Nupur Aggarwal v. Bharat Petroleum Corp. Ltd. Etc

  
  




!"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- ./

 



  





  

  
) 123
32 +#'#(") +3,4##"!5!6!(/3#(&+$7%!"#8&"5 +4&"95!+/$7%!"# +"5#:#"&"&(#+ +!4!(35!+4!/$7%!"# ++#':($#("' !($  '!;:+##"9!,+3&$5,/$7%!"# ++#':($#("  !6#'5&($!;

(  ,(',%%#''

,;  !::;&%!("  +  !;;"4#("    2 &'"+&*,"+'5&: +7&;;!<#&-!;!/&'"+&%"!+&$!*!$/5!' &;#$"5#:+#'#("

:#"&"&( 2#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#:#"&"&(#+',*4&""#$"5!""5#:#"&"&(#+ *#&(< ,;;-#;&<&*;#!::;&#$ +2&'"+&*,"+'5&:&(:,+',!(%#""5# !$7#+"&'#4#("&'',#$(=

.5#+#',;"8!'$#%;!+#$/&(85&%5"5# :#"&"&(#+8!'!" /85#+#!'+#':($#("8!'!" 5#4#+&" ;&'"8!'%5!;;#(<#$*-+#':($#("*- &;&(<
.>0

= 5#:#"&"&(#+!;' &;#$
 ?0

"5"5#:#"&"&('8#+# $&':'#$ *-"5&'%,+"7&$#+$#+$!"#$@@

++#A#7!;,!"&(("5# *!'&' "5#4!"#+&!;!;+#!$-(+#%+$ "#++#A#7!;,!"&(/"5#+#',;"8!'

$#%;!+#$#':($#("8!'<+!("#$(#4!+B#C"+!/85#+#!'(#4!+B

 !;+#!$-  <+!("#$  "  "5#  :#"&"&(#+  8!'  +#$,%#$/  !'  !  +#',;"    85&%5 +#':($#("8!'+!(B#$!" &("5#4#+&";&'"  5&;#%5!;;#(<&(<"5#4!+B'!8!+$#$"+#':($#("/ ;#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#:#"&"&(#+',*4&""#$"5!"&("5#%+&"#+&!;!&$$8(&( "5#!$7#+"&'#4#("/"5#4!+B'8#+#"*#!8!+$#$ +$&

#+#(""-:#'

&%!"&('/  85&%5  !  %!($&$!"#  :''#''#$  5#  :#"&"&(#+  &'  
 &#$"&'!:+ #''&(!;!($"#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(/ +85&%5 @4!+B'

8#+#+#D,&+#$"*#<&7#(/58#7#+/8+(<;-'5#5!$*##(!8!+$#$4#+#;-

4!+B'/%('&$#+&(<"5#D,!;& &%!"&("*#'&4:;#'"A+!$,!"&(# +# #++#$""5#%;!+& &%!"&('&'',#$*-7!+&,'(&7#+'&"&#'!($#$,%!"&(!; &('"&","&(' !($ "5#:+':#%",' &( ',::+"   5&' !+<,4#(" "5!" &" &' !

"#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(# ,+"5#+',*4&""#$"5!"&("5&'%!"#<+-/#7#( !%5#;+    (<&(##+&(<  +!$,!"#'  5!7#  *##(  4!$#  #;&<&*;#   &%!"&(&'(# "5#*!'&%D,!;& &%!"&(':+7&$#$ +!$4&''&(""5# %,+'# !'"#+ 
4:,"#+::;&%!"&(/4#!(&(<"5#+#*-&"&'#7#( 5&<5#+ "  "5!"  #  ,+"5#+ ',*4&""#$  "5!"  !8!+$    (#  #C"+!  4!+B  " +#':($#("&("5#%;,4( &(%4#8!'!;',(A%!;;#$ +(',::+"

  5&'  !+<,4#("/  +#;&!(%#  8!'  :;!%#$  ,:(  6,$<4#("'    (1*;#  "5# 3,:+#4#
,+"&(;#%"+&%&"-!+$!($"5#+'735&7!+!-!(!($ !("5#+/

@ .3

 >!($+&''!&<5
,+"&(,':!B#5#+!!($ #"%7E&%#A
5!(%#;;+/"B!;(&7#+'&"-!($"5#+'#"%/

. +&''!

