High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13978/2018dismissed

Davinder Singh Bajwa v. State Of Haryana And Another

2019-07-05Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

"#$$%&'&()*+, -.

"/&(0$12&(34"56"

$#&#&($1 7$1'*'

2#"#$"1,"(""(#4$1 $'8(0$(#'

! "#$% &'()*%*) $

1$'$(#) 1 9 "+&:.2$(&10/%"#$6&#4 12*(&+0".0/%"#$.

1#4$8$#&#&($1 ' "+&:" (3".."1,"(".

1#4$2#"#$ ;;;;; *) $+& -

00&#&("+ "&0"/&# "+(3 6&#4 <$0&%"+ 1$81# 0"#$0

&'#":$((1$%10 '#"(0'0&'8'$0 =-

1&##$('#"#$<$(#1$'8(0$(#"+(36&#4(($>*1$'

?# ?&'#":$((1$%10 '#"(0'0&'8'$0

4"++$(3$&(#4$81$'$(#61&#8$#&#&(&'##4$10$10"#$0

(($>*1$ @A! #4$ 00&#&("+ 4&$ 2$%1$#"1,. *B+&% $"+#4 (3&($$1&(3 $8"1#<$(#. 64$1$B, %+"&< #4$ 8$#&#&($1 1

$>#$('&(&('$1/&%$1<-,$"1'#A ,$"1'.4"'B$$(0$%+&($0 (A ."'8$1#4$"/$1<$(#'.8$#&#&($16"'"88&(#$0 "'''&'#"(#>$%*#&/$(3&($$1. *B+&%$"+#4(3&($$1&(3$8"1#<$(#.

"1,"(""(06"'81<#$0"'4&$(3&($$1"#$14"/&(3B$$(81<#$0 "'>$%*#&/$(3&($$1"(02*8$1&(#$(0&(3(3&($$1 (1#*("#$+,.&(#4$ <(#4"(*"1,.

=64&+$(&%&"+0*#,"'4&$(3&($$1.<$#6&#4 "("%%&0$(#"(0'*$1$0'$/$1$4$"0&(5*1,4$8$1&84$1"+

&$+0!/&'&(&( B#4#4$$,$'."'""++*##4$"%%&0$(#.4"'B$$(1$0*%$0#"31$"#$>#$(# 1 9 "+&:.+$"1($02$(&1*('$+"''&'#$0B, 12*(&+ 0".0/%"#$.1$81$'$(#&(3#4$8$#&#&($1'*B<&##$0#4"##4$"1,"(" /$1(<$(#&''*$0&('#1*%#&('( =

(($>*1$ @!&(1$'8$%# #4$$<8+,$$''*$1&(3"0&'"B&+&#,<1$#4"( C"(0"B/$#$>#$(0 1$#&1$<$(#"3$1<-,$"1'#A ,$"1' $#&#&($16"'$>"<&($01< $0&%&#, $0"(#"!*1*31"<"(00&'"B&+&#,%$1#&&%"#$1$+$%#$0<1$#4"( -C 0&'"B&+&#, $#&#&($1 '*B<&##$0 " 1$81$'$(#"#&( 0"#$0 A

(($>*1$ @ !1B$&(3$>"<&($0B,#4$ $0&%"+"10%#1'

2. 4#":.B*#6"'1"++,&(1<$0#4"##4$'"<$%*+0B$(+, 1$$11$0B,#4$4$"0#4$0$8"1#<$(#%%10&(3+,."1$81$'$(#"#&(0"#$0

(($>*1$ @=!6"''*B<&##$0##4$4$"0#4$0$8"1#<$(#. &$.(3&($$1@&(@4&$. *B+&%$"+#4(3&($$1&(3$8"1#<$(#."1,"(" 2&(%$(0$%&'&(6"'#":$((#4$1$81$'$(#"#&(.61&#8$#&#&(B$"1&(3 A

6"' &+$04&' *1#./&0$ 10$10"#$0

(($>*1$ @!.0&'8'$0#4$61&#8$#&#&(#0$%&0$#4$1$81$'$(#"#&( "'$#4$8$#&#&($16"'16"10$0##4$&1$%#1. 2. 4#":.

64&%4'*B<&##$01$81#(($>*1$ @ ."'8$11$81#.#4$ $0&%"+"10

#24"1<". 2. 4#":8&($0"'*(0$1)@

"# "!

