← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1007/2023disposed of

Joginder Singh (Deceased) Through His Lrs And Others v. Union Of India And Others

2026-05-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

  

           

   

  +

.  ' /(    !"#"$ ) ) 0    



)



*# +,

 



  &&&/  



&&&, 

   

     %&     -&.#!

/    & / !  -&#

0#  &  

2&345 -&.# $ - /

 

2&& 1

.!&1#  5 / ! .

# $" 6666  '

&(    )*+,  *  /   

 

        





 

  !

     

2&34  1123 #"$  $# %  &'   (

  & ,

  

#& 

-,    



    

 



 

 &

-2- 2   7 #

 8 &33&8

   "

 

2&345

&  !

   

 #     

 

 

#  

  &  '

(

7

 !

% 

  7  %

#

     

        

           

    

          

   

                        



   !"!""! 

 #      

 $    



#   #   %       

            

 &

      #    '

  # #         

   

  & 

   

  &

 #  

#         

    

 (   )  *    

 &

    +       

   

  , -

, ' ./0"000   )       2   34

-3- 5 6

          

  , -

'   

         $""&      

+   

   

     

 

 +      '

    # 

 

   

          #

  

 7    

 &

   #  

       

            #

   

  

 #  

         

 &

 #

      

   #   

 

      8

 

  # 9 1

   

   #

 

7

  

  9# 

!



"



  



  #    

   

   9#







#  & & 

 !" # $  %

 #

,&88  

7  $#

:



 3 &8&83; 

 1#

  "#    7 7 

&  &&&

'(   ) !  ! 

  *  $ + ,   !

<&

-4- =

#  

 

  

  $#

  

 

7

:  



  #

 

  

 #   

 7 7 #





  

 

  &        

 #

  > ?"  #

 1#

    '

 --

-- !"!  . ,-#. ! #/  # !

0 

' &,112&&<

  % 7

 , "!  .   ,  (

$!1 #

& 

@ ) ,1 &07

3



 7

    7

 

  

 

7

 "

 

 77



 &, !  2&33 "$4 6#!

#'#758 (

 2&3 , 3# -  #

 #

 '

59#: ++   --3!

# 0      #  

 



 

 '   

         (4 6

-  : ;  :

; )  )   < =  #    '

<= >"**6''$$> 

#     

   6    #  5  

       

 4  

    '

#   

       

+     ) ,  # 

 '

       = > "0 6'' =

 6' 00" 

   '  

-5-             

        ?   

  

    

   6   #  5 

>   

   :

; 

   

       

   @ " )  

    ' #  4    /#   > "A

   ' / 0!&"" :/

 

 

 # 6     = < ;       , '    

  

        ' )       >  '  

 B ?C  #        

   

    

    

     C   

      

 4       ,  '  #       4  

     '  C 

  >   '      

    

   #          

 4         

 

     'C     +      #     

   C > 

>



 

   

4 

        

>   4   

     '   

> # >

   @    

:

;   

  

      > >   +        4 

 

          

:

; > # >   +  

-6-     

 '9 ;

59+  , 6#!

# '

,#

   6 '

   

   

   >       

    +    #

     

     

   '   

          

        

   >  >               

   

 >         C    

      

   

:

;    

4           

 

     

  C 

 

   

- #

      

 

   

    



 

      ,  ' 

    ,  '    #  

              

      

   >  6  $*      

 

     '

 

  

9   !

7  

#  

 

"!

  7   

    1123



"!

 

&>7    

"



 

 &  

& /  #  

 #        #"

  

    9#  !

 $#



&8&83; 

 1#

  "#          7 7 

&  &&&

'(  ) ! !



-7- * $ +,  !

<>7  ( !# 7  %

    #

     ,& 88:       

9#

!

  #

   7 ; +

/9#  / 3A #

   &8&33

!(

 #

# #

  3 & <=    

 

 # )*   

)*  

      !

   "!

 #  & <= /  

 #    $#

 

 *  $ +, 3#-7   

   1#  

 7          

 #      & <*= 1 9#

    3"#5#3  

   * $ +, 3#-& <)=  # 

    "



 

 & <0= / 7    

7

)* :!

 # #

  )* : "$  )*   

 

 

 !

"

"

   

( % #   



 !

   )*"

 

B% #

1#& <.= 

 

# )* 



)*



& > ) 0     '  ( ?++@         C   (

:, 

  2 C  , "   2