High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19183/2016dismissed

Satnam Singh & ORS v. Commissioner Hisar Division & ORS

2018-05-10Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()

)

) !"'!*%'+,!'-",#.& #"%"%'#.& /& **%&&%'#.%&!. %0%&%'%&!.!'-",#.& #&1'-#'"& 2(3 42 552 2(3 42 552 2(3 42 552 2(3 42 552 .#&#'"( 2.6!7 !%'8-0$!"#8

.",#1#"%"%'#.& 2.!9.!:,2,9'"!8 8!.7!'! 552 8 552 8 552 8 552 8 ,# 1#"%"%'#.&,!0# 1.!7#- .",# %&&9!'$# ! ;.%" %'",# '!"9.# $#."%.!.% . <9!&,%'+ ",# .-#. -!"#- 1!&&#- :7 ",# ==#$".8 %&!. :7 ;,%$, ",#7 ,!0# :##' !&>#- " -#1&%" ?8) )@ ' !$$9'" &"!*1 -9"7 !'- ?)@ ";!.-& .#+%&".!"%' ## !'- ",# .-#. -!"#- A 1!&&#- :7 ",# **%&&%'#.8 %&!. %0%&%'8 %&!. :7 ;,%$,",#!11#!= %=#-:7",#1#"%"%'#.&!+!%'&"",#.-#. ",#==#$". ,!&:##'-%&*%&&#-

':.%# 8'#!B9.%'+,&' %.%'+,#C#$9"#-!.#=#!&# -##-%' !09. ",#1#"%"%'#.& ,%&,!= &,!.#%'",#=!'-$*1.%&#-%' 5,#;!" )85,!"!? *#!&9.%'+ >!'!=&?*!.=!&&%"9!"#-!" /%==!+# %.8#,&%=!'- %&".%$"%&!.' ?;,%$,;!&.#+%&"#.#-'

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

#=7%'+91'",#%'&".9$"%'&-!"#-)? ,!&&9:*%""#-",!"@ .- &"!*1-9"7%&.#<9%.#-":#1!%-% ",#1.1#."7%&9'-#."#'!'$7 .!1#.%- *.#",!' 7#!.&!'-=#&&",!' 7#!.&'",%&.#+!.-,#,!&.#=%#- 91'!-#$%&%' ",%&9.".#'-#.#-%'",#$!&# I'%=59*!.7!= I'%=59*!.7!= I'%=59*!.7!= I'%=59*!.7!=/& "!"# !.7!'!'-",#.&J "!"# !.7!'!'-",#.&J "!"# !.7!'!'-",#.&J "!"# !.7!'!'-",#.&J D ED%0%=E )) '.-#."1.0#",!"",#1.1#."7%'-%&19"#;!&%'1&&#&&%' ",# .- 1!."78 ",# 1#"%"%'#.& ,!0# 1=!$#- ' .#$.- 6!*!:!'-%& . ",# 7#!.& A8 !'

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

"#.1#.9&!= ",# .#$.- !* ",# $'&%-#.#- 1%'%' ",!" ",#.# %& ' *#.%" %' ",# !.+9*#'"& =#!.'#-$9'&#= .",#1#"%"%'#.&,#%'&".9$"%'&8;,%$,!.# &9+,"":#!11=%#-"",%&$!&#8!.#""!==7%'!11=%$!:=#:#$!9&#",#=#!&# !"#'!'$7%&!&%'#<9!''",!""&,9=-:#*.#",!' 7#!.&!'-'" =#&&",!' 7#!.&;,#.#!&%'",#6!*!:!'-%&%"%&';,#.#*#'"%'#-%'",# =9*' .#'"!&",;*9$,.#'"%&:#%'+1!%-:7",#1#.&';,%&%' 1&&#&&%' ;#0#.8 ",#.# %& ! 1.#&9*1"%' ".9", !""!$,#- " ",# 6!*!:!'-%& %' "#.*& #$"%' ?? ",# 9'6!: 4!'- #0#'9# $"8

A;,%$, %& ",9+, 1#' " .#:9""!= :9" . ",!" ",# 1#"%"%'#.& ;#.# .#<9%.#-"=#!--$9*#'"!.7#0%-#'$#'",#!:&#'$# !'7#0%-#'$#"",# $'".!.78 ",# #'".%#& %' 6!*!:!'-%&8 ;,%$, !.# 1.-9$#- ' .#$.- :7 ",# 1#"%"%'#.& %' .#&1#$" ",#%. $!&#8 !.# !+!%'&" ",# 1#"%"%'#.& :#$!9&# ",# 1&&#&&%' !+%.5!9.%&'".#$.-#-!&!"#'!'".!=#&&##

? ,9&8!* ",#$'&%-#.#-1%'%'",!"",#%'&".9$"%'&-!"#- )? !.#'"!"!==!11=%$!:=#%'",#1.#&#'"$!&#%'",#!:&#'$#

!$" =!'-:#%'+'"#'!'$7.'=#!&#;%",",#1#.&'%'1&&#&&%' ",#.1%'",!&:##'.!%&#- '0%#; ",#!

.#&!%--%&$9&&%'8-'" %'-!'7*#.%"%' ",#1.#&#'"$!&#!'-",#&!*#%&,#.#:7-%&*%&&#- D552 E D552 E D552 E D552 E )

)

) ,#",#.&1#!>%'+@.#!&'#- ( #&@ ,#",#.#1."!:=# ( #&@