Gurmukh Singh v. State Of Punjab




      
   

!

"#$%$ & '

() )



       

 
 


 

  



     

 !

"#  $
 

   !            %&' (

(      #  #       )* +%+  ,+ +, -,+'       &,- &,%* ( #    # $  .  /   #              

0   -1 +, -,-,      +% "   1 "    0   2       #  # #0             # 0   *             ##0 #             # 3 4#     +, ,1 -,+1   5      

      +6% (

( "           

                 *       )*       #0    + 0 +  

,+ +, -,+'          

   &,% * ( *      )*             "      "  #              

*      #   )* "# "           

    "                

  #    #     "  

  #      #        " 

          # *     

              "#       # 3 4#           # *          ++ ,1 -,+1

2 8&9 "# "      0  #                      #  7   &&9       ##0             

  0  2 # 0     0       "        

    ( # :2     . # #     

( #:2 7

2 8%9 "                 2   ** *** * ;  )        # #    "         "# #   "    2   ##               #                "#         *      "          

 <

     # =  (  # . #
  "  0

  #  "           #         7   0 *       5 0           5 0         "  #  

         " #         

#       "  "   0     "                   " 

          *      #  "

0     "   

0 

 

 #      "   "        0  2

      #0 #       #0 # 0   (        0 

 ##       #         "     

  "

   #                . >#  ( 

  !!"

# $% $!%   &'()* 

+),  "##         .

(  $-   !!"

# . !$/ !$% 0$ 11   )2&3)
% &2(+ /    #             #  #            "   #              "  #     #

"            #           

      5 0        "        "   2 2   #

  7      

*   /    #  #      0      "   0    "##           

#  0     !  (   #   #        

 # 3 4#    +, ,1 -,+1 *    

  5 0  

      +6% (

(

                     

! )*   "     #0    + 0  +  

,+ +, -,+'     "       

&,% * (        &,- * (       0  "     

#     )* "# "                   #   )* "# "        # 8 

 "        "              #  0 #

               #    #      # 3 4# "  

   "     #    " 

          # !      0 #   #               ##      "#               #

   #0  

#      7

2 8&9 "# "

        &-        

    0  #                &&          ##0    

+ 

  0  2 # 0      0         &?              "#           # 2     # # 

#    # 2   "# "               2   ** *** *    "  "   "       

! . >#  (  *   

 79  #   8
  

                      

           

    

 

 

   

  

 !

  "

 

       



   #$  #$%     



  &   '  

 



   

    ( )* ++ )* ,- .

  )%* / '  -  0 )#*   0 )$* 1 0 )2*   0 )3* +  0 )* "

       

 



     &  4 1  &4 0        

                     & &&     4  1   

 

    

 4 ++  4

  &  & 0   



 

 

&   5    

      

   6              

0  

 

  



 & 

0   

  

        & ( 7    &0 0  &&    

 &     4  

 

0   & 

      1 &    



 &

      &

   8  88 988

8 --- --- ---

( : ;  + +

  <         &9      

              

  

  

  

  4 ++0 ,-       &  4 

     0  0 &     &      &  

           <     6     

    

        

   =         

    &  &&    

 &     4  

 

0   & 

        &                4

 4    0              

  

  &   8 8&8

88 8  88 >8 )       $-  79  .

(# 8
3 .

               88

8(58 --- --- --- ) * ;88  8 58  8)<*8 8    08  08  8  88

8 8 -8   6 0880808 8 8 8 &88 8  8&8  8  & 8 

 8 08 8  888  8

8   8 8

8 8(5 ) *8?8,88<888)@3:*8#8<82:$ ) *8 & 8A88<88  9&81 ?8@@%8<8$ ) *8  B  .  

  <  

   

8)@@*8$8<8883@# ) *8?8

88<88A8

88):CCC*8:8<8:%C )*8

  ,  

  <  D

 

):CC3*8:8<8 ) *8E  

   

  <  4



8):CC3*8$8<8#@# ) *8<  84988D  88

8):CC*8$8<8:$ ) *8! 488<88?9 8):C#*8%8<8%: ) -*8/  < A

  F   <  ?9 8):CC2*8:8=.8:%@0 --- --- ---

, : <                 &9 0



 &   

 

  

           & <  8? ,  <  8)*0

 



 

    8  088& 88

8(5

  

 5  

 5     

  

 5 B   

 & && 

 &  

 

 

  & 

      &            4

 4     5 1  6         ++   

   & & & &    5   

  &   '  

 



    & 4 5    4              

 6 0     

8&8

88  % 1      9       0         &  7   7  )     *  & G

 

 

  4

 9   &     0     

         0   0 

  0  0     &0            5  



     0 

 &       0        4  '

 < 0       8<  49  D  

8)*0  & 88

8(5        &            &  /  9   &   & 

     &  

 

   &     

         0  

0 /  9    4   &   &    

   )3  @* H?.

52$G:CI 

 

 

  0  9    & & + <0    9      /  9  

9         &  

  -     9  1   9 

          



 &                        

  <&& + ) = $* B  0  

  

  <&& + ) = $*       -       0    &      & -   -  1



 )15:*     

      &  /  9   

  

             

 0 1



 )15:*    

   <  49 )15*0    /  9 0 

      &

 8 &  A  < 

 9&8)*(5 7      

         

  -

   



           



   

    & &  

               &        

       



   &               4    

 4   &     

    1



          

 

               & 0  &  &

88



 > =      8     #   #              #0  # #0     "#     "               

 ##            ##0      

   !      #

"        "#      ##0 

    # *       5 0 "          5 0   ,1 ,@ -,-, 7

2         " 

          " "     #   ! #         5 0      #"8
B     0      & 

 

1          ,4 <  

 

  -      

,4 <  

 ,48 < 8 8 8  8   8 8 1   

     

 

    

      0     0 ,48 < 8  8  

1 8 8 8 0

 6

     0 & ,4 <     &   0 ,4 <   &





  



   &

 08888  8> *       #   #        

    

  5 0       !

     0 #   #         # #            "#   ##0  

  #

4

 "             # 0   0    #   +% "   1 "    0   2       #  # #0             # 0        ##"            # 

 #     

 # A 0               # (A $0           

5   

."    #   0      0      #   #    0   "  

 "#         #     ##    #     

B

  ##       # 2              # "#     #0         "    #0     

  #  

-.

/0 12

 #345 (6

+

8A C

A  DAB C# DAB