@> ? (+#':('#/;#!+(#$%,('#; +5!+!"#"+;#,4
+:+!"&( 2"$

+'5+"/1"5#
+:+!"&(1 ',*4&""#$"5!"+#':($#("5!'*##( !8!+$#$4!+B'%++#%";-&("5#%;,4( %!:!*&;&"-"!++!(<# &(!(%#' 5#+#D,&'&"#$%,4#("'!($!

&$!7&"8#+#!((#C#$# ,+"5#+',*4&""#$ "5!"#7#(& (#4!+B!8!+$#$"+#':($#("&("5&'%;,4(&' +#$,%#$/'"&;;'5#8&;;+#4!&(!*7#"5#:#"&"&(#+!''5#5!''#%,+#$= 0. 4!+B'/!'!<!&('"= 004!+B''#%,+#$*-"5#:#"&"&(#+'+#<!+$'!8!+$  4!+B' +D,!;& &%!"&(&'%(%#+(#$/&"8!'',*4&""#$"5!"
&'("! :+ &%!"&(/5#(%#/"5#'!4#8!'%('&$#+#$&("5#%!"#<+-   '"A+!$,!"#  %,+'#  
  &'  ("  ':#%& &%!;;-  4#("&(#$   &(  "5# #C!4:;#'<&7#(&("5#%+&"#+&!;!&$$8( +!8!+$  4!+B' (%#"5#

 &%!"&('5!7#*##(':#%& &%!;;-4#("&(#$!($"5#:#"&"&(#+5!7&(< (":''#''#$!(- "5'#/ 
*#&(<(""5#+#/ "5#:#"&"&(#+8!' +&<5";-("!8!+$#$4!+B'&("5!"%!"#<+-#+# #++#$""5#6,$<4#("

"5&'%,+"&(2 ?



F!5,;5,;;!($!("5#+7($&!(&;

+:+!"&( !($  "5#+'/$#%&$#$ (  @>

/  "  ',*4&" "5!"  #7#(   5!+4!%-%,+'#/ +85&%5!$4&''&(&'"!B#(!

"#+ "5%;!''/8!'("5#;$ "*#!:+ &%!"&( @ 2#!+(#$%,('#; ++#':($#("',*4&""#$"5!"!;;"5# (&7#+'&"&#'$# &(#
%,+'#"*#!'"A+!$,!"#%,+'#(;-!($$ (""+#!""5!""*#!:+ #''&(!;%,+'#5#:#"&"&(#+5!$:!''#$5#+ 3%::;&#$;#%"+(&%'!($"5#+#!

"#+:!''#$5#+
#C!4&(!"&( +4 ,+,*&($3&(<5($+!:+!'"5!(&7#+'&"-:+ #''&(!;%,+'#&'',%5 85#+#(#%!(%!++-(5&'G5#+:+ #''&(&(!$$&"&("#4:;-4#("5# 3#;#%"&(
44&""##5!'+&<5";-!8!+$#$4!+B'""5#:#"&"&(#+!'8#;;!' +#':($#("5#+#&'(#+++&("5#:+%#'' '#;#%"&(/5#(%#/"5# '!4#$#'("$#'#+7#"*#'#"!'&$# 0 (+#':('#/;#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#:#"&"&(#+',*4&""#$"5!"

"5#+#:;-+#%#&7#$*-+#':($#("&(+#':('#""5#D,#+&#'+!&'#$*- 5#+%!(("*#%('&$#+#$!'"5#'#8#+#8&"5+# #+#(%#""5#D,#'"&('

%;#7#+;-:,"*-5#+#+# #++#$""5#+#':('#<&7#(*-9,+,B'5#"+!

(&7#+'&"-  8&"5  +# #+#(%#  "  !(  !::;&%!"&(  &;#$  ,($#+  "5#  &<5"  " ( +4!"&(%"/85#+#
$#<+##5!'*##(5#;$"*#:+ #''&(!; . #!+$;#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#:!+"&#'!($:#+,'#$"5#:!:#+ *B > ("5#%!'#&(5!($/"5#
+:+!"&(&'',#$!$7#+"&'#4#(" + %!;;&(<!::;&%!"&(' +!;;"4#(" 2&'"+&*,"+'5&:!"7&;;!<#&-!;!/ &'"+&%"  !+&$!*!$  #'&$#'  "5#+  !::;&%!("'/  "5#  :#"&"&(#+  !'  8#;;  !' +#':($#("!::;&#$("5# &+'"+,($/!""5#"&4# &(!;'#;#%"&(/ "5#:#"&"&(#+<"= 0.4!+B'/85#+#!'+#':($#("<"= 0.4!+B' #':($#("%5!;;#(<#$"5#+#',;"*- &;&(<
.>0

= 5#+#!

"#+/  #7#(  "5#  :#"&"&(#+  !;'  &;#$ 
    ?0  

&4:,<(&(<!8!+$ 4!+B'"+#':($#(" 5#:;#!+!&'#$*-"5# :#"&"&(#+8!'!;'"5!"'5#$#'#+7#'"*#<+!("#$4+#4!+B'&(7&#8

? 5#+#$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&(/!'
&'!"#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(5#8+&"

:#"&"&('  8#+#  $&':'#$    *-  "5&'  %,+"  (  @@

 $&+#%"&(<  "5#
+:+!"&(  "  %('&$#+  "5#  4!""#+  ! +#'5  5#  +#',;"  8!'  "5#+#!

"#+ $#%;!+#$/&(85&%5"5#:#"&"&(#+'#%,+#$= 004!+B'!($+#':($#(" '#%,+#$= 0.4!+B'(#4!+B "5#:#"&"&(#+8!'+#$,%#$/85#+#!'

+#':($#("      8!'  <+!("#$  (#  4+#  4!+B  '  !  %('#D,#(%#/ +#':($#("8!'&'',#$2#""#+ ("#("/85&%5&',($#+%5!;;#(<#&( "5#:+#'#(":#"&"&( = 5#:+&4!+-&'',#+!&'#$*-;#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#:#"&"&(#+&'

+#<!+$&(<!8!+$ 4!+B'"5#+ +#$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&(5#%+&"#+&!/ !';!&$$8(&("5#( +4!"&(+%5,+#/&'#C"+!%"#$*#;8) H    @ H
2 I2


3  2
 !'&% !"+&%,;!"#G3

GJ"5:!''

.

!'#$(&( +4!"&(

$%,4#("'<&7#(&("5# !::;&%!"&( J"5:!''

> +!$,!"#'

'"  <+!$,!"#'  +  5&<5#+ &%!"&(' $$&"&(!;  D,!;& &%!"&( (-&:;4!G#<+## !'&%D,!;& &%!"&(:;,'

 4!+B  +  !$$&"&(!;

&%!"&( !(- $&:;4!G$#<+## + #''& A(!;

#%5(&%!;G2!8G  #$&%!;G !(!<#4#("  +!$,!"#G
5!+"#+#$G
'"

%%,("!("  +  5&<5#+ &%!"&('A  /   #%5/  / 
  + #D,&7!;#("4&(&4,4?-+'

:'" "5

@

5#  D,!;& &%!"&('    "5#  :#"&"&(#+/  !'  4#("&(#$  &(  "5# !::;&%!"&( +4/!+##C"+!%"#$*#;8) H  ! " #!$%&' ""!%5%:- :+  $,%!"&(!;I,!;& &%!"&(' 

K A"!::;&%!*;#&(%!'# #<&'"#+#$3%&#"&#'/
+:+!"#'/7"+<!&'!"&('#"% I,!;& &%!"&(
#+"& &%!"#G#<+## !+$G(&7#+'&"-

#!+ !''&(< 33
G  !"+&%  + D,&7!;#(" 33

3

==.

+!$,!"# 3% ::;&#$ ;#%"+(&%'

#;5&(&7#+'&"- '"+!$,!"# + #''&(!;#<+## 
 3(&7#+'&"-



@ I,!;& &%!"&(
#+"& &%!"#G#<+## !+$G(&7#+'&"-

#!+ !''&(< $$&"&(!;

&%!"&('

&:;4!  &(  ,;"& #$&! +#(!,;"&#$&!

