← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20055/2015allowed

Punjab Technical University Non Teaching Employees Association Jalandhar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-06-02Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri48 pages

        

  



  

  

       !  " #    $   



 



  "

        !  " #    $   

!

"

#$



%   &  #    

       !  " #    $  

%&'

(')*+*, - .,'

/

%'$()*'+,-($ "&%(*"*.$'!$ *'+,-($"

"&%-&".&--



 / 0 $  #-  1   

1     2 3   #   $  2 4 0     

    5  2 

  )( (  "

"

  #    67 %0 3898/#38/:

(  ,

"    1 (  "

    ( ( ; ;    #    67 %0 3<9=>#38/:

( ; , "    1 (  "

  #    67 %0 388::#38/:

( ? "





   .  

 ( " " ,

  #   4 < %0 388::#38/:

#   3 %0 3898/ 3<9=># 38/:

( " ? "

   #   < %0 3<9=>#38/:

( * "

" 

  #  1 2/ 

 0  

 # # 

 1      #

   

  6 # ;1  ++# ; #  71    

  />>@6  +/>>@ +7    

  1              #  

  

   # " # #  

!

 1

 "  1      

 

   (   $   "

 "  

 6 # ;1+($""+7      ;1 ( $ "

" 

 

38/<6  +38/< +7



1  1  #   #

     # " # #    1 ,1

 #     

 #





 ,

 ,  A

; A   "

 AB

;  A B 

( ( "

(;"

   "    

 " #  

 ,

#            & # 

1 



  

1 #           #

 

    

   1

 

 # # 





1  ## #

  



" .       

1      

 #   

  

 11     

 # 

 

 0 1

 C    #  1  # 1   1  1

    

# D  #38/<  ($""

"

, #            #      1            #     D        ($""   ; 



##    &%0 3<9=>#38/:

     # %    &   #         

   D   "

:# 38/<    #

1 

/>6/76 7

/>6/767  #    %    #  &

  "

  :637  #  38/< 

         # 

 1

1      C 

     

  

 # ($""              #

   

    

  #   

  #

    #   



 "

:6/7#38/<  # #      

    #

#    

 ##

           #



   D       



   

      #   

   #    

    1       ##        #

1    #  %0   388::  #  38/:        #     

    #      

    6 

   

7  

             

    1 #   # "

38 #38/<    ($""1

      # 1# ($""          

"

1 # .   "

38637# 38/<  

     #  1 #      1   

   

  />>@   

1      3898/#38/:    #    1 ;    

   1  

  

 

1  

#

1

  

 # ($""      #

   

 

   ($""1

#    

          

"



 1          D       (""  #

##    1

       

   

  

  0

"  #    

  

 1

  

  ##

  6" 7  D     

 1   



"      

     

#

 #

   , 

   +    1

  D    # " 

     #  

  "



    

      # 

#      

  

 

 1   

11 

          

       #   

   ; 



$$0 )& "

36#7#/>>@   + + 



 

   

      

#  

   # #    #

    # " # #     1

"

<# />>@ 

#1   #  1

 

 1) E<  1   #  

  6/7 (;     #  

 

  

 

  

$  

 

             

 

    #   #    

 



  1  637 .               

%   

   

 

      

  # # 

    647 &   #  

  

 

  

 F 6<7 *

 C           # 

 

  

     

   1  7 "

    #     # %

    C   #      $   

   C     

 F 7 "

  

     

 

      F 6:7 %#      

1  $  F 6@7 &  # 

 $  



 

        

     D    

               

# 

  $  

  -  

  

 F 6=7 &     1  #

1

  





 

  C

   B  



 # $  F 697 &     *

 * F 6>7 "      





#   #     ;

    #     

   

   1 # F 6/87 ' 

    



  D  # 



  

  D 6//7 5   



#   

        F 6/37 *

 (    1 1

    ##  F 6/47 &     67    

5  F 67 C  , F &# , F

7   , F 6/<7 (;  

    #       #

   

   

 1

  

 ;1 6/:7 (;  # 67    #  % %   

  F 67  

 

 F

 

F 6/@7 %               ;     F 6/=7 $

  #    # #

$

" .   %  .  

