Harbans Singh v. Union Of India And ORS.
!
"!#$%&'&$ (
) "*"$+',
-$&$
!."/,$
$0.$
!"#$ %&!$## ' !()
!"#$ $# ' !() ****
$% ""2+',(.#"( !,0
"3+,"2"(.#"( !$0.
44444 $# ' , 0 $ "''. *5 .$ .".
89& :
; ".
89& : ;( <,*5 , " .2$"*&"(,".'",#,8!$,=>;(,"$.#. ,$#"2 &,!,"$*#"2.!0"52!$? @A ,."5. 0"52 ! '"&5 < !
@ , ."! "#&" 0"52 "$ ! @ )7B: #. !2 , 0 "'<, $,"$"$*0"5.! ,!"#$2""'!2,<0"., '" 00#" " ," , 0( ""' , "' ! $&0"&"(,"..!2,$#< !
6
@"!.'
2,"675"$!$# "##&!,2(,0 <"$.",0$"5*!$<,$'<,, "<"5 0"2"##."#<,, "<"5+"8 $; &$( CC6
8!$,= CC6 &$>;
$0,"2(,0<"$0". 0$"5 *!$ < !
@( *& , "2& ! ",:#&2:
2"&58!*5= >;,&! 6( 6( 7)B:<"$ 0".
0$".".
C89&:6;!"$!, "!2."2&<"$$&*2.
,$0.$$".!"$'
,'"&5(#."$&2!@ )7B:!2,$$""5!,2,!
0( @(<,#,#$$".,2$&*2",0$".".
C89&:7;
,0<"$$&0$.#.".7
( <,*5,0"2,".$&',#,<,"2&! ,'&.,"""2&!
B:<"$&$".'"D "$ #22#" .* "'"$ , 0 -. . .". 6
89&:
;(,$0$"!"'.#5!"!2. "2&".<,,.'! <"$3#.
,0!'
"''.!.
CB B
*!(<,#,<"$(.. .".
(.$0$.!'"'*5,$0.$, 0#."!$,,2""##."#<,,&$ <"$(,<( .#..$*&$,<,,.*!$<,<2,$!2,." !. $0,$". ,0(,'"&5<"$<,,.
6".,$*"#F.0!,2"(#20.,0! $&*$G& '"00#"#"2',!<'!%: ;
! "# $%
& '
+ (
" ) * + ,-. ///%01$2+/$ 0013 ""2+',(".#&$0$',0 $&*2.,",0"2#&.<,,., "...&#, "2&"$"!2.<,&,.'"G&5 "$.&0 ,0$ @ !, "<"51"&"9"#.,<0*5 &'',"""<"5.&$".,#,"'$"G&.*0".*! .5!'.$ ,,"$!"."F#$.", .".
CC 89& :
;( <,*5 , "<"5&,$ " *&.0"5#20&.$,."5.0"52!'"&5*5. ,2,$!2,."!2!,
<"$9"'&.,",$0.$&$5<,,. ,'"&5!,0<,&"5"$$3&$!#" , ##5"00.,0$$! . & (<,#," "00#"*,0#.'$&.,.2$"*&"$# , "'. $". ! , "<"5$ ! :## ! , !', *5 , 0,&!
B:<"$*"#F.*5"5#'"$$
"3 +,"2"( ". #&$ 0$' $0.
$&*2.,",090$$.*5,3#',#"2 .$<"""5!# $&2! C( 7( 7)B:$$0.'
"'"$,0 ,0<"$$0$*!"H', ##!',",2!*F'!<0$"F!0"$ "$$" ". ,!. +" E
) , '"&5 "2& !
6( 6( 7)B:<"$ ".3&$.".#.<".$,.*!D""0& +"
)
!&,$&*2.,",0"2#.&#."G&5
"'"$ , 0( <,*5 , <"$ ,. $0$* ! , "#&" "2&"$.*5, "!!###&$ !!#! @(
( B:(&!
<,#, 7(E (E)@B:<#.".$"""$$"+"", 2!.5(*&*""#!
B:$$".*0.'"'"$ ,0<',###,"''!!',""".#"$$ "$".!<"'".#"$$"
@
""2+',(*&"(.&0 &C! CC6 &$ #.,"$5, $.(<,,"$,0<<,,. <,."<"0$'"&5".(,!(,"#!,$0.$ <,,.','"&5<"$"5"'"$,&$
,",".,".#&$!,0"$"."00"$. ,0"0*F
,"00#":0!. '"00#"( (
CB B
(<,#,#"2!$<"$"$"$. ,$!"#$ !#.!2&. 89;<,#,$0.&#."$&.%:
= *&
! 4
6
3 , ( . . .".
( ,". ".". , 20&'."#,0"!,20&,5<,,., "$#*! <(*5<"$'".,$0.$ 0#."!$,,2",<"$02$$*&., "&!2&".
,<,,.*!$<*.$*&$., "00#"<,<2,$!2,."!#!.#05!,.<"$
, 0$.,20&,5 $ #. ," . ,"!$". . <"$ $ '".'$*0"."5."5.0"52!$#*!$ $$."<,""!(<,#,,"$*$&',".'".($,*5 .#"F7 ),""$2"5(,$0.$< ,.$0$*."5', (!(,G&5,.("$&2!
B:<"$!&..&".$,0"2,"$#"$&2! C( 7( 7)B:
$&#,"$&"(&0(,$0.$#"* ,."*<,,"*50"5$ ,!(,!.'..
*5,.5',$$##0$0# ,.$ .".
".
(,&$(#"*!"&.
.',..&#! @ )7B:!2,$""5!, 0!,2,!0( @("$0,<$"2!.*5 ,$0.$(<"$"*&.,.&$",2!!"$2
,'#&.*.2$".*5,0,","#!, $0.$..&#'@ )7B:<"$&3&$!.
G&"5(#&.
*!&.,.!,*&".#',$"2
,"$$"!2.(<.!."5'"5 0$5,20&'..$.".
".
, &0,.',$"2(,<0$.$2$$.
8 %&!$## - .$# - !() !() /0/1'2 34 5 5 16 37 08
%
5 5 3: %