Som Lal v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"
!# !
$!!
! !# !
#%&'
#'()*) + ,,
! -". ,
/ !/
/
!"#
!$
% &!'
( !"#
! ' !"#
)* + !/
/
, 1%2 , -
.
!
# **/0**1
%
2
$
.
0
.
3 3
4,56
# ##
7
3
,88+*889 "
$
%
&
* -
#
#
.
!#
# .
$
%
,/8/,919! #
,:81,9:,;
:53 ,:81*889 . #
<,81*889 ;.
. ,88+*889.
<,81*881- .
#
.
.
<,81*881 -
. #
.
#="
3 &3
.
#
. .3
#
#
#
#="
"
.
# #
:53 # %
. # ,:81,9:, < &
#
#
"
#3
"
3 *8,+ .
#
3 >
3 3
.
3
.
<,81*881 <,81*889 + #
#
7
3
#
#
#="
.
3
,88+*889. #.
#
.
.
<,81*881 ;
3 #
#
. #. 3
. 3
.
? 3 #
3#
# #
?
3
.
.
#
$
3. #
#
;
#
#
3#
3
? 3
##
3 "
.
#
# %
# ?
3
.#
#
3
? 3
# #
3 #
.
#
.3 #
# 3
. : ;
#
@2
@2)<8*
,8,**889
+*8 +/1 +/5 +1,2 %
- @2. 3
3
#
.
%
3
% ##
#
! "
#
#
#
A
#. "
!
> =,< *1,,*8,1;
3 @2.
# 3
.# "
3
.
/ #
!
> =*
# .
.
#
#. 3
,88<*8,8. 3 #
#
. 3#
" #
"
B
. "
"
2
)* #
#
"#
3
.
#
. #.
"
3
.
#
.
-
#
3 B
3
#
3 "
#
#
3 B
3#
,:81,9:, #
2 . "
< #
#
$
<,81*889
<,81*881 - "
2
)* < # = * - "
)/<++00C085 * !
#
,18<*889 B
3D
)/<++ E &
$
"
,18<*889
.
,:81*889 (
.
,:81,9+9
$
%
3
.
7
,8 # ( B
3
,8 # #
#
"
#
3
$ %
)+1+918
#
#
$
#
.
"
,:81,9:,
.
.
##
,:81,9:, - #
##
" # . 3
.
#
. # .
"
3F> $
G .
#
.
- #
#
3 B
3
#
3
#
3 B
$
,:81,9:, # < - %
<2 )< )*
),9:8
-
898+*889
. # . $
$
),9:8
898+89
"
<,81*881 ##
,:81,9+9
$
"
. ,:81,9:,
## .
<,81*881 . $
3
#
3 B
3 #
3 B
3). #
#
3
$
%
3
#
$ %
<,8189
<,81*881 1 #
!
> !=, . #. .
% =<1+8*8*8 #
#
#
$
"
#
3
3 3
3 3.3 =
#
-
. *881*8,5
#3
.
3$
3 # % ;
#
% .
$
#
.
% = =/9*,*8,*. #. .
# !
> =< 8981*8,*- # .
%
.
# #
.
. .
# ,8 8880= 5 #
!
> =:
. 3
.
!"#
%
#
#
@2
# -
"
%
"
!
> =5 ,<8**8,+ #
$
3 %
;.
#3
3.
.
3 *8,+
9 #
.
"
.@ 3
,88+*889 .
3
"
.
3 *8,+
##
3
. . .
3@(
#
%
!,/,
%+34%5% 6'17* /&%&'
7+8%9 %+3
&4'1*
,991<%-+/5
;
#
"
. 3
,88+*889
.
<,81*881. 3
. 3
#
3.
3
.
,8 ( !"#
)* +
#
. B
3"
!
> =:. #
.,:81,9+9
.
.
<,81*881;
. 3
("
!
> =*
3 *8,8
. # *,,,*8,+;
"
. @2
#
.