  

   D       #   #          #    

#     F 6/97 



  1 

 

1 #

   D    #   #   G  "

:

   

   1

# " #    

" #  

 , #. #          "

:6/7 637       C   1) E: 6/7   

  1

 

C 

  1   #   

 1 # " #     

" # 

 , #. #         F 637 1 



  

1  #            #

  

 

   1

 #  

  6/7

1  ## #

 

 # " .   



  

1     



 #   

  

11

     

 #   %



     .;5     F 

 67  #

 ##

      # 



1 1  #   

   C    #    

 

     

       # 

   

 #  

   C   

 1 

#  #   # 

  

            $  F 67   

      

   

C     

               C    #    

       #    

          

        #1

D



  #

 C 

'# D  

"

/<697   

   1) E/< 697   ,  #  .   

     "      #         

  

#

1 1  # ) 67           ##   #  

 F 67           %

  

  # !

%

#  #        #      #      #  

  #  & H

 H

           

E" 

  %  G         #         #

  # & H

 H

 F 67              

 

# 

# !

%

 7   

 F 7 #        #  F 6 7      5  H  %  H"

 H   #  

  #       

 F



6#7      #     ##      ) 67    ,  F 7      # #

        

  #,;

F 7 

 #   1   

 

   

  #  F 67 

 #  #    #  F 6;7      

          D #  ##

# #

 F 7        

# 

##  ###  F 67    # #1;

 

   G "

/@

# A  %   

 1

  C  ) E/@ 6/7  A   %   

   #  

#

1   

!

%

% 

 "

       .    #  

!

5  #A 

7   "

       .    #  

5    #  

    

&   F

7 1  # , #.     % # , # .  637  A  %  

   , # . 

# 

   "

)&

 E 6/7     

     1

 

 

 C 

  1   #  

   ,

 ,  A

;  A   "



AB

;  A B   (  (  "  (;  "



  "5 

# " #

       

   "  #        

 , #             6371 



     1#    #



  

   1

 #

 

  6/7 

1  ## # 

 

 # " .            

 1  

   

 #   



"

   

   1 1

         

 # 

 

 G E 6/7 " .  #    



1##  

 

    C 

 #   

 # 637 " .  # #



  #   #      

  

 ( $ "

" 

  ,

  #:8):8 G           1      #    38/<  ##     #    67 %0 3<9=>

388::#38/:

0   #  #     # %A "

 # 

 

    # %A "

 #    ) 

 3 & #  

# . #&



      #    "  .       # 





   

 H   # 

    

            

        

            0  1;     

                    

  #

     %A



 

  , #.       

  

 #     #  



   #               # %A 

1

;     

1   #:  G E!    

 #

#

  D  



     1

.  

# 

    1

#   

    # 

    #



  

    B   

##  #   



   

 

1;   1



 %  # %#    1#



##

 #

#    #:  &

%A    

 #    #  $ /88     1   %  A



 "

21   1     # #    #

 1      

    ###

    C 

        #  #  #

1) 

 # 

 #

 

 

           #  

  #     #   

   

          

    

 

7    

 #    

     ##         

  1

67    1      #

;

  6    

 ##     



7#

   

  #   

   6     

       

 

           #  

;  1 

   

6



# 

    

#  #   6

7            1

     C 

 #  #   #

#   ## 

 C  

 

# 

  C7  # 

    #   

  1;

6C7 

# 

   

 1 ;      31  1    #  

  

 #     

   

    

 # 

    #  #

    #       #      

%     $5     ##  #      

     #   %A

%  A #  

#

    

 #  :8I#   

  C  #

  7  #       # 1

          

    

  1      1

   ;

 

       % #

67           

 # .  #&

" .  .

,



1  %A

6 5   # 

#     #

 #   6

&              %  A

     #    # .     

6

7 ,  

# 1

             C7 ##

# H 

 #    # 

#

     #   6C7 ,   , #. #

  # 6C       

 # 



    ;

   1

 # %  A #  

 #  A     

  # 

  



# 

   # %A

0

  21   1   # 1

      

 1 #

1   &         

    

 6 7# 3# .  " % 

  />:>6<@#/>:>7 

$

   #  

         %  .    "

" "

 # " .  

5   '##

" "



5        

  1    

H

,;      ;

7 &         #         #  &



   #&

 />@4 6:3#/>@47-&% 





   :/I.   67 &     #  

      %   .      " .   6 &          ##              

  #         1      #

  





        %  .  " .   6

5  1        

 1

  

     #   #      &

    1

        %  .  #  #

 6

7# 6 7#"

4@#&   6

7 5  1       



#      &

1

       #             # 

       #   #      

 #   &

# 

   1

  %  .   #  #

 6

7# 6 7# "

4@#&   C7 &   .  #&

"

 # 4@< .   ,

6C7 &    #

 #      #       .  #  &

H"  . .

