Sona Devi v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ORS


   

 
  
 
   

  !""#$%%



   

    

 



  &
 '() % * )* ))  ( ****

    

  ! " #

  

$ %  ! " #

 



 *+$", #-".!/0 % &

  #

   '

 

  ! (()#

*

+ ,'



#%% # "

     

    -#

 #

   .

 

'

%

 #

#

-#





() (0/(

"



1 #

% "  #

" 

-#

# '

 

 # 



# 

- '

' '+ , '

     - 2  . '

   , 

 #  ,"-.

"%  



. # #

'

 "  ,  ' 

-#

 '

 #  3" .%   - , 

, -.

  

%  

 

 #  .  "

,4   - ,  '

   05 (0/( 

   "

,4 

  

 %   6 57894 



   "  #

  

%% '  

- #

 # " . #

CWP-1936-2016 - 2 - %   " -  ,  ( #

 '

  %  #

 -.   / :'



-% 

"

,4   (0/(" -.

-#

() (0/(

%' "  -.





#  

;

.  05 0< (0/( 

=

. , !>?' #   -  #

, 

,#&9&

 #'

,#): $!&9> -.%+ ,9#% ,-,  %   

%%  , 

-#



%7068 /0 (0/( =!3  47? %    <7 :8 "  %   5):(  /8 (0/(#

, '+" 

-.

-#

 =!3 4)? %5/9 >45:8( /< (0/(=!3 6?   "   #

    ,

 ,

"  !%

 . 

" ,'

# 

 % #

 !

( (=-?#

2-*

 "

%@@  @=# 



A? 

A % " ,A

-% -



 '



 "

, ' #% , 

     #    "  ""   "

,    '     

 

( (=-?#



 @

 " # 



#

-#





() (0/( 



, '"  " '   

 .  %  " ,  "

,4   '     & #   -" #      '

 

'

 % .   

 ( (=-? # 





 "  - 

 #

   %,

 " ."

 -##"

 ! %

 ' '3-.

*  +1 2+/34%55+6
+67+$+!8/!9!56+$

CWP-1936-2016 - 3 -

!.+1(!1!5"+$"#5264  #%:#; "

8 / (0/0  '



*  

% "# "

  "

%  ;

.# 

'

#  % " -  "  '

 

  -#

 !"" , . 

'



 

'

   "

  

   9 . -#

 

 =- '

' # 

 

  , ?

 B

.    " %  B@  "%%

# #

   ,'

 C<D

   

 

 #

- #

  () (0/(

"



1 #

% '

 # 

 # "  #" ".#

 "" , .

 :0 (0(:

  *+$", #-".!/ 

-".

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No