High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15525/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Gurdev Singh And Another

2024-12-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#$

!"!%"& !"#'

!!"# $% &' ( )* (# )*( ++

+ ,

)*( + ++ + ( +( ,-. /&$' 0' 1

1 * 2 3 /)&4-10+&5* +

+ ,

/01 7 ( 8* 0* 9:2

0 *- ( 9+

# :0 * ,- 1 +; <5 7,

1 5 08,-51;* ( ,1-* 8118

/&2%/0/&34 !%"

7 5

11 * 8 11- 11 +;-9=()(; : 5(;8 (-- &5> 0* 11 ='8

;&58=' &57085( ! ( -!; -&5+;5(; &50* 88 (18;515(-

9*; :

+; 5(0,1-8?

@95;*:,-)1 /514

7,1-1; 51;* 8A5 ,-;* + -0 (

*,1- 8 , ,1 , (((&,- ;1- &5 <1 (((&0* 13+0, 1 +; <5 7,

1 5 0 8,- 5 511 (A5 9:73+0,5; 118&7*&* #5 .

!"#$%&'$' ( ) *"+

! ""! #

%&'(

)*+

, "5

!5267 !% 2 4*5 (;B 5&A 5 * 8* 0 1 5; (8 ,11; -&C& -;;, 5 *

10, *, ( 11 ;-0* 1

(0 ,5; ( 10;;, 5;, 5,1; 0;; (

50- ** * 0 * 1; 5, (5 ,1, 5 ( 1, (5 ,1,5;((&, , ,1;1-&50 5D 0;0* 5*1 A (; ,-E F,1+*# 0 51 ,- -*"( ) 0* .'$/0

$1 7 1& *(* &5 #5 "

- -

/ 0 1 2

- -

- 3

"!+ -

4 5

6 $ 7

*"8 93''0$

:;1 0 1

' -

- <$ = %$ #01> 0 1 &

0$ 1

0 -1'

- <$ #01> 0-1'

- ?

- < #01> 0- 1'

< #01>B 0- 1' @

3'' 8C

0@ 7 1 "!!"D86 /C

- ;!

- -

, G + 5& (9:,&#5* 5*10 (* 1-5108 ,1-,5; 1 -;;,5;, 5,1; 0 85 # @&0 0 ( - 5,1;;, D , &1;+;-0, -D , ( , ,1-*

10( ; ,1-* - ;;,5;, 5,1; 08,5; 1 8 ,1- D ; @ ;0 , ;*&1- D 51 ; /51 40 5 1-

5 ( ,1-, (, ,1 ,5; (((&,-;1-&5751 ,5; A ,-6 $ 7

*"8 93''0$

:;1 ! < ;0 ( * ;* ( - 3F3-

*-51 ; 11 -;;, 5,1; 5 0*511-8 ( ,5; ( 110 5, ,5; (, 8 -/&0 ( 1 * ;* 0 8 - 0 55 ,D 1-0 ,- ** ( 9: ( -0,* ;,D 1 ( &5 ;;, 5 ,1; ;*&1-0

*& ( 8; D , 9 *:- 3F3- 5 0, ;*1-0 50

;

5(0 051; ,5; 15&,1-* /&0115 55 ; 5 &5 ,- 5 0,511-5 H0 51 (8 -&C&5 0D 1D ;1- &5 2 ; , ( ((& ,- , , ,1;1-&5 4;-0 ,5;1 * 5*19:-5 , 1,1-* 5 0, 1- .

:+;55* 55 ;1- &50; (,5; (5,-/51 4 && , ( , 8 85 8&0,5;5 ,- (;

,5; 1 ,:+ - 0;-1 ,D 1- ,5;5 ,-/5140 ;

;1-&5 , (, ,1;1- &50;, (5 ( 1 < 0;51* 15 1

&, 5 ;51#; 5 , ;0 *,5; ( 1 &50 0 ;811 ,;& (&50- 9 *:0/514D 5 ( /&0151 *0; - /514118( 1 18 * I% /519/1- :0JI"

1; .