  6C &       #%A      1

 #         # #+%A 

+1

   

       #

&           #    !

 %

 #

  31   1 

 # 

 ;      

@      1 %A 



      #     H   #  

  ,        #       #  

%A  

  

   #

 # 

 1

  # A  %  #

#

1  )   

 H  H   

 C 

    

 # 

      

   # 1 #  #

  #  

  C 

 #    # #

A  

     #      #   A   #

 

   #

 %  # 1

 

   #     

#

#

1 )    

 #   #  #

    

  #  

  # $ :88  



#      #    

 

 

    

   #  

  

   



"   ,;  

  #     

#   1

 

  C #



 

 1

#

1 ) 67   =:I#          6#          #7  #    =,6 7 67    #  #    =%

67   

    

   

(  

  HA 

%        

  

      *  #

         #               

    

6@7       * 

#



 #  

    #

!

  #

#   & 

  ;1

 # A 

%  , #.  G -   #      "

:637# 38/< 

   

#     

/>6/76 7 />6/767 &    

     

  1    # 

          #  

.     

     # &% 

 ,    #

##

1

  #1

  

 1 

  

      1

 

            

  1  #

  1

  

 

 #



  1              

  

  ##

  1  

 

 &    1

# #    #

 1

  :/8?("1

  

            1       

     #       ##          #

   

 

  #   

 1

1  1    

       ## 1

    

&   

  D         

 

       

 D  1

      1 

"

 #

#   #

1  

 

#     

 #   #  

  

   1  #      #     #                   

  1

 #       # 1   

   #  

.       1     



;            #

# 1  

;

  D  #    

 1

 

B    #     D  

1 &

 "

386/7 6371

 1  .   

   # 1   # 

 #

       #  

      ##  1

         "

38  

  #+

 1+ D    ; 1       



#   # 

    

  1  D   

"

38 &      

  ; 

,      #

    #   # 1    "      

      #    "       D             #   

            



 #

#  1 

 



 D  

     

  , 

    

  

  # 1  ;  A  %  

, 1

   1        

D  

# ,

 

 #   1   D   "   

 

     

1

              

 ##

   

 # ##     1  0       #  

 0  #   #

1 D   1  ) 7  0   

  />6/76 7    />6/767  #  

%    # 2

70 

   #

##

 # 

E 0 #       #    %0  3<9=>#38/:



/>6/76 7 />6/767  C   1) E/>     #         

  #   # 

 

   7#

 F   

0

67

#   

     G       

 



                

  

 

$ 1.45'6'

.5& %+'+  &  



 # 1    #

     ##   #

#  

  1   1       

        C

   

&  

        D        1      

   

 D       ## #

1 #     1    ;

  

          #   

   C               #

   ##

 #  # .  +

1

   #

#

/>66/76 7 />6/767 & 

  

         



 67    )     

/>6/76 7 

B 

#

 #



 

     

 

 1 A #   

/>6/76

            1    

#

     

%  , 

#

%    !  "

 #$

J&$/>@3"% 3@4K 1

1  

  

 ) 6&$ 3=8 /37 E%& L

#   #



#  ##         #



 #    

      1

        

 



  

 



##



1 # # 

 ##

  #  #  

          G

7"&  '

 '  #   ( 

% C   1      

 1                 



    1      

   1      

               

 

     # 



 #1#       # 

#   1 #

  

1

    1



 #  ; 1 %   #     

/>6/76#7 6"%% @989/ >7

 & "

 #$

 

%

 #     #   

 

  

/>6/7

   ;# 1 

D  1   

   

 #    #

1



 6376@7    D

 676 7#

/>6/7 # %   %# 

) 6"%% =4:

397 E&) L  

/>6/76 7 J K

   

   #       

1

 #  #

 6<7#

/>   

    #

/>6/76 71

   

# 1   #

   * 

   

         +

 ##    ( #*  # , -# 

  #1

      

 6<7# 

/>1

     

##   $ 

1

  ;

$

  

        #

    1

 



       # 

B   

          1

       G 6   

0  # #   

/>6/76 7  

   # #



       ##   #   #  



  

  1#    G & . ,    ' # (

 &$

$#

1

#!#   *+  "   %         )     E!  &     

       ##

#      ## 

#    ## #

      

 />6/76 7    #  



 "

:647##

     &   

1   E

 1           

 G "

:#  1

        

#  

1   

  

1       $  1  

!

