Chhote Lal v. Union Of India And ORS
!"# $%&%!'()*+*) CHHOTE LAL
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
( ,-
* ./ .* 00000
!
"
# # $ %
&
!
!'
((((( / .* 1* 2 Seeking setting aside of the order dated 30.01.1995 passed by respondent No.3-Commandant, 35 Battalion, Border Security Force, Amritsar, and the subsequent dismissal of the appeal by the Director General, Border Security Force, New Delhi, vide order dated 11.12.1998, the instant writ petition has been filed. ) !* " ! " "
+
&
,-. / *0
1122 + ,3 * " 4 )
5
! "
6 "
7 ,
!
$ 181229 11224 "$ ! $ !
$ +
$
" $:" *
+ ;" +
!
,*
11-0 ! " )
* <
12=> -" ! !
?")<
12=>@0 + " 188 !" )
*<
12=2-" ! !
?")< 12=2@0 A
;
,"! !"
" "
" !
$* + " "
*
= ! " )
* <
12=> ' ,$ " ! ,
+ "
" $ "
; !&
! *
, 18 ! " )
* <
12=2 A
!
" ,$ ""$
*
!; 3 !
$ ;" $
* ! $ !
$ "
, !
+ ,* "
:" $ ;
$ *
"
6 ,
! $ + $$ * + "
!
+ ; "
, *
:" ! "
,* " & $$ "
!
"#
# $ %&% '
(
) $* +,*- *.
+*
,*"/+) /0%
) )
1 )
) 1 2 )
/ 3 % , & ! )
) )4 /! -4 & ) -4 6 / 7 ) 1
/ ,1 ) 80
8 ( 1 9 '
/ , & !: 9 B !
" ,$ " " ; " $ + $
111122>,* ;"!
+ ;
6
)) /5 " )
/&
)
2
) ;) 1 ) ) + 1 2 ) 1
) )
) )
1;
1 ) 4 B ,$ ""
,*"
"
*
;, $
!
$*+ "" $
*
!
$ ; " "$ &
3 * " $ ;
, , "
$
9 = &
!
"
"
+
" "
6
", ,
$ ; !$$, !" !
B ,$ ""
")
*<
1=1122 + , "
"$
12-)0 ! " )<
12=>
! * ; + "
!!
; " , !
! :" ! " "$ !!
"
C ?
!/") 6 # )/ / / , / ) ) #
//,
/ 5 /2 "
) / / /
1!/") 6 # ) / /"
/2 "
) " / + /
!/") 6 # )5 + +
+ ) )
+ +2 ) /
+ +: 8 &
!
"
!
" ,$ "
" $
!" "$ ! $ "
+;
!
!*!
$1>91229 1841229
! " $
; ! " ,3 * "
!
C
!!
" * +"
"+;
!
$1>41229 18=1229 :" !
"
!
+ ;
*
4
" C
!!
*:"
+" 3
*
1=81229D"
+
"! $ , :" & $$ E 194> 821229 ; "
" ,$
;$
$
!" $:"
"
+ " $"
* $
$ , + "
!
$ ;" "3 :" !
&
! *+
1221229 "
$
;"
6
"
7,
:"
! ,!
"&
! * < + ;
,$
! "
,* " &
! * "
+
+ "
; 811229 ; " $ ,$ " !
; "
! $ !
$
,!
11224 ,
+ ! B
" ,
! *
"
$ "
*
; !
" C
! +
11-0 !")<
12=> + " 188 !")< 12=2 $ "
! $ !
$
"
:" ,3 ! ,*"
+ $ '
"C
!
* ! ;" +
""
" * " ;" $ ;
,* ! ; F
E 4 ! 1222 ,!
" B
6, B ;" &
! ",:" +
$ ;,!
"B ;"
= &
+ * $
18112!
+ !
:" !
" +
+! > ' ,$ " "
+
C $* * !;" $+" "
! "$ + 1224 "
**
"" * "; !
=* 2
!
3 * + "
!
"
!
" ;
$
+"
"+ , ""&
! *+ *
"
+ ,$ " ! :"
!
"
", , ! *
$
*
! ;
"+ $ 1 ' " "
&
;
,"! ! "
" ;
"
;" "
$
; + "" +
11 )!
; !
"
$ C
"
*
;
; " * "
* ! ,
+ "
= ! " )
* <
12=> !
*
, "
, !
+ +" *
, "
$ , !
$ * + "
+! "
* !
!"
* *
$
:" $ C
<
8
!=
1; & 1 1 ) ) ) ) 2 >
2
1 21 )1 )
1 1)? )
2
) ) 1)
2 > 1
2 ) ) 2 2 @ ) 2 2
2 > 2
2
? )
) 1 )
2
) 1 ) ) ) )) 2 2 )# )
1
9 ) 1)
/!
) ) 1 )
)
)
))2
&21)) 1) 1 :" !")
*<
12=2 C
! 7 ) # >
1
1 A
) ) )1# )
/!7)
19
+!.) 1
1 ))
>
#
) >
)
1 ))
!7# 9
)
)
)
,!7 # 9
>
2 2
)
) 9
)
) 2
)
1 ) ) .) &2"/
"/!
