Babu Ram And ORS. v. Vijay Singh And ORS.




   
  

" 1. #$%& !

"' ()*
 

      

    2. #&

&!

"' ()*   

       

     )+  ,-)  #
 ) #
     

 

  "

#$%& !'(()



*++  



  "

!'(()

   

!

  ,,,
   -./  

    "

!'(() 
 



 "

'(()   



  !0  * ! "

!'(() -'/  

 !

     

 

 

($(%'(() 1   !

!!2  

 





 

 

'%(''((& 34  54

 6 4 

' -#/   !!2  !  !



!!

 !! 1  ! 9   !

 .$%%2%$  "

... ($.'.$$'!  1         

 



 !!5

 : !  !!6 3 9       



!  

    !! 


1  1 1

! 9 ;

 

 .$<<  

      


1      

    

 !!





1

=

1 !!


 !
1  

 


1    1 

      3=

 !! 

> !
1 

  ! 32==

   ;       !!2   

  

 !
1

      

  !! 1 

 
   



?!

!
1

@

 

  

      





 1 1

 !!  

 !  

         

 !



!*  1A

     

  

   1 !!

 1

  !!    

 @   !

      

      

   

!

#  !!  !! !

  

  !!       

    @   1   !    !!        ;

  

 *

  !  



@

 

! !
1 A

 



   

   .$$'   

 

   "

... 

 !    1

 ;9  1  (%.'.$$'   1 

   3 

 

  @

    ($.'.$$' 1



  !! 

  !!    !   4 

      !   !    

  1

     

 1 

 !



  

 1    "

... !!  1

 
1    ;

 1 

    

 

  

         

  

  

    B

 *   

!  -&/    1

    71   !
1 1 

1

 

 .$<. 

 



  
1     

 

   

    



 
1   1



1 

 

 

1

    1


1  ! 



!
1 



    

  1

& 

  

!

: 



  

C !

  ! 

!!

  9



   !!  

2    1

   

  !  -D/  !

 !     3  !

 !

 1  2
    



    



      ! !!

  "      ##  "   $    

 %                 &

 '  $&   (   

 ) *    "

'21 ! 2
+      , -    .

      - /

* -)/    

  

 

  A3  1

 "

.

'

'2 #   

 

 

!! 

!

   A 3  !

        

     

 

'%(''((&

D -</  :





 1

1 

 3  !    

 :

  

 3  A

   

 3 

 



 

   1

 
1      

 1 



 

 

'%(''((& 

3 A 1 

   

! -%/  =

    !

   

  -$/    !  !! 1


1    E



  

 

   

 1 

 
1      

 



1 !

1

  



1  !!

 

:  

 

 .$<) 

 * 1

=

1



*     

!  

  !! 

  



!!1


1 =

$ !

 .$<#2<&CF.





1

  

     !
1    A 

 

 A

  



! 

!B' !3

     B #     !      A



        

 D(

 =  C

)  A

! "

.#

   

!   

  !!  
1  

 



 "

.#     

 

  3 



 @ 1



1  3  !

CF< 

!





 

F

 9 !  1

 

 

  

1



!  ! !!

   1





  

  

  -.(/ 

 

 

   

!  

 

        

 .(< .D.33CF.(=

    !

*9

 

1

 

1 !
1   

  !

 



   

#D

C  

 

         !!   A

 !

    

 1   F  B &     







!

 !!

 !

   





   !
1 1 !



2  

  

!!

!    ! 







  3   "

<$# ! .$<) !

  !! 1

<  1

1 1

 

    1     !

          

 1 

    

  !      !!

   

     7 '# . # 7 ' '1   -../ 

  



  

$  CF.

 

     



 ! 

  9  

  

    

     

 A

 1

!! 

  * 1    

 
1     

 F

!
1 1 

; 



 1       1 

 

  

   1


1 =

1

    .$%< "



 





 1 

   "

   3

 

! 

!

 



 

! 

CF.. .'     1

 

 



!!

 !!

!  .' *

! 

  





!   1    C  3   "

<$# ! .$<) 1 1

1   1

 !7 '# .  # G 7 ' '33

! !

  

 

% -.'/ 

 

!   

 

  

  

   !  

 !! 