  # #

 

/> 6/76 7 



 1 

B 1

  #    1    ## ##

1  1

   

!

  #

 

   

     # 

   

  1              #    &1                 ##

1  ##   

 # 



# 

#      1#



 1

 



      

 &     $

   !  /

      $

0 

  J/>@3637"%$3@>K 1  

      

 />6/76 7     

  1              







 

 



 #   



   11

        

 

 

/>6<7    #

 

    

/>6/76 7 C 

!

   

      #   #   

     

!&  !  "

 # $

  J/>@4637"%$:<=K 1

#    

 1

    

 



  





##

  1 # #



    ##     #     #  

        1



 

!! #        #'     

 "

  #  $

  

   J6/>=/7  /  "%%  @=9K         ##

 1

 #  1  #  

  

          1         

  

1 @4#- &&#"

"    %   1

*

" 1     1

1  # #    # *

"      "

$     

 1          #    

  1  

   # 

" 1

      #   #

!

1    # 1  

  #    1  

#   #

"

   

# "

1  1

   (      

;    

"

   1     1

*

" "

    1

  1## &  



1

   #   #  1

 # "

    

"          #          #    "

    #    

  

/>6/76 7 

1  

 ## "

:#      5  ! %

  (   "

    #  1

  #

1   0    #   #

/>6/76 7 G

7!0 &     #  ?       ,

(H"%H883>H/>:9)  J/>:>K  &"%$>>: 



486/7

%   /8:4)   ;        

  #        

# 





       1   E#  

  1

G & 

   1

!!

G  # 





# 

  

     ;         #  

 #  

486/7   #            

   #  

   #       #   1  #  

       !#

  1 

  )  %       

   #



  

  

     

  #  

"      

"           C

#    

&      # 

      1

    # #

     #    #  #  #      0 #      5!%

 1      C#   5!

%

                

     

     1

   #

486/7 # %  1 

  



 #  

 

 #"  

  

           # !

  1  

!"

 #

       #

  .;5    />@>     1      C 

  1       

   

       

. 

 ?  ,

   # 5!   1   #  #

    1      .;

 1

1

## 

  #                     5!

  1   

 !

  *



   # 1  #  #   

                "



   

     $  

 ' #1 

   !

10$# 1           #      



  

   

 

   1  D     #

1 

3>637 486/7 />6/767 & 

 1    1

 

        

        &    

  1  

# .   1

   ##  1 

     

#$  #      



&%

!

&  

   



      

  &%          #       #    

   1

  



      

 

#

.  #   &   ;

 #    # 1

 

         ##

   #1  #

1

    D     



/>6/76 7   #

B #

#

1

1

  #

1  +

 + '  #            1

+

+     'C#  

   +  #  

 #  ++      

;

 1     +  1 +

   #+1

 +

1     1     #+    +

1 +      1        1;  &     # 1       1  +

  1 + #        1  

  1

      

   ## 

  

   

1    1

   

!0

1   

B 

  " +  #  

  





   

    

 

1

 

       # 

  

    %  1



  #     

  

 1     

 #   #1

1

  

M1

 

   

 

   #

 #

 1          

1  

#  

 

   1

     

  

   

  #



        

         

                     

   

    &



    1

    

 #  C 

 

 #

  # "      1 # 



# .  

 

  #  # .    

  #  



 

  

      

  .        C



   #



 # .   

 



  

    #   # 

   

!#

   

  

    

 #    0 # # #   />>@        />>=   D    

   

       1  

 ##  ##

1     # &%     



  

1  &  

 C 

   



#   ##

   #  # 

  D  38/<     



 #

 ##

 

   1    ($"" &  ;1

    1  #

 #   

#     1

## D



     ;  

            1     

  

                      # & 

 ;

 

#

  ##

   #1     

  1

   

 #

  

 "

:6/7#

  

 



   ##

   C ($""  



!