$"!%

%"'

()*& + ,- 7&0$10$10"#$0

.8$#&#&($16"'%<<*(&%"#$0"

0$%&'&(B,00&#&("+4&$2$%1$#"1,./$1(<$(#"1,"(". *B+&% $"+#4(3&($$1&(3$8"1#<$(#1$3"10&(30$$<$01$#&1$<$(#("##"&(&(3 #4$"3$'*8$1"((*"#&(.&$.-,$"1' 1 "+&:B*##1$''$04&'"13*<$(# B,1$$11&(3#(($>*1$ @=.64$1$B,.#4$0$$<$00&'"B&+&#,6&#41$3"10 # B#4 #4$ $,$' 4"' B$$( $>8+"&($0 B, #4$ "10 4$ %"'$ 0&'%1&<&("#&(6"'"+'8&(#$0*#B,1$$11&(3#(($>*1$ @-0"#$0 =

.64$1$B,($ "::"1.2*B&/&'&("+(3&($$1.646"'

"+'4"(0&%"88$04"/&(30&'"B&+&#,<1$#4"(-C.6"'1$#"&($0B$,(0 #4$"3$-,$"1'*8#A ,$"1'4$1$81$'$(#"#&(%"<$#B$0$%&0$0 /&0$ &<8*3($0 10$1 0"#$0

(($>*1$ @A!. 64$1$&( 0$8"1#<$(#."%%10&(3# 1 "+&:.4"'<&'&(#$181$#$0 *+$=#4$ "1,"("&/&+2$1/&%$' $($1"+! *+$'.

A #6"'"+'%(#$(0$0#4"#0*1&(3#4$8$(0$(%,#4$61&# 8$#&#&(. &%$ #4$ 4&$ 2$%1$#"1,. "1,"(" "%:(6+$03$0 #4"# 8$#&#&($1 &' 4"/&(3 84,'&%"+ 0&'"B&+&#, # #4$ $>#$(# C "(0 #4$ 1$#&1$<$(#"3$0&'"B+$0$<8+,$$'4"/&(3<&(&<*<0&'"B&+&#,-C "(0"B/$.4"'B$$(&(%1$"'$01<-#A ,$"1'.#4$1$1$.4&'%"'$&'

%/$1$0*(0$1 *+$= &!#4$ *+$'.

A"(0&('#1*%#&('"(*"1,.

A. "1%4.

A.81&+.

"(0"(*"1,.

-4$ $0&%"+"10.

/&0$%$1#&&%"#$0"#$0

.%$1#&&$0#4"#8$#&#&($1&'"B+$#8$11< 4&'0*#&$'"(01$'8('&B&+&#&$'"'4&$(3&($$1 &/&+!"(0.#4*'.'*B<&##$0 #4"##4$"%#&(#4$1$'8(0$(#'&'64++,"#1%&*'"(0"++"%&*'&( 0$%+&(&(3#4$1$+&$B,(#1$#"&(&(34&<B$,(0-,$"1'

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

<(&#1"++1$+"#$0"88+&%"#&('8$1#"&(&(3# 4&''84$1$61:"(0'8$(0<1$#&<$(%<8*#$11+"8#8 6&(3# #4$/&'*"+0&'"B&+&#,.8$#&#&($16*+0(#B$"B+$#0&'%4"13$#4$0*#&$' "(0.#4$1$1$.1&34#+,'4&'%+"&<4"'B$$(0$%+&($0"(0.#4*'.*13$0#4&' *1#10&'<&''"+#4$61&#8$#&#&( 4"/$4$"10#4$+$"1($0%*('$+1#4$8"1#&$'.

A *+$'

$<84"#&%"++,1$+&$0*8(B, 1 "+&:4$'"<$1$"0#4*')@ D. !/0

& *

& 2

& & * * #%

2 & * 3

4 5

+ 4

. &7 &

* & 2

1&& &*&

& 7

* 3

& &

- 4$ "1,"(" /$1(<$(# &( '*8$1'$''&( #4$ 81$/&*' (#&&%"#&(.&(#$1<'#4$&<8+$<$(#"#&(#4$ $1'('6&#4&'"B&+&#&$'

F*"+ 881#*(&#&$'. 1#$%#&( &34#"(0 *++ "1#&%&8"#&(!%#.-

$(#1"+%#A!181/&0&(31$'$1/"#&(14"(0&%"88$0."+' &''*$0(#&&%"#&(0"#$0

#&''$##+$0+"6#4"##4$&('#1*%#&('

%"((#/$11&0$#4$1*+$'4$1*+$&'<"(0"#1&+,"(0'#"#*#1&+,1$F*&1$0# B$++6$0B,#4$0$8"1#<$(#' 6*+0B$"&+&(3&(<,0*#,&((#1$$11&(3#(($>*1$ @= 0"#$0

.64$1$B,#4$ $0&%"+"10%#1'3"/$#4$0$#"&+ #4$/&'*"+'*$1$0B,($ "::$14$'"<$1$"0'#4*')@ D4 .

+ 477

#% 4 &

& 8&& *

) 8+ ) 8+

"% $""9

"# 0":

;

;.*& );#< "

= );> * *

5<);

1& *

* .*& ); = ); &

;+ &7 1&

.*& );4 &

= );4 &

? .

;

+ & *

< "

.<)

* *

=<)

:#'

( ,

> &

.<) -

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

1#4$1$"'('"1$<$(#&($0.#4$&<8*3($010$1.&(<, /&$6.0$'(#$("B+$#4&'*1##1<"0&$1$(#8&(&(4$61&# 8$#&#&(&'"%%10&(3+,0&'<&''$04$&(#$1&<10$10"#$0

&'"+' /"%"#$0 &/0-+ *) $ 12 &'56% 4 4 37 18 9:

;

< 3:

4 4

< 3: