Parveen Kumar v. State Of Haryana
!
"
$!
% $&'( ') '*''
'! ') #'
+,- ./ 0 ) 1 ).+ '2 0
, 34
'
6(7"
&$8! " )""
'3 #$ !'
'9- (:
)""
'3 #$ !'
0 &
!
"
! # $ % &
'% ( )*$ +,+-$+., / / 0 / 1& #
$2* ))2 ))- )+3 %/" 4 & +,+$$+.- !
5 6%" / #
& &
&&
+7+$$+.- !
# & !
6 / +)+7$+.* ).
&
&
8 4
/
4
!
% (
& 4 ! 9
1 /
Page no.1 out of 7 pages
&
4 0 4 #
4 8 # )$ & # & !
4
+3+-$+.,
#
8 9 #
& 8 # 1 ( .$13++, " # ! !
9 :4; #
# 8
! 9 !
.+)+ &
/ 1
# # 9 !
9 #
#
! 9
# 9 # &
4 9 :4;
# &!
! +7<))3. # 9 # )) '% # ( #
& ' .2) "/" # "
/ 1& # "
$2* ))2 ))- )+3 %/" # & +* # # =& !
&
).) "/" #
> #
!
#
!
"
#
! !
"
3.
"
!
!
"
!
&&
!
& 4 Page no.2 out of 7 pages
3$ / &
/?.
4 @ #
& A
#
5
4 0 8 #
.7. "/"
& # ! =& !
3) ' # # &
#
& & =&
9 # =& ! 9
4 >
! =& #
#
A 33 5
& # 9 & !
! &
/?.
9
! ! 3, / &
& 4 &
B A !
# , >
!
"
& !
"
Page no.3 out of 7 pages
& 4 &
&
7 %
!&
!
! 8
& & & :8;
2
"
#
# &
4 !
- & 9 #
!# ! !
&
!
& & ! !
=&
&
B 9
* &
/?. 4 @ # 9 #
&
9 #
#
& #
&
/?. # ! =& !
!
:C=/?,D ;B #
# C= /?2D /?2D 10.
The accident occurred on the G.T. Road, as the car was traveling from Delhi towards Karnal. An examination of the site plan reveals a divider along the road, with a break at the turn for village Page no.4 out of 7 pages
Passina Kalan. This turn is only accessible from the right side, when approaching from Delhi, while it would be on the left side for those coming from Karnal. Since it is established by the prosecution that the tractor turned right at this point, it implies that both the tractor and the car were moving in the same direction, from Delhi towards Karnal, as is also depicted in the site plan. Testimony of PW1 suggesting that the tractor came from Panipat/Karnal or denying its position ahead of the car, is contradicted by the site plan. Additionally, if the tractor indeed came from Panipat/Karnal and attempted a right turn without giving any signal, it would be inconsistent with the layout of the road, as the village Pasina Kallan is on the left side from that direction. .. ( !
&
=& :C=/?2D /?2D; &
#
# 9 %
# 9 !
# ! 9 >
=&
# &
!
# ! 9 #
&
=&
#
#
!
# # 9
& ! ! ! 4 !
&
/?. Page no.5 out of 7 pages
.$
# 9 #
!
&
9 & ! 4 !
.) &
/?. 4 @ ! ! &
=&
# ! !
"
! # !
& ! &
&
/?. .3 ' &
#
# & !
& = # # 9 & ! C ! & !9 9 #
!
! !
.*-*
& & ! A 9
# # .,
& 4 & +,+$$+.-
+7+$$+.- !
"
B !
& !
"
4 & +)+7$+.* ! Page no.6 out of 7 pages
!
/ A
& !
/
# '2 0
)""
'3 #$ !' &$)#"
?
D9 E <D(
?
! E <D(
Page no.7 out of 7 pages