Uhbvnl And Others v. Babli Devi




  
   

 ! "#






















$%&'(&)*+*,-./ 

%%$$0$,$*12*3*%$,*4$5%($,(%6&+ 788&22$,%+ 

$92*&:*$,($,%6&  &+8,(&,%+  "-  ;"

 
 <
  ;"

 
 <"  

&+&,%

"*%&+6 $,(*%=(:)$%&='%6&$88&22$,%+ "+*:0$6$5$=(:)$%&='&+8,(&,% >>>>>  <
=
! $2# !#

6& 8&+&,% *,%$ )?% $88&$2 6$+ 9&&, '*2&( 90 %6& %%$ $0$,$ *12* 3*%$, *4$5 *5*%&( !' +6%= %6& *4$5# % )6$22&,4& 1?(45&,% ($%&(    . 8$++&( 90 $ 2&$,&( *,42& ?(4& ' %6*+ ?% $22@*,4 &+8,(&,% A+)2$*5'&4?2$*B$%*,'6&+&:*)&+ ! # '&@&2&:$,%'$)%+5$09&,%*)&( !.# ,   =&+8,(&,%1*,&(%6&*4$5$+$@&&8&, 8$%%*5&9$+*+:&,%($0+6&+&:&+%6&*4$5$+$@&&8&,%6&+$5&%&5+
,%6&5&$,@6*2&=*,%6&0&$ /=+6&8&%*%*,&(%6*+?%+&&C*,4&4?2$*B$%*, '6&+&:*)&+@6*)68&%*%*,'6&+=%6?46%6&*58?4,&(1?

(45&,%=6$+9&&, $22@&(90$2&$,&(*,42&?(4&'%6*+?% # &'& ?+= %6& ,20 91&)%*, $*+&( *+ %6$% %6?46 %6& *58?4,&( 1?(45&,%&+8,(&,%A++&:*)&+)?2(,%6$:&9&&,(*&)%&(%9&&4?2$*B&( 9&)$?+& ,     +6& 6$( ,% 9&&, $88*,%&( $4$*,+% $ &4?2$ +$,)%*,&( 8+%$,(%6$%&:&,%($0%6&&@$+,&4?2$+$,)%*,&(8+%$4$*,+%@6*)6+6& @$+@C*,46&&'&=%6&&4?



 @6*)6$2+$882*&(%%6&*4$5=)?2(6$:&,%9&&,$882*&(%6&)$+& !#
,%6&2*46%'%6&?,(*+8?%&('$)%?$28+*%*,%6$%&+8,(&,%6$+ &,(&&(?,92&5*+6&(+&:*)&':&.0&$+$,(%6$%&:&,%($0+6&),%*,?&+ %+&:&%6&*4$5=@&$&,%*,)2*,&(%*,%&'&&@*%6%6&*58?4,&(1?(45&,% %6?46@6*)6%6&*4$56$+9&&,(*&)%&(%&4?2$*B&%6&+&:*)&+'&+8,(&,% *5820'%6&&$+,%6$%%6&*4$56$+8&5*%%&(&+8,(&,%%+&:& *% ' :& %6&& (&)$(&+ $*+*,4 $ 8&+?58%*, %6$% %6& 8+% $4$*,+% @6*)6 &+8,(&,%@$+$,(*++&:*,4@$+&4?2$*,,$%?&$,(%6$%6&+&:*)&+@&& $2+&E?*&(90%6&*4$5,$&4?2$9$+*+62(%6&@*+&@?2(%&,(% &,)?$4&%6&?,'$*8$)%*)&'&F82*%$%*,'2$++
3&5820&&+@6@?

2(9& C&8%$+($*20@$4&+':&%6&&(&)$(&+@6*)6=*+$%%6&2&$+%=,%&F8&)%&('5 $,*,+%?5&,%$2*%0'%6&%$%&2*C&%6&*4$5  #
,%6&)$+&'6$99*$2$,(%6&+=$+*5*2$91&)%*,=$+%$C&,90 %6&*4$5*,%6&8&+&,%)$+&=@$+$*+&(90%6&$0$,$3*(0?% $+$$,*4$5 *5*%&(!'+6%=3 #6*+@$+*,&+8,+&%$8&%*%*,'*2&(906$99*$2 $,(%6&+%6?46@6*)6%6&0)2$*5&(&4?2$*B$%*,,%6&4?,(%6$%%6&0=2*C& &+8,(&,%=6$(+&:&(%6&3 $+@&&8&+&%)=,8$%%*5&9$+*+=' /% D0&$+2&$,&(*,42&?(4&'%6*+?

