Punam Sharma And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.







  
      
 

 !"# $%&



!$%$'%(# $%&


 

  
  
 

    
   
)& *+ )

,
 ,, -

*+ )

,


-+     
! 
"!!# $%! &"

 ' !(#

( )# !!!*"


!!

" !

# )# !!!

 ' !(# $%!*"

+"!( +! !%"! !# $%!


"$!)! # $%!

, ! !# $%!!




"!" !# $%! & -
 ....

,, -

.



/ "  %(!  !

    "  !  *      &  ! ! ! !

" %% ##& "(% ! /01231/4&" !!!)$#" #" (!  (! &!%5#"#" %

-!($!

(&  &"5 (% 3 "  (!  %(  !!  &  "    "! &%&((  % #    (!'   #    "  ! !  &
%/1/ &"  "!6!! !!% 7!  %5#  "!

(!  ! (  %#  31/8 9"!&  &  "  &    !  "  : %  &  31/8:; !  %!

 



%! "< %&31/8:#" " !!! %3/&31/4# $*"&!=!% "!&#"!"(! ! -!($!

(&"($! (%"&#" "!!  "!"(! #%$&"!((!%"

!%5  %      " 7!  %5  %#  /420 9"!&&"%!(( !": %&/420:;" % &(( ! #!"!-!(!$!

(&  &" ($! (%#" "!!$!(!

(& %

(! &!%5        


     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                    "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#  

 *  "

# 

"  "

 #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 8 >"! !$ "*#"!" !"%!(&"  (! " "!$ !'"%!(&"(! !"# %!" " %%  !("#"!  *!" " "!$!%5 "(! (&$ & "$! (  0

$# !(% "!" "!$ % !

"!%%&$  %!#!%"





!#" (! "(! &"(! *!

?!% "(! #*"!#" %  ?% "    (!     !%5#  " "  !'  "   

&%!9; @ >    !      "  "!  "    !(  6A-082-31/4 &"6#%"!(( "!%5 % #$*&
%3093;&": %&31/8:#*"%"*!

  " "  !     !

    /3/13131      &  " ?

      ,  -# "     .  / 0,12323$ 

4
 B >&"!$ "*#"!$*& %(!C&"(% ! /01231/4&" !!!)$#" !%5 (!  (! &!%5"($!&" (%9!;=!% "!& 5
6-# $

 ""    7  4"  

  &"'            '   " 

' ( !

  "#

    !

&  ""

 

! "'  

"   
!

&"

 #'   '  ""'  

*                   "

  8' 


9&

( !:#

 "   

 "  

 *

/



  ;   

    

'    "   "    "

 "   

     " '  %#"      & '   "  #  "'  %#"  

 

         '    "   ''      

 
2!; "      

*

    "&

!  ##

"#

 < 

    #



   
C ""!$!(&( !9 =- /8; &"!"%% ' (! &"(!  $*&"(%9!; 4 "#"! !$ "*#"!" -!%5 (!  " !  %! (D"(! !!"#"(!  (!

&!%5   $!

(-!( 0 $% 1$!

!2(34%5 '784 4$% $1 90!%# ($'% 9 1$!

:3434$%!

2 >!!"!"  6A-08231/4 &"6*"(&&"!((!%" !%5 %   % %(!    %  (!    $*  &  " $ 
%3093;&": %&31/8:#! #"! *   %  #    /3/13131  *$# *"  "

 



$&
%/1/ &": %&31/8:*!=%!" *""*9!;*! &"6# &"! $#"%( "!(* %(!=9;(&9;&!%5#*"!#"  !'"! %(!"!(*#" #

"! !

"!(*#"!

(!

"!*#"!!%"" %(&(#!# !&  3 (366 /1 "  (!  %(  !!  &  "    "! (!' " #!$(&
%/1/ 9!;!*((!# !%"&%(!C&"(% ! /01231/4&" !!!

)$#      "  !     %  %(( " #"&!%&!%&%%= !!

!" /0&" (#!&& !$#!&" " "  %% #%*"&!=!% "!& =
6 



"         '              '

 
6  >

$ 

3   



#
6   

 # "

 #'



     ? 

@
+ //  !

 &  "  !  %#    !'  !"%  %9;#"!"(! !!!' &"!  (%! " !(D #!(D!

(#! #! $!

(&&!%(! "! (%65(#" %(&"%!! #"!"(! ! "  -!(    $!

(  &  &!%(!  "  !   (%

;



"%!*((!!  #"$ &
%/1/ &": %&31/8:$*&"(% !

/01231/4  6!(#    $!(  !  &  !(  (!%"

!%5%  ": %&/420:#"" #&!#&"(! # "#%!(( *"  "  $ (   -$  "   (%  #  "    !" %(((!*&("! "!"!

$  

!$(&
%/1/ &": %&31/8:#(% !

/01231/4#%((%!%! !(! !"!

 "!  "  !      "#  !!    - !($!

(&"  (! #"&&!%(! " ! (%#!"!  #!$(& ?%$ %(!#!!

 "!"%% #! %" !

$ ?%$"%(!# !&!$#"!" (! !! !(%&"(!(!(!  "%(&"($! (%"&#"(!

%(&""!!

((!' "!

$! # " "$&
%/1/ &": %&31/8: ! E##(% ! /01231/4 /3 6%(    $  &  *"  $  " !%5  (! #    "     %% #  "  "!   !%9;&&%!9;9!;#" *""
! % !

(*&"!%5 (!  (!("$& %(    !

(  *"  $  "  !%5  (!     "  -
!#"!'*((* *""! &" $ %  :

( =6"%!&  

!" # !$  

%&'()) 
& $!'!(&"

<



!%5 (! " " (%!%"#"$&  (D #"=% &"!

$* !!

(*# !"!

(#!" "!%! %&%"

"
!& !!!#"*( !((" -$  " (%9;"&#=%!$!=%!( %%!%#!%"!#%%%& #"<  = !    &  %!     #  " !' "(5 !#%!!  "
! =%"5#"#" "!!!&-!( $!

(&&"!%5 (! #! %!



"
!& !!! *$#"!

$=%!!$!(!

( "% &"%! /8 6%(!(*""! ! "(!

!( $%!)!(# !!!"!*"

!*!(&"(% 9!; !%$% !&" ! "!$ "("(%9!;('( -%!((  /0

$#!!(&!!@&"(&(

"       "  *  #      $!(  "!  &!"  & /0!&%$ "  %! !#!(&( " ""(! 6((%%% #! &"!%#" &"(! &%6%% # *"%"*! % 1/183110 /@ "&&%&"!

$#"!#" "!

    !%%  "  $!(  &  "  (!%"  &  "  !%5 % #! " "!!" &%"!(( " $!( &"(!%" &"!%5% 





/B "#"6!(%!( ! *+#!!

,-.

! /! . 012.2!3 45

    6#!*&

 )

#"!

( "

!(*"(!!"!*"($! !!

!"&"$ %9!;!=!% "!& =5
A" # ' 

" "     

'

       "    <    #'< 

  ( 789#### 3!

2:#!   4 #4
!  !# 22 ;% 4<2

!&&! - :=4!  :

  #     10-          !24#

!&#4#:4-20 :

%  !!

% #     10-&  !  4<2  2  #  4   >)?@ 789###! 4 #4
4 30! 4 2! 4& 02 # 

  44&    4#

3  # 

2

 44 2  4<2!  .43!&  2  #  4   >)?@ 789###

44# ! 0!3#  !!# # 4<2

# !:4-20 :

%

!!

%&#32&# #

# ! :2 ;&&#

42!:#!.!!!!& 0 .24-#  @ 25
6 '$323@"

           

 " #"  

   #    "      ?'  # 


/# #



    23@

 # 

       

6"

"   

$

'   #$3 23@ 'B ;
223 

"

' '  8$%#"                  

    '      

"

   # "= #

+ = +
B#' &"'      #       

 



$  3          '    $ ""

! #'       

 $  3           $

'                  $ %#"8 '  "#' $  4          

5         #

  " 

 "= #

+= +




@3
6"

$ 23@ $4

5 " 

   $3
6#'' $4

5



&    $  3
 6          # $3  #?  '




6 



  

" #              "        $  %#"   "

<#  ?'  '


@
A " #$3 #   $%#"  "  *  '  "

'  = #   +=  +   '

  4 42!.2:

4 .2.!
7-.# !!!2..

8 @
  

  #  

       BC

$

"    

  '   $ 323@   *  " <"

 $%#"    #

  

 #

"= #

+= + 

 '

#& ' =



+

 6      '      '   

!

   '    

    $  %#"  ?'    &      $  3          23@ #$'#" #' ?""

 


""

   





" '

  
,  #'  ""

       

      !


6  #" '

  ""

 

      !     &"  $   

5
D  

 #$ %#"8 '  "

 "

  #     

   

                   



6# #  "           "

   #             & "( =AB'

B,C67'8 6 '   $ 323@ =  *+  " <

 '#"                

        

      #  " = #

+= + ' 




AB'

B,C67''8 6 ;
! '#
6 $3'#   #   

' 



  '



AB'

B,C67'''8 6                  '#
 6

# #'      #  "  = #

+    =  +'   # 

 *     

 #  " 
+ 4%09 !#!

$1
$'!3

/C >!&!"#"6& "*# "! %((&$(#"5   

*"%"&#"!  *"%& @1#111E- !%"&" &"*"  "*""





:- 4#

 !# .

 (

# !# 

* & ! " !!( !"
!%%  /4
%"!%!(&"!  % #"#!(("  !(%!9;#&!#!(! 9;  &

=,, ->

  =-+  >

   '!$ " 636!

:0?4%5 !0 $%# &

$ 636!

!:$!3079 &

$