← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23434/2013dismissed

Aman Ranjit Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2015-02-19Mr. Justice S.C. Datta19 pages



  

  

 !"#"$%&%'( ) 

*  

      

         (+, - - 

  

    

 ! "#     ! $

 

  

   %  !

 & '' ( )  *    ' ( ) *  )     '+ ,)

- 

 .          

""/0""1

  2       .     3         4/45"445 671   "7%* 2)   %*)       4145"445675        87   2

7..  - 7 7 # 

)   9 *         :   

                  8;/685/6$<4: 

) 77



         )       

            

  $7% 

2

           8;/685/6$<4),    =92=     

    + >

). 2 )  )* 

     "84"<5167)

 :  

         *

?(        ,

 @ 

* )        

   %   >

)     

 

 * 

     1"<5167"     )         2 

        *   

     "845<<5 67$#   *         *     "4$<<4678 .         *  )  :  

         



               8;/685/6$<4  

  

   *

? ( ) #   %           "7%*  2)    ) *     $41"44167;)      $7%   27 7%   2

)            

      



 *    $7%  2

 

    $445"44167/  %* '   )   

     * )

$8 $1 + * )551  )= 551 =.    )  <$6 75   "14<"441 A *)  "  *      $41"44167;)*       4/45"445671  

                   *    

                        4/45"445 671) *   

  <$   "14<"441*     4145"445 #   

  *    : 

)

  "5"4      ;41"445 6   : 

) *             671 75 :   )   8            ,                     *   8$     *

  9  (   '  #   

       "84"<51         

  -*   <4;)   *

9( )#   %      ,$;1$

5



  

                 = ,  % ' = -*       <"47")*

?(   4;$

48 #

?B   "8$

1   *

9(  *

?(  *   ?    *   /*

?(   .  )  <";7"/)*

9( 

$$$4

 /<8 . </)  

*

?(   4;$

8   

*"8$

1  <"8*

9(    ) *

?(   "</

 . </)*

9(  

 C  @ D  -* )*    678       ) *

9(  $$$4

    <"; *

?(    "</

 A 

>  

 C  D  1

, 1"0$1 *

9( <;87;; <;17;5 #            

*  *      . )    *

*   .  

    <8;78/)  <8<7;4)  <;$7;8)  <;17;5)      *

  9 (     $$$4  

                8<  )



A  

    

      

           %* @ E )  

     6     * 

    "448<11675     

   ,  "8$

1       ) 

  

                 

     * 

    4/4<1567< .       *     4<11)       



 %*  @  E )                 "/<,  1      ,  $$007477"757<7"4)  $8007"7$787;7/71757<7477"7$787;7 /71757<7"4)$;007"7$787;7/71757<7477"      *  *

9( )#      

A 

)

 

   2

)   )*     4"<5"674     )     2 2)  %*) 

   *     "$"<5;67 #  )  :   

      

       ,           

     "84"<5167.  )    

         "448<11    4/4<15 6  75    7<   *        )  )



  

 

       :  

#      : 

  

 

    .

     *          

       "84"<51)    %*  2)      %*)            ,         

     

   *     $41"441 67;)  *)     

 *       4/45"445671     

-*  .  *        *

9(   * , )

   : 

   

 -*  2 .      

    * ,    

    )   *

)? ( )?(  ) )  )(  , 

  *

9( )     *     * %* '   )  )

   67"    )    *

9(      @ % 



-         $4"4$6 7$)   *

9(   ;1<5< #



       

  *

? ( )  *    

#   *

?(            ;   "548<;8)A 

>  

 7         8/  

  ;      #

    *

9(  *, *       /4"<5$  6  78            /4"<5$678*       /<8 )

 *)        *    

          *

9( ;<4 9 ,   *       *  ): 

  *    F*    )     77       

*   7 , )      2  %  *%    *   )  *    

;5 551  88 F A

 2   * @    )<85E )

      *      ;               *    *           * * ;   + F*    * )<1$  

 

*   2 2

 %*

E )  4"<5"     *     2)  #   :

      

         A

2    ?"/; <1$

      : 

   

  #       , 

     8;/685/6$<4    *

?(  # ,       

*

9(  . *           +        

       

 3              A=     2 )    *            

     "84"<5167



)    3      *     3         )     *     )  *     

) :

      * # 

          

      : 

.       

