← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/398/2009dismissed

Cit-I Chandigarh v. M/S Pb.Info&Comm. Tech. Corp. Ltd. Chd.

2023-01-18Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra13 pages



     

& '()*   

        



!  "



 # $ % &

%  & '()*   

        



!  "



 # $ % '

%  &+'()*   

        



!  "



 # $ % (

%  &+'()*   

        



!  "



 # $ % ,%

%  &++'()*   

        



!  "



 # $ %

!-  &

./.

+ %+% ) 01)2%2 01)2%2)2  !#)

*

+% ,

,



     

 - .

,

/ 

,

1 0 /   )2 6%  1#

!

3 / 4   +'56&775  +'55&775   +&5&&77  +&5'&77"   +&85&7

!



9

0

//  

    0   

#

&77'7(&77(73&7737:&77:78"&77876  /#  



 

0     !#  

  ;  <

<=9

0



 !#

!/ #

 /!        +'56&775 & !

  

  #0



!

/   



   

  

# &77'7(

'7&77'

!

  / #  0  

 0 

 

0 

>

#  

, (';&=0

 787&77( -

/  

    

 

# 0 

 40 !

/

   #

/!# 

     

 

-

 0 

  

0





! 

0 - #

  0

!#  0 0

#5 -

#$ -.

  0 !





/ 

#   

  

 

 

% 86

 

  



 / 

?0/ 

  



 #! 



 



  / 

0  

  !

 

% ('7777  @#,#- 0 0 !#

    



 

0 0  4

     / 



 !

   

!



0 

0

   

0     # 

, &8;=;=  5:;  <<=0 !

  #

 ' A

   /  

        

   &7&&773 

 

, (';'= ! 

  ; =   ;  B;=C=0/  75&77:0 

 

0   0 0



 /!# ;=0  !    

 

       

0



  !#    

      

  0/    





! 

00 

 ;=



,  





 



!# 



 



0

9

0

)

= D 



  0 

0



 ;=

 / 





0  !

/ 0      

#    0  !#  

E

= D 



  0 

0



 ;=



   

 @#  ,#-  F

  

        !

 

/    

;,G=@#,#-F

    

0  

E ( $





   #  



!#;= 

 

!  !! 



 #!

/  !

  

  

% &(7



 

  

% 53( #0

0 !

 /  

   

 

% 86 

  

0 0 #    

 #!

/ <     <  !

 

,





0 9

  



!

    

# ,

 



!#;= 



 

  

@#,#-F

!# 

 

 

 0   

!



   /

0 /





 !

  





!

 !! 

 3   

    !/  

  

      



   

  ;=0 

0

/

- / 0

 #0     

/ 0   !  



 



 ?

  

0 0 

0 

 0  #

 B

C B/ C

   

 / 

 / 0 #! / 0   ! !#

 #

9 #





 9   0 

 #

 #

 : $



 

  

4  



0 

0  #  !

 0 ! #   

0 0 !

  !#   

  



  #

  ?     

     !

/

 !# !0

 !# 

0 

  0  

0  !#    

  0   0  

        

  



 !#

 

0  ! !

0  !

/

 /!

 0   #





 



      5.

.#!$ & .//.

5 &

 !"9%2!$!5#:5.!2.#$ " ; $$.

<11;&7&&=&: G% .

  H  .//.

5  &  

  !"  4

!.  9%  .$!4!5.

9 /- -  '*  1-3%  ;&776=  (  ,    

    &'&H !$ :--!

 #!

=1-3%9% .//.

5 &

 !"6> /- <!$6%535 ,:3H!? /424!

-.$!$)!53.!9% #:-= .//.

5 &

!";&7&=&3(%7''6H  .//.

5 &

 !"9% .@:

) 5 -.$ 2 59.

'*1-3%;&73=&&G%.

  &88H 2 /4  / 5-9-%1-3%9% %%%%+'&77( !# ?



*  6&7(" .//.

5 &

 !"!

-4 59% .

/4A:!5 $;&7=&'5%77(: 8 D  /     

  

    !       

!  / /  !



!#  

  #

 # 

!

/   

  G



# &77'7(  # /  

 % &(7          

      

  

   

 

% 86 0 !

 !# 



   0  

 /  

 0

 !% 53( 





 0

0

          

 9 

0 !