5!
2
1 ) 1 # >
!B
"
)
1 # >
"!-
1; &2#
)
9
1 )
2
C
)
2 ) 9 )
)
!7
1
>
9) 1 #
1)
1
1 >
C ) 1 #
!&# > 1 ) )
/! ))
# > > ) 1 ) )
5/2# >
1 )
D
!
! &
)
1; &
2
2 )
1
; )
)
!
2
2 1) )
1 2# >
1 )
)
! )
)2 # )
-
& )CE
1! &
; )1
1; & 9
) 1 7 #
) ; 11
! &
2
2 )
1 2
1 )
2
2
)! &
) ) 1
4 # >
1 ) ) 1 # )
)
! &
)
9 1
@
!
"
7 ) # >
1
1) 1 )
1 ) ) # 4
)
)
) 2 ) )
2
!
!
" &
1; &
# >
1 )1 4 #
)1# > 2
1 ) ) # >
0 @ )
!
"
7 ) # >
1
1) 1 ) ) ) # 4
)
)
) 2 ) )
2 : 1 ' !
$ ! " !
;
; " !
"
7,
")
*<
*$
&
! * " &
! * 3 ;"
" $ ! + "
!
; ; ; "
,"
,
! " +"" " * !
*
5 *
"&
! *
;
" " ,
+ + "
+! "
*
11 !!
$* " ,
"
,
"
7:"
!
;&
! *
18 ' $ "
* ! " *
; , " $ * 18= "
;" "
" " ;" "
,
+ *!
+ "
+ !" $ ;
"
" * !
+" *&
!'
*" ;, "
" *$
!
" ;, ,$ "
$ "
*,*"&
! *
+ " 184 !")< 12=2
, ; 18=< " $
"
"
*" !
*!
; ; ;
$
+ " " $
*
!
$ ; " * ! $ :"
$$
* "
" 821229 ; "
)
B3 " ,3
11111229
* ,* ;
" * &
! * + A + ""
+& E 811229 +"
"
"
,$ " !
; "
$ $
$
! ! *&
! *
!
; 19 :" ! "
, ;"* ;
$
; ; $
*
$ "
*
; 7
+ "
* !
$+
;
; "
! &
! *
3 $ " , ;
!
"
!
;
1
"
$ * +
*
!
* "
" $
,
! * !
"
!
; !&
! * *G
$$
;
;!
$"
$ "
" "
,
+ *!
+F" "
" " *"
; "C
!;
"
", +
"
$"
$
;"&
! *
;
" , $ *+ :"
" !
! *$
; " +!
! &
! *
"
$
! * *
; / , ;
! "
"
6 !
" $ ,!
" &
! + ; ! !
; "$ :" &
"
,
" ! !
$
!"!
$ 3 $ !"
, "
; ,* *
,
$ +"
"
$! " * ,+ "
6 ; " ,
$
! $ ,* "
$ " &
; ; $
; ; "
" $
*
3 $ + ""
;
$ :"
"
;*
C
$
1 +" ! ; !!
" ,!
" &
" "
$ ,
,
, "" ; 14 B
" ! ; $
" *
, ,
, *
,* !, " ; "
"
* $$ * !
$ +E $ C
, !
"
F"
*
"
! !
$
"
*+* "!
1= &
3 * " $ ;
" ;" " !! !
$;
, " !"
! + !
$
$
+ ""
*
, " )
*<
12=2 18 :" &
+
"3
+" !
+ ,;
"
" ; * ;" !"! " "
"
;
C " ; !
'
! ""
5 , 122 "
! "
7 ,
,+ % * 122 "
*!
>2* !
+"
""+ "+ ">*6 ;
'$
$ -'0 <
& * ;
!
$ ; 5 , 122 " *!
" >2 * + $ * 7+ "> *6 ' "
" ,
!
$ % *122 ;2* !
+"
" 3 "$ + $ '
" "
! *C
19 ,*
C$
":" + "
" !
* !
"
C" ,
* , " $! !
$ *+ "
"
7
F" "
$ ", !!
;!
$
% *8 1229 "
$ ,!
*
$ "
*
" ! ",
,!
" &
" $ " !
, " ,; $ ,$ ! "
;" 1> * +"
! "$ !
", , " !"
,
"
"
$ "$ !
!
"
"
+
; "
$
! "
; " ! " " " ; "
!
*14* ,!
" ", B ;" &
!
3 ,!
" &
+ " "
6 , , ;" "
*
! + , ,* ;
!" *
12 " ;
$
' $ ! "
" "
! ,+ ,* ,*
$ ;"
!
$
!"
!"
,,*+ :" $ $
$
*, "
"
3 !
&*43 56&* A " !
$
, ,* "
+ "
!"
$
" !" ! !
* !"
14 ! ;+"
""
",
$ $ H=I
$!
$" !! ; !"+
, $ 21.
:"+
;* ! / .* .)1) F 4 F"" ;G
( JGE F""
, JGE