Punjab Technical University Non Teaching Employees Association Jalandhar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
! " # $
"
! " # $
!
"
#$
% & #
! " # $
%&'
(')*+*, - .,'
/
%'$()*'+,-($ "&%(*"*.$'!$ *'+,-($"
"&%-&".&--
/ 0 $ #- 1
1 2 3 # $ 2 4 0
5 2
)( ( "
"
# 67 %0 3898/#38/:
( ,
" 1 ( "
( ( ; ; # 67 %0 3<9=>#38/:
( ; , " 1 ( "
# 67 %0 388::#38/:
( ? "
.
( " " ,
# 4 < %0 388::#38/:
# 3 %0 3898/ 3<9=># 38/:
( " ? "
# < %0 3<9=>#38/:
( * "
"
# 1 2/
0
# #
1 #
6 # ;1 ++# ; # 71
/>>@6 +/>>@ +7
1 #
# " # #
!
1
" 1
( $ "
"
6 # ;1+($""+7 ;1 ( $ "
"
38/<6 +38/< +7
1 1 # #
# " # # 1 ,1
#
#
,
, A
; A "
AB
; A B
( ( "
(;"
"
" #
,
# & #
1
1 # #
1
# #
1 ## #
" .
1
#
11
#
0 1
C # 1 # 1 1 1
# D #38/< ($""
"
, # # 1 # D ($"" ;
## &%0 3<9=>#38/:
# % & #
D "
:# 38/< #
1
/>6/76 7
/>6/767 # % # &
"
:637 # 38/<
#
1
1 C
# ($"" #
#
#
#
"
:6/7#38/< # #
#
#
##
#
D
#
#
1 ## #
1 # %0 388:: # 38/: #
#
6
7
1 # # "
38 #38/< ($""1
# 1# ($""
"
1 # . "
38637# 38/<
# 1 # 1
/>>@
1 3898/#38/: # 1 ;
1
1
#
1
# ($"" #
($""1
#
"
1 D ("" #
## 1
0
" #
1
##
6" 7 D
1
"
#
#
,
+ 1
D # "
#
"
#
#
1
11
#
;
$$0 )& "
36#7#/>>@ + +
#
# # #
# " # # 1
"
<# />>@
#1 # 1
1) E< 1 #
6/7 (; #
$
# #
1 637 .
%
# #
647 & #
F 6<7 *
C #
1 7 "
# # %
C # $
C
F 7 "
F 6:7 %#
1 $ F 6@7 & #
$
D
#
$
-
F 6=7 & 1 #
1
C
B
# $ F 697 & *
* F 6>7 "
# # ;
#
1 # F 6/87 '
D #
D 6//7 5
#
F 6/37 *
( 1 1
## F 6/47 & 67
5 F 67 C , F &# , F
7 , F 6/<7 (;
# #
1
;1 6/:7 (; # 67 # % %
F 67
F
F 6/@7 % ; F 6/=7 $
# # #
$
" . % .
D # # #
# F 6/97
1
1 #
D # # G "
:
1
# " #
" #
, #. # "
:6/7 637 C 1) E: 6/7
1
C
1 #
1 # " #
" #
, #. # F 637 1
1 # #
1
#
6/7
1 ## #
# " .
1
#
11
# %
.;5 F
67 #
##
#
1 1 #
C #
#
#
C
1
# # #
$ F 67
C
C #
#
#1
D
#
C
'# D
"
/<697
1) E/< 697 , # .
" #
#
1 1 # ) 67 ## #
F 67 %
# !
%
# # # # #
# & H
H
E"
% G # #
# & H
H
F 67
#
# !
%
7
F 7 # # F 6 7 5 H % H"
H #
#
F
6#7 # ## ) 67 , F 7 # #
#,;
F 7
# 1
# F 67
# # # F 6;7
D # ##
# #
F 7
#
## ### F 67 # #1;
G "
/@
# A %
1
C ) E/@ 6/7 A %
#
#
1
!
%
%
"
. #
!
5 #A
7 "
. #
5 #
& F
7 1 # , #. % # , # . 637 A %
, # .
#
"
)&
E 6/7
1
C
1 #
,
, A
; A "
AB
; A B ( ( " (; "
"5
# " #
" #
, # 6371
1# #
1
#
6/7
1 ## #
# " .
1
#
"
1 1
#
G E 6/7 " . #
1##
C
#
# 637 " . # #
# #
( $ "
"
,
#:8):8 G 1 # 38/< ## # 67 %0 3<9=>
388::#38/:
0 # # # %A "
#
# %A "
# )
3 & #
# . #&
# " . #
H #
0 1;
#
%A
, #.
# #
# # %A
1
;
1 #: G E!
#
#
D
1
.
