High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2917/2020allowed

Innovative Facility Solutions Private Limited v. M/S Aec Digital Studio Private Limited

2021-01-19Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

!!" #"

$ !%&' (("" ! )*+,"# '$ !%&''- .(' !"" !

$ /&-0-1

-(("" 1-"#- '! 1 "2'-'!' .

34 &'!

(' 5 4"-'!

(' "#$%&'&(()*+ 0-(("-3 "', '' 6

('3

-" '''" ',2

&( "' # - '+" 7-

'8-8 0- (("" - , -

' 88 .(' - 39" 39"'' 7 6-

'8- 39"8' ('- ' " '' -

' 8- 8 0- 39" ''

7 6 ( &

:;< -

- " "',1= /$/ >'=" -(

(

0) 0*# 0- &' 39" '' , ' ' & %1( ' - -3( !'' &-

'3"'(( 3"- =.

&- & +" ; 0- 39"=3 '? ( &

, &=--(('&, - &'' ( "'3 -'&, 0- &, &''

7 6=? '3=- 39"'-'-&" , '' & @

" &, - ( ''

@ @ '3 -# /

""&& "

3"-&'

- 3 1 +4 9 ('&4' ''

: @

='"1'=0-

"'3(' - #&&- ,= "

0- 39" ''' ; : !1,+" 39", &=--,! ,- 39"( -( '

- 39" "'3 ' A

0- = (''3 !'" '' 7 : 3A, ! -'" -, '--+4 9 ('&= "

''-' A

B"&"

'' : 7 &, - 39" ""=' 3 ''

7 !1,+" 39"

,-'( 0- 39" (''!'" ''

' 3&'- "'31 39"-&=

' , ' '

' . ;

;)9 = '&''

-&- -

& -! 3 &'-

" (

--3 "'-/,-+

'-&(', 0- 39"-"

,-'(-, ' 39"''

3, , '(

&- , '=-" - 39" = ( &'

( &!

3",,)< (&)&!3"( (

&0- ( # -= "' , & " '-&-3""=' : 0-(("-3 "'3 '",- =-9&"''

6 6 7 6 : @ '

-!3?'3"--- -'""",3

< ,- 39"& = '( - &('

, - ,-- 39"''& 3 , 'C'- -3 3&'-'' &-' &' , '

- 39" ; % ' " -((""- '-- &( ,'

- ((" ' ! 3 ' 3 - & 3' ( &(-- "'( 3=- 39"'-'3

(", " (- & -&, &"- ,- - ( --'3 "'=- 39" , &0-&, &=! '

- "((, -, '--'

"'' , '=- -' "'-( 3

,-&' &( 3( &'(( 3 ' ( 3 ! ", ( # ( 9 (( -( -( !1 - &'-(--(= "'3

' '&3"' 3'- (= "'' !3 '."("' (

="" !"

#$ "

%#"&'( "

))* ++0- ( 3&'-# -( "- &

- &&=- ' -(, - # - ' -&'- = "'3 ' '9." ("' (,

"-,

! . &

/ "

)+* ,"" 0 / ' * ' A ',& ''

: @ ('3 -'

/,-+

((" :77 7 % ' " 39" 3&--'- " '-&, ' ""

',=--- 0- ((

&- -&&= &= "'3 - " '''" ',2

&'- = 3- ( '3 & "0- -((" ""

'3-"

3 "'3-"

-3"-"",-&( ,'

-, ' -&-!,3(' -&, & !- ,-# (=3'- ( ! -(("" "

-!"& (''

'-&'

'3 -

'(&'3 39"'-3 '3 -" '''"

',2

&( A '3, '-((""'- "'-"",-&( ,' % ' "(" "

( ,12 ' & '3 4

)5+ ,"" 0/ '5 * 3&-- , "''= < '3'''( - '--& "'3'''-& , /" " ( " "".! "67 ''

.4''

8 ) 9'

, 3&--( ' ' ( !'' # - '&'

'--&?'3"

/!,- '" ' " -( '=-- -!,(

'- ' & -' '(--"

& "

< '=-- -&( ,' ' !3'- '--+

"'?&- D 6

-3-"' 9

! " #$# ! # # %

& & ! ' # # # % ( !

)( * !

/ # #( %

+ !"

#$ -3-"' 9 E,-(

./# 0 ! ' # 0 # 0

1 # 0 ( 2 (

' # 3 3 3 3 #

33 '(# #*! ( 4# ( '( +

0- ", 3 '( ' - ( !1, -

' -+

-& -!-&&'

,-'( "

-- &( ' = "' & ( ?& - " ( ', ( ', = "'3"', &

" - 0-!= (( '3 -#,"C- ',& C&3 /,-+

"-,

! .

=- ( -='&'-, '

"1 -(

-( - 39"((,-( "'

-!'

&= &'' @

( =-- '?

,- '( " !"'

& ("

7 ,!- '' 7 '3 !1, *!'

&" ' " 39"-&(' 3& --"="", 0- !'"

(("" ",, -!, ''3, & " % '''" ',2

&- "'?&-(

-& '- &'-- = "'&&

0- &( ,' '' 6

3""='

' (3,?( '- '3 " '

"'-& " (

@ /=! 39"= "'3"3 3(( ( & "

&- ,

0" !1