.



 
!
"#
$
%!!
&
'( 
!9062(*,4$+'22@+-

)%

!
+ !
,
 
!
+!



- .

/

%-+0



 -.

#

 ,
!(
"
,


!
- .
& 
,

/
+ !
,

!

,  ! ,
!!
!
+ !

!
/

!#

1
, !(
2/* !

 !#

1
!
/* !


 
(
!

, 
& 
!
+!

#






!
, ,*! ,0
! 
+!

-#

$
*+/ 




4
 !
 
 
!
+ !

,!
!
/ 5
!
"

,
&
!
+!

#6
!D# 6& $'& &'&&( 1?(45&,% ' %6& 2&$,&( *,42& ?(4& @$+ )6$22&,4&( 90 3  %6?46 $, *,%$ )?% $88&$2 9&*,4  D 

'( (!
 /*
!#
 
!
"#
 
!@6*)6 $88&$2@$+(*+5*++&(90$ (*,$%&&,)6'%6*+?%, D6& 8&$%*:&8$%'+?)61?(45&,%&$(+$+?,(&- )$& 0
!

(
/* !
+
- ,
!

, 
& 
!
++

!
&


,.

!

"

!(
&
/ 
", 
- ,, 

/
!



&

/
/* !
, 

/
+ 
&
!
&
!
- .* #

3!

 ,,+! 
!!
!
%!!


*  (
  

+* !!
!
 !
!
,
 & 
 
+,!

,


 !
+ 
&

"

!(
&
/ 
", 
-


7!,!

/
- .
& *
- .*
& 
 * !
!
,#

3!

& 
!
%!!
!
& *

, 

! 
/#

$ 
-
,!
&
 , *
*.
!
+ + 
&,
 ,!


&

&
 
*+ !
&!
!
,
&
"

,#

$
++
"
 0
* 
+!

, (0
- 

(
 (
&
8 (
- ,


!! !
!
!
+ ,
& ,!

/
!
,


!!

!
&
!
++

!#6




 !/# 6& 3  )6$22&,4&( %6& 1?(45&,% ' %6& *:*+*, &,)6 *,   9 )$+& !+?8$# 9&'& %6& ?8&5& ?% %6?46  !+#/DH / '( (!
 /*
!#
 
!
"#
 
!I@6*)6@$+$2+(*+5*++&(,  /  !# *5*2$20=*,$9?,)6'8&%*%*,+*,@6*)6%6&2&$()$+&@$+G

/   
 
!
"#
'( 
 (!

1 /*
 !

!$2&$,&(*,42&?(4&'%6*+?%),+*(&&($+*5*2$5$%%&$+%6& 8&+&,%,&$,(&1&)%&(%6&91&)%*,'%6&&5820&%6&&*,@*%6&4$(%%6& ,, $:$*2$9*2*%0'+$,)%*,&(8+%+))(*,420=&4?2$*B$%*,'%6&+&:*)&+' %6&8&%*%*,&+%6&&*,@$+(*&)%&(,%6&4?,(%6$%%6&06$(+&:&($+@&&8&+ &%) ' :& %@ (&)$(&+  6& 8&$%*:& 8$% ' %6& +$*( 1?(45&,% &$(+ $+ '22@+-



 : & !
- !
!
, !

" ,
(
!
%!!
!!
! /
!
+!



- .

/



0
%-+
!,#
& 
"
!-
,
!
! 
,
& 
/

,  !

, 


,
!
-




+ !0
! 
 !

:
1 #
4
&


0
!


;  
!
#
$
%!!
&
'( 
!;
, 

#<# <
2,!
!
/* !


/
!!
,
!(
"


-
!
- .
& 
,


/
+ 
&
!

*0
!
,

!

,  ! ,
!!
!
+ !
-

!#
$
%


= ,







2/*

 

;


:


!
#
'( 
>
?" +* !
!  !(
 !;0
+ !

 4
4
%@

A !

/
+/+

&
!!
2/* !
!
!
&

-

/
&&,!B

)####

&

"

!(
&



+ !

, , 0

*(

0
, 

/
!
&,!
!!
!
+!




- .

!
!

