← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19990/2015dismissed

Gurdial Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals-I) Punjab Chandigarh And ORS.

2017-08-02Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

Vinod Kumar 2017.08.05 11:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

 

        

 !"!#$%& 

 

!"##

$%&&  '()*+  ,

'

($ #)*+ ,'-"

!



.

"/0-( ' !# 

- . /0) %1"

)2 .%#

& )

 .1

 3)%%)*+ .%, )%1"



4

.

"/0-( ' !#1 5

"  &



#"" '&6#  7  )

&&"  !#'9

,

*+ " 6 95 

,

4$ 



  :,

;( 2  <'%$(

*+ " 6 95 

) =$ 



 

:%"

;(

 $($(

#  =/ . 

1 5++)5 >

"

 &)"" '&6# #%&

."

 "

   &

   

   

  48 + 

6 1 #3     &&

 

3      + 6        

  %&

."



 +

1

 !#'9 ?

) ) 2  2 



 +6

 # ) 2







% 

&



 

< 

&& +

) &7 2

  &&   6 

?'

2  6  &#   

1  6 

@'

?

  

?)  2"  2   "   +6   +  >1   .



 & @

 5

)



  



6 

?'

)2 &&"

+

 





 ) )& 



  +6   #

   &&   1       

  

   5

"  

 

 +626 1 +

##

  1 &

2

##



  &   





+

1 2  *#

=

& "

"##







6 

  &*#

&  

 .!2"3

'

!#) @$(90

2 2 

 1

!"##

5 !"##



2

#

 ##

)







 &6 # %&

."

    #

 &&

"

2

""

#  



+#

 :

 "

;    +   

             + "

42 62

+6#3'&6# 

 A )"



+#

 &6 

48 2 

# &&"





 &&

     2    &

       6  +

     ?

7 +#

  

2 6

'

 *

&

+ ) 2



  62

&6

6 &&"



&&

 71   "

 &

 B#

1+ "2 +

"

<    $($(    %"

 &1

  

3

 

 &6 62 

"

&"

 #  &

"+   <'% )2" &1  

 '&6# &1 <'%$(1 13 + "

 6

  "1  

#

&1 <'%$( 1 +

5 + # " #&1  <'%

"

 3



 &

< # " #

&1   <'%$( )2"&1

"



""

#



1  &

#6)2 ) #

 " 1* "

) "

 7  &1

 1 " )

)+62

 "

) C

 ""

&6+ """

2  1 & )

#6+ )+ )2 4 6 & "

7 

1   6 

<'%$($( "#&

 

   1 +  2  

+

2  6 ?

 C

) )2

2

"+

 

&&" +6

  '&6#

  E " 

3-'!# '3!#4/ 2" !# # !

+((!""!# '1 -#5 *1 

$<(,,$1(4 

  

&6# 8+ 2  6

"

) 2 2  # "

 $($(

2#3

+

) 2

#&

+   2 

 ) ## 

6  

<'%$($( )2"2 2 

# :

"

;+ &&"

#"

&

)  2 "#

2 

  :

"

;  &

2 +

 

'



&

+

 5 )1 2

 "

) 66   





  "      %

  

  )     

!"##

 > #

 -4-"

1& 6

.

"/0-( ' !#7 2!#8 -4



38  -

8 

 & +

-

8