High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1744/2007allowed

(O&M) Vikram Anand v. Ravinder Singh And ANR.

2024-09-19Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma18 pages

!"

#$%$!&'

() () *$+, - & &.

/00 11 & * ,%2% 3$&. , 4$&56

&.

&!6 , // %0!&. &% '

78

4) 4

4

4

!

4

4 ) 8

"

$ % &'

""

(&&) ")) * "+,,$ !

#$ $ - . #$ ./ % $

0 %

4 (

$ (+ &) (&&1 % 2 344 $ 5 $ ! % 4 $ ! 6 $ "& 1&

$5 $ 2

75$8 2% $5 4721'

2+1))- 9 :/ ;

!

# 2% %$$5 " 3 2

8

$ # % 3 ; 54 $ ! $ $ % % % % <

$ =

5 ">&(+ ) (&&1 % 5 $ ! ('+11, !

/ %1&% $ % ?! 4 % 7 >(>)(> @&

A 5 "( 0 >

= #$

% 2

! "

$

!" #

%

"

! !

&'%

( & @

3 #$ 2 4 0

4

484 ) 2

$

0 % =7%1 $ - % /% =7

$

%

'

2 ! % % $ #

) % +

7 % $ ? #$ 2 *+

"

!

, '"

#

"

#!

"

'

"

#

,

$ #

+

-%. . / 0

#!

1 &

+ '

/ /!"!" ' ##

-2

%%) . +

# / !"!

'"

+ 3 #

& $ %, "

,

"

"

'"

'3 #

! '

' " ,

"

#

!

'

.# 1 & / &0 #" " #"

4 / + # #

" #

1 &

# # "

' "

"

4 0

! #

# '"

+

4%40/ 2544%

+

$ " #

##

0

# !

" # + # "

4

/ 2544%

# "

"

'"

#

1 &/ &

'

" "

+! # !

'"

# '" +! #

"

'3

'"

0 # & $ 6 % ! '

' " 0

# !

#

, !

, "

#

'"! #

#

1 &"

"

+ " "

"

7

#' " # %& $ 0

-%. .

'

:

! #

"

1 &! # # ' "

'

"

" +

3 #

" "

"

# #

'

"

#

!

#' $ # # .#

'" + "

#

#

"

'3 " !

"

'"

#"

8 "&

% 62(% # =

5 ">&(+ &) (&&1 % 5 $ ! ('+11, !

/ "'1! !

3"% % 5 "% =

7B 2 5 "% % 3 % $ % 2

$

('+11, !

# 35% $ 5 " 3 2% B

/ % % 78% %< 621 % % % % $5 "

/ % % ? #$ $ % =7% 395:%

# % $ 5 " 3 % 5 "- 39 :/% $ % 2

$ ('+ 11, !

/ ? #$ $% % %$ # % $ %&'

""

(&&)

/ 7 ? #$ 5

"1"@ %% % $ % $ ? #$

4

8 8;

4

""

4:$ ! % % $ # <! < =2- , *%) < > =2- ,

&.

&!6 ,

420, - !2, % % 99

2

?

9+ /:

0 !2))6;0 ; # " #$!"

#

!3 !

+$ "

# # " #

!

!

#

+

# $

3 #

!# $ "

!

0

$! "

$+ #

!

$ # #

"

" $

$ !

# 6<.=< #

+= ! 0 & 2-4 <# . %-5! &> ,

. 6

? !2296<..99

@ !

2-40.(5- 5 +

"

"

$ "

A 73

# ! B ! #

!

!

!

# 3

?

6

"

$ "

#

$ ! #

A

( 6 ?

# C 6 ?

#

1#

3 '

# 6D > # > #

!

#

$ 6? #

6

E # 6 ?3 6

#

$ ! "

"

6 !6

6

6

$!"

#

! "

6

6!6

!6

6

#

! #

3 ! #

6

E #

3

! 0

$ 6#

#

$ !

