Excise And Taxation Commissioner Haryana v. M/S Sita Singh Engineer @ Sons (P) Ltd.

  
    


 !

"#$ %$&'(')* + 

,
 



 

 

  

  

 
 



  

  !



 * -.  .

-.  
 /$($)#* ( "0#"')12""23"/4 $56#7%8&"#$
$)$/"24"/7")" /6)'2")3"/4%8&"#$ /#9$/$(5)%$)#  ":$(9')%"2 9$ 223')1;6$(#')( 2"33$/$/$ $//$%<7"/7")""= /'<6)"2##9'(&6/#8'%$/%$/%"#$% 

5"(($%')   ++ >

?

* @ '!

A9$#9$/')#9$ "&#(")%&'/&60(#")&$( #9$&"($4#9$ ("2$ <6(<%'$(<7#9$/$(5)%$)###9$$=5/#$/

5"(($)1$/<6($(;6"2'

'$( /$=$05#')6)%$/$&#')

B! #9$$)#/"2"2$("=&#4 ,C

''!

A9$#9$/4  )  #/6$  ")%  &//$&#  ')#$/5/$#"#')    #9$ 5/8'(')( $&#') B! #9$$)#/"2"2$("=&#4  ,4#9$(65527 <6(<%'$(<7#9$/$(5)%$)###9$ $=5/#$/ 5"(($)1$/<6($(&62%<$2$1"2279$2%#<$ - /#9$56/5($ &052'")&$3'#9#9$"1/$$0$)#/ /%$/ //')/$2"#')#$=5/#- 5"(($)1$/<6($(C

'''!

A9$#9$/#9$/'<6)"2&62%2$1"227'1)/$#9$:6%10$)#

   5$=6/#/$5/#$%"(

 + !#9"#3"( ;6#$%")%/$2'$%65)<7#9$/$8'(')"2"6#9/'#7')9'( /%$/%"#$%



C

'8!

A9$#9$/#9$/'<6)"23"(2$1"227:6(#'

'$%')%$&'%')1#9$ "55$"2  $=&26('8$27  /$27')1  65)  #9$  %$&'(')  

D"/)"#"E"'196/#/$5/#$%"( BF+B&'#$% <$ /$  '#  )  <$9"2    #9$  "55$22")#  ")%  "<(26#$27 3'#96#&)('%$/')1#9$%$&'(')/$5/#$%"( B

G !&'#$%<$ /$'#)<$9"2  #9$#"#$C

8!

A9$#9$/')#9$ "&#(")%&'/&60(#")&$( #9$&"($#9$ $=$05#')')/$(5$&##("2$ <6(<%'$(&62%<$ "223$%')#9$"<($)&$ 5/$(&/'<$%$8'%$)&$') /0 #  $(#"<2'(9  #9"#  (6&9  <%'$(  9"8$  "&#6"227  <$$) $=5/#$%CH ##9$8$/76#?($#42$"/)$%&6)($2 /#9$5$#'#')$/ "'/27 (6<0'##$%#9"#')8'$3 #9$:6%10$)# )-<2$#9$65/$0$6/#') #"#$ D"/)"#"E"8I"%"&96'2%$/(8#.#%")%")#9$/4

 !  F4#9$;6$(#')()0/$(6/8'8$ 9$/$ $/$)&$'(4"&&/%')1274%'(0'(($%

":$(9')%"2!

6%1$

"/(9")')19!

6%1$

+ 

, 0E A9$#9$/(5$"E')1>/$"()$%*

$(> A9$#9$//$5/#"<2$*

$(>

B