High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19092/2016allowed

Satish Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Of India & ANR.

2017-02-21Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"#"#$%!&

!'($%)!%"'

* + *

, -

+ *

, -

! " #$% !&' ( ) * &+$ ,"(! - ! &..&/ 012 & ! ) 3 !!-/ 03-12 $ -/ 0$-12 (

.& &..6

3 - 3 -

! &' ( ) ( 7! .& 58 $! )( 3 - 3 - %39

! :&. 3

) 5;

&..8 ! &4 5& * ! !!

%39( :

3 - ! ) ! /< $2 ) <! * 6&=5> .6 .6 ?!

" 3 - .5 .& &..; ! /< $2 ! ! )( 3-((

.& &..6( !.5 .& &..;

! %39) 3-! &' '

) ! ) ( ! 3-

&..6 $ /$ -2 4 65 = ) $-&> .4 .6 .:

&..6 !55

4 '.

$! )(3- $- @&;

.& &..>$- %39!3- @45 .> &..8 ( !!

%39

3-!<:&.:6>:6; :>53 > )( (( !)?

.& &..6)( 3

- ( !)?

)(3- $- &..6 < !55 4 '.() 3- $ - &..6 ! &' ( ) ) (7! .& 58 ! !55 4 '.) 3- !A

&' ) 3- .& 58 ;

3 &.5: , $ ! )(3- $ - ,39( &> 5.

&.5.

3-! ,39 ) ! ! &' )

.& &..6(3- ! !&& .:

&.5:!< B! $

3 ! )

.& &..6( ) < B! !

)!)

< B! ) ( ! ) .'

&.5:! ) ! &'

&.5: !( ) 3- , $

! ( ( (!( !&'

( !) 5& &.5: ! < '/52

3- #( !&' ( 5;.

)!$< B! 5.

( ) ?! ! ! < '/'2

# < 3 - 9 A! < B ! < B!

! 3 ( 45 5& &.5:

?! ! ) 5& .'

&.5'

< B! +

!"#$$ %&'

( % ) & '

( % *( +& , - (

. '*+ /0 1

. .

2 % .

. - 0 3'

4 . 1

! ) ! )! ( !&' )) ) ) # < ) 3- ! ( !( ( !&'

)) ) 3 - $ - ( 3 - ! &' .& &..6( 3-( !4 65 ) $ - &> .4 .6 .:

( ! )! )( !&' ) !4 65) 3- 5&

( (! ! &' 3 - 3 ! (

) ( !

.& &..6 ( )( 3

- < B! )! $ @ !(!) < B! < B! !&' )! ) < B!

?! ! 5& .'

&.5'( ! ( !&'

# (

) 5& .'

&.5' ( ( ) ! !

() #( !&' % ( ) ?! ! )! ( ! ?! ! (( 3 (

% ( " ! ?!!&&6

1 $ ! &' ( ( )

) ! !)! #(($!

( ! ( ) 1

) ) ?! ! ( ! ( ) ?!

! ((

)( !&' !4 65) 3-$- 5'

3! (

/2 %$9 ) ! (

3 ) ) ) !&' (

)

( .

, /

C = D=* C ) D=*