High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15556/2017dismissed

Dalbir v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-01-23Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&' (

)

(

)

(

)

(

)

*+$, "!$!$&", -% ! !" ,. & &/!0",% "%1&/"&!% 2' 2' 2' 2'3 4255 3 4255 3 4255 3 42552 2 2 2 ,"%"&!' 2, 06* "%7 *8/9# !"8

,!0"1"!$!$&", 5528:4;

5528:4;

5528:4; 0"1"!$!$&",0 %1, ."/ ,!0"$%%6 &#" 7,$!!0"& !6," < &/ <6%/$,"#!$&=!0","%1&/"&!%!=, &!!0"1",<$%%$&!16,#0 %" &"7 7" 1& +. /"*"!$&= !0" */ &" ,< 0$% *$#"&#" &/ ! /"#$/" !0" 1"&/$&= ,"1,"%"&! !$& / !"/

$& !",<% !0" ,/", / !"/ >(

1 %%"/+.!0$%6,!$&)>)

( &+,$"

8!0"1"!$!$&",0 % **"="/!0 !0"$%,6&&$&= +,$#??$*& ! &"1 ! &/ $% *% 1,1",!. /" *", " 7 % =, &!"/ ,<% *$#"&#" @AA 2AA &

70$#07 %9 *$/61! >

@ &/0 % +""& ,"&"7"/ 61! >

) 0" 1"!$!$&", 0 / 16,#0 %"/ ,"

6+*" ,,"* 6& +" ,$&= >( ,< 0$** , 6& 6%"8

0 /6,= ,0&

7"9",8!0"% $/7" 1&7 %%!*"& ! "*0$ &/ $!% 6&!, #"/ ,"1,! 7 % %6+<$!!"/ +. 2"!,1*$! & 2 =$%!, !"8 "*0$ 9$/" ,/", / !"/

) 0","

,"8 !0" 1"!$!$&", 16,#0 %"/ ( +," 1$%!*

) ,<2A%&/$ 6&6%"82 &% 86&B +& (

@ 0"% $/7" 1&7 %"&!","/$&!0$% ,<%*$#"&#"+.,"%1&/"&! !$%

6,!0",<"&!$&"/!0 !&" >/ !"/ >

7 %,"=$%!","/6&/", "#!$&% >) 8 8 > 8> )8> &/ 8 >8 @ !0",<% #! ! *$#"! !$&$!.2 &% 86&B + = $&%!&"2 0"%056< ,,"%$/"&! 2 &% :6&B +;8 70 7 % ,6&&$&= =6& 06%" $& 2 &% :6&B +; 0" 1"!$!$&", 7 % %?"/ ! 1,/6#" 0$% 7" 1& 7$!0 < = C$&"% &/ !0" 10!#1. !0" ,<%*$#"&#"70$#07 %! ?"&$&1%%"%%$&+.!0"1*$#" &/$&!0$%,"= ,/ ,"1,!/ !"/

7 %=$9"&!!0"1"!$!$&",$&#" 0$% 7" 1& 7 % &! ,"*" %"/8 !0","

,"8 !0" 1"!$!$&", 0 / $*"/ )>)

( *&=7$!0%<"!0",1",%&%!$!*"/ %D2 &B56< , &/ !0",% -% ! !" ,. & &/ !0",%E , %""?$&= /$,"#!$& ! !0" ,"%1&/"&!%!0","$&!=, &!1",<$%%$&!!0"<!16,#0 %"&"77" 1&%+. /"*"!$&=!0"*/&" ,<!0"$,*$#"&#"0"% $/7,$!1"!$!$&7 %/$%1%"/ &>(

0","*"9 &!1,!$& !0",/",1 %%"/+.!0$%6,!/ !"/ >(

$%," / %6&/",' D0$%1"!$!$&$%/$%1%"/ 7$!0 /$,"#!$& !!0" $%!,$#!2 =$%!, !"80 BB ,!*?$&! !0","1,"%"&! !$&&&"F6," ,=, &! 1",<$%%$&!16,#0 %"&"77" 1&%+.!0" 1"!$!$&",%8 $& #&!"F! ! !0" #$,#6<%! &#"% !0 !!0","$%&#,$<$& *# %"1"&/$&= = $&%! !0"1"!$!$&",%&# %"8 %1",!0""*$=$+$*$!. #,$!",$ 8 !0" 1"!$!$&",% ," "&!$!*"/ ! 16,#0 %" &"7 7" 1&% &/ !0". +"$&= &! $&9*9"/ $& &. !0", #,$<$& * # %" , >/ !"/ >

6&/","#!$&%>) 8 8> 8> ) &/> &/"#!$&%

(

,<%#!8,"=$%!","/ !*$#"! !$&8 $!.2 &% 86&B +8!0".76*/+""&!$!*"/

, !0" 1",<$%%$& $& # %" !0" ,6*"% 1",<$! "#"%% ,. %!"1% +" ! ?"& ! #&%$/", !0" ,"1,"%"&! !$&&&"F6," 7$!0$& 1",$/ !7<&!0%&# %"8 &. !0"1"!$!$&",%

$*"% &.%6#0 11*$# !$&+.=$9$&=/"! $*"/ $&/$9$/6 *1 ,!$#6* ,%8!0"% <"< . *%+" /"#$/"/7$!0$& 1",$/ !7<&!0% !", !0","#"$1! %6#0 11*$# !$&E ! $% 6,!0", %6+<$!!"/ !0 ! !0","

!", !0" 1"!$!$&", < /" ,"1,"%"&! !$&/ !"/

!!0","%1&/"&!% ,#<1*.$&=7$!0$&!0" ,/",/ !"/>(

+6!!0"% <"0 %&!+""&/&" &/0"&#"8!0"1,"%"&! 1"!$!$&0 %+""& $*"/ 0 9"0" ,/*" ,&"/#6&%"* ,!0"1"!$!$&",$&/"! $* &/ !", ! ?$&=$&!#&%$/", !$&!0" #!% &/#$,#6<%! &#"%8# <"!!0"#&#*6%$& !0 !!0"7,$!1"!$!$&$%&!< $&! $& +*"+"# 6%"!0","1,"%"&! !$&< /"+. !0" 1"!$!$&", , %""?$&= 1",<$%%$& ! 16,#0 %" &"7 7" 1& & !0" */ *$#"&#"0 % *," /.+""&/$%1%"/ +.!0$%6,!&>(

+.$%%6$&= /$,"#!$& ! !0" $%!,$#! 2 =$%!, !"8 0 BB ,8 70 0 % +""& %?"/ ! ! ?" &"#"%% ,.%!"1%7$!0$&!7<&!0%&# %"!0" $%!,$#!2 =$%!, !"80 BB , 0 %&!! ?"&!0","G6$%$!"%!"1% %/$,"#!"/+.!0$%6,!7$!0$& %!$16* !"/ 1",$/8!0"1"!$!$&",# &&!+" **7"/! $*" &!0",7,$!1"!$!$&&!0" % <"# 6%" #!$&%""?$&= /$,"#!$&!!0" $%!,$#!2 =$%!, !"80 BB , % !0","<"/. 9 $* +*"!!0"1"!$!$&",$%! $*" #&!"<1!1"!$!$&$&# %" !0","$% 9$* !$& !0",/",1 %%"/+.!0$%6,!$&)>)

(0","

,"8!0$%1"!$!$&$%&!< $&! $& +*"$&$!%1,"%"&! ,< &/$% !06%/$%<$%%"/ %%6#0 :552;

:552;

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

) 0"!0",%1" ?$&=A," %&"/

"%A 0"!0",,"1,! +*"

"%A