← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1005/2023disposed of

Chaggar Singh (Deceased) Through His Lrs v. Union Of India And Others

2026-05-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

  

           

    !

  ,

" ) -*  !"!#$%$&

 .    

'( !)* 

   $$$- 



$$$*           '(     + $,!  

-   $ - + $ !

.!

  $    /$0123 + $,!

" + -    /$$   ,$!

 4 -,   !

"  5555  ) (*    

+"   -    

 

       

     



   3 

/$012 //0!1 ! " "!# $%   &    $ *   !$ 

+"     

                

$

-2- /  6 ! 7$00$72

        /$0123 4  $       !

            !   $  %&   6

    # 

 3

6  #   !

 3     

        

           

   

          

   

                        



   !"!""! 

#     

 $    



#   #   %       

            

 &

      #    '

  # #         

   

 &

  

 &

   #  

 #          

  

 (   )  *    

 &

    +       

   

  , -

, ' ./0"000   )       2   34

-3- 5 6

          

  , -

'  

         $""&      

+   

   

     

 

 +      '

   # 

 

   

          #

  

 7    

 &

   #  

       

            #

   

  

 #  

        

 &

 #

      

   #   

 

      8

 

  # 9       

   !  6    

 8!

 

           !

       

   8!

 

   ! $$ 



 ! "# $ % ! &

!

*$ 277   

6"! 9  0$7$70:  ! 

 !

 6 6 

'  '''

  ()

 * "  " 

!  +  % , - !  "

!;$

-4- <  !  

  

        "!    

 6  9  



  !     

  !

   

6 6 !  

     

     $              !      = >  !   ! 

   ( .. !

.. "#" ! !/ -.$/ " $0

$ "

!1  ( '-22''; # 6

 !- !#" ! !/   -  )

%"!2 $

$  ? * -2 '16   0  226      6  

    6      

  66   $*   /$00 $&2334%#%!)%536*   /$0 !- !3$ .   ! !

 3 ( 62637%8 ,," ..3#%! 0      #  

 



 

 '   

         (4 6

-  : ;  :

; )  )   < =  #    '

<= >"**6''$$> 

#     

   6    #  5  

       

 4  

    '

#   

       

+     ) ,  #

 '

       = > "0 6'' =

 6' 00" 

   '  

-5-             

        ?   

  

    

   6   #  5 

>   

   :

;

   

      

   @ " )  

    ' #  4    /#   > "A

   ' / 0!&"" :/

 

 

 # 6     = < ;       , '    

  

        ' )       >  '  

 B ?C  #        

   

    

    

    C   

      

 4       ,  '  #       4  

     '  C 

  >   '      

    

   #          

 4        

 

     'C     +      #     

   C > 

>



 

   

4 

        

>   4   

     '  

> # >

   @    

:

;   

  

     > >   +       4 

 

          

:

; > # >   +  

-6-     

 '9 62637," !- !4%#%! ( ,#

   6 '

   

  

   >       

    +    #

     

     

   '   

          

        

   > >               

   

 >         C    

      

   

:

;    

4           

 

     

  C 

 

   

- #

      

 

   

    



 

      ,  ' 

    ,  '    #  

              

     

   >  6  $*      

 

     '

 

  

9  6    !   

   6    

  //0!1 



     $=6   

   

   

$  

( - !    !

      !

        8!      "!   0$7$70:     ! 

  !

       6 6 

'  '''

 ()

* " "

!

-7- + % ,- ! "

!;>6    &! 6  #   !

    *$  277         8!

   !

    6:) -8!

 -  0@ !   $$00

&

  !   !!

   0 $ :;         !

'(     '(   

            !  $ :

; -  

  !  "!  

 +  % ,- !3$.6     !    6          !

     $ :;  8!         1$%3%!1 ""

    + % ,- !3$.$ :

;  !       

   

$ :.; -  6     6  '( 9 !

 !

 

  '( 9  3 " '(   

            

      & #!         

     '(   A#!

! $ :<; 

 ! '(   '( $ =

 .     )  * ?++@         B  &

9*  C / B *   C /