Scientific Awareness & Social Welfare Fourm Th Sham Lal Singla v. State Of Punjab & ANR
!
#$% &%'()( *+
! !
!
,'(%*$("('
-#.%*%)) , '(#/ %/"#.% .01 $2. 032 ,2#1 4#/ ,(*3/#
!!!
%$($( *%.!
5%.)0)
0*6#7 #* $2%.
!!!
%)8 *&%*$)!
+
9 4 !
, ,!,!
, 9 4 ,!
, 4,
44 .%)%*$+ .!
,2#1 4#/ ,(*3/# 8%.) *!
,!,!
, :
!
"(/%& *#$0.% &(.%'$(*3 .%)8 *&%*$):
(!%!
0*6#7 11())( *:
0*6#7:
2#*&(3#.2 (18/%1%*$ (32$
'$:
9$2%
'$9 )2 .$ $.0% )8(.($ ) 80.8 )% )#1% &%"%#$%&;&(/0$%&!
0.(*3 ' 0.)% 2%#.(*3:
8%$($( *%.:
-2 #88%#.(*3 8%.) *:
)071($) ,%'$( *
'$ (18/%1%*$%&!
)#(& ,%'$( * .%#&) 0*&%.+ <
2%.% 11())( *:
7%:
$(1% &%'(&(*3 ' 18/#(*$ #88%#/ ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
2#):
.%#) *#7/% '#0)%:
.%"0)%& .%'%(>% #88/('#$( *
(*" .1#$( * "0.*()2%& (*" .1#$( * -($2(* $(1% )8%'("(%& )07)%'$( *
)%'$( * ?
1#/#"(&%/= &%*(%& .%@0%)$ (*" .1#$( * A* -(*3/= 3(>%* (*' ..%'$:
(*' 18/%$% 1()/%#&(*3 (*" .1#$( * &%)$. =%& (*" .1#$( * )076%'$ .%@0%)$ 7)$.0'$%& 1#**%.
"0.*()2(*3 (*" .1#$( *:
)2#// (18 )% $- 20*&.%& "("$= .08%%) %#'2 &#= $(// #88/('#$( * .%'%(>%& (*" .1#$( * "0.*()2%&:
) 2 -%>%.:
$ $#/ #1 0*$ )2#// %B'%%& $-%*$= "(>% $2 0)#*& .08%%)+ . >(&%& ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
)2#// 3(>%* .%#) *#7/% 88 .$0*($= 2%#.& 7%" .% (18 )%& 2(1+ . >(&%& "0.$2%.
70.&%*
8. >(*3 2% #'$%& .%#) *#7/= &(/(3%*$/= )2#// ""('%.
""('%.:
7%!
2%.% 11())( *:
7%:
$(1% &%'(&(*3 ' 18/#(*$ #88%#/ ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
2#):
.%#) *#7/% 8%.)()$%*$/=:
"#(/%& .%'%(>% #88/('#$( * (*" .1#$( * "0.*()2%& (*" .1#$( * -($2(* $(1% )8%'("(%& )07)%'$( *
)%'$( * ?
C 1#/#"(&%/= &%*(%& .%@0%)$ (*" .1#$( * A* -(*3/= 3(>%* (*' ..%'$:
(*' 18/%$% 1()/%#&(*3 (*" .1#$( * &%)$. =%& (*" .1#$( * )076%'$ .%@0%)$ 7)$.0'$%& 1#**%.
"0.*()2(*3 (*" .1#$( *:
)2#// .%' 11%*& &()'(8/(*#.= #'$( * #3#(*)$ ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
)%.>('% .0/%) #88/('#7/% 2(1!D
182#)() #&&%&!
8%.0)#/ #7 >% ,%'$( *
)2 -) 8%*#/ *#$0.% /#=) & -*
8. '%&0.% -2%.% '#* (18 )%& #/) @0#*$01!
11())( *:
7%:
$(1% &%'(&(*3 ' 18/#(*$ #88%#/ 2#>% #0$2 .(E%& (18 )% 8%*#/$(%) -2%.% ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
2#>% .%#) *#7/% .%"0)%& .%'%(>% #88/('#$( * (*" .1#$( * 2#& "0.*()2%& (*" .1#$( * -($2(* $(1% )8%'("(%& )07)%'$( *
,%'$( * ?
