Surinder Kumar v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. & ORS.


 

       
 

     

 





         



  

  
     !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,3-



  

   !

 

 

  

 



   

"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%4"-&-1+#($"#,#%516#,-78,'+1-% 66-'+$, 7716#%-+9  9%#7',#($-%#)1,$#%"1,+8*#-+$"#1-*#$%16 86"1+#-+ 1+,01$#-7$"#(1%#6$1-+1,,'#($-"1* #48,,#%5#( 41$"8,"-468',#+-$16#-+  $-#:0.81+8,$-4";$"#0#%1-(7%-*  $- 8+(< $-9  =94-%>1+)(8;,?/#+-$ $%#8$#(8,@
41$"/%#8>1+,#%516#A "#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%6"8..#+)#( $"#8'$"-%1$;-7$"#66-'+$, 7716#%= ?$-1,,'#,'6"8,"-468',# +-$16# "#%#87$#%$"#(1,610.1+8%;0%-6##(1+),4#%#1+1$18$#(8,8)81+,$"1* '+(#% -+('6$1,610.1+# 00#8. '.#,B=7-%,"-%$C '.#,C?

"#%#,0-+(#+$,08,,#(8+-%(#%-+<  (1%#6$1+)$"#0#%1-(7%-*  $- < $-9  8+(  $-B   =$-$8.DB(8;,?/#$%#8$#(8,
 +800#8.48,0%#7#%%#(8,8)81+,$


$"#-%(#%08,,#(/;$"#00-1+$1+)'$"-%1$;/;$"#0#$1$1-+#%4"16"48, %#&#6$#(/;$"#800#..8$#'$"-%1$;



#8%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*8(#/;.#8%+#(6-'+,#.800#8%1+)7-% $"#0#$1$1-+#%

1%,$-78..$"#-%(#%-7$%#8$1+)$"#0#%1-(8,
1,+-$ -+#-7$"#0'+1,"*#+$,0%#,6%1/#('+(#%$"# '.#, #1$"#%"1,,#+1-%1$;

+-%"1,68%##%0%-)%#,,1-+-%%#$1%#*#+$#+$1$.#*#+$4-'.(/#877#6$#(/; ,'6"8+-%(#%08,,#(/;$"#'$"-%1$;



'%$"#%1$1,84#..,#$$.#(0-,1$1-+-7.84$"8$'+.#,,$"# 0%-6#('%#0%#,6%1/#(7-%6-+('6$1+)(1,610.1+8%;0%-6##(1+),48,/%#86"#( -% $"# 0%1+610.#,  -7 +8$'%8.  &',$16# 4#%#  +-$  8("#%#(  $-  -% #:$%8+#-', 6-+,1(#%8$1-+,"8(6%#0$1+$"#-%(#%,08,,#(-%$"#-%(#%48,$81+$#(/; 8%/1$%8%1+#,,-%680%161-',+#,,-%$"#-%(#%48,08,,#(41$"-'$8+;/8,1, $"#  E'#,$1-+  -7  1+$#%7#%1+)  41$"  $"#  -%(#%,  08,,#(  /; $"#  1,610.1+8%; '$"-%1$;4-'.(+-$8%1,#



$48,,'/*1$$#(/;$"#.#8%+#(6-'+,#.800#8%1+)7-%$"#4%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%$"8$,"-468',#+-$16#48,1,,'#(/;$"#66-'+$, 7716#%= ?

4"-"8(+-8'$"-%1$;$-1,,'#$"#,8*#  +868%#7'.0#%',8.-7$"##+$1%# 71.#4#71+($"8$1$48,-+.;$"#1,610.1+8%;'$"-%1$;4"-"8,'.$1*8$#.; 1,,'#(  ,"-4  68',#  +-$16#  7-%  (#%#.16$1-+  -7  ('$;  *1,6-+('6$  8+( 1+(1,610.1+#8+(08,,#($"#1*0')+#(-%(#% "#%#7-%#$"#1+1$18.,"-4 68',#+-$16#1,,'#(/;$"#66-'+$, 7716#%= ?(-#,+-$"85#8+;1*086$ -+$"#0%-6##(1+),1+1$18$#(8,8)81+,$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%/;6-*0#$#+$ 1,610.1+8%;'$"-%1$;

D

!#71+($"8$$"# #+$%8.(*1+1,$%8$15#%1/'+8. "8+(1)8%"

#+6""8,%1)"$.;%#&#6$#($"#6.81*-7$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#% "#%#1,+-*#%1$ 1+$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+8+($"#,8*#,$8+(,(1,*1,,#(

 ! "     #0$#*/#% !

 "

'.8$1