Raj Kumar v. P.O Improvement Trust Patiala & ORS.
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&, - -
#.
/01#2 ------ %$*$*&,%2 3%2+0+ 2%+*(*,5
''*)%26 ,(0+$2*#7 2*80,#76 #$*#7# &$4%2+
------
%+9&,(%,$+
: ;
< <
2%+%,$ 2- -/- !&52#6 (=&)#$%
9%$*$*&,%2-
2- <#,(%%9 /40,5%26 (=&)#$% 2%+9&,(%,$+ &- - - - <
%$*$*&,%2
#.
/01#2 '*7%( *,+$#,$ >2*$ 9%$*$*&, 0,(%2 2$*)7%+ &,+$*$0$*&, ,(*# *++0#,)% >2*$ ,#$02% )%2$*&2#2* ?0#+4*,5 >#2( (#$%( -@-
,,%A02% 6 9#++%( ,(0+$2*#7 2*80,#76 #$*#7#
4%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( :$4% 2*80,#7:6 >4%2%8B 2%7*%'
%A$%,$ 2%*,+$#$%1%,$ +%2=*)% 8#)C >#5%+ (%)7*,%( &,7B 1%#5%2 #>#2(%( 9%$*$*&,%2-
- 2*%'7B6 2#*+%( #, *,(0+$2*#7 (*+90$% +%2=*,5 (%1#,( ,&$*)% (#$%( - - 09&, '#*702% )&,)*7*#$*&, 92&)%%(*,5+6 (*+90$% 2%'%22%( 0,(%2
) ,(0+$2*#7 !*+90$%+
)$6
4%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( : )$: #(.0(*)#$*&,-
- )7#*1%( 4% 4#( )&,$*,0&0+7B >&2C%( 2%+9&,(%,$+ &-
4%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( 2%+9&,(%,$20+$ @ B%#2+ *-%- -- - - %7(#2)01<>%%9%2-
$ )7#*1%( +%2=*)%+ 4#=% >2&,5'077B6 *77%5#77B6 1#7#'*(%7B6 #28*$2#2*7B 0,.0+$7B $%21*,#$%( - - >*$4&0$ *++0*,5 #,B ,&$*)%6 )4#25% +4%%$6 %,?0*2B >*$4&0$ 5*=*,5 #,B )&19%,+#$*&,-
$ '02$4%2 )7#*1%( #$ $*1% $%21*,#$*&, 4*+ +%2=*)%+6 5%$$*,5
+- 6 -
$ #77%5%( .0,*&2+ 4#=% 2%$#*,%( +%2=*)% 2%+9&,(%,$20+$- $ +$#$%( +*,)% $%21*,#$*&, 4*+ +%2=*)%+6 2%1#*,%( 0,%197&B%(-
4%2%'&2%6 )7#*1%( $%21*,#$*&, 4*+ +%2=*)%+ =*&7#$*&, 92&=*+*&,+ )$- ))&2(*,57B6 92#B%2 2%*,+$#$%1%,$ +%2=*)% )&,$*,0*$B +%2=*)%+ 8#)C >#5%+ #7&,5>*$4 )&,+%?0%,$*#7 8%,%'*$+ 1#(%-
- )7#*1 )&,$%+$%( '*7*,5 *$+ >2*$$%, +$#$%1%,$ >4%2%*, 92%7*1*,#2B &8.%)$*&, $#C%, 2%'%2%,)% 8#( 7#> 52&0,( 1*+,&,.&*,(%2 ,%)%++#2B 9#2$B
4#*21#,A%)0$*=%
''*)%2-
$ )#$%5&2*) +$#,( %,5#5%( 902%7B $%19&2#2*7B (#*7B >#5% 8#+*+
2%?0*2%1%,$ >&2C-
$ +$#$%( #, *,(0+$2B 0,(%2 92&=*+*&,+ )$-
$ +$#$%( >&2C1#, 0,(%2 92&=*+*&,+ )$ 4% 9#*( >#5%+
