Bhajan Lal v. State Of Punjab & ORS.
!"
##""$ % $$& '$ #$
! "#$#%&
(' $() *$ +(,( &$ ##""$
( '
()"*-* '
'!
.
##""$$ ) ($$##"(/()$$() (& )+$$ 0 1#'2",(("3)
4(*3" (,(("($5&
(6 ($&("'2$ ##""$ & "$( $ $ &&$ $ $ 5 0 $ 1
#'2(#($$&"(*3" 6 '2$ ##""$#"($(&&6(+(&+("&$ '
"("6($ $("1 '&$ ,$($$(&7(6"" $
0 # '2 4#$2 7#$ -" & "(* 3" )*6 '2 (#$$(6 $*("")"( $ $ $($$'"""() $ #((")$$ +$(+*#2("+($ ($$##"
&$$()($ )+$$8 #'2" 4($($3)*3" (6 &($##"&("'2$ ##""$6 (+( ($"2*$ &$#$ #"($$ ##""$#"($(&&
($ #"(#$+$,$'"(4+'*
$3" 1
*$ ##""$6#$$5+ "$2 "'( 9+"(
#(() 6(#"("/#$ (4() ($2*$ ##""$&$ $ "'(9+6+(()&+ ("/#':$"2* 6)($)($$ ##""$(;751$1
$(*1&7,4()$ #2&$ &( )($ $ ##""$* 6 (+( &+ ( ( 5 0 $1
#'2(#($$&"(* 3" "&$ '"("6($ $(" 1 '&$ ,$($$(&7(7$6" "'2$ $($6$ #$('"$ "(:(2($ +#("&$ ' "( " <6* $ ##""$ 6 :($$ ( $ &+$((+("($($$)($ (+.
&$* + #$$($$ 4#$27#$-"&"(*3" )* 3" ,$$ '$ $ + 6 $ ( $
0 ))(*$ ##""$&("($ "")()$ &($ )$ $ 6$)(2 6$(##$($2& () '&#()$ (56'2$ #( () $ ($2$6 2($6$#$('"$ "(:(2 1 =#$(*$ #$##'&$ "$("
,$$$$ ($7$ (6($$$$+$*$ #$$/ #"(+(2' $($ (")&"(+($$(+($('("($2
+($*($6#"'2$ #$$ ##""$($#&+
($($(&$("2 "#"$(6($ $(("$( $(""+$"*$ ##""$ "#$($+"2 "'( 9+(#()&+#"("/#7$6"$$$ $)"(:(2
( 6(#62($6(+#$('"$ "(:(2" &$ '"(".
&$*#"($($$ &(6($$ $$+$6&("'2$ ##""$#"($(&&+2(6&+ ("() $ ( & "(& .
&$* $ ( & $ #$( 6 ("$(+$"2*$ ($&$ ##""$#"($(&&6(+(6($
$&&$*$ ##""$#"($(&&#&##"'&$ " "6##""$,$6 "+$6($ +&$56*$ ##""$
## $ (,$&'$ ! +(,(&$ ##""$(&"2$ ($&$ ##""$ '6)"2 "$'''2"(+($$( .
##""$6:($$'2, (&3((" )($$
($ ($($$)($ (+'2$ #$*6 (*$ + )6 ($#6 "$ ((+("&+(> *$ ($6 &("'2$ ##""$
+()$ $($6&("6""6($ ($ "(+($$(#(&127$6"$$ $$ (+("($"& 6("")"($$($$ #((#"&$" $(( )"(:(26 " ? !$$"'+($$$ $(+#) )+$ '#&$$##($(&$ (( 6($ "6$ &*($2($&'2$ ,$ 7(6&$ )+$#'2$ <@'"#+,$(
!"# $
% " "
&'(
&(
# :$(&"6$:($'
&+(##"'&$ '<2<() ,$6 (($(((+(''2#((&$(&$ '$*
6*($ (,$($1 "2&+$ '$$(":$(&"6+$('"6*$ +('()$/#& ($( (
8 7 $ ""&$ #$(#$ ##'/6($ ('"($7$$#($ ##""$6$ (+(&+ (($&$ (+(")($)($
(+ '2 $ #$ $ * ($ 6 $ $(&$2 $ & $ ##""$6"" (""$(6($ $((""+$$ $"$ ( )&+$ (1
7$ &(+(" AB*($
'6 +$($ ##""$6(+('&$ (+(")($ (+6 ($ '+$($ $)($ $ "6($$(B($()$$ $(+*($6$#$('"$)( 6 $($$ ##""$ ")"(:(2#"&$ '"(".
&(#()626($ (:(26 +$(($("($ $1
#AB41 0 &$ $$(&$ ##""$#"($(&&:"(+($$( #((*($ $'(("() $&$ $6 &$(#$ *$ ##""$6(+(&+ (( '2$ #$($1
6 $ ($ "")() (+("6($($$
*(*&$2&+6 &$("$ ) *($6)'2$ ##""$$ $&$(
) $""2 + ($ '()
* 6 6 :($$ '2 $ (($(",$((+("+$()&+;751 AB$ 1
"))($ (+'2$ #$($ ++$$6 "
((+("7&
($/$ $6 &$(* $ #$($(&$'6""6($ ($ "(+($$(#(&12 <6*('*($(:($"$ $)($$(&(+(" )($$ ##""$($&+$ '(&(+#)&(+("'$($ 6$ "$&(("$($/)($ (+$ (:$('"$$ $(+&("$($ $$& '7$((#((&$ ,$$ &:($$"$
(&:$$ :$( & "(+($$( ( $ #$ .
& $( 1
*6 $ &(+("6#'2$ #$*$ + " ' "")6($ (#(&12.
&*$ ( &"(+($$((()($$ ##""$#"($(&&()$ ($($($$ '2 (+''2"(+($$(
7(6&$ '((* '&$' + $ $ 6$ 2 ($& ( $ )+$ $ 0 1#'2",(("3) 4(*3" $ )+$ $8 #'2"4($($3)*3" "$$"2*$ ($$##"( '2(+( () +("" ##"($( * (& 2* "" " $ (#&()"2 !)"(,++($$(($$#2+$($+( ,(#" *! ! > $ #/()C DC5 > $ #$'" DC5