==.

5#  &'',#  ',<5"  "  *#  +!&'#$  *-  ;#!+(#$  %,('#;  +  "5# :#"&"&(#+&'"5!"'5#&'#("&";#$"<#" @4!+B' +5#+D,!;& &%!"&(*#&(<&( "#%5(&%!;%!"#<+-/85#+#!'"5#
+:+!"&(5!'"+#!"#$"5#'!4#'&4:;-" *#!'"A+!$,!"&(D,!;& &%!"&(!8!+$&(<5#+ 4!+B' "5+##4!+B'

!+#!8!+$#$""5#:#"&"&(#+/'5#8&;;%#+"!&(;-4!+%57#++#':($#(" /  "5,<5  ;#!+(#$  %,('#;  +   +#':($#("'     !($    5!'  +!&'#$ %("#("&("5!"
&'("!:+ &%!"&(+"5#:,+:'#/5# +# #++#$""5#%;!+& &%!"&('&'',#$*-7!+&,'(&7#+'&"&#'!($#$,%!"&(!; &('"&","&(''!<!&('""5!"/"5#:#"&"&(#+5!'!;':;!%#$(+#%+$"5# %;!+& &%!"&(&'',#$*-$&

#+#("(&7#+'&"-'"!"&(<"5!"
$#<+##&'! :+ #''&(!;%,+'#8#7#+/&(4-:&(&(/"5!"8&;;("*#!5,+$;# + +#!%5&(<"!%(%;,'&(!'"85#"5#+"5#:#"&"&(#+$#'#+7#'"*#<+!("#$

@4!+B' +#$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&('*-"+#!"&(<"5!""*#"#%5(&%!;+

4!+B'*-"+#!"&(<"5#'!4#"*#'&4:;#'"A+!$,!"&(("5#%;,4(

#$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&('/"5#+#!+#"8',*%!"#<+&#'/(#&'*!'&%!($ !("5#+&':+ #''&(!;5#:+ #''&(!;5!' ,+"5#+*##($# &(#$"&(%;,$# "#%5(&%!;

5#&'',#!'"85#"5#+
&'!"#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(8!'

%('&$#+#$*-(1*;#"5#3,:+#4#
,+"&(''%&!"&( !(!<#4#("

+&7!"#
;;#<#'7;;($&!
,(%&; +#%5(&%!;$,%!"&(!($"5#+'/

  3
 =@/85#+#&("5#D,#'"&(,($#+%('&$#+!"&(8!'H85#"5#+ "5#
%,+'#*#%('"+,#$!'"#%5(&%!;#$,%!"&(&("#+4' $# &(&"&( ,($#+3#%"&( <  "5#
%"LM

 ;;($&!
,(%&; +#%5(&%!;$,%!"&(&'!'"!","+-*$- %+#!"#$,($#+;;($&!
,(%&; +#%5(&%!;$,%!"&(%"/ =>. + +#<,;!"&(<"#%5(&%!;#$,%!"&(&("5#%,("+-5#! +#'!&$D,#'"&(8!'

!('8#+#$*-(1*;#"5#3,:+#4#
,+"5;$&(<"5!"
%,+'#&'! "#%5(&%!;#$,%!"&(5#+#;#7!(":!+" "5#6,$<4#("&'#C"+!%"#$*#;8) H?    5#  !*7#  4#!(&(<'    "5#  8+$'  1"#%5(;<-1  !($

0 1#(<&(##+&(<1!':#+"5#$&%"&(!+&#'+# #++#$"',:+!8,;$ %;#!+;-<"'58"5!"
!;'%4#'8&"5&("5#$# &(&"&(   "#%5(;<-  5#+# +#/  "5#  %("#("&(  "5!"  "#%5(&%!;

#$,%!"&(&(%;,$#'
!'+!&'#$*-"5#;#!+(#$'#(&+%,('#; (*#5!;

 "5#
'"!($"&"'+#!'(&(<!($;<&%&(7&#8  "5#(!",+# 
%,+'#85&%5&'*#&(<&4:!+"#$""5# '",$#("'!":'"<+!$,!"&(;#7#;85&%5&'*#&(<%($,%"#$*- "5#&('"&","&('/%('"&",#("%;;#<#'!($!