1#/#"(&%/= &%*(%& .%@0%)$ (*" .1#$( * A* -(*3/= 3(>%* (*' ..%'$:
(*' 18/%$% 1()/%#&(*3 (*" .1#$( * &%)$. =%& (*" .1#$( * )076%'$ .%@0%)$ 7)$.0'$%& 1#**%.
"0.*()2(*3:
)2#// (18 )% )!
; %#'2 &#= $(// #88/('#$( * .%'%(>%& (*" .1#$( * "0.*()2%&:
) 2 -%>%.:
$ $#/ #1 0*$ %B'%%& )!
: ;!
$%.1) ,%'$( *
:
)(1(/#.
&%"#0/$) '#* #/) .%' 11%*& &()'(8/(*#.= #'$( * #3#(*)$ ""('%.
""('%.:
7%:
)%.>('% .0/%) #88/('#7/% 2(1!
2%.%" .%:
""('%.
""('%.:
11())( *:
"#(/) 8%." .1 2() &0$(%)
'$ &().%3#.&)
8. >()( *) #'$) ' *$.#>%*$( *):
2% /(#7/% 8%*#/$(%):
8.%)'.(7%& ,%'$( *
'$!
-%>%.:
11())( *:
7%:
"#'$) '(.'01)$#*'%) %#'2 " .1 (18 )% &%"#0/$ 1*(70) &(.%'$( * /(#7/% ())0%& $2() 0.$ (18 )% %#'2 %>%.= '#)%!
%B%.'()%) )$#$0$ .= 60.()&('$( * "0*'$( *) $2%.% 1#$%.(#/ 7%" .% 0) ". 1 '#* )#(& %($2%.
(18. 8%./= %B%.'()%& 60.()&('$( * "#(/%& %B%.'()% #88. 8.(#$% '#)%:
- 0/& &(""('0/$ 8#)) &(.%'$( *!
2() )071($$%& /()$ '#)%) 11())( *:
0*6#7 -!%!"!
! !
C !!
!
$ )071($$%& 0$ /()$ '#)%):
(18 )%& */= C '#)%)!
*) "#.
' 18%*)#$( * ' *'%.*%&:
)071($$%& $2 032 )#1% #-#.&%&
?
'#)%):
2 -%>%.:
)#1% #'' .&#*'% -($2
8. >()( *)
'$!
>%* (18 )%&:
#'' .&(*3 8%$($( *%.:
' *) *#*'% -($2
8. >()( *)
'$!
#7)%*'% .&%.) (18 )%& #7)%*'% #33.(%>%& 8%.) *) #88. #'2(*3 0.$:
- 0/& 0*"#(.
0*.%#) *#7/% 8#)) &(.%'$( * %B#1(*(*3 1#$$%.!
'#)%:
" .1%& (18 )(*3 ) 1% '#)%) (18 )(*3 $2%.) '#* */= %B#1(*%& %#'2 8#.$('0/#.
-#= 60&('(#/ .%>(%- 8%.) * #33.(%>%&!
#/.%#&= * $('%&:
8. >()( *) ,%'$( *
'$ 8%*#/ *#$0.% (*> />(*3 '.(1(*#/
8. '%%&(*3) %*$#(/(*3 8%*#/ ' *)%@0%*'%) 1#(*$#(*#7/%!
#*$#
#/ >!
!,!
2#0&2#.=:
C , ?:
2%/& '.(1(*#/ .%3()$%.%& #3#(*)$ )8%'("(%& #''0)%& 8%.) *):
$2(.& 8#.$= 3#.7 /($(3#$( * '#** $ '2#//%*3%
8. '%%&(*3)!
" // -(*3 7)%.>#$( *) #88 )($%+ <>%* $2%.% 1(//( * @0%)$( *) /#- &%%8/= 3 *% (*$ %B#1(*%& '.(1(*#/ $2() *#$0.% .%3()$%.%& #3#(*)$ )8%'("(%& #''0)%& 8%.) *):
$2%1 $2%1 #/ *% .#()% #// @0%)$( *) '2#//%*3%
8. '%%&(*3) (*($(#$%& #3#(*)$ $2%1 #88. 8.(#$% $(1% 7%" .%
8. 8%.
" .01 $2(.& 8#.$(%) 3#.7 /($(3#*$)!D 2%.%" .%:
#33.(%>%& 8%.) *) #))#(/ .&%.) -2%.%>%.
$2%.%
(18. 8%.