#
1
#
#
#
B
## #
1; 1
% # %# 1#
##
#
# #: &
%A
# # $ /88 1 % A
"
21 1 # # #
1
###
C
# # #
1)
#
#
#
# #
7
#
##
1
67 1 #
;
6
##
7#
#
6
#
; 1
6
#
# # 6
7 1
C
# # #
# ##
C
#
C7 #
#
1;
6C7
#
1 ; 31 1 #
#
#
# #
# #
% $5 ## #
# %A
% A #
#
# :8I#
C #
7 # # 1
1 1
;
% #
67
# . #&
" . .
,
1 %A
6 5 #
# #
# 6
& % A
# # .
6
7 ,
# 1
C7 ##
# H
# #
#
# 6C7 , , #. #
# 6C
#
;
1
# % A #
# A
#
#
# %A
0
21 1 # 1
1 #
1 &
6 7# 3# . " %
/>:>6<@#/>:>7
$
#
% . "
" "
# " .
5 '##
" "
5
1
H
,; ;
7 & # # &
#&
/>@4 6:3#/>@47-&%
:/I. 67 & #
% . " . 6 & ##
# 1 #
% . " . 6
5 1
1
# # &
1
% . # #
6
7# 6 7#"
4@#& 6
7 5 1
# &
1
# #
# #
# &
#
1
% . # #
6
7# 6 7# "
4@#& C7 & . #&
"
# 4@< . ,
6C7 & #
# # . # &
H" . .
6C & #%A 1
# # #+%A
+1
#
& # !
%
#
31 1
#
;
@ 1 %A
# H #
, # #
%A
#
#
1
# A % #
#
1 )
H H
C
#
# 1 # #
#
C
# # #
A
# # A #
#
% # 1
#
#
#
1 )
# # #
#
# $ :88
# #
#
" ,;
#
# 1
C #
1
#
1 ) 67 =:I# 6# #7 # =,6 7 67 # # =%
67
(
HA
%
* #
#
6@7 *
#
#
#
!
#
# &
;1
# A
% , #. G - # "
:637# 38/<
#
/>6/76 7 />6/767 &
1 #
#
.
# &%
, #
##
1
#1
1
1
1 #
1
#
1
##
1
& 1
# # #
1
:/8?("1
1
# ## #
#
1
1 1
## 1
&
D
D 1
1
"
#
# #
1
#
# #
1 # # #
1
# # 1
#
. 1
; #
# 1
;
D #
1
B # D
1 &
"
386/7 6371
1 .
# 1 #
#
#
## 1
"
38
#+
1+ D ; 1
# #
1 D
"
38 &
;
, #
# # 1 "
# " D #
#
# 1
D
,
# 1 ; A %
, 1
1
D
# ,
# 1 D "
1
##
# ## 1 0 #
0 # #
1 D 1 ) 7 0
/>6/76 7 />6/767 #
% # 2
70
#
##
#
E 0 # # %0 3<9=>#38/:
/>6/76 7 />6/767 C 1) E/> #
# #
7#
F
0
67
#
G
$ 1.45'6'
.5& %+'+ &
# 1 #
## #
#
1 1
C
&
D 1
D ## #
1 # 1 ;
#
C #
##
# # . +
1
#
#
/>66/76 7 />6/767 &
67 )
/>6/76 7
B
#
#
1 A #
/>6/76
1
#
% ,
#
% ! "
#$
J&$/>@3"% 3@4K 1
1
) 6&$ 3=8 /37 E%& L
# #
# ## #
#
1
##
1 # #
##
# #
G
7"& '
' # (
% C 1
1
1
1
#
#1# #
# 1 #
1
1
# ; 1 % #
/>6/76#7 6"%% @989/ >7
& "
#$
%
# #
/>6/7
;# 1
D 1
# #
1
6376@7 D
676 7#
/>6/7 # % %#
) 6"%% =4:
397 E&) L
/>6/76 7 J K
#
1
# #
6<7#
/>
#
/>6/76 71
# 1 #
*
+
## ( #* # , -#
#1
6<7#
/>1
## $
1
;
$
#
1
#
B
1
G 6
0 # #
/>6/76 7
# #
## # #
1# G & . , ' # (
&$
$#
1
#!# *+ " % ) E! &
##
# ##
# ## #
/>6/76 7 #
"
:647##
&
1 E
1
G "
:# 1
#
1
1 $ 1
!
# #
/> 6/76 7
1
B 1
# 1 ## ##
1 1
!
#
#
1 # &1 ##
1 ##
#
#
# 1#
1
& $
! /
$
0
J/>@3637"%$3@>K 1
/>6/76 7
1
#
11
/>6<7 #
/>6/76 7 C
!
# #
!& ! "
# $
J/>@4637"%$:<=K 1
#
1
##
1 # #
## # #
1
!! # #'
"
# $
J6/>=/7 / "%% @=9K ##
1
# 1 #
1
1 @4#- &&#"
" % 1
*
" 1 1
1 # # # *
" "
$
1 #
1
#
" 1
# #
!
1 # 1
# 1
# #
"
# "
1 1
(
;
"
1 1
*
" "
1
1## &
1
# # 1
# "
" # # "
#
/>6/76 7
1
## "
:# 5 ! %
( "
# 1
#
1 0 # #
/>6/76 7 G
7!0 & # ? ,
(H"%H883>H/>:9) J/>:>K &"%$>>:
486/7
% /8:4) ;
#
#
1 E#
1
G &
1
!!
