High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15528/2017dismissed

Punjab State Warehousing Corporation And ANR. v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Patiala And ANR.

2019-07-23Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages

!"# $#%&'&() * +(,!-."!"#!/#0+'&(1 /2/!"&(!($!(/ 3#"&"&(#/' 4#/'+' 5($+'"/&!6 /&-+(!65!"&!6!!($!(/ 3#'2($#("' # /#)

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

"#//# #//#$"!'F"0# /&-+(!67@!'"0!"0#@!' #(1!1#$ !' 0@:&$!/ !" G#0/!1!1!5 &'"/&%" .!(1/+/ +($#/ "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("@# D** !($%("&(+#$@/:&(1!''+%0 "&66D (!'!6!/? EC2#/;("0!

"#/@0&%00&''#/9&%#' @#/#&66#1!66?"#/;&(!"#$( 0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" &6#$

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

5&(9&#@ '"!"#;#(" +"0/&H#$#2/#'#("!"&9# /#'2($#("E@/:;!(5#B 2!/"# 2/%##$&(1' $!"#$ !1!&('" "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" @#/# '#" !'&$# '+-,#%" " 2!?;#(" %'"' EC 0# %!'# @!' !$,+/(#$"D /2!?;#("' %'"'!($#9&$#(%# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( ( D5 %'"' !@!/$#$ @#/# 2!&$ !($ %/''C #B!;&(!"&( /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( @!' %;26#"#$ !($ "0# %!'# !$,+/(#$" +/"0#/#9&$#(%# /#'2($#("E@/:;!( 0#/#!

"#/5 ( *5 "0# %!'# @!' !$,+/(#$ " /#26?E/#%/$-?"0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" => 0!"5 ( 5 ((# !22#!/#$ ( -#0!6 "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("5 %('#A+#("6?5 "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" @!' !1!&(2/%##$#$!1!&('"#B2!/"#( 5+"0/&H#$#2/#'#("!"&9# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( %6'#$ #B 2!/"# #9&$#(%# !($ "0# %!'# @!' "0#/#!

"#/!$,+/(#$ /;"&;#""&;# /#B2!/"#!/1+;#("'!($#9#("+!66? @!'$#%&$#$#B2!/"#(

=> 0#/#!

"#/5 "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E ;!(!1#;#(" &6#$ !226&%!"&( ((#B+/# E ("0#'!;#$!? 2!''&(1 #B2!/"#!@!/$ "0##B 2!/"# !@!/$ ((#B+/# ED $!"#$ ( %('&$#/!"&( "0# !226&%!"&( /'#""&(1!'&$##B2!/"#!@!/$5"0#6#!/(#$ /&-+(!6-'#/9#$ "0!"'+-'#A+#("6?0!$(#&"0#/-##(26#!$#$(/2/9#$.;+%0'"0#/# @!'(;#("&( /$#/$!"#$ 2/%##$&(1#B2!/"#!1!&('""0# 2#"&"&(#/'E;!(!1#;#("&("0#!226&%!"&(((#B+/#E #B 2!/"# !@!/$ $!"#$ 5 &('"#!$5 ;#("&( @!' ;!$# "0#/#&( 2#"&"&(#/'E ;!(!1#;#(" 0!9&(1 -##( 2/%##$#$ #B 2!/"# ( @0&%0 0!$ !6/#!$? -##( '#" !'&$# ( DD ( ( -,#%"&( -? "0# +"0/&H#$ #2/#'#("!"&9# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( #'&$#'5 ( !

&$!9&" @!' &6#$ !6(1 @&"0 "0# !226&%!"&( 0# 6#!/(#$ /&-+(!6 -'#/9#$ "0!" &( "0# %&/%+;'"!(%#'5 &" @!' !22!/#(" "0!" "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("0!$ !&6#$"26#!$!($2/9#'+

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

=> = > 0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" &6#$/#26?""0#%6!&;'"!"#;#(" $#(?&(1 "0# !9#/;#("' ;!$# -? /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( @0#/#+2( /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( 0&;'#6 '"#22#$ &(" "0# @&"(#'' -B !' !($"#($#/#$0&'!