%B%.'()% 60.()&('$( * )2 -(*3 " .1%&
8. 8%.
$2%.% (*".#'$( * ,%'$( *
'$!
>%* $2%.-()%:
1%*$( *%& >#.( 0) ) '(#/ #'$(>($(%) ' *&0'$(*3!
-%>%.:
* $('%& $2() 0.$ ".#1%& #(*$#(*#7(/($= *$%.%)$ 4($(3#$( * 0/%):
9$2% 0/%)9 )2 .$!
0/% ?
0/%) %*>()#3%) %3()$.= %*$($/%& >%.("= #*$%'%&%*$) 8%.) *:
) '(%$= #)) '(#$( * (*> A%) 60.()&('$( * $2() 0.$ (*$%.%)$!
-2%.% %3()$.= & 07$ #*$%'%&%*$):
""('% * $% %""%'$ 80$ 08:
%B'%8$ 8%$($( *) .%'%(>%& 8 )$!
%3()$.= 8.%)%*$ .#()%& 76%'$( *) .%3#.&(*3 1#(*$#(*#7(/($= /($(3#$( *:
.%' .&) -.($ "(/%& #'' .&(*3 &(.%'$( *) 8#))%&
(>()( *
%*'2 $2() 0.$
6#(7
,(*32 >!
0*6#7:
!
F?
C:
&%'(&%&
! ?!
C:
#>#(/#7/% (32 0.$ -%7)($%:
.%8 .$%&
C 4 ?!
.%)8 *)% )#1%:
1%.%/= .%' .&%&G 94 1#(*$#(*#7/% "#//) -($2(* 0/%)9!
$ 1%*$( *%& '.%&%*$(#/) -%.% %>(&%*$ ". 1 3%*%.#/
8. "(/%
**%B0.% :
*)$($0$( * , '(%$=
**%B0.% C:
#88.%'(#$( * /%$$%.
**%B0.% .%3()$.#$( * '%.$("('#$%
**%B0.% !
6#(7 ,(*329)
)08.#:
(>()( *
%*'2 $2() 0.$ %182#)(E%& )8%'("('#//= &()'/ )% 2() '.%&%*$(#/) 2() &(.%'$ (*&(.%'$ 8%.) *#/ 1 $(>% (*> />%& '#)%:
#*=:
-#= #""(&#>($!
%B8.%))( * <)8%'("('#//= &()'/ )% 2() '.%&%*$(#/)D:
2%/&:
10)$ *#$0.#//=:
(18/= 2% )%$ " .$2 -2#$ 2% & %) 2() /(>(*3:
-2#$ 2% %)8 0)(*3:
? - .A & *% 2(1 7%2#/":
8#.$('0/#.) 1#$$%.
8.%"%..%& 2(1 4 %#./(%.
0.$ 2#& 8#))%& .&%.):
%$'!
$ ' 0/& (18/= 1%.%/= -.($(*3 )%*$%*'% 8%.) * .%)(&(*3 ,$#$%:
9807/(')8(.($%&9 ():
$20):
"(/(*3 4!
&(.%'$( * ())0%& %3()$.= %*)0.% )$.('$ ' 18/(#*'% -($2 $2%)% .0/%) .%$0.* 8%$($( *) )$=/%& 4 -($2 76%'$( *
) 0*/%)) $2%)% 8#.#1%$%.) -%.% )8%'("(%&!
$ 2%/& "#'$:
$2%.% 1#*&#$% %3()$.= 8%.
/#0)%?
)#(& 0/%) >%.("= #*$%'%&%*$) 8%.) *):
, '(%$(%)
)) '(#$( *) -2 (*> A% 60.()&('$( * #*&:
$2%= )#$()"(%& -($2 #*$%'%&%*$):
.%$0.* 8%$($( *!
.%"%..%& .%3()$.#$( * '%.$("('#$%
**%B0.% '%.$("=(*3 ,'(%*$("('
-#.%*%)) , '(#/ %/"#.% .01:
,#*3.0.
2#& .%3()$%.%& , '(%$(%) %3()$.#$( *
'$:
F
#1%*&%& 0*6#7
1%*&1%*$
'$:
?!
'%.$("('#$% ())0%& ! !
&&($( *#/ %3()$.#.'01%*%.#/ #*#3%.:
()$.('$ *&0)$.(%) %*$.%:
#/%.A $/#
,#*3.0.!