        " ##

  1

($""  



 



 

"    C  #

 # 

  C 

  .   &#  1

  

  1 

   1   ## 



 ##

 1 #  1

    1   1#      1



,    

  1    

##           D        #

        "

  :637  1

 #    ##



   

  

   1       #     

         

    # ##

1       ;   1    "

  :637  1

1      1 

  #       1 

        #  &          #   "     

#   

 

    

 # 38/<   

#            />>@ 1

   

1

 D  1

  

       

    ,       1

     

   

#

1

  

  

  #       ##

 1

!$

 # 

  #  

0 1    C    1

    ##

            #

  #             C   

           

   

                           # 

   #            $    4 1 #

# 

     

   #          #    

   #     #    

 

 

      #                     

 ##       #

   

   

1;   

#   #

  #     

           ##

         C 

   #      $  <

 

# ###

  #

    $  =   



#   #1

 C 

     

          #   #  #    #      

"

 1

   

     ##

   #  # 

 "

38#      " .   # 



 # # 

 

      (   $   "

 "  

  ,

  #:8):8    # 1#  



        

      

 

  #

  1

     # 

 

         0  

 

      1

       ;

#  # 

#   

   />>@ 1       



# 1         #

-   #   1          1   1    # 

   #  

   #    

  ,

#  .   1         

            # 1  #  #   *   #     



#   

  0 1

  #   

  1

  & := 9# ,    = 9 38/:

      #               

"

.    

 "

 

 ## ##           C 

 #   ; 

        &          < > 38/:  1

1     3= >   

# $ =:  ($"" ,

  

# .      

  , # . ##  -    #         

 1

 #     1 # #     

, #.       #      # 

 #          # #   

 

 

   1  

 #   #   #

 " #    *      #       1       #  

 1



#;

 #

    

                   # 1#    

  

#    , #5     # .   0        # " .    

 

"

/<697 "

<6/7



  # 1 # 

 

"

#    /3#      #                  

    

1

      #   

#   

 1

       "  #  



  ,

 ,

A

; A  "

 AB

; A B  ( ( "

(;  "

       "    "

  38637  1

 38/<   " .   # 

 # # ($""   D  1    

        ,      

   #  1   # 1   #  

 #   





  0  1          

           

 #  %

#(  1     

     #  1   C    #.

N

"



 ,

 1

 # 

  " .   &  



        C  .

N

"



 ,

 

/>9># 

  "

    D        .

 N

 "

 %

  #        

   ,

    1      

  ($""     

  

"!

#     

 

 />>@    # " 1 394

   6    (        

    * (  %

 7 ##

 1 C  @3888  &    1;

 #   

    

##

#  

 #   

    #



          #  #            



   #($""  

   1#1    

#   1  

1 

   & ;11 1  

      1              ##

    &   

# .  1

  

 # 1

1  



 # 

  1##   "

386371    # 1#1

      #         # 

  #        # 

 

              #  

 1

      1

1

  ( 

# #





    D 1  

   

## #    1    #

""

# #   0 1   #   D

     " D          # 

#    

     





 

 *+ "  %

! ! 

0 ' #1 

 + !

"

1 "0 1

1

      

  

   #    H%  #

 #   &

      #    ) E'  1  ## 

##  #   

   H H  

 # 1 1    

33@# %      #  # #

   1      

       

#  #     #   

 #   

 # #     #1

1 

     % # 

#  # # 

        1   

        #     



  #  %

"

      

 #

  C   #

  



#

;

    1   

  #     & 



      C 

  #  

 C

 

 

# #   #     &#  C   #



 # #  C 

 # 



 %        #

 



   # 



 1

 # # #

  

%#

#       +    +    #      

          #    1

      #  #     # 1 A      ) E9  E    G           #            #  #   

 # 1   C  E  G   

 1 ## #



       F           #  

  1      

  ##  

0 1

 D 1

 

"0

  1  C  E

 

  G &     

  

1 !!

1

 *+ "  % 1) E  C  +  +    

      &   #

 #

 C   

 &        

  # 

    #

 #1

   



 #     C #

 +       C #  

 ##     G &  ! ! 

  67 

*+  "   %          

     

   

   #

       1  



1      #  0 

 1       #      1  

      # 1   ##      

#

 "

38# 38/< 1

    # 1 ##  #

  ' #  

 + 

# 

     #  

"#

#   + 

 #

  #   

E

# 

  

   #1 #  #    #

 + % D          1         ## 

#   # 1  

 38/<          

       #  

    1  #

    

   #   ; #  #

 #   #

   ##  

       #   

1 #

C #



#   #

 

"



  1 #   1

   

      

            ##

           

          D

  #



    

&1

 

##    #

 

           # 

     





   #

       # 

       

#



       #          # 

 

 "



  ## 

    

"

 1

   1

  #  1 

"

:637   

/>6/76 7# %  #&

1

"

38   #       #    />>@      #   

  # 

#  0

 # 

1  11   1    #  1 

 ##

  

         1              #  

       #        1  1



;  

  #  D   5  # 6(*"*.$'!$7 5.

 3 38/@6-&".&--7

  5.