&$!9&" B!6(1@&"0$%+;#("' B" B #'2($#(" E@/:;!( /#&"#/!"#$ "0# 26#! 0&' 0!9&(1 @/:#$ %("&(++'6? '&(%# D** " D !($ 0&' '#/9&%#' 0!9&(1 -##( &66#1!66? "#/;&(!"#$ ( @&"0+" !(? %0!/1#C'0##"5 #(A+&/? / !(? %;2#('!"&( !($ 0&' $/!@&(1 '!6!/? EC 2#/ ;("05 -#'&$#'5 0&' 0!9&(1 !22/!%0#$ !($ '+-;&""#$ /#2/#'#("!"&( " "0##2+"? 0&# 8&(&'"#/ //#1+6!/&H&(10&''#/9&%#'( D9&$#

B!'!6' 0!9&(1'+-;&""#$/#2/#'#("!"&(""0#8!(!1&(1&/#%"/ !/#0+'&(15 /2/!"&( 0!($&1!/0 B ( D !' @#66 !' -# /# "0# #2+"? 0&# 8&(&'"#/ /#1!/$&(1 6#'' 2!?;#(" ( **

BC5-#'&$#'5 0&'0!9&(1%;26#"#$$!?'&("0#6!'"%!6#($!/?#!/ !($ "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" 0!9&(1 /#"!&(#$ ,+(&/ #;26?##' @0&6# &66#1!66?"#/;&(!"&(10&''#/9&%#' =*>

B!;&(!"&(C&(C%0&# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( @!' /#%/$#$( @0#/#+2("0#%!'#@!' /%/''C#B!;&(!"&( /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( ( -+" ( ((# !22#!/#$ ( -#0!6 "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" @0#/#+2( "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" @!' 2/%##$#$ !1!&('" #B 2!/"# !($ "0# %!'# @!'

/ #B 2!/"# #9&$#(%# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( @#9#/5 ( DD5 "0# 2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#(" ;9#$ !( !226&%!"&( / '#""&(1 !'&$##B2!/"#/$#/$!"#$ !($("0#'"!"#;#("'+

#/#$-?"0# +"0/&H#$ #2/#'#("!"&9# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( /#1!/$&(1 ( -,#%"&(""0#!226&%!"&(5"0##B2!/"#2/%##$&(1'$!"#$ @#/# '#"!'&$#'+-,#%""2!?;#("' %'"' EC@0&%0@#/#2!&$("0#(#B"

$!"# 0#!/&(1@0#/#!

"#/"0#%!'#@!' /#("&/#/#;!&(&(1#9&$#(%# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!( 0#/#!

"#/5 "0# %!'# @!' !$,+/(#$ ( *" &6&(1/#26?-?"0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("!' @#66 !' 2/$+%"&( /#%/$ -? "0#; @#9#/5 ( 5 ((# !22#!/#$(-#0!6 "0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("(/@!'!(?/#26? &6#$ %%/$&(16?5 "0# 2#"&"&(#/E8!(!1#;#(" @!' !1!&( 2/%##$#$ #B 2!/"# ( 0#/#!

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

&%&#(" %!+'# / (" 0!9&(1!22#!/#$( !($"0#/#!

"#/26#!$#$&("0#!226&%!"&((/ 2/9#$ 0+'&("0#%&/%+;'"!(%#'5!(!$9#/'#&( #/#(%#&'6&!-6#"-#$/!@( !1!&('""0#2#"&"&(#/'E;!(!1#;#(" =>

9#(-# /#"0&' +/"5"0#2#"&"&(#/'E8!(!1#;#("0!' !&6#$ " 2/$+%# !(? /#%/$ " '0@ "0!" "0# 26#! "0# /#'2($#(" E@/:;!(7' 26#! 0!9&(1 @/:#$ /; ** "&66 D @!'

=D>

!%"+!66? &(%//#%" !9&(1 !-'#("#$ ( "0# $!"# / 2/$+%"&( /#%/$ &# !($ "0#/#!

"#/5 0!9&(1 %("&(++'6? !-'#("#$ "&66 2!''&(1 "0##B2!/"#!@!/$!($"0#/#!

"#/;9&(1!(!226&%!"&(("0# '!;#$!? #B2!/"#!@!/$@&"0+";!:&(1+"'+

&%&#(" %!+'# /0!9&(1!-'#("#$ /"0#'#%($"&;#( &#"0#$!"#( @0&%0"0#?@#/#$&/#%"#$"2/$+%#"0#/#%/$!($"0#/#! "#/ /!2#/&$ ;/#"0!((#?#!/"&66"0#2!''&(1 #B2!/"#!@!/$( 5(%!'# @0!"'#9#/ &' ;!$# +" @!//!("&(1 &("#/ #/#(%# @&"0 "0# /$#/ $!"#$ 2/%##$&(1#B2!/"#!1!&('""0#2#"&"&(#/'E;!(!1#;#(" /"0# '#%($"&;#!'@#66!'#B2!/"#!@!/$5((#B+/#CD$!"#$ / "0!";!""#//$#/((#B+/#C $!"#$ $&';&''&(1"0#!226&%!"&(

/'#""&(1!'&$##B2!/"#!@!/$((#B+/#CD$!"#$ => ("0#6&10" "0#2'&"&(!'("#$!-9#5"0#@/&"2#"&"&(&' -#/# " ;#/&"!($&'!%%/$&(16?$&';&''#$!''+%0 .!6&! * +$1# !;&" 1. Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No.

2. Whether reportable :

Yes/No.