   

!! 
1  

 !     

   !

   

  
1  

 .$<& 

 

! (<.(.$$& 

 !

 

       

 A

   

  1

 

 


1     

  !! 

   

 

!
1    A

 9   1

 !!



 

H !!   !

!

1

   



             1

= 

 

   

 !   !        $ !

 .$<#2<&CF.

!B'  B#  

!   1



       

 CF< 

    3 

 

      !    

.(< .D.33CF.( -.#/  7



 

    

      

$  !

   .$<#2<& CF.

 

   

 

1

   !           "

$  

 

 !   A  



1

 1  

1

1

  :

  !

 

 



$

$     

 

&& ! : 

  A

    

  

   

  

 

  C

 9



  *   1 

 !!  

$    

   



1 ! 9



 !! 

   





$ 

   !



  



! *   1 

  





!*  1 

 

 

1

! 1

 



+   1 CF& 

1



 

   3 

 @  ==   

 .(('.$<<





*  11 !.$<DA

 $ 

   .$<#2<&     

  

   !

   

   $ 

 !

 

.(('.$<< 

*  11 !.$<D 

!!

 $ CF. !

 .$<#2<&A

! "

#   3 



 @



!



!*  1   A

 

 !!  2
0        

  $  -       -   0"    -      & -  

.( 0"   -   0"      1

 2 -    &   , -  2 -   - $3    4  3   $  " $& , - "    - 4  $(

       $&  -  $&     "         5  , - ,-     - , - & * -.&/   !     !

!  

 7!!  CF< 

*  

  

 3 3    

 

!

  1

  !   !

  



  





  !  

*   

 1



  

C   

 !  "

.#



  

  F

  

 

 

  7!!     

F  

    =  



 

!   CF<

  

!

 !

!B' B#1

 

1

  



   !!

9 ! 

 D(

 C   


!

        !   CF.

 

  CF<  

! B'   B#  

    

 

  !



..

 



 !

   





*

!!

 

C 

 F

!!





 !

  



!

7

      

*  

 

 1

 =   

 !! 

 

 !  1


1      

    

  !!   



B.4

B'  B#

*+ -.D/ 



 

  

:

  

 3 

     

          

      * 1     ! 

     

 

 
1     

  !! A

B.



1 

 

  

 !  

 



* 1  

    ;

  


1   1   

 1

   



   

 A

 1   

 

   

 

1 1





   

   

 * 1 1

 

   !

     

B '      1   

1

     
1   

  

1

  

 !&ID A

.' 1 1 

 

A

  1 

*+ B#1

 !

  !4

"

'A

1 1 '$  ! 



    

 1 

 '&.('(('
1    

 .$<.



 !*


1 1

F

A

1 

  

     * 1    


1 E22E 

 

!!7

!! 

2   

       !

  1



*         2   

 

!

    

C 

2  



 !      

     

     ;

    7 '# . #  7 ' '33 





  1

 

  1!

 1

   1

"

 1 

 





!

 

  7  !  1!   

 

   !

!       !

 !   1

   !  "

... 

($.'.$$'! 

C

1

 !
1 

  ! !!

1 

!!

  !!

  0 ! (<.(.$$&1



.# # ! 

 

! 

  



1

  -.)/  = 

 

!

 

=  

9 !



   !    

      J  "

 

1  !!    1 ! !

 !  

:

 

3  

 

 

  A

      

!  



   J "




 

   1

 

 CF< 

 



 



   

!  

 !  

 

 

11

 7

  

!





 



F

    

!

 1 

 9 "

3

1 

 

! !

  

    1   !

 

 

! 

 CF.

 B'   B#    !   



1

 

  6 $  CF.      



  

    

  

 



  *   1 1  1 !  .$<D 1  $ 1    *  1!

 

$ !

 .$<'2<#

$ 9  



 

.&



 A



!

  $  F   



33

 $  

 

 1

 !  9  !   







*  1

 !!  J "

 1

 

   ! !



1 ! 

!!7

!!

2  

    

  1  



 !     

 

   4     

  

  !!  

2   J "

C



     



 

1  

  

  -.</  ; 



 =! 

      

       

 

:

  

 3   

       

  9 

     

     '

) #
* (%(.'(.)