2#  .->*&+ $&3#2-3).$&'%  ,52&  -*#  ,.>*&  2&0/  $A*%'*&+  ,52&  ')$  %,*'  >)-%#- &,.7$#% =

)$;$-#&$032,&%$;%-55$-#*&+42#')$5-#'*$%'20-:7$42#$')*%
2,#'-#$/ 

!/')-'')$6,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$ &&$A,#$=/7$3-.$ 5-%%$02&')$%-*03*1*;%,*'/?)$#$7:%/')$5;-*&'*44B%%,*'42#')$%-*0#$;*$4 7$3-.$0$3#$$0'2')$$A'$&'-%.$&'*2&$0*&')$0$3#$$%)$$'

<

!,#')$#.2#$/')$;$-#&$032,&%$;-55$-#*&+42#')$32&'$%'*&+ ;*'*+-&'%-#$-;%2/

!/')-'')$%-*00$3#$$)-%-3C,*#$032&3;,%*1$-&0 7*&0*&+$44$3'/-%&2-55$-;')$#$-+-*&%')-07$$&*&%'*','$07:')$-++#*$1$0 0$4$&0-&'%/7$42#$')$;$-#&$0!*#%'55$;;-'$
2,#' $%,;'-&';:')$#$7:%/ 6,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$ &&$A,#$=/?-%#$C,*#$0'27$$A$3,'$0/')#2,+)')$ 5;-*&'*44/?)2*%2&$24')$325$'*'*2&$#%*&')$*&%'-&'?#*'5$'*'*2&/'),% *&%'*','*&+-&$A$3,'*2&5$'*'*2&7$42#$')$
2,#'244*#%'*&%'-&3$ 2?$1$#/ %,3)-&$A$3,'*2&5$'*'*2&)-%&2'7$$&4*;$0

2&$')$;$%%32&'#-#*;:/')$*&%'-&'?#*'5$'*'*2&)-%7$$&4*;$0 7$42#$')*%
2,#'/3;-*.*&+')$#$*&%#$;*$4/')-'')$%-*06,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$ $&3;2%$0*&&&$A,#$=/7$0*#$3'$0'27$$&42#3$0')#2,+)-.-&0-.,% 7$*&+.-0$,52&')$52;*3$244*3*-;%32&3$#&$0/'25#21*0$52;*3$-%%*%'-&3$ 42#')$#$;$1-&'5,#52%$/$%5$3*-;;:+*1$&0$%5*'$')$%-*0#$C,$%'7$*&+.-0$ ,52&  ')$.  7:  "  32&3$#&$0/  :$'  #-')$#  ')$  %-*0  #$C,$%'  #$.-*&*&+ ,&)$$0$0

)$,&-%%-*;$06,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$245$#.-&$&'5#2)*7*'2#: *&6,&3'*2&  $&3;2%$0  *& &&$A,#$  =/  ?)$&  )-%  -''-*&$0  32&3;,%*1$  -&0 7*&0*&+$44$3'/')$#$7:%/')$5;-*&'*44/?)2*%2&$24')$32;*'*+-&'%/*&')$ *&%'-&'?#*'5$'*'*2&/-&0/?)2-55$-#%'24*;$-#$5#$%$&'-'*1$%,*'/'),%2& 7$)-;424-;;')$1*;;-+$5#25#*$'-#:720:/?)$&)-%&2':$'4*;$0-&$A$3,'*2& 5$'*'*2&/42#')$#$7:%/%$$>*&+')$$A$3,'*2&24&&$A,#$=/#-')$#)-% 3)2%$&'2-;2&+?*')')$2')$#325$'*'*2&$#%/'),%*&%'*','$')$*&%'-&'?#*' 5$'*'*2&7$42#$')*%
2,#'?*')')$5#-:$# %,5#-')$#$*& $%,;'-&';:/*&')$ ?->$24')$-721$/')$5#$%$&'?#*'5$'*'*2&*%&2'.-*&'-*&-7;$



)$#$42#$/*&3-%$')*%
2,#'5#23$$0%'2-%%*+&')$#$;*$4 %,5#- '2')$5$'*'*2&$#%/0$%5*'$')$4-3'')-'2&$24')$325$'*'*2&$#%*&')$5;-*&'/*%

@ -1-;*0#$3*5*$&'24-7*&0*&+-&032&3;,%*1$1$#0*3'-%$&3;2%$0*&&&$A,#$ =/')$#$7:%/')*%
2,#'?*;;7$-%%,.*&+2&'2*'%$;4')$6,#*%0*3'*2&24')$ ;$-#&$0 A$3,'*&+
2,#'/?)*3)'),%/-'')*%%'-+$/#-')$#?2,;07$+#2%%;: *.5$#.*%%*7;$ 