  , 

 

  

   

      *

 9( )?(     7     "84"<51+

          

,          3  

       *   #  )   *

?( 

  

        *

)   

  .             

             *    )

   3     

  

 ,  *  3       +            )                      3    

     +       

   **

  *

9(     *    67"    *    

7* 

       67")

 *   *

)?( )? (  )  )  )( ' , )     *

9( '#   *

9

 

(   '     

0*,        <5$        

     9  )          

  *

9(  , )       . *   *      

  9   )  

    *   551  8/)44)4 48 4; 551   & 

   

  

 

      

    

     

      



      

      

!

        

          !

  

   "              



      

    #

   $" 



  

  

  $" 



"

 

      



      



 !

  "       #      $%

%& 

     

            

       "        

     '$     

!  !   "  

     



 &$   

#  

&($" 

!     

       ( ! 

    !     ! 

 !          !    !       



       !  #

   "         ')         

  &" 

   "           !     !     !  $" 

     *

! "   !   ! 





'

! ((((

  &$             $%        ' $" 

!        $" 

!! 

  





  ( !   "   "             !         



) $%      & +     "       

      ,-!      !    $" 



   "! 

  !

#

"

 

  

 

!

 

 !       

 

  !

   

  ')  

   

    

#

!

  

  $" 

 



.  / #        

)  7    )     *  

   #        , )  *)           

,   *       

*

 ?( )9(   .     



  

)

  %   27 7%   2

     

   **   #    

  **

  )  )?(  )



?( )), )( '

     *

9(  #    * 

 *

?( *  

   )  

  

 *

9( 

            

)       *  * * 2  . ') 7.   E 

 AA

2 

  & *+ , 

*- 

.

/

0 %  )0

*  

 



  

      

 

   "

       #

          

  % 



   

      $"   1

    .      !    * &2&& 3   4 $" (   

        1 56))!$ 7!

    "

3

  

      !   

      #

 1 2 0 %#%&$ 3 (  $"

   * &2& 4 $" (     "

   

 "      ! 

!  

!

        #

               "

  !     "    "

  )  (    

   

         

 



  



    4'

  "   *                           

                 8$" 1

 

$" 1

      9                           $" 1

     1

"       

   

.

(      $" 1

 "

          

     

  

$" 1

 

  

  

  

  

    

 

"



     "

     



     

  5         "   1        :

!     

      "

  

     

 

  $"   1

       9         4      "



    !

  "   65     )      

 !  9   

        "

            *)   

   #    

#   

 

    0        #    

         !



      

     # 0  

    !  

       # ! 

         

              

   ;

  #  "  !     



   

 !  ! !



!        '22       

       

   "

 

 0

          





"   ) 

 !

   !   !  

       



 



        

  #

  

  0

! 

  

       

      )  

    

                 

 



 



 #



          

      

 ! 

    !  "     

  )          

      !     

9       .                 0  

   "



   *   "

 

   ! !

 

     

       !             )

8  " 

   

                       

9  < 

  

  )    #                    

       



             *  

      *!              !   

!       

 

    )

8

  "1     !   .

     "   !

     ! 

 !    *

 "             9  <

 .         

! !

"  "

+      9     .         

#

  

   

 

 

 ( !         "      "   "                

                    

    "   

 )  



    !



              

   

     "  

    

   " "

     "  

         $" 1

  9   "     "

    



""

 

      / @

  **)         #    67"

          *

?( 



  . )               3    * *  E   )               .            *

9(   )    

0*,  <5$    

  )   *

9(           *                    *

  9 (    

): 

  

   *          "84"<51.            

      

 

 *       .

 

*      *  )    

    

   .   ) 

   "



$%7

+,#%/&  $  

 +,#%/&<<8 22   

  &      



  

        

   

 

  



 

              



 

   

   !

   

    

 !

    

    

          "   

       #         



  $  

    

  %    

        &          

     

  !   

 '   

 "

'      %     !      !   ( )  #      



( )  #   

   *+,-./

 

 (  )           

 

#!

 

    ( )     



     



        

  



(

)  0       

               

 #( 

           

+,-.

  

&            

         '



             

     

   1 .* *  )  

     %  2  

) 

*