High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15494/2017dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Sakuntala Devi And Others

2017-07-18Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"# $ %!&'()* +,"# $

!-%./'

0')'

1%2)%%./'

'3-'

!" #$%&'"#()$ '&&!*#$+,"

!" #$%&'" '&!*#$+,"

'( 4 %56)5%,-&%, !/3'

77777 '&!*#

8 ! -% /%' &/%9- / - -%-

$:;) 8<--=*/%-5'%=)%, /%-9%/ &/, /%-9%/ :! '/ >?<, @/=* 9% 33&%!-=*3%'3-'

%-",/%'=%@-@/ A)%'/9/--%-+ B:;)8C<,@/%!)/-& /3'8&'-/&%'!/%33&%9%-9/ 5!53'

/!%&'%-9/!9!/3'@3% /%/%'/*%5%'',@/@%'@29%'D :@1<%&/% %&/ ' !!&%&&)@/ %-%)1 5=%%',@/ /%'', -- %9 =/- @! %- % ' -@81%2)% :'3-

< ')=5- % %33&% ! %335 &53%''%9)-!/''8'3- "4)'/6)5% 4 %56)5%,%-&)'3'9/38

! -% ')=5- /% 3)')%& / %!5- %33&%,/3%5,--%-

C,--&'- /5%-'=-3-1%-%33'-'3-

! &'-9/&%'!%335&53%''%9)-!/'!,! '/'-'- '3'/!,'3-

:@-@<')=5-% %33&%!%335,=)-)9/9)5,--%-

, / 3%5 /%- &%!- /% / 5%- ' &% = &'-- ! 9%95 &53%''% 9)-' ')%*, '3- ":5%-'<@%'&'--!%;%/59 /-"+

=*/& %;%55%-/&%'@%'

E&---%-C#

:;)8 < /'%--@%'

&/%9-=*!9 9%33&% #B#D##C##D"# B,@/&/@%'

&'-=*%29)5)'=E&'%'5)&/%'/%/'3-8 -3%5 /%- -)&- %'*'5! %&% !3' %)' %=)'%*-@%%'3%&%!&'-9/A)''! 9%95&53%''%9)-'%-%/'%-5''==!' @3%-/-3-'!/-&%'-,''&%%5)!

B#,###D8%- '

B, B$D8@%-';89%%%-1@3%- !)/')=5-/%---%-

$,/ /%')'*%@-/%33&%@/A)%'/9/--%- + B :;) 8C<, @/&/ @%' %' %;- @/ / 3, @/=* 1)3- ! ' !!&', 5=%% ', 5=%%, !5-'3-

%=)E&!/&%'!%335 &53%''%9)-%-,/)',/-!/'')'%%= !)/')=5-/%//%')'*='-/%/@-@- -%)9//%'=%-%3%@/%-&--%)9/!/3)3'!

- 85%%9%-,/!,3'&=-3''/)-/%=%&%- /&%'!!%5*!/%'/*%5%'!%''''9-9& @, '3-

,@/')=59/%33&%,/%-'/@*@ -3-'

/!%&)5!/'')-*9 #F"@%'')=5-

/3&*-''%93'&=%*3'! 85%%9! @-@--%)9/,/)9/--%-

C:;) <, -&--%)9/)9/!%5*@/&/-@=-! 3'D'&'!)5%-%=*!/')='A)5%%9 / @-',/'&'%9/&%'/%=)'%33&%=-%/ !/1 /3%5/%-&'-/&%'/=%''!/ 3%&)%'5-/%33&%-%-B

%-@!')&/ 3%&)%','3- ",/5%-',@%'D'-%* 5 3' )- / '&/5 %)' " ! / ')&' -%-

C:;) <,;%&-/@ 3,/%-= &-%-,/)',)9-/')!'98%'-/53)9--

/% /%- / %- &)' ! / 3 %- %33%'-/3%3=2

/,-53)9---%-

$:;) 8< /%' -- !%335!'3- " &53%''% 9)-,=)*3%''-%-&8&'-/&%'!/%33&%

/'%2!=*,/3%3%!/-%-'/)'(8 >

/% 9 &%!) &'-% / 5%

/)9/,4'

'/% %,-%)9/!/-&%'-53* @%'5%-%/5@/1/ /%'/*%5%'3%''-%@%*, =) '/ /%- = @-@- ')='A)* %- @%' @ -3- / 3%% !%5* / 3)3' ! 8 5%%9,'//%'=%-%3%@/%-&--%)9/ %-3'&=-3''/)-/%=9/&%'!/

!%5* ! 1/ /%'/*%5 %' ! %''''9 -9&

4,/%33&%%&A)-/A)%!&%! #F" )"#

,@//'&%'!%335&53%''% 9)-'@%'&'-- 13

' 3/&%5!

%-&)'!/%33&%,/%33&%/%-5%- / '3- 3%5 9%-9 /' /%&- A)%!&%,=)/'%5@%'%2%&&)@/ &'-9/&%'!/%33&%

@!/-'&)''%=,'!/%/-'! E)'& @)- = 5 @/ -& / '3- -3%5&'-/&%'!/%33&%9%-9 5!53'%&&)!/'@-@-'' =9-3-/3%%!%5*%-%'%&&)! /' @ A)%!&% ! #F"

&&-9*, - -%- #+ #"

B:;)8C<'A)%'/-%-'3-'% -&-&'-/&%'!/%33&%/; 59 ! / & %;% 55 / '

-'3'-!%&&-9* ?

/='%'!/%=%'-)3/&'-% /%5%9%-9%%9!/%&-A)%!&%/%'=9 ')='A) !9 !/%33&%,@/&//%' =%2 %&&) /93-/3%58&'-/&%'!/ 3%'3-','%-/*&/'&/%9/'%5 /*&)- /%&'--%/3'%'-&%-/%!5--%- 3%''%!'/-%!%@%-933)*!/%9/3% '3-'

)@,/-!/'5'&))' / 3' /% = -&- * 8&'- / &%' 9%-9 5 ! 5' 3', 3%&)%* %&&) ! / !%& /% @-@-''&%=-3-/3%%!%5*%-%'@ %'/%&5!/A)%!&%! #F"

//%'%--%

/3'%'-=*/'3&3%'

-!-%*9%*%-3'*/53)9- - /'%5-'&%!%*!& ')%*,/@ 3'-'5''-

:#()$ '&&!. / '&!.

#$+,"

#012* 34 6 6 57 38 9:

;

( 5:

6 6 3<

( 5: