M/S Sunstar Lubricants Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!
"#!$" #% "
& '( )"* (" +, !"# $ %"& !"# '"& (")%" "
" (- ". / "0&1( ")"% .&( 2(/0&/ "(, " "0 3!"-/0 -0&/4 "-/)"*
$ %"&* '(, "(" ((-- 2(5! 1(" !
(# 05! 0/ "("/7(6 071"! 6
8 96
/ ",&-*'(- 1!2($5!" "(&-,% !-: (" "'" ," %%!
; / %"1 < *,"1(8 %"2" $- $(+, ,/ ," 8 %"12" $-- 2+/, %"1 2" $-- 2)=6 -&"- (>!
< *," +1()=64!"2 14!"!2"% #"
!
- " ( , " !$% ( ( 5! 5! (-, -* 0/($ !,""( % (+2(?"
%, '" ," * # 05! /+($- +-% 0/
8 "("/7(
807@ "%
80/ 5! ($("!
"(-0/
%-*/(6 0/1((1(! (" (," / 0 1! 96
'(!($ 2 $*?!--A (
(!"
9
<>!2% 86
/($
, ( -*(1("
0($ !,""
/( !"("," 2 $ "" "%
80/ "(",- 6 0
80","!("!
"
=
+&#, " "!"-# & #! ./ .012 % &
& ! %'
- & " # !" #
3 1( 2 *( 2
(0/ * 2 !
"(# 05! 0/6
/= 1(" 1"!
" ( # 05! 0 ( $ %/ ( / -- ,"& (0"- 2("%
%, (--,,-*B" $1(" 1"!
" ($
%/( !(," 2(-- !!
"( ,"& (# 05! 0/ 0( $ ",-C '( -, D,"$*(?!--A ( (!"
7!,"/D"$-1 = '( ," 2 ,!"!
8 !
0"-% -*
",!", ! 2,"-% "* 5!"* ""* 2 ! ( !"&* !$-* ( - ,", $ 5!" A/ ,," ( - " (,,","4&"
% E
5!"(- ((* -$> /
* -("($> $ ?"(,!", ,*% %, / ( (- 0$3 "(,!", D 2( "$, ",!$- - ," ": ("" !"("" / $/ (""-(2/(" %-*"-'(" "/& (!2( (
03 ( "("% " %, $! &"(- $ 3 ( 2!
"( 0'(," 2 "5! $$ -* "!,,-
% 1(((2 -" 0 '(#2-!"$*
80(,"& "(- ," %(&-, " !
"(- 0@,"&( 1( 2 *(
80 *(- 5! 2F E!
"(-6
01(" 1"!
(" ($
%/( --(,"&
80 "- 2"% %, ",,-* '(,,-$-* (,"&
8 0 ",*% %, 1!- -*$
," 2!
"(-6 0($
$ "
1(((,, * "(
"%
80 '(,,-$-*
801((-1(",- & 2-"
(D &2((-6 0(-- ",-'(
!$ ( &("1,"&
80/( ",- !
" !$ (-- $ (- ,">!"
(2 "-,,- 40+,- %" %"
"%$! !$ , 2 (
( #2-!" @ ( ("
D,"-*"$* "*%,-
8 01$"2"1,
0 1(--*" ,"( 1!-$ -" ",-'(",- ", 0 - " !$ 1
80,"&B(1&"/$* !$ ,">!"
(2 "-,,-
40 '( 1
8 0 ,"& " &"- %,""*/ ,"2"& --* $ - -2-&%!"$"3 21* "%(
(,"(-1 ,"&%( % "% - %, ,!$- ,!", 1(( (" 0'(1
8 0$- 1","& 2 "($ - ,"& -2- (- "1(- !2($5!"((*2($
( 1-2-&, '( !!
0$ "(,, *
!
"(1
801!- !"%
,"& "%
9 40 -* (," 2!
"(- 0 (& $ F E $ "
1((1!-$(("($ !,,-
% --1$*-" 0 2 0 ,!$-(!
- 6 0 (
- 4: $! (
1,,"-" "(%% %
80
1!- $! $-
-1(- !(,!$- (2& !(,!$- $3 ( ,!$- ( @ -* ( ,!$- (- ( $ (("1 (
," $-(% -$> ( '((" 2 $> !
9=0 (,!$- 01!- $,"%$- "",- "%% %
80 "%
(," 2
$(& $ F E!
"(-6 0 ( -" !
" (" ( $
! -*1( (-" !( (- ," $(&$
F E@ ("1"/ -"
"% 0 $ "
/(- 2
$(&$ (" "/ 1!--,$*&"!
80C #"
!
- "( ,!( " -2-, (/(1" (- 5!"1
!
$* ( # 05! --"
'( %!
1
"&$*(, " "(" 2-"
!
- "(," " (!$% $& (&1D,"$*?!--A ( ( !"
7!,"/ !"&1/( "
0/ 6
8/(-,5!(, "/ -" 0( $ !$ " ",- 0 %
80
," (01! 96
)1&"/( (--$-$"*(" "( ," 2 "5! " 21((- " ,!"( 2 " 2(- " 1(-1/ (-
5! "5!" " %,- * ,"> " ("1 '( , "(--% !5!"2" 2(- 5! " ," D% ( $-( 3 0--("! " (1", "- , (!"( D," * , (" '(1", , " 2-* +>(A - .!2
4!"& " 2(4-- & .!2 ((",3 2 " G (("+,"$- G