High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2022/2015dismissed

M/S Sood Industries v. Presiding Officer And ANR

2015-02-09Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!!"#$#%&'

($)*%*+$ ,#!$ -- ! # #%!, .!,$+$

,!$#*#%/ #"!,% 0!, -- !$1%*!% $

,!$!% &-

,2,3# )#%/04*5" !, 0!1! # #%!, 0!#%$ % 7,# 1! # #%#$*#,!" */#%$ 0!7,** !* 89 %%!:+,! -8 41$$!*;< 0!%*+$ ,#=,#;+%=-"+2->;+, +, 4 4 0%*#/,04 70!,!;< 0! ,!!,!%"! 0$ ;!!% %$7!,!* #% 5+, 0!7,?2%(,!$1%*!% %%*0!0$;!!%0!=*!% # =!* ,!#%$ !2!% 7# 0"% #%+# <$!,5#"!=%/7# 0@;"?7/!$ >!,%!*"+%$!=11!,#%/, 0!1! # #%!,-2%/!2!% 0$ ,/+!* 0 0!>;+,+, 0$!,,!*#%% /#5#%/*+!7!#/0 /! 0! *"+2!% $**+"!*#%!5#*!%"! 7,*$: -( -(70#"0 7!,!#% 0!% +,!),! +,%$%*70#"0,!=!" * 0 0!7,?2% 7$% % 0!,==$ 0!2%/!2!% %*0*% 7,?!*,!5!% $#%/=! *< 0$ ;!!% ,/+!* 0 0!$! ,! +,%$ 7!,! $+#"#!

% $+;$ % # ! 0!1=! 0!2%/!2!% 0 0!,!!:#$ !*%,!= #%$0#1 2$ !,%*$!,5% %*$$+"04 0!A+!$ #%7# 0,!/,* !,2#% #%%* %%-"21=#%"! 0!1,5#$#%$%*+$ ,#=#$1+ !$" *#*% !5!% ,#$!% 0!,=#2; 0!,/+2!% ,#$!*;<=!,%!*"+%$!=#$ 0 +%*!, 0!,!=!5% 1,5#$#%$ 0!) !%!,= !/+= #%$4' 0!0= <!,=<,! +,%$, 0!1!,#*$ 1,#= 9 0)!1 !2;!,,!,!A+#,!* ;!#=!*%,;!,! 0! 05!2;!, 0 <!,%*$$+"04 0!

-- ,! +,%$ 0 0*;!!%**+"!*#%!5#*!%"!;!,! 0!>;+,+, 05! ;!!%#=!*$1!,=7%9B% !% #%,#$!*#$ 0 +%*!,$+"0 " +=$"!%,# 0!>;+,+, 0$7,%/+==<*#$",*!* 0!,! +,%$;< !,2#%/ 0!$2! 05!;!!%#=!*$+;$!A+!% 0!* !$!,5#%/ 0! *!2%*% #"!* !*8B 0$=$;!!%"% !%*!* 0 #%$,$ 0!,!=!5% ,!",*#% 0!% +,! !%*%"!,!/#$ !,(2+$ !,,==$! "7!,! "%"!,%!*4 0!2%/!2!% 7$% ;=! 1,*+"! 0!$2!%**+! 3+$ ##" #%0*;!!%!,!*%*,!!,!%"!0*=$;!!%2*!

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

% %* 0!$2!05#%/;!!% 1="!*%,!",*%*11!%*!* %%!:+,! -=%/7# 0 0!#%$ % 7,# 1! # #%" !/,#"$ %*7$ ?!% 0 0!7,?2%0*%!5!,$!,5!*7# 0 0!2%/!2!% %*0!%"! 0!,!7$%A+!$ #% !,2#% #%/0#$$!,5#"!$ %* 0!,!%!5!,!:#$ !*%<,!= #%$0#12$ !,%*$!

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

)+"0*!1$# #%2*!;< 0!2%/!2!% 7# %!$$# $!=7+=* *!2%$ , ! 0 "% ,*#" ,<$ %*0*;!!%*1 !* % 0!%!0%* #% 0!,!1=< 0!"=#2$ !2!% # 0*;!!%$ !* 0 0!7,?2%0* %!5!,;!!%!%//!*%* 0!,!7$%,!= #%$0#12$ !,%*$!,5% %* % 0! 0!,0%* -90**!1$!* 0 0!2%/!2!% 0*%!5!, !,2#% !* 0!$!,5#"!$ 0!7,?2%%*70, 0!,;%*%!* 0!3; % 0!"%$#*!,!*5#!7 0#$+, 0!>;+,+, 0$ ,#/0 +==<*#$",*!* 0!5!,$#% 0!2%/!2!% %*,"/!% %*5=#* ;$#$0$*,7%%#%!,!%"!/#%$ 0!2%/!2!% $,!/,*$ 0!

-C7,?2%05#%/7,?!*,1!,#*C*<$#% 0!1,!"!*#%/ 2% 0$ ?!%,2 0!* ! !,2#% #%#!8B #$;<%77!==$! =!* 0 #%*#%/$,!",*!*;< 0!,#;+%= "%% ;!"0==!%/!*#%1,"!!*#%/$;!,!,# +, % 0!/,+%* 0 0!!5#*!%"!**+"!*7$#%$+#"#!% ,#%*!A+ ! $+$ #% 0!$2! *!A+"<,#%$+#"#!%"<!5#*!%"!=!*%1#% %* 0!#%!,!%"! " ;!*,7%,2 0!$#*#%*#%/$,!7# 0#% 0!!:"=+$#5!*2#% 0!,#;+%= !!,!%"!#% 0#$,!/,*2<;!2*! 0!*!"#$#% 0! %D;=!)+1,!2!+, #%

0! 2%/!2!% 05#%/ #=!* 1,*+"! 0! ,!",* !%*%"!(1<2!% ,!/#$ !,$! ", 0!1!,#*#%A+!$ #%#%$1# ! 0! 7,?2%05#%/#=!*%11=#" #%#%$+"0,!/,*4 0!#%# #=%+$ 0 7$ +1% 0!7,?2% 0* $ * *#$"0,/!* 0!>;+,+, 0$ ,#/0 +==< *,7% % *5!,$! #%!,!%"! #% 0! 2 !, %* /#%$ 0! 2%/!2!% 0!,!7$%*!=<% 0!1, 0!7,?2%#%,#$#%/ 0! #%*+$ ,#=*#$1+ !$ 0!*!2%*% #"!7$$!,5!*7# 0#%1!,#*7!!?$ 0#$+, *!$% #%*%<#%#,2# <#% 0!#21+/%!*7,* *#,!" #%/ 0!7,?2% ;!,!#%$ !*=%/7# 0"% #%+# <$!,5#"!%* 05#%/,!$ ,#" !* 0!;"?7/!$ @ 2!,# 41! # #%*#$2#$$!*

!"# $% =+"?< 0! 0!, ;!,!!,,!* !1, !,E!$