* !
& 
!
!
* 
! 
(
! &
 -
!!
!
- .
"



&
,

 
!#
:


"

!

&
!,

/(#
C"(
, 



/
, *+! #
'>?

!

-

(
, !


/

!
%!!
& 


#
3!

" +

!!

* !


!
, 
&
!
%!!
 
, !

,
&
+ !#

$
 
, 
! &
+!

/
!
-  +0
! &
&
+(* &

!

* !
!,#

A 
!

*

#
$
2 
!*+ (

!#
$
+ 

A 

/ 
 ####6

D!0

, 
& 
!
+!


 




*(
2/*

:
1 #
4


&
 <0
;7*
?"

#
'( (!
  !;0
, 
# # E

- ,
!
+ !
1 /*
-
+!(
&,

/
!
*

 
-
+ !
(
#
@#%#
 0
" ,!
-
++

! 
,

-

#
$
 !
&!

/
!
2/*

%,!(0
%!!
&
F !.
 
!
#
>*
?"


!0

 
%
.

/
!
!
! ! /!
&
"

,

!
= 
 
1 , *+

/
&
"

(
 
!!
!
-  
++
 & 


A ! 
!


!
,
&
!
+!



!

!,

!(
&
!
-
" -
!
+!


!


!
, *+ 
(
&
"

,

# #
- 
!
!
&
+  ,* !
&
2/*

>*"

,
+#

@ (

!
,


 ;
,
+

:
1 #


&
 <
!


;%



#
'( 
 (!

1  !
 
!;
, 
#<# 8
/

!
- ,

1 #
<8
&
 8

 

<#E# 8


;F22
%

/
 
!
#
%!!
&
'( ;0
 <

%##$#
 0
3



-



, *
& 

&
"

,#


!
+ !
,0
!
, *


2,!
& 
!

!!
!
+!



!
& &

!
!*



&
!
+

,(
&




,
!(
"
!
- .




+ !#
$ 
/* !


 
!

! 
,
 
!
+ 

-


!
 * !
&
 

!




!

++



! 
,0
&
!
!
,

! (
+!
&
!





,
!
+ +!* !


!
!!
!
+!




 
!
+

!
!
!
*
&
+
2


!
 *

 //
!


 
"

,
/ 5#
$
+


&
 

!




!

/ "
-  *
*

/
(
!!

/
!
+!


++ 7 *!


!
!
,  !+!
-
"
,
/

&
"

,

!
*
1 /*G= 
-


- .

/
  
!
  

!
*
+ !
&


0
%-+
!,#


<
 ,, 

(
 


 !0
& 
!
& /

/
 0
!
+!

-0
!
*+/ 



7#



!
<#4# <

!
 #
3 ,
-
*+/ 

"

+0
!
*+/ 

,!

!
 
!


/


!
,

+#
$
+ ,!
!
5
!
"

,
&
!
+!


- !


, A
 & !
 
&
+(
&
!
(
+ 
!
!
!
&
&

/
&
!
+!

-#
$
/

-

 !
,.
!
!
+

,(
!
#8#

#6
!#   9)$+&@$+%$C&,?8*,$,*,%$)?%$88&$29&*,4

.

/ '( (!
 /*
!#
 
!
"#
 !@6*)6@$+(*+5*++&(90$ (*,$%&&,)6'%6*+?%, D  90 62(*,4$+'22@+- )
+
&
!
 
2/* !
-  
/

!
 -
!!
!

& 
!
+7
 !
-
/

/
!
/

+

,(
&
!
H " * !
&
3



+ ,
&
!

&
!
+7
 !

>*
?"

;
,

+

!

# # #
$


++

!
& 
!
$ 
-
"

/

+!

*
*+ (
 
-
!
/ !
!
 & &
!
*
 
!
$ 

 
2,!
! 
, *
&
/

#
' -"0
!
$ 

,!
!!

!

*
,*

& * !#
$
*!!


 /!
!
! 
 !
(
 !0
>

&
3


!
+!

*
*+ (
-

,!



 
!
& * !
!
+

,(
 ,
!
& 
!
 !#
,, 

(0

-
+

,(


& * !


,!


-

!
 
!
, *

+
!
-
+

,(
!
4# #

#
$
!  
!&!

2,!
!
, *
"



!

##

!
/  
!!
!
-




+ !
 
!
(

!
, *+ 
(
&
"

,

# # 0
!
!
&
,

>*
?"