(
3 #
.
3
8:,,*8,+;
3 # 3 (.
;
.
#
#
456 3
,, 2"
#
,* #
3
. #.
"
#
.,:81,9:,
:53 ,:81*889;.
.
,88+*889
3.
<,81*881-
# 3.$
,88+*889
. 3 >#
<,81*8,9
3
.
&
#3
#
.
3
.
3 *8,+
. .
3
#
<,81*889. # 3 - #
"
3,88+*889
<,81*889. #
.
,<
3
%
!
# <88=! %
2 E3#$
3 ,91, %
(
# Hon'ble %
#'
:)+%+3%+ 1%*%3 6'1*7* /&%&'
")4%1 %+3
&4'1* ,91,*%%<<8
"
#
.
.
3.
;
3.@
=222 %
2
.
%
2
# %
- "
# =
!
"
$ % &'!
( )*+,
-+.
(,
/ 0
# 0 0
% #%
010 2# # # 2# #
& 0
#
0
% # % /
#
%
0 #
#0 #
0 3
4 # # $# !
4
0 0
#
$
&
% / 5
0
5% 0 #
/
6 0 0
/ % %
0
0 3 #0 3
4 #
%
0 0
#0
#
010 2# %
% # # # #
-
$ 7
! $ % )*.1 $ !
8.)
/ 9
9 9 0 3 : )( ,(, ( ,
0 % # 9 #
; ,+ - %
(
#
Hon'ble % .
.
3
/&%&'
4%1:4%+3 %+3
&4'1* 6'1*7* )&'+31% <7=%1 /1)6%*&%6% %+3 %+ &4'1
*8,<,*%%*,8
Hon'ble %
3
#
.
.
3. )5 ,/
# = .
&
:
% % 1 #
< $
65 =
>
? &@ ( ).,
$ AB
4 < :
<% 5 %
% 0 0C
.
#
0% /
:
0 / D & %
3 0 # $%
D &
# 0 #
#D )
D D % % 5 #D & 5 # % 0
# D E 5 0 /
0
-A
/
0 0 % %
0
<5 6
$ =
F )+ G $
$
!
*8 #
2# #
2# # 0
& 0
H
&
/
# #
# 0
#
#0 0 $ : >
&/ $ (*,;
&
;
5 0
0 0 # : AA1:
&
*
# I ;
: AA1:
& C
6 #
#
0 ;
= 0 % 0 /
#
:
# 0
0%
: AA1:
& 0 5 0
# # 0
# # ;
,:
# # # .
.
###
.
3. .
3"
. ! #
.
<,81*889;.
#
. . @2
# .#
. B
3
. ,9:, ,9+9-
#
3.
>
#
3 .
3.
# - @2 .
,889*889 . 3
3
. #
#
3
#
.##
3
#
!#
#
. 3 #
..#="
##
#
3.
#
#
.
3 "
!
> =,<
*1,,*8,1
. #.
3
B
# . 3 # 3
= %
. "
!
> =*
. #
. #3 "
<,81*889 <,81*881 . =
- "
!
> =* 3
# ,/ - #
. . "
.
3
.
. #"
3 #
.
F"
.
3
# .
"
!
> =:
.
#3 @2
3
# "
.
B
3
)"
*8,+ -
3
#
.
3 3
. #"
,1 "
.
3 .
-
4/6
3 3
. #"
3 *8,+.
"
<,81*889 -
##
<,81*889
3
.
3 ,5
#
#
3
.
? .
3 3
=3
3 ,88+*889
<,81*889
.$
.
.
,88+*889
<,81*889
,9 - 3
3-
3 *8,+
3
.
.
# % "
.
> 3# . # , 88 8880=
$. #
.
3 *8 # 3
.
3
496
/6
*, -
3 #"
# 3 % # 0
>
3 .
# 3
##
.
. !/
/
!>1)2
E
$
0) E
0)