Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. v. E.S.I.C. & Ano.
! "## $!%&'( )* "#+
,-$./$ 0($123* $$$
4&,& 2(5&/$&,$%($*6$37$68$6
&(3&
!"#$%&!&% '"#()!
# 66 (&!%$($(&2$5.$03&6-,3729
.!36 (&9 ) 666-,372&6,3.(367&9
&'
: 4&6$6$,36$5*3%$* !6(
: 3$&6:$;*3%$* !&(3 #
: /$3(<6,7*3%$* !&(3
===== &% '"*+,
,-$./$ 0($123>!&6?
/ 1@A 6$&$(($%636&,!B,$&67!63&>C,& DE* D+ $3 A,3/%E+D!62(5/$&,$%%*# >! .5 ?6 %@A* 3& &&,3 ,3 /% +D ! 6 % >C,& DF$3 D A$3$&0$&!B,$&676%.,!6 (3 GF )"
## # # $3 #
#
)# #"
#
$& &60 C, D)A06$!,6($5!&&,$%!$0!2$3$2,& 3%7&(3 #(363$&$&606%.,
!6(3$&&60C, DF6$&.0;3,
6 / 16$&;36-,&3%!6&,6 (2&6$(# #
+*6:,%($($*2&$6$3 . (37 %%5 2&$ 6$!* 3 $72 >C, D#A*6(0&3066 ,-$./$%%5 $3$3&%6 ,-$./$%%5$36$&.3&&3*6
/ 16$&$&&,236
6$& . %33 .5 : 4&6$ 6$,36$5* $3 %,&!6(*6$6 / 10$&!$..7$&3.5%7 6 % !2 &(3 # %$27 %., $7 06 6 32$3!3$2$7&$3&
&$2$!%36$6$7332$36$&. $3-,&3.56($!26$%%,!6(D($
: 3$&6:$;*$3%,&$(($7!2(5& /$&,$%($D&(3 #&,.2&6$6(&0 (&2$$$.$&6(D%($6$&$$$ 235.5$(($%676/,;76(0&,3/%F+ >#A>7A$3> A!62(5&/$&,$%%*# E $36& 2$ ! %$27 6 ! ! %., $73 6$ . %3.56/
6&$;!.5*(&&!/%&F+>#A>7A$3> A !6%$C$%36.0'D F+
:$& . 3%33 .5 6 2(5&H &,$% , I>#A!$5B,&3&(,$&&$&I >$A066$5(&&$2(50662$7! 6& % 066 6 & $. ($5 6 2(5H&
- %.,* >.A6$!0$7&$$73$50$7&!$2(5! 6(,(&&!6&%* >%A6$!%.,($5$..5$(%($2(5 &(%!$52(5* >3A6(&06&0$&6(%($2(5&(% !$52(5* >A676!$5(&$5.!$3$&6$2, $33,$6!* #J>A$53%&&,3.56($,3&% ++D$0!$5($52!3(3$&H.!&*K J===K >7A$562$06%6&3&(,.0$(%($ 2(5$36($*.0$(%($2(5 $3 $ 223$ 2(5* .0 $ (& $3 6 ($ .
0 $ 2(5 $3 $ (%($ 223$2(5*&(%!$5%.,.! 63,&($5$.%$.,36&%*)J$5 62$B,3.06%62$5.3%33.56 2(5&H&,$%,,36&%K*&,%6B,& 3&(,#J&,.-%6(&&!&,.D&%> AK&6$. 3%33.562(5&H&,$%,$%%3$%06 6(&&!6&% > A J/,.-% 6 (&& ! &,.D&% > A* 6 !07%$2&K&6$.3%33.562(5&H&,$% ,*$25'I >$A%$2!6%5!%.,!26(%($ 2(5L >.A%$2.5$(%($2(5%%.,&!
2 $5223$2(5L )J===K >3A%$2$7$&$(%($2(5,3&% L >A%$2,3&%F"!6%5!
. $2,!6.!&%3.5$(&066& $0!,536L$3 >!A!$5%$2!6%5!$5.!$32&&.,3 6&% EJ> A!$5(%37&.!62(5&H&,$% , $ 3&$.2 B,& $&& $3 6 3%& ! $ 23%$ .$3 $ 23%$ $(($ .,$ 6$& . .$36&$2$363%&!&,%6B,&& %&&$5!632$!6%$2B,&.! 62(5&H&,$%,*6$,&6$3%6 ($6$6B,&3%33.56&%$3&6$ 6$! (%3 06 6 32$ ! 6 %$2 B,& .! $%%3$% 06 6 3%& ! 6 23%$.
$3623%$$(($.,$*$&6%$&2$5 .* C%( 06 $ $(($ 6$& . !3 .! 6 2(5&H&,$%,,3&,.D&%> A!&% +ED06%6%$&62(5&H&,$%,2$5&! 32$6&&,&$&7.! K +J> A 2$ 06%6 & 3&(, .0 $ (%($ 2(5$36($&(%!$5%., $563,&&6$.$&3.56(%($2(56 2(5&H&,$%,,&&66$&3(&3066 ,!!5(% !6$2,3,!262$&%$23.
336$6,2$5*!$&&.%33 07*0$3,%6$2,.3(&3,36& &,.D&% K >)A%,&6$6$-,&3%3%33$06 $5B,&3&(,$&$!&$3$3-,3%$$5 $.506%6.5,36&%&.3%33.5J$ 23%$ .$3* .5 $ 23%$ $(($ .,$ .5 6 2(5&H&,$%,K (,&$ ! 6 $!23 (&&* $&
/ 2$!3,.6$6(D($6$&$$$235 !%76%.,G3$2$7&$3&*06%6$%%376 (*0$&$..($3
%$&6(D($$(($%6&6/,* 6/,&6$2$;$3$3%36%$2!6(D ($$&C(3,&5$&(&&.*(!$.506$(3!#M 5$& 6($&&6$.$.5(6%$&.5$373%
66$!23.&$&*60(&$3& 3&(&3!
0-'/ *&% , +1 "#()!