&;&!"#$%;;#<#'" "5#  ,(&7#+'&"&#'  5#  '!4#  &'  !  "#%5(&%!;  #$,%!"&(  !($ "5#+# +#/&"%4#'8&"5&("5#$# &(&"&( "#%5(&%!;#$,%!"&( *," +&"':+:#+%($,%" %,+'#!($+#<,;!"&("5#+;#


4,'"*#!$7&'+-!($ +"5#'!4#/!("#'5!;;*#<&7#( ""5#
 +&"'&4:;#4#("!"&(*-&"*,"(""5#
 %%+$&(<;-/:&("&'!('8#+#$&( !7,+ +#':($#("


M

? 5#%("#("&(+!&'#$*-;#!+(#$%,('#; +"5#+#':($#("'

"5!"
*#&(<("!:+ &%!"&(/5#(%#/8&;;(" !;;&("5!"

',*A%!"#<+-&'"*#("&%#$!($+#6#%"#$ +"5#+#!'("5!"(;-"8',*A %!"#<+&#'5!7#*##(4!$#&("5#%;,4( D,!;& &%!"&(' +"5#:,+:'#  !8!+$ 4!+B'5#"#+41:+ #''&(!;15!'*##( ,+"5#+#C:;!&(#$" &(%;,$##7#("#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(/*#'&$#'2!8/#$&%!;/!(!<#4#("/
5!+"#+#$%%,("!("/
'"%%,("!("/!%5#;+ (<&(##+&(</!%5#;+  #%5(;<-#"%+#D,&7!;#("4&(&4,4?-#!+':'" "5("5!";&<5"/ "#+41:+ #''&(!;1%!(("*#<&7#(+#'"+&%"&7#4#!(&(<"&(%;,$#(;-"5# :+ #''&(!;  D,!;& &%!"&(  5#  :#"&"&(#+  &(  "5#  :+#'#("  %!'#  5!'  *##( !8!+$#$ 4!+B'*-"+#!"&(<5#+D,!;& &%!"&( 
!''"A+!$,!"# &%!"&(/85#+#!'*#&(<&("5#%!"#<+- "#%5(&%!;D,!;& &%!"&(/&"8&;;

!;;&("5#',*A%!"#<+- :+ #''&(!;!($"5#:#"&"&(#+8,;$*##("&";#$ " @4!+B' +5#+D,!;& &%!"&(  '5#&'!8!+$#$ @4!+B' +5#+ #$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&(/'5#8&;;'#%,+#=?004!+B'/!'!<!&('"= 0. 4!+B''#%,+#$*-+#':($#("!($8&;;+!(B!" &("5#4#+&";&'"

@ 5#&'',#+#<!+$&(<!8!+$ 4!+B' +%!:!*&;&"-":+7&$#

&(!(%#&'("+#D,&+#$"*#<(#&(" +"5#+#!'("5!"#7#(& (##C"+!

. 4!+B!8!+$#$"+#':($#("&'+#$,%#$/"5#'!4#8&;;("4!B#!(- $&

#+#(%#("5#+#',;"/!''"&;;+#':($#("8&;;'#%,+#= 0.4!+B'!'

!<!&('"= 00 4!+B''#%,+#$*-"5#:#"&"&(#+/#7#(& &'',#+#<!+$&(< #$,%!"&(!;D,!;& &%!"&(&'&<(+#$

0 +"5#+#!'('4#("&(#$!*7#/"5#8+&":#"&"&(&'!;;8#$ 5#&4:,<(#$+$#+'$!"#$ 0>

((#C,+#A

!($

((#C,+#A?

!+#D,!'5#$5#:#"&"&(#+*#&(<4+#4#+&"+&,'"5!( +#':($#("/"5#
+:+!"&(8&;;"!B# ,+"5#+'"#:'&(!%%+$!(%#8&"5 ;!8

!6#'5&($!;

,$<# #*+,!+- ./

4B

# #+"#:+"#+