3%*%.#/
8. "(/%
**%B0.% 1%*$( *) *#1%) 1%17%.):
""('% 7%#.%.) :
%B%'0$(>% 1%17%.) #(1) 8%$($( *%.G 7%)(&%):
$2%.
#'$(>($(%) 2#>% ' *&0'$%&!
/()$ 3.%#$ & * .) .01 #1 0*$ 3(>%* 2#>% 1%*$( *%&!
*)$($0$( *
**%B0.% C .01 8/#'%& .%' .& #/) (*'/0&%) %1 .#*&01!
%1 .#*&01:
1%*$( *%& 0*&) , '(%$= -(// &%8 )($%& .%' 3*(E%& 7#*A -($2&.#-#/ "0*&) '#** $ #// -%& )(3*#$0.%) $- ""('%.
7%#.%.) 0$
F .%)(&%*$:
,%'.%$#.= (*#*'% ,%'.%$#.=!
/()$ 1%17%.) -2 0*#*(1 0)/= 8#))%& .%) /0$( *
?!!
.%/#$(*3 %1 .#*&01 3(>%*!
4%$$%.
#88.%'(#$( *
**%B0.% ())0%& *%:
907/('
#0)% %)%#.'2 0*&#$( *9 )($0#$%& #E(#7#&!
)#(& & '01%*$) $2 032 1%*$( * .01 '#..=(*3 0$ >#.( 0) #'$(>($(%)G 2 -%>%.:
$2%.% 1#$%.(#/ )07)$#*$(#$% )#1%!
/%$$%.
#88.%'(#$( *
**%B0.% 0*'/%#.
-2#$ )$#*&(*3 907/('
#0)% %)%#.'2 0*&#$( *9:
())0%& /%$$%.
#88.%'(#$( *!
$2%.%
8. >()( * ' //%'$( * "0*&) 1#**%.
0)%&:
2 -%>%.:
&()'/ )%& 7#*A "0*&) 1#(*$#(*%&!
2#.$(=# 1% 8#$2= //%3%:
2#.#$80.
>!
,$0&%*$)9 0*'(/ 1% 8#$2= %&('#/ //%3%:
#(80.
$2%.):
F
, :
,08.%1% 0.$ &%/(*%#$%& 8 (*$) .%/%>#*$ &%'(&(*3 1#(*$#(*#7(/($= 4!
0*( * )$0&%*$) 2#& '2#//%*3%& #'$( * 5('%2#*'%// .
-#= 4!
$ 2%/& 0*( *:
10)$ &()'/ )%+
( -2%$2%.
#0$2 .(E%& "(/% /($(3#$( *G
(( ) :
-2 1G
((( -2%$2%.
)0""('(%*$ "0*&) (*&0/3% /($(3#$( *G
(> 7#)() #//%3(*3 2#.1 (*$%.%)$!
$2%.-()%:
2%/& )2 0/& #// -%& /(32$/= /($(3#$% *#1% #3% $2%.)!
.01 )2 -* -2%$2%.
#0$2 .(E%& "(/% /($(3#$( * #*&:
) :
-2 1!
&()'/ )%& -2%$2%.
)0""('(%*$ "0*&) (*&0/3%
/($(3#$( *!
/()$ & * .) $2 032 1%*$( *%&:
70$ &()'/ )%& 7#*A "0*&) 1#(*$#(*%& -2%$2%.
"0*&) 2#>% #// -%& -($2&.#-* "(/(*3 8.%)%*$ 8%$($( *!
&()'/ )%& '2#.$ )2 -* 2#>% (18 )%&:
$2%* -2#$ 2#.1 '#0)%& 807/('!
2%.%" .%:
7#)() 1#$%.(#/ 8/#'%& .%' .&:
.01 /(#7/% #// -%& /($(3#$% /(32$/= *#1% #3% $2%.)!
* 7#)() 1#$%.(#/ 8/#'%& .%' .&:
@0%)$( *
"(/% /(#7/% A%8$ 8%*!
'(.'01)$#*'%):
-% "(*& 1%.($ 8%$($( *!
)#1% #'' .&(*3/= &()1())%&!
@0%)$( *
.01 "(/% A%8$ 8%*!
,!,!
,
4,
44
! !
,-#.*6($, $%+ 2%$2%.
.%#) *%&;)8%#A(*3 + %) 2%$2%.
.%8 .$#7/% + %)