(#B+ 4% #)$0#77B 9%2'&21%( (0$B-
$ +$#,( 7%'$ +%2=*)%+ 4*+ &>, (*( $%21*,#$% +%2=*)%+
9%$*$*&,%2-
$ +$#$%( >4%, (*( 2%9&2$ (0$B6 4*+ ,#1% +$20)C &''
(#*7B >#5% 10+$%2 2&776 92&)%(02% #(&9$%( (#*7B >#5%2+-
, 1%2*$+6 #77 #=%21%,$+ +$#$%1%,$ )7#*1 >%2% (%,*%( 8%*,5 >2&,5 *$ +$#,( %,5#5%( +&1% $*1% %7(#2 &2 +&1% $*1% <>%%9%2 #5#*,+$ (*''%2%,$ 9&+$+ (#*7B >#5%2-
$ +$#$%( =*%> *19&+*$*&, 8#, &=%2,1%,$ ,%> 2%)20*$1%,$6 ,& ,%> 9%2+&, %,5#5%(#99&*,$%(-
%97*)#$*&, >2*$$%, +$#$%1%,$ '*7%(-
2&1 97%#(*,5+ 9#2$*%+6 *++0%+ >%2% '2#1%( 9#2$*%+ 7%( $4%*2 2%+9%)$*=% %=*(%,)%-
- &,+*(%2*,5 1#$%2*#7%=*(%,)% #=#*7#87% 2%)&2(6 2%$02,%( '&77&>*,5 '*,(*,5+
#
%+9&,(%,$20+$ #, :*,(0+$2B:
>*$4*, 1%#,*,5
. )$-
8 %$*$*&,%2 4#( >&2C%( 1&2% $4#, (#B+ B%#2 *11%(*#$%7B 92%)%(*,5 (#$% 4*+ $%21*,#$*&,-
) 97%# #8#,(&,1%,$ >&2C >&2C1#, 92&=%(-
( & %,?0*2B )&,(0)$%( #5#*,+$ >&2C1#,-
% <%2=*)%+ >&2C1#, >%2% $%21*,#$%( =*&7#$*&, 92&=*+*&,+
)$-
' &2C1#, %,5#5%( 902%7B 8#+*+ (#*7B >#5%+ 2%?0*2%1%,$ >&2C-
5 & #99&*,$1%,$ 7%$$%2 5*=%, >&2C1#,-
- 52#,$%( '&77&>*,5 2%7*%'
!
"
$
%& '(
)
"
* "
*
+ ,
-./
0
1 ** 0
$
%& 2$
*"3
4
* "
*
-./
)
5 1
*
5 *"# ,
0
,
0
$-67-8 !
*
"
0
#
"
0
$
%& 2$
*"3
"
*
# *
** *
*
:
#
** *;
8*
< @- , #'&2%1%,$*&,%( )*2)01+$#,)%+6 '*7%( *,+$#,$ >2*$ 9%$*$*&, 8%'&2% $4*+ &02$ #5#*,+$ *1905,%( >#2( (#$%( -@-
,,%A02% -
- 4#=% 4%#2( 7%#2,%( )&0,+%7 2%+9%)$*=% 9#2$*%+ 4#=% 9%20+%( 9#9%28&&C $4%*2 #87% #++*+$#,)%- - &,)%(%(7B6 >#2( (#$%( -@-
,,%A02% *1905,%( 2%+9&,(%,$!%9#2$1%,$-
'$%2 #250*,5 +&1% $*1%6 7%#2,%( )&0,+%7 )&,'*,%+ 4*+ 92#B%2 &,7B 2%5#2( %,4#,)%1%,$ #>#2(%( +081*$$*,5 #>#2(%( 7&>%2 +*(%-
-
, &$4%2 4#,(6 7%#2,%( )&0,+%7 #99%#2*,5 2%+9&,(%,$ 20+$ &99&+%( 92#B%2 %,4#,)%1%,$ +081*$$*,5 #>#2(%( .0+$*'*%( #))&2(*,57B6 92#B%2
(*+1*++#7 *,+$#,$ >2*$ 9%$*$*&, 1#(%-
- &,:87% <092%1% &02$ )#+% =4,6 > = *#
<
4%7( 0,(%2
*
1
"
*
** #
** *
* **"
** /*
"
0
*%
** **"
% * % "
0 ; * ?
