High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/94/2009dismissed

Krishna @ Kalwati v. Rajinder

2015-01-20Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri11 pages

!"#!$% &

'( ) ( '(

$*+*", $-.,."/0!&123!,* $,4*!55*00!", $!"6.2#5,!&123!,* $,4*$*+5"1*",

!"#$!% " &'" ( )* +)),-. ' "'&"$!/ /% !01 2 *)2 +))3$ '&"2 42 " $0''!&"/566 7 2'"8"&"2 5669: -.

' " 2'

2 $"2 2 '%''! -.&'2 <2'& " '2 ";

$- # '

+ '& ./"' < " &" & -2'"2 ' $ '=;

"' %''"2'2 "# '2 )3 )6 55,"<

/ '

7 :/' $'"

&'%2 '" <"2!"'$- "'%''! -$" 2& -2' 2$"2 " 2&>

"<''"" '2%"<'.-! !2 " %''!/"-<2$'2 '2 "# ' .%%-' "2 '' <'.'$ ? !!'.'2 /". ' 2""

""2 '.!< -.'' " 2 " @$'' % "'" '2 ""&2$ "

"<' !" $

'<' % " A "2"'2 """' "' $ - "2

! % -$"'% % " """$ &2 " $"2'% '"2 ''

$"2'% "2$"%

2'."2!"'

&"'2 " .%%-'< "' "2% "'22 "2'

% " .& '% " "$'- & " .'2$" &$'2 - ' 2 '

% """ 2$ -'% $ #$'2$"2&2 " $"2 < "" '2 "

6 ) +))6/ " '2 " . %%-' '$'"2-' !&2 2$'" <2 %2"2'&.& '2%'

"' " 6. "'" "" &"'% 2"

/ 2$ ->

!< <'-" ! "$' 2$"2 "%"'%2 2% -'"'& 2" &%"2'

' " 2% & 2'" 2 2"2' "'/ 2 "2$"

&2 2 !"&'$ ". ""2"2$2 "'2 " 2 !

"2% '&"- '2 " 2'%2 &." "'"2'2 <" %""'-.%$"$ ""

% "/-$""'2 " .%%-'

'% % " '"'""'% 2'&2 2$'" <2 %2"2'&.& ' "'!<6/)))B;"2"'2 " A' - ". "2 $

2"' % " '"2' "2 " 2% ' "'/2 +) )+ +))*/ ! "$' 2$"2

"%"'%2 2%-."'2 " .%%-' -' "'& 2"

2'"2 &."&2 < -.' "'"2'&2 & "%""''2< $" '2 " .%%-''" '"' '"& - $ "

.' $"2""

' "' " &."%%-' ' $ " $2$"

&+) )+ +))*/ - < ! "'' ""<

7 :

'2 "

<'-2"'"2 @$'-2$"'

' '"'

"2$" .

$ A&$ $/$-%"" !""' !'

"2' "" 2 "'2 " - '"-.%

"2$" .'2 - &$/"

"'. 2'2 $"2 2 "'

%''!-.&'2 <2'&

'2 " &2 "" " ""2 "'

!"2 2 "

"' " !"2% 2 2 '.-.%

.%%-'

% "'"% "B.& $ "2 "

$'"' ""<'"'"2% "'22 "2"

" 2' "'" "2 -$' ' < " < " 2 2 ;

% "2 % "& .% "2 6/)))B;"2%-. "'2 "

" 2 &&2' !"2%/$

'% " '2- %

$' ! " '2 2

/ "

" " " 2% "2$"-2"' ! 2'% "22>"'"% " "'

'&2<'/%

2'""2-' ! "

" -&>"2" 2%/-$" ' .%%-'

.' $"222 " &$' !" &."%" !"""

< 2& %! "% &'.".

"><2'&"'2$!" 12$'"2

'"" &2%'2% "2- "" &."

( " ! 2 " '"/

! $ '

'%=;

"'"""2 ' ""

"2&'2 <2'& 2 "!'2$ 2 &'$ "./

! """2 C 7+:

$' !< &/"

"''

4 '"'"'

!"2 "2 '

<"A 4 2$2'"

'<'2 /A% $ $""/ !-2$'/ 22 "'2$!

<"A '-'2"' +' / 2% 2"2 " 2'%2

<"A + "2"' /'2 "# '' 2 !"'2$!

<"A B'"'""" "> -.

% '"" ""% "

2 A% + 0-'/ -'2"'; ;

"2&2''2-2'"""%2 .

* 12 ' !"< &$& -."'" " $-%2 % 2 "' -

/ ' "' 12$'" &% "2 " &2 & $2 """

" 2"- - "2"- "" - "'" "&'$ ".2 &&2$ "2 % 2 2 '.2'- '"-."'2 "

&&2' !

./$2 &! "

'$ " 2 &2 2 $ 2 / " ""2 % "&2" D ! !!'< -. " #$!% " &' " ( )* +)),/

"' "' ''" " "

$-%2 %-.0'

%" !

/ ' &2$

'' " ! "

" 0'

#< E$"/ ' &2$

'' " !"'2 "<- &2 ' "'&2'- '$ %"" ./"%''!-"

"'" 2 % F 2 )3 )6 55,' $'" &'%2 "'%''!/".

<"2!"'/"%''! &2 $%%"/-$" 2& -2' 2$"

" 2&> " """2 & % !&'2 <2'& '2%" '2 ";$- -."

2 + )6 +))3 '

!"2 '""-

;"'" .&

.$ " "'2 " .%%-' ' 2"" ""2 '.

!< -.'' " ".% < $- '"& >&2 2$'

" <2 %2"2'&.& "& "2 2 '.