G #
#
; #
#
486/7 #
#
# # 1 #
!#
1
) %
#
#
"
" C
#
& #
1
# #
# # # # 0 # 5!%
1 C# 5!
%
1
#
486/7 # % 1
#
#"
# !
1
!"
#
#
.;5 />@> 1 C
1
.
? ,
# 5! 1 # #
1 .;
1
1
##
# 5!
1
!
*
# 1 # #
"
$
' #1
!
10$# 1 #
1 D #
1
3>637 486/7 />6/767 &
1 1
&
1
# . 1
## 1
#$ #
&%
!
&
&% # #
1
#
. # & ;
# # 1
##
#1 #
1
D
/>6/76 7 #
B #
#
1
1
#
1 +
+ ' # 1
+
+ 'C#
+ #
# ++
;
1 + 1 +
#+1
+
1 1 #+ +
1 + 1 1; & # 1 1 +
1 + # 1
1
##
1 1
!0
1
B
" + #
1
#
% 1
#
1
# #1
1
M1
#
#
1
1
#
1
#
&
1
# C
#
# " 1 #
# .
# # .
#
. C
#
# .
# #
!#
# 0 # # # />>@ />>= D
1
## ##
1 # &%
1 &
C
# ##
# #
D 38/<
#
##
1 ($"" & ;1
1 #
#
# 1
## D
;
1
# &
;
#
##
#1
1
#
"
:6/7#
##
C ($""
!
" ##
1
($""
" C #
#
C
. &# 1
1
1 ##
##
1 # 1
1 1# 1
,
1
## D #
"
:637 1
# ##
1 #
# ##
1 ; 1 "
:637 1
1 1
# 1
# & # "
#
# 38/<
# />>@ 1
1
D 1
, 1
#
1
# ##
1
!$
#
#
0 1 C 1
##
#
# C
#
# $ 4 1 #
#
# #
# #
#
## #
1;
# #
#
##
C
# $ <
# ###
#
$ =
# #1
C
# # # #
"
1
##
# #
"
38# " . #
# #
( $ "
"
,
#:8):8 # 1#
#
1
#
0
1
;
# #
#
/>>@ 1
# 1 #
- # 1 1 1 #
#
#
,
# . 1
# 1 # # * #
#
0 1
#
1
& := 9# , = 9 38/:
#
"
.
"
## ## C
# ;
& < > 38/: 1
1 3= >
# $ =: ($"" ,
# .
, # . ## - #
1
# 1 # #
, #. # #
# # #
1
# # #
" # * # 1 #
1
#;
#
# 1#
# , #5 # . 0 # " .
"
/<697 "
<6/7
# 1 #
"
# /3# #
1
#
#
1
" #
,
,
A
; A "
AB
; A B ( ( "
(; "
" "
38637 1
38/< " . #
# # ($"" D 1
,
# 1 # 1 #
#
0 1
# %
#( 1
# 1 C #.
N
"
,
1
#
" . &
C .
N
"
,
/>9>#
"
D .
N
"
%
#
,
1
($""
"!
#
/>>@ # " 1 394
6 (
* ( %
7 ##
1 C @3888 & 1;
#
##
#
#
#
# #
#($""
1#1
# 1
1
& ;11 1
1 ##
&
# . 1
# 1
1
#
1## "
386371 # 1#1
# #
# #
#
1
1
1
(
# #
D 1
## # 1 #
""
# # 0 1 # D
" D #
#
*+ " %
! !
0 ' #1
+ !
"
1 "0 1
1
# H% #
# &
# ) E' 1 ##
## #
H H
# 1 1
33@# % # # #
1
# # #
#
# # #1
1
% #
# # #
1
#
# %
"
#
C #
#
;
1
# &
C
#
C
# # # &# C #
# # C
#
% #
#
1
# # #
%#
# + + #
# 1
# # # 1 A ) E9 E G # # #
# 1 C E G
1 ## #
F #
1
##
0 1
D 1
"0
1 C E
G &
1 !!
1
*+ " % 1) E C + +
& #
#
C
&
#
#
#1
# C #
+ C #
## G & ! !
67
*+ " %
#
1
1 # 0
1 # 1
# 1 ##
#
"
38# 38/< 1
# 1 ## #
' #
+
#
#
"#
# +
#
#
E
#
#1 # # #
+ % D 1 ##
# # 1
38/<
#
1 #
# ; # #
# #
##
#
1 #
C #
# #
"
1 # 1
##
D
#
&1
## #
#
#
#
#
# #
"
##
"
1
1
# 1
"
:637
/>6/76 7# % #&
1
"
38 # # />>@ #
#
# 0
#
1 11 1 # 1
##
1 #
# 1 1
;
# D 5 # 6(*"*.$'!$7 5.
3 38/@6-&".&--7
5.