0#
*"
** *
* *"
0 *
4
7 * + 5
)
0
*
0 "
**
1 $ *
0
$ "
*
0
*
** *
&"
"
*"
@ 4
7 * + 5 0
*"
0
* " "
4
*"
0 #
*
24A
B 0 C +0# 3 4)) 3#
* *
0 *"
#
*
0
0 "
)
*
* 0 "
*"
"
0
*
*
# *
0 "
D<
- , )#+% 5
# $1 +0 )
> E 4
<092%1% &02$ #+%+
#8&=%+$#$%( =*%> #''*21%(- $ 4%7( 2%*,+$#$%1%,$ 207%6 *$ (%9%,(+ 09&, =#2*&0+ )*2)01+$#,)%+6 7*C% ,#$02% >&2C6 1#,,%2 1%$4&( #99&*,$1%,$6 7%,5$4 +%2=*)% %$)- , =*%> 2#$*& .0(51%,$+6 2%'%22%( #8&=%6 52#,$ *,+$%#( 2%*,+$#$%1%,$ 92&9%2 2%1%(B-
&,:87% 9%A &02$ 97%$4&2# )#+%+ (*2%)$%( 7*%0 2%*,+$#$%1%,$-
%'%2%,)% )#, 8% 1#(% (
+ 0 , ' " E1 *A !3 4))
4 $ 0 (
** , 8
7
A !3
4)) E+5 0 5 B A !3 4))
-
#C*,5 ,&$% '#)$ >&2C%(
%7(#2)01<>%%9%2 -- - - 8#+*+D +%2=*)%+ 4#( $%21*,#$%( =*&7#$*&, 92&=*+*&,+
)$ $%21*,#$*&, $&&C 97#)% 1&2% $4#, B%#2+ #5&D )&097%( '#)$ 7#*( #,B )4#77%,5% >#2( (#$%( -@-
,,%A02% #7+& )&,+*(%2*,5 7*$*5#$*,5
@
+*,)% D #1 )&,+*(%2%( &9*,*&, #>#2(%( 7&>%2 +*(%- - &,+*(%2*,5 $&$#7*$B )*2)01+$#,)%+6 1B )&,+*(%2%( =*%>6 *,$%2%+$ .0+$*)% >&07( 8% 1%$ *'
#>#2(%( %,4#,)%(
+- 6
+- 66-
%+9&,(%,$20+$ (*2%)$%( 9#B
%,4#,)%( #1&0,$
#'$%2 #(.0+$*,5
+- 66 *'
#72%#(B 9#*(6 >*$4*, 9%2*&( $42%% 1&,$4+ (#$% 2%)%*9$92&(0)$*&, )%2$*'*%( )&9B $4*+ &2(%2-
, )#+%
,&,9#B1%,$ #1&0,$ >*$4*, +$*907#$%( 9%2*&(6 +4#77 8% %,$*$7%( )7#*1 +*197% *,$%2%+$ #$ 2#$% E #,,01 $*77 $*1% +0)4 9#B1%,$ 1#(%-
@- *,+$#,$ >2*$ 9%$*$*&, (*+9&+%( #'&2%+$#$%( $%21+- - 9%,(*,5 #997*)#$*&, +6 *'
#,B6 +4#77 +$#,( )7&+%(-
<
!
- -
+.C+ 4%$4%2 +9%#C*,52%#+&,%(
"%+
& 4%$4%2 2%9&2$#87% "%+
&