High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20512/2015disposed of

Mata Sundri Institute Of Nursing And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2016-06-09Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

!"!#!

$!!

!!#!

# #%%& ' ( (

)!!* # *

*!#

* %% + *! !"!#! , -(

*).))

!.*

*%% + *! !"!#! , (-((

/ 0)1 *!*!!

** ) 2*!

*!"

0! %% + *! !"!#! , 3 ('3

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

(-4

. !

** 0

*%% + *! !"!#! ,

( (3

"#*

* ! 0 *!. %% + *! !"!#! , -

4 ( **))

* %% + *! !"!#! , 4 3'3

*!#!.** %% + *! !"!#! , ' (

*%6/ 71 %% + *! !"!#! ,

)*# ! !.* $ %% + *! !"!#! ,

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

(3 3

!.*

*!# ! %% + *! !"!#! ,

*!# #!**!

!".

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

3 (3 (

)!.!# ! !.* $ %% + *! !"!#! ,

(3 -

*##+!$!2*

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

( (3 4

* !#$2 *!!*!*!) %% + *! !"!#! ,

- (3(

!".* $ %% + *! !"!#! ,

4 (3(

!!2# ! * $ %% + *! !"!#! ,

' (3(

)!!

* !)* $ %% + *! !"!#! , (3(

"!"!*2!

#)#!.*

* %% + *! !"!#! , (3(3

"!"!* !**

* %% + *! !"!#! , (3(

)!.!$!) # *

.!#* $ %% + *! !"!#! , (34-

# ! !.*

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

3 (3'

* !*# ! !.* $ %% + *! !"!#! , ((

"!.* !.** %% + *! !"!#! , ( ( '

2.*

*!#!

!)#!.** !# * %% + *! !"!#! , - (

"!)!#!** ..

*%% + *! !"!#! , 4 (-4

2!.*!

!. *!.!#

* ! *

*!#! %% + *! !"!#! , ' (-'

# *$!).!.!!

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

( ('-

"#* ..

* %% + *! !"!#! ,

!)&

! "#$%& "#'() ""&(#

"#($& "#$('

"#%*& "+&* ,

! "#(## "+&* -.

! "##"& "+&* ! /

! "%$'% "#&&) "#%*"

"#%*) "#%#+ "#%#* "#%)( "#%$" "#'&$

"#'"" "#()"

! &+*&) "+&#

01 23 456

! "9456 !4 8

4 ! "+*&" "%$'% "#&&) "#'&$

"#'"" "#%*" "#%*' "#%*% "#%** "#%*# "#%#+

"+&* 9&+*&) "+&# 2 6

! "

! "#%)( "#%$" "#%#&

"#%#* "+&*

! "

! "#(## "#$%&

"#'() "#%*& "##"& "#($& "#()" "#$(' "#%*(

"#%*) "+&*

::::

! "#

$% &'%(!)*

- + # % )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

0 ;&< 0

54 ! "+*&" ""&(# "#(##

-. "#$%& "#'() "#%*& "%$'% "#&&) "#%*" "#%*' "#%*% "#%** "#%*# "#%*( "#%*) "#%#+ "#%#& "#%#" "#%#' "#%#% "#%#* "#%)( "#%$" "##"& "#'&$ "#'"" "#()" "#($& "#$('

"+&* ! &+*&) "+&# 6 =

4 > 61 6 4 4 ! "+*&"

"+&* ;"< 9?4 4

= 4

4 456 !4 8 4

@!8@

4 4 ! 1 = A = 4 >641 "+&* B1

4 = A >641 "+&* =1 4

1 A &) +$ "+&* 2 4 ! ?? 1 6

1 =

4 = 1

4 4 1 A ;'< 9?4 ?4 !4 =

4 4 ! 3! 4 B 4

= ! 4 "+&'9&% ! ? 1 A = >641 "+&* 4 = = 44 "+&* ?

6 "+&* 4

1 A =

= 4 1 A ? ?? 1 = 61 4 4 ;%< B 4 "+&'9&% = 4 6 &* +$ "+&'

! "9!8 = = A &* &" "+&*

&* 1 = C4

= 6 '+ &" "+&*

4 ;*< ? !4 4 != 2 ?!

> ! &9#D"+&'9?!

+( +& "+&%

C4 A '& +& "+&% 64 456 3 A 61 &* &" "+&'D'+ &" "+&'

;#< B 4 =

'+ &" "+&' ! "9!8 E 46 ? F ! ""(+% "+&* =

= = == = 61 =9

44 1 6 4 B 41 = 6

A 41

61 =

;(< -

41 41 G 4 4 C41

1 3 456 = &( +% "+&* 4

1 3 456 B

1 +) +# "+&*

1 H4 8 3 456 B

4 '+ +( "+&* C41

1 3

1 0 3 456 E 1

&$ +) "+&% =

6 456 "% +) "+&%

;)< B C41 = 46

- +% +$ "+&*

1 C41

1 B

1 4 41

&$ +& "+&# B

= 4 +# +* "+&#

1 3 456 = = 46

1 4 C41

1 3

1 0 46

1 4 A

6 C41

;$<

B 4 4 4

4 A = = - && &" "+&* 4 ! "9!8

@ ?4 A 465 =

= = 4 6 ? ?? , ! 4 6 4 4 ? =

4 4 =

4 6 465 =

;&+< F 4

46 1 4 = = 46 = ! "9!8 =6 64 4 6

;&&< -

C41 4 ! "9!8

4 =

419 !8 &) +) "+&* 4 ? , ! 4 6 1 = 4

4 4 4 6 ;&"< 44 4 1 = 2 5 /4 2 H4 8 456 6 ! &

6 ! "9!8 = ? 1 6 ! & 4

C41 6 ? 4

= 4 = 65 4 4 4 ? !4 4 84

;&'< B ? !4 4 84 =4

?4 ?4 = C4

61 4 = 4 6 (*I 4 61 1 4 1 6 ?4 ;&%<

1 465

C41 =4 4 4 F 4 ! & "

46 C41

4 = 4 61 ;&*< - 4 6 A 4 ! & 4 = 4 C41 B1

44 1 =1 2 5 /4 2 H4 8 456 6 ! & 6 ? 4 4

1 6

=4 +# && "+&# 46

=D = C41

;&#< ?

4 B = 4 1 1 4 = = 46 6 '+ &" "+&'

= ! "9 !8 =6 B 4 6 =

1 64 =

?4 B 1 4 = = 1 ! "9!8 = = 1 =

1 ;&(< B

1 = ! "9!8 =

1 B C4 = = 4 A4 =

4 ?4

;&)< != 4 1 = 4 ?4 ! " = C41

6 4

1 3

1 0 3 456 C4 - =

4 C41 = 41 4 64

6 46 = C41 B4 ! &

1 +# && "+&# 46 C41 64 4 = 4 6 4 4 = 4 ! & ;&$< >4 4

4 46

! &

41 = 4 6 4 C4 6

1 1 = 41 46 = ! "9!8 =6

;"+<

4 46 ! "9!8 64 = ! "9!8 =

1 1 4

A >44 4

C41

?4 ? 4 4 6 ! & 4 C41

;"&< / = 44

1 4 =4 6 54

! & 4 C41

1 B 6 1 4 A 61

? C41

4 =

=4 4 6 4 ! "9!8 4 = ! & = ;""< - C41 C4

=4 6 61 = = ;"'< 6 64 =

74 +$ "+&#

/ ! ) !*1