+ #

"

" !

#

+

!

# #

63

" !"+

!

# #

+ "

$ '

"3 #

# 3 #

3 #

+

#

"

+ "

+ # #

#

!

!

$! !

"#$

%

%%

&

%

% '

()(A+

$ ! "# !" %4

&%444E'# #

0 > ;

! #

#

$ " 54F

#

" %4F+

" + 9F

!

## !

" . "

"A 0

#

A&%5!444E' ?

# 69F

#A &9(44E'

/

"

A-

?

A69(443-A &2!)44E' '

(*(A+

$ " %4 !

&%444E'# ,

#

#

54F," #

# $

,

## "

$! " ++

-9F. "

"A 0

#

A&%5!444E' ?

# 6-9F

# A&-444E'

/

"

A-

?

A6-4443-A&(!92!444E' '

(+( A +

$ " 9

0

!"

# "# !

" #

" +#

# " -4F0

$

"

!

" -4F+

"

"A /

##

#" #

A&54!444E' ?

# 6-4F3

# A&(444E'

/

69 A)

?

A6(4443) A&-!95!444E'

G A +

60

6@

+

6."

#

0

=# / 6 H "(

4:$ ! , ' +- .

/0 @

:

4 :? A

% "))")12"), * "+,,

% 2 -/ ; <

C - /

C -!/ $

C -;/ 7$ <% C -D/ =

% 8$C 2 < 8 2 +!"

# 3 # # !

#! ! #

3 &9!444! &(4!444

&9!444 +

@ '

#'

"

# "

# 4F

9

"

8 "1

4:$ ! 1 .

1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34 2 *-+ "

3 #

A

% %(5(

%(6(C +

# %

$ #

.# ?

<

!

4- 0.I -44 6<. (5

$ # ! . @ # # # #

< :# 6<#

> + .

0 !4420.I 2)6<. 9'9 !# ;); "

3

+

< .

!!" # #

;);

;-; -

%

%

%78

! #

"

I

/ J !4)0.I46<.

<

= $ 0>

J0 !4-0.I2-26<.3 "

I

6

)A

K)

#

0

#" # #

" + "

# # ! "

A

!

#

#

C

?

#

#C

+

# # "

#

C /

3

##

C

6 ?3 K G# H +

# B

$ # ! <

= $ 6

# # "

"

# #

! "3 #

! " E B )

# L #0 4I 4%+

$

A K, % A

#

#

#

#

# % !(J9#

6

# 6 # 6

3 "

!

< . #"

@ # ! #

$ " 3 1!

%<

= $

6 "

# # !

#

!! " #

"

#

#

%F+

# $ #

.? 6 !#

56

!

!" 94F

:

$

"8

! "

"

2F

" $

#

I

M 6

!

!"

#"

2F

"

. +0,+-9'0, )+

! !

9 !"

"A :

) ?

" 6&(!5()33%E44 &2!)!2-)E'

1 694

&(!24!2)2E'

/

3

!

# ! &)!(5!)5(E'

? # #

&9!44!444E'

? #! #

# &!94!444E'

&!44!444E'

+ &(!52!)%E'

+ " !! &(!52!)%E' # "

#

2F

##

# 8 "@

% $8

11!B .%&'

""

(&&) % %$4:$ ! $

2 $ %

5

4 ! % "

7 "&&&&&02 (

7 )+(&&02-7 ("(&&F>,&&&02/ ? 7 +&&&&02 > 7 (&&&&02 @ !

7 @&&&&02 ) # 7 "&&&&02

!

!-0 &% $!& %)9C9(C D ")

$4:$ !

; *.

. ( 9: <. 0

.$ , $ +

420, - !2, % % C

G+H

I

"'

75 12 ! % % #$ % % 8 # #$

?

$

2 $3 #

2 $3 #$

",

;

"+

4

4

4 0 -E , (C 6 3023 3 6 $ J