← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19331/2016dismissed

Vinod Aggarwal And ORS v. Union Territory Chandigarh And ORS

2016-10-17Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages



      



 

  

"#$% & $%'% ($")*#

# "#$% & &+, -./0+&1(123(+&+0 -./0+&1(&+&1 $%$" +3%#  #

!* 45 "$*

"#$6$""$% 777

    "#$    "#$  6$""$%*   8$!)  #  8   %#  :

$5$ %$ ;*6'5# %$ "#$<  "$= *< + 9$"*$5" *

#*      6$  '5"  #$!

  

     ""

!  % !$ " =>*

?,%'8  *@

?,*A$ '5" 8$)* A)#8* %$C'$ A)"#$"$8% 5 "% '5"#$$

"$* !!"8$"!$""$

 @  :$D'$,;

%%%'$ 

4' !!""$$*8$" "#$$"# ""#$ 5$ % !$65$" $"#$ "#"$$%""#$$ ""#$ B6$

'8 %# !!  A$  6 ) A!$    "#$$  $C'

!  %"

!8$"%*  "#$  %"

!8$"A$ 6 ) A!$

  *$"#$$D6) $)$ 8 "#$

'5"%%$%% %# 4$"#8 > @  * %%$4 $" 8"#$!$""$

@  :$D'$, ;

, ,

#!$"#$ !!""$$ % 5%"'5""#$%"$ C'$%"*#$

'!"$ 8 "#$6 )8$" " %"

!8$"%* #5# $$6 ) A!$

 

 @*"#$$ $*4



 >:$D'$, ;*"#$%"

"$

5$*($")*#

# :$%6 $"@;$%'8$ $"$  B "#$65$ %"$'A%$C'$"!)*4

@ > = :$D'$,@;*"#$

!!""$$ %'8 

?,A) ) $8 

""

%"#$ )8$" %"

!8$" "#$%"$* "#"#$ '"#$$C'$%"""#$ '"#"$% ""8 "$#8"#$$8 '"%"

8'"*6 ) A!$A)#8- 4

  $%6%$  8 "#$  $%6 $"%*  "#$   !  !!""$$  5# !!$  "#$

$%'86"



 >A) ) 



 = *  #5#  %  A)"#% 5'"  4

 :$D'$,>;- $4$*" %5!

$ ""#$ !!""$$5 %"!!$D$5%$ "#$6" $6'5# % "#$%"$' $"#$64%% &'!$,

#: !$ "$% /'!

;&'!$%*  :#$$

"$$ "

%E"#$&'!$%.;* "# "5 %$*"#$!$""$

@ > = $6%"

$8 

"A$5% $$ %#%$C'$%"#$$

"$*4

 :$D'$,;*$%6 $"@"8 !!""$$"# "

%'8  *

?, '$*%'AF$5"" '

"* 55'" %"

!8$"%* "$$%"  $"'$    "#$  $D" 

)*  4 $  !$""$ 

 :$D'$  ,;*  "#$  !!""$$   "#$  8'"*  #5# 

59 !$

$$5$6"

:$D'$ ,=;#$$

"$*4

:$D'$, ;*$%6 $"

>$,"

"#$%"$

4' !!""$$*$D$5%$

6 $%5 ' $&'!$ "#$&'!$%*%'AF$5""6 )8$" 

, , @ ?,$6$%$" ?

 

$$5$A$" $$"#$65$ !!)  "#$  4 !'$  "  "#$  "8$    "#$  "?5!$

5$   !!  "#$ '"%"

'$%" %8$"$ "#$% $,"

$!$""$* "8$)*$ >@?,* %"A$6  "#

)% 8"#$

%%'$ "#$!$""$#$$8 >B 8'" %$C'$ "A$ "#$$ !$C'

!%"

!8$"% *@ ?,$ 5#

:$D'$, ;*"#$ !!""$$

8'"  55 !)*  4 $  !$""$ 

 :$D'$  ,;* $%6 $"@"8 ""#$ '"#"$%' $"#$'A!5$8%$% :45" ( '"#%$ 55'6 "%;5"* :#$$

"$$ " E"#$5".;*$

$, !!"8$" "#$%"$C'$%" $C'$%"$ "#$8 " $!4$6%%$%% "#$%"$""#$ !!""$$#$$

"$*4 8$8 

 :$D'$  , ;*  $#%!

*  #

#*   586! 5$ "#"#$ $% '"#"$%' $"#$5"*# 4$"#$ "6%%$%% "#$%"$""#$ !!""$$

"#$8$ "8$*$# ""

 # ! *5!

8     *#$#

$"$$ " 

$$8$""%$!! "#"#$

!!""$$$

6'5# %$ "#$%"$C'$%"*  A"

"5 %$*

" A"

8"#$54!5'"#$

%8

$'!$ 5'"0:;> =>

 A)"#$ !!""$$"#$8 ""$

A)"#$6$D'"4

:$D'$, ;#$$

"$*' "' "$!)*"#$ !!""$$$D6$ 

- $4$*"#$$C'$%" # ""

 # ! "$,"

$"#$%"$ C'$%"#%

4' %$F$5"$

@

=#$ 66$ $4%6$"" A)#8

%""#$%

,@, $ $$ !% A)"#$#$  8%"

"*(#

# :$%6 $"   ;    4%$  "  "#$   8%"

"*  (  #

# :$%6 $"   ;  4 $   $% 

  

@

$%6$5"4$!)