""2" A" " 2 <

!"2 "" ' ;

. "' "2 % "'22 "2' "'" "2-$' ' < &

$ - "2 $

"'% " 2'

!"2 "" "'2 2$"2 "%"'%2 2%2 6 ) +))6 "' 2'% ' "'-2$""% 2 "'2 " "22> &.""2 "2$2 "'2 " %6/)))B;/ '"2'"2" 2%/-$"$ "%" .2 +) )+ +))*/ ! "$' 2$"

"%"'%2 2% "'2 "' $"2">'-&> "

2'"%-.' "' "" 2 &."

)

< & -. "

" &2 " 2 '

'< ! ""% " % "'2$!

<" A 4G " 2"2 2 !-2$'$ $""/ '-'2"'' / + .F !" ! < &2 "

" " '!'"2'

!"2 "" % "'" '-." '2 " "" ""%" %"2% "'22 "2'/

' "' 12$'"'&2'"

! !=;

"## $

& '

() ( !

% !

* + D$'"'/ ! ""

!"2 2 "

"""" '2 " . %%-' % < $- '"& > &2 2$'" <2 %2"2'&.& "2 2 './" !2

' "' 12$'" '$ '=;

"##

"## +

* 4

' &2$ 2'"

"&2$ 2 "2$" 2''2'2'

'<'". &2%%"" -. ' "' 12$'" '&"2 2 " < &< - 2 "' " '2%" ! "

2"2 2 "

"""'

!"2 ' 2"2 .! ' -$"

'<!$ - <

!"2 """'2 " .%%-'"'"2% "'22 "2'&2$ 2"- "> !"

&"' "'$" "

!"2 /"

"2$

<- 2"2 "2& 2""/%2 " .'2 & $& ""%" % " 2 " 2&&$'' & ' 2 &' .'@$'"2-% "2 "- &2 %"'

'"&$ '/"2 . ' &""& -' """

"2 '2 &2 &2&"

!"2 ( 2" !

& " "' 2 % 2 2 '. 2' 2

&"2 2 &'$ ".2 "

"-."'2 " .

%%-'&2$ - 2''2<-.'

''2 2"2 " '2 " % &2 2$' " <2 %2"2'&.& 2 6 ) +))6 "'" !"2>

' & $ - "2 $

" % "'2 '2$"2 "%"'%2 2% '" ' %''2 )3 )6 55, &% "" 2' %2"< .' 2$& % '-."'2 "

."""#$ &"$'/% ' "%""'-&%2'2$"" "$' 2$"2 " 2%/&2$ 2"-A -."

"""""' "' ""2"2$2 " '2 " 2 !

" &."/ -$" 2" % . '2 / 2 '"&" " &."

A% $ $""/ 2"" """" " &." ""% 2'2 '.- '-."'2 " ' &/-$"%"" ./ 2"

% &."%%-'"' " !2 "

"2'

'2"2 %"'2$!

<"A 4 +' /-'2"'2

"/ 2 2"""-2$"' &2 . &."

$' !"%" !2 . &." 2'""

!"$"-"

"'" &/ '2<"2-'2&$' " 6

" 2" "" '"$' "2 " 2% "' "$' 2$"2 6 ) +))6 ?$" "

2 "2 2 "" 2 +) )+ +))* ! "$' 2$" 2 " 2%

2'"-.' "'"2'&2 & "%""' " " 2 &."'2< $" 2

!"""'2 "

'" '"' ' $"2""

'""%"'%2 2% "

!"2 2 "

" 2/"'@$'%"' '"&$ '

'- " " &""""

" %> !'&>

!"2 ! ""'2 ";$- < ! 2$-" &"2 $2'""% *

'2 "

!"""

" ""%"'%2

2%2 '2 <2 "2 "'< 22%% " '2- % "'""> !"'"% "

"' "%""$' !

'&'2;A% "2 "" ""%"'%2 2% 2'" '""% 2 6 ) +))6 """"%"'2 " $

' ! '2%2% % " '2- % $'"'""""< ". ! " 2%/"'2 "$"2">%& . 2'" % " % "

'2 "" ' < &

$ &'!&'A $-.'"% "2 .&"'./&&2' !

"2 &'% 2" F"?

'%2"E'$" ""$" 0& & &"2">

)( ), +))*"2)+ )5 +))* 2&$% "$2'""<'2 2 "'2 """"

" " &2% . $

'"%2" 2'.& .&2 2!& $2'"

3 <2 ? &2 "0.2'!12$'" .$#;!55!2 )!-!0!--!& 99%+$* 2"&""&"2 +42 "&"

$'2'""2%2&'" &2 "2 " "'"2 "2&"." '!

& "'" % " !&2 " $ &2 %"'%2 '%2 .

"2$ "2'< ""'$"2 '2- &"2 +47:7:2 "&"'2<"" "12$'"" "" .

" !'2$ 2' !' " ! ' A" " ""2 ' 2 '2&"12$'" 2""> !< "!2 2''2 '2 !2'

- "./"

!' ""'

2"' 2'/ '"12$'" " ""!'2$ 2'"' /"

"%2 '"2' $"2 !' ""' '"2 "2 2 """""2 '"> !

< "!2 2''2 '2 !

"& /"$&& &"

.'2<"""

!$ ".2 <

!"2 ! ""'2 "

2""'2 " 2'"'/'"''

&2 #$! &2% . "2$" .$

& "&$ "2$'"%%2' " " """2 2'<2'&#$" "''&2<' &2%2$"2 "

.&/&&2' !"2"

"/ "" 2%2 ++ )+ +))* " " """2 2

+ )6 +))3 &% """!'2$ 2 '"2 2"< - "2 '

" -2< '%/ "' ' 2 !'2$ 2'

"'< "2 " !2 ' "' 12$'" "'- ! 2%'"

" /"'-.% <) (= <

= !"#!$% & .