 !#

9 #



# 

      

               

!#0#B     C;= 0/ !

/     0   

 

 



  

!#;=+0

!

!#

0  

# 0!#

  !#  !00 

  E 

 0 ! /   , (30  0  

  

 !

 

    

!  

  0      

#    #, !, &

,  4   */

  #    

,  !  !#  # 

   

  

     # 

  

    

B

,  C0 

 

, &  

 

 

  !# 



 

5(5



!/ /

0  



 

     B!

    

C     9

    0   

,  !*/

    

,  !#0# !   



,    

  





0

, (3;&= &57355:  





 # !  



 

 

 

    



   

  B

C 



 

 

  

4 # 



 B    #

/  C   

 



   0 # 

 B

C

 





 

 !#



 



 

!  











% 



  !  .

/4A:!5 $0/ ;, =0

?



G 0 

0  

00



 

 





! 0 #

0

#-  

 0

!

/

 

0  #  

B

C B/ C

  ! 0!    

D -

0 !

 

0

  



0      

9

  /

   ! / 

   ! /  !



 0 



 0 !  /  6 %  

 !.$!4!5. 9 /- -'*1-3%0/  ;, =0

? <!

!

/

  !#!

  ! 

 #0 

  

  

 

    

     0     

 







4 #0 

/  #  /  # 

! 0  0    /  5 ,            

  !#  0#    <  

   <

  0

!#? <! 

9% =:

3!. !9= 3:/-5. / %1-3%6 ;&778=&7% ;,=860

0  !

/ 0  



0 0   

@  0   

   

          #  <    < <   <

 



 

   

 0                

 0  

4    

,  

! #/ 0  /    !

#  ,

 9 0



9%)!

./4:.$3> $$'*1-3%;&7=:'G%;G=':5 0   0  0    

      0 #       

 !# 

 

   

 #   0 0

!

#



0 E 9 0

0 

/



H

2!$!5#:5.!2.#$ " ; $$.

< 110/ ;, =0



0  

!

 /        #       

    /       0 !#      /         

     /  

D    ! 0

B  

   C  D   

  

    0      

0      /     

 / !#

0

!#

!#

 

  #      0 0!#

 

+

! !#   0 0 

4 1# #





#

!

H

 !? /424!

-.$!$)!53.!0/ ;, =0



0 0

   ! 

!

#   !

 0  !  / !

? <!,  

!

/

  /

 

      !0  

     !

 

  

#

!  / !

      

  !

  #       A



.@:

) 5 -.$ 2 59.

'*1-3%0/ ;, =

  #0  0  

!

 /

  #   !

#   ! 0 0   !

  0

 

!               /   !

       

  !

 / !0 3#

0 !# * ?





0 ! 0       /    

0





/  

  !

  

 7 > #



 0  





!/       #

#   

    #  0  #

  B     

C    !

/

   !#    

   #   

   ! !

0  !

/!# ;= 0 

   0 0

# !#



 /

#

;= 

  0 

/



!#

++



 0  ?









 



 

!#;=!

/



#0 ! 

 



#   

  





,

(3



   

  

  !   #0!#







       !                   #  /!



0 

# 





   

  

    !

    0        

    0                        .$!4!5.

9 /- -  '*  1-3%0/    ;, =    0  !

/  !#    ? <! ,  

 



 

 0 

!!#   

  

 ! 

!# # 

  @     





   

 !



 

  



"$ 

  

 #0  

 

  !  /



   >        

   

 

 

    





4



 



!#          ! -!#-



  

 !

   



+







!#!

/

 

0

   !#    

              

     # % 0 !

/



0

    0  0

#

  0     

  !#





   

  

     > 



 

 

  !

/  !  !#

      0!#

0 



 #   0  !



#

? 





 0             ;= 

 #

 

0 !#

0

   !#

 0 

  0     0 

   

 /



     

 !# !0 



 0

 #

   

 &   @#,#-F



 

037I



;=!

/ 

!

!#



 !



 4 ,  # 0 





0    @#,#-

 #!#

!#,G 

+

          

             







  

 4

    / 



 !





 





! 



 



  

!# !0 



   /!

!

   

  0    



         

 

 0

  0  9



 

  !#



#



 '

 

  ;

=  #  

 '* ')2*        + %+%

D -

  J

+ D  ! J

+