"$')-'-%*'.-:/42#$&%,#*&+')-'32.5;$'$6,%'*3$*%02&$'2')$ 5;-*&'*440$3#$$)2;0$#/?)2*%2&$24')$325$'*'*2&$#%*&')$*&%'-&'?#*' 5$'*'*2&/-%%,3)/-%5#-:$042#/7:')$;$-#&$032,&%$;42#')$5$'*'*2&$#%/;$-1$ *%+#-&'$0'2')$5;-*&'*44E325$'*'*2&$#/&-.$;:/,+-;F*%)2#$/')$#$3*5*$&'24 ')$32&3;,%*1$0$3#$$245$#.-&$&'5#2)*7*'2#:*&6,&3'*2& &&$,A#$=/'2 42#')?*')*&%'*','$-&$A$3,'*2&5$'*'*2&7$42#$')$;$-#&$0 A$3,'*&+
2,#'

32&3$#&$0/  42#  ')$#$7:%/  $&-7;*&+  ')$  ;-''$#  '2  .->$  -&  $44*3-3*2,%  -&0 %,33$%%4,;$A$3,'*2&246,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$ &&$A,#$=/'),%/-+-*&%'')$ 0$4$&0-&'%*&')$3*1*;%,*'32&3$#&$0



)$%-*0-55;*3-'*2&42#$A$3,'*2&5$'*'*2&7$42#')?*')4*;$0/-&0 ')$#$,52&/')$;$-#&$0 A$3,'*&+
2,#'.-:*'%0*%3#$'*2&/,52&/')$6,0+.$&' 0$7'2#%E0$4$&0-&'%  *&  ')$  %-*0  0$3#$$/  #-')$#  #$%*%'*&+  2#  27%'#,3'*&+  ')$ ?-##-&'

%244*3$#2#')$7-*;*44/*&)*%.->*&+%,33$%%4,;$A$3,'*2&%24')$ 0$3#$$245#2)*7*'2#:5$#.-&$&'*&6,&3'*2&/'),%2&-&-55;*3-'*2&3-%',&0$# $3'*2&<

/7$32.*&+4*;$07$42#$*'7:')$5;-*&'*44E0$3#$$)2;0$#/ #-')$#  5-%%  2#0$#%  ,52&  ')$  6,#*%0*3'*2&-;    32&3$#&$0/  '),%  42#  ')$ 5#21*0*&+%2452;*3$-%%*%'-&3$%'2')$?-##-&'%244*3$#2#'2')$7-*;*44/%2')-' ')$-721$$&%,#$')$%,33$%%4,;$A$3,'*2&24')$-552%*'$0$3#$$



&  3-%$ ')$ %-*0 0*#$3'$0  52;*3$ )$;5 *%  &2'5#21*0$0  '2 ')$ ?-##-&'% 44*3$#2#')$7-*;*447:')$6,#*%0*3'*2&-; 32&3$#&$0/0$%5*'$ 2#0$#%  '2  ')$  %-*0  $44$3'/  7$*&+  5-%%$0  7:  ')$  ;$-#&$0  A$3,'*&+ 
2,#'

32&3$#&$0/')$#$,52&/*'*%25$&'2')$;$-#&$0 A$3,'*&+
2,#''2.->$-

= #$4$#$&3$'2')*%
2,#'42#5#23$$0*&+%42#32&'$.5'7$*&+0#-?&-+-*&%'')$ $##-&'6,#*%0*3'*2&-; 32&3$#&$0 )$;$-#&$0 A$3,'*&+
2,#'32&3$#&$0/ .-:-;%27$42#$32&%*+&*&+')$$A$3,'*2&5$'*'*2&'2')$#$32#0%/.->$-2#0$# ')-'')$0$3#$$245$#.-&$&'5#2)*7*'2#:*&6,&3'*2&%'-&0%%-'*%4*$0/7,'%'#*3';: *&'$#.%24')$6,0+.$&'-&00$3#$$ &&$A,#$=



*%52%$024-332#0*&+;:-;2&+?*')-;;5$&0*&+-55;*3-'*2& %/*4 -&:

   10(.1)(2)30(!

/0"6.

 1034
*".(3)0(!

/0"6.

5  

  )$')$#%5$->*&+E#$-%2&$0 ( G$%E2 )$')$##$52#'-7;$ ( G$%E2