;
,#
@ (0
,!



 
!
& * !
!
+

,(
 
!.

,

!



+ !


+
*

#
$
 ,!


-
!
++ "
(


/
!!
!
'

/
 !
,  !
7, 
+ -
!


* *
!



,!
!
+ !
 
!
& * !

+!

, 
/

+

,(#
@ (0
!


,!


-
!
 
-


+

,!


!!
+ -

, *+ !

(

+!

*


(
-/
-
!

/ !
!

**
 ,
+(
&
H + ?
+ !
-##&#
 # # <


, *+ !

&

(
&
"

,0
- ,"
!#
3

, 
+

0
!


,
(
#1 -
 
!!
!
+

A!

 
 
++ (
!
+!

*
- .
 
!& 
!
2/* !
&
3 *
?"

+


!

++

, #

3!

!

,
!!

    
  

   

0




 
& 
!
+7
 !
/

/
!
/

!
/ !
(
!
'

/
 !
&


+ !
!
&,!
!!
!
H " * !
*+ (


- .



(
-/
 


,
/!0
4#
$
+7
 !
,
!!
!
(
-

 
"

,
& 
 !

(


,,  !
&
!
&,!
!!
!
++

!* !
-
/ 
!
!
,.

 
 !(


/ ++

!* !0
!
 & !
&
/


!

/ !#
$
,

>*
?"

+
-
 
!

!
+ + (
 ! 
(
" 
%!!
?+!* !
-
!
 !
!
, !,!
*+

7+

"
*

#
3!
-
,
!!
!
- !
+!



 

!



 /  
!!
!
++

!* !
-

/

, !"

&
!
 

&!
!
-
,
!!
!
 
*+ (

, *+ 
(
&
"

,
 
!*+ (
!!


/ "
!
!*#
@ (0
!

!*

!

/
! 
"

,
 
!
2/* !
&
!

%


I/
 !
?

"

= ,
&
!


'

/
 !
-
!
 
(
,!

#
$
 
2/* !
-  
++ (
A

!
&,!
 ,*! ,
&
!
+ !
,
  #

3!

,
, ,*! ,0
.+

"

-
!
,./  
- ,

 ,
(
!
 
%


I/
 
-
!

++ "

!

&
!



&
!
 !

!!

&
3


-
+ 
-
"

(
, *+
(
&
"

,

.

!
,
&
>(
%

/0
"
 / !
!
 & !
&
/

0
!
1 /*
!


, 
!
&


!
+ !
++ #
$
*

 

(
<
(
&
 (

&

!
,
&
 
(
&
&

!
,
&
7*
?"

#
,, 

(0
.+

"

-
!
 "
,./  0
-
 

*
!
& !
!

!&

!

+
(
!

%


I/

&& !
,
 


*
!
!
,


!
 (

&

++ #
$
*+ (
-
"
 
"
<
(
&
"

,

! (
 
-
-
*+ (
!
!
& !

! ,
(
!
!-


= G1 ! &

! 
.

/0
- ! !
, *+ (

/
- !
!
!*
&
!
!
(
&&

/
*+ !
!
!0
,

!

 !

, /
(
!

!,

#
3!

!

,
!!
!

%


I/
-
7,

/
2

 
!



&
!
 !

!!

&
3


-



,!

(

 
!0
!
+


&
A !(
-  
, *

!
& ,
"

/
!
! ,!
 
&
!
+

!
!,



/
(
#1 -#
 
,


 /!
&
!
&,!
!!
!
+ "!
+ !

  3
*+ (
-

-
!
!
&/
 
&
! 

&


. !

*+ (
 -
 
"
"
!
= G1 /*
!
!
!
&
! 


!(

! 
( !#
$& 0
!
 & !
- ,
!
 
%


I/

/ !
!*
!
!

-


!

!
 0

!
+,


&,!
 ,*! ,#6
!# 
,%6&2*46%'%6&$'&(*+)?++*,=@&$&,%*,)2*,&(%*,%&'&& @*%6%6&*58?4,&(1?(45&,%  ! #  *+5*++&(   !.# 

&,(*,45*+)&22$,&?+$882*)$%*,!+#$2++%$,((*+8+&(' J <
K   ./ 




































J <"K *       G6&%6&+8&$C*,4H&$+,&( - &+H G6&%6&&8%$92& - &+H