% 1 5*1I 70, 8; 8 ; ,&* 5*108; 1; * * +;-0 *1; -;51#; , (; - 33- 10 ,5;5, ;, (; 28; ,5;** 8 ; (/&01 D ,; 0;5 08 5 1 # * 0 2 ( 0 * 0 * 11; *

* B ( *150 - 33- 5& ,- ; ;1-&508,-0 ;-5 , 8D 1 (&5 +;- 58, ,1,5;((&,- ;1-&5 01D ,(; 508/5140 11-*5;B 1 5& 5 155B0*5 11-** ( & 0 (;*1-; '+;51 5 D 0

&1 ( ,15B 5 ( 5 5

5 8;0,5; 5/&0 ;*1-; 1) 1 1-0,-;-,5;5 D * 0 ,D ** 1; B *1508 5 ( 1, 8( ;1-&5,, (, ,1,5; (((& ,-*; 5;1-&5 1-0 *;*1- 5 D (** 1; B (*150 ,- /5145 015 0 ; 5 5 -0, -; *, ( 1; -*

1 ;-0 &- 5) 1 1- ,D 5&5 2 * 0 (5 ;1-&50, 8 1 1118115 ,-/51405& * , ,5; 5 ; 5& 5 1 ( 5 5

5 8,-8 1, 1,1-*

E8&0 8 & 0 D ,#5 (5 * 0,5;5,- )1/5140#5 . 2)!)2!234 565,) 782 +, 1)1 *=,1-8&55 8 ,

9 .:&!/ !

; -

.:&!/ + & &

99 9

9 "

.:&!/

K"'

*5 0 5

, ,1

((& 5 5 9)* E %/3!:

78/ 9:

7!"

.1 + (5&1; ** 1; B (*15 ,5;; ; * 5*19 *:51,-E F,1+*# 5 1,- -*"( ) . /,-/51 40;858&0 ,* * 0,5; 1 +;-0;B*1; - ( 0 51 18 A (; 9 *: ,-* ;* ( 8D 1 &50D ,& ,1- 8&&* 7 ( * ;* , ,1,

1& 5, * ;* ,5; 5 * E8&0 5 & 5 5 (5( (

&&* 05( 1- , (* ;* 0, 11-15 -1 /5140 ((1 &

(0 ( ;*1-; ' + ,15B 5 ( 5 5 1 5

5 5 D 9:0 8,- ;- ,5;

&1 ( ;-*

10 ,5; 5; 5 1( 5;1--/&0 ,-81D , ;51* 0 , 811; 85 ( 1 ,5; ((&,- ,5;, ,1;1- &5 G E8&0 (* 9 *:051 , 5 -*; &, 5 # 9 *: )1-0 5 & 5 , * ;* 9 *:, 1,-* 0,-0 5 (& 8((* ;51,0 #5 9 *: *5 1-0 ,- 5 5 5 , ( *11 ; 0,,- 5

,,D 1 5 1( 5 ;1-- 1-0D ,51;

;1-&5 0D ,51 ,, ,1,5; (((&,- ;1-&5 ,-* * /&0 ( 9:

55 81&5,5;*;,- 5*

1 *50, 5 #*; 1& ( 1 085;B (9: *50 ,( D 1 50F (

; ;1-&5 ,5;((&

,- ;1-&5 5 D 5015B #* ; ( 1 0 5 5 0& (9: * * 55 *50,-0 ( , 51 ,5; ((& ,- , , ,1 ;1-&5 ! < 0 5 ;A (; ,- +*# 0 51 ) *"+ ?

'$#

$01$< 8 051 ; # 0,

(0,5; 8 5 ) 1 1-1

,1( ,5; & * * B ( D **

(, (; & "& 8 5 51 18 ; &59 *:;B51 , #* 1 18 ;0,-0#* 1 18 ;0; &5 9 *:1;B

5 , && 5 *

1 5 0 0 0 1 1 5 0 -;B( ( 8; ;

0 0 115;*1; 0*1

0,*5&,0 -01- 15 70 ( ( , **

(0 ;&59 *: ,-7,

1 5 01 ; -11(1- D ,

7"/0

!5267 !% 2 ;0 ; 8* 8,& ,&0;; 7;* 0*,-1 7,

1 5 0; ; =*1 (811* (**15 9:0 - .+

+ ,

.+ + (1 ' + L+> *B (2 .

K2 *,1 .