$4$ A)"#$% $%*# ""

 # !



= =

* #5# !% A)"#%5'"4



:$D'$,=; @ #$  6$""$%  !%    "    "

$  

 $%#6 #"%$%6$5" "#$%"$C'$%""#$

4'*A$ !$

#$%   "#$ !  !!""$$  #$) !%   "   $8 

"%

8'"  "  >*

?,  $ 5#  "

%  A 5$  '$  "

%  "#$ "8$)* #5# $$$5$4$ $$5$6"



:$D'$,@;#$% " !%$F$5"$

A)$%6

=:$D'$,>;* A"# "#$

$8 

"% $$$"'$ ""#$6$""$%#$ 66$

@

:$D'$,; A)"#$6$""$%

%""#$%

!$""$

"$

6 8$"# " )$ %* A)"#$#$

 8%"

":$%6 $" ;4



@:$D'$,

;&$4%6$"":$D'$,

; A)"#$6$""$%

%""#$ !%A$$ A) 4%""#$ 8%"

"*(

#:$%6 $" ;4

 

:$D'$,

; #'%* $$!

$4$

%" "#$ A4$% !$""$? $%

=* 

@  

*%%'$ ?6 %%$ $"

%@* *$%6$5"4$!)*$F$5" "#$5!

8 "#$6$""$% $  $%#6 #"%$%6$5" "#$%"$C'$%""#$

4'*

,>, A$ !$

!#$% !!""$$*"#$6$""$%# 4$ "#% "

6$""  ' $  "5!$% 

?

    "#$  %""'"     *  %$$9

%%'

5$  ""#$ "'$ 5$" "C'

%#"#$

$% 0$ $  5'%$!    "#$  6$""$%  5"$  "# "  "#$ 6$""$%# 4$ !$

)6 "#$$"$ '$ 8'"* !"#'

#"#$$ %8$ $!

)8 "#$6 )8$"%*  #5#6$ !"$$%"5'!

# 4$ A$$86%$ /'"*"#$$C'$%" "

$ "#$ $%#6 #"% %"$C'$%""#$

4'# %A$$ $5!$ A)"#$$%6 $"%"#$

' ""#$%"

!8$"% $,"

$ $$"6 "8$ &'!$,     "#$  &'!$%  $

 $,"

$  %"  $6$ !$  "#  $

$5"  8

 

 "$ 4 '"#'

#"

'!5% """#$5"$"%

%$ A)!$ $ 5'%$! "#$6$""$%* $ " )8$""#$ "6$""   A $  6$'% !    $, !!"8$"  !$""$ 

:$D'$, ;$4$ !%"# ""#$%"$C'$%" %$,"



4'

!!""$$*$D$5%$ 6 $%5 ' $&'!$

"#$  &'!$%*  %'AF$5"  "  6 )8$"    @ ?,  $6$%$"  ?

   "#$

$$5$A$" $$"#$65$ !!)6 "#$4 !'$ ""#$"8$

"?5!$

5$ !!"#$'"%"

'$% "#$% 8'"

%"A$6  "#

)% 8"#$

%%'$ "#$!$""$ $8 >B 8'"  % $C'$ "A$6 "#$$ !$C'

!8$"% *@ ?,$ 5#*

!! '$  *

" %8

$5!$ "5 %$ )%"

!8$"%"6 "#$

'$

"$*"%# !!A$ $$8$ % $,"

58$"$

$5"

,, "  %   

8""$  5 %$    "#$  6$""$%  "# " 

"$  8

)8$"   >B 8'"  "#$5% "  8$) 4 $  !$""$

:$D'$, ;*"#$

"#$: !!""$$;

"6 )"#$ !8$"%-$5$* %6$"#$"$8% 5 "% "#$% $, !!"8$"

!$""$*" $$8$ "$,"

"

9$6!

5$ "#$%"$ C'$%" % $%#6 "#$%"

"$

5$%%$%% 9$ 4$ %6$ $5"% "#%5'"4



:$D'$,=;6 %%$ 

= =

#'%*"# %A$$ #"!)A%$4$ A)"#$$4% '"#")4 $86'

$

 

"# ""#$6$""$%# 4$ #"*""!$"$$%" "#$66$")  %6'"$#'%* $ " )!!$

!")6$4$%")"#$86'

$

$%6 %%$ A)"#$ '"#"$%A$!  $""%* 55 !)*       5"A$*

!  "   #$"#$%6$ ?$ %$

2$%? #$"#$&$6"

A!$ 2$%?