T.R.Puri v. Presiding Officer And ORS
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - ./* ------ %$*$*&,%/ 0%/+.+ /%+*(*,1 ''*)%/2 #$#*#3# &$5%/+
------
%+6&,(%,$+
/%+%,$ /- -7- #8#82 (9&)#$%
+-
*$.
#*/#1*2 (9&)#$% 6%$*$*&,%/-
/- :5*3 ;#+5<#62 (9&)#$%
/- #/9%%, ;- ;#$#/*#2 (9&)#$%
- - %$*$*&,%/
- ./* '*3%( 6%$*$*&, /$*)3%+
&,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# +%%:*,1 ,#$./% )%/$*&/#/* >.#+5*,1 #=#/(
2 6#++%(
/%+6&,(%,$ 5%/%*, =5%/%4< /%'%/%,)%
#,+=%/%( '#9&./ =5*3% 1/#,$*,1 #A&.,$*,1
+-
2 3*%.
/%*,+$#$%A%,$ +%/9*)% #3&,1=*$5 &$5%/ )&,+%>.%,$*#3 4%,%'*$+-
/*%'3<2 6%$*$*&,%/ /#*+%( #, *,(.+$/*#3 (*+6.$% +%/9*,1 (%A#,( ,&$*)% .6&, '#*3./% )&,)*3*#$*&, 6/&)%%(*,1+2 (*+6.$%
/%'%//%( B%)$*&,
B%)$*&,
) !*+6.$%+ )$2 ?
5%/%*,#'$%/ /%'%//%( C?
)$C-
/%'%/%,)% /%#(+
!
"
# - + 6%/ )3#*A +$#$%A%,$2 *$ 63%#(%( 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, %,1#1%( &,
--
&/%A#, (/#=*,1 +#3#/<
+- 2 6%/ A&,$5 #$ $*A% *33%1#3 $%/A*,#$*&, &,
-- -
$ )3#*A%( )&,$*,.&.+3< =&/:%( 6%/*&( '/&A
--
-- -
$ +$#$%(
#66/&#)5%(
(.$< &,
-- 2 5&=%9%/2 5% 6/&9*(%( (.$< *,'&/A%( +%/9*)%+ +$#,( $%/A*,#$*&, =-%-'-
-- - $ './$5%/ )3#*A%( '/%+5 #66&*,$A%,$ A#(% %9%, 8.,*&/+ =%/% /%$#*,%( /%+6&,(%,$+#,#1%A%,$ #'$%/ $%/A*,#$*&, +%/9*)%+ 6%$*$*&,%/- 6%$*$*&,%/ './$5%/ +$#$%( $%/A*,#$*&,
6%$*$*&,%/C+ +%/9*)%+ #A&.,$+ .,'#*/ 3#4&./ 6/#)$*)% ?
)$-
$ )3#*A%( $%/A*,#$*&, +%/9*)%+ 9*&3#$*&, 6/&9*+*&,+ B%)$*&,+
?
)$-
$ )#$%1&/*)#33< )3#*A%( 5#( =&/:%( A&/% $5#,
(#<+ /%+6&,(%,$#,#1%A%,$ <%#/ *AA%(*#$%3< 6/%)%(*,1 (#$% $%/A*,#$*&,- $ './$5%/ )3#*A%( 8&42 &, =5*)5 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, %,1#1%(2 )&,$*,.&.+ 6%/A#,%,$ 8&4
+%/9*)%+ =%/% $%/A*,#$%( =*$5&.$ #,< ,&$*)%2 )5#/1%+5%%$2 *,>.*/< &/ 6#<A%,$ #,< )&A6%,+#$*&,-
))&/(*,13<2 *$ 6/#<%( %,$*$3%( )&,$*,.*$< +%/9*)% '.33 4#):
=#1%+ '/&A
(#$% *33%1#3 $%/A*,#$*&,-
,&$*)%+
/%'%/%,)% =%/% *++.%( $5/&.15
+2 5&=%9%/2 '#*3%( #66%#/ 4%'&/% 3%#/,%( /*4.,#3 4%3&=2 (%+6*$% (.% +%/9*)% 9*(% &/(%/ - - 2 =%/% 6/&)%%(%( #1#*,+$ %@6#/$%-
& 6/&9% )3#*A2 5*A+%3'
#66%#/%( $%,(%/%( #''*(#9*$ @- +.66&/$ %@6#/$% %9*(%,)% =5%/%*, 5% /%*$%/#$%( )&//&4&/#$%( #9%/A%,$+ A#(% )3#*A +$#$%A%,$-
- #$*#3#2 9*(% *$+ =#/(
2 *,$%/ #3*#2 5%3(
* =&/:%(
(#<+ <%#/ *AA%(*#$%3< 6/%)%(*,1 (#$% $%/A*,#$*&,
** 6#*( #,< )&A6%,+#$*&,2 ,&$*)%2 ,&$*)% 6#< 3*%.
,&$*)%
*** +%/9*)%+ 5#9% $%/A*,#$%( 9*&3#$*&, 6/&9*+*&,+ B%)$*&,
?
)$- &,+*(%/*,1 A#$%/*#3%9*(%,)% &, /%)&/(2 3%#/,%( /%+*(*,1 ''*)%/2 5%3( '&33&=+
$ !
"
%
&'
(
!)*+,-.
/'0001 2
&0+0&0+& &&+0&0+/"
&+0001 3
4
,
&+0001 3
4 -'
"
567
"
# - 1#*,+$ #'&/%+#*( =#/(
2 #66/&#)5%( $5*+ '*3*,1 6%$*$*&,-
&,)%(%(3<2 #'&/%+#*( =#/(
*A6.1,%(
5%/%*,- - 5#9% 5%#/( 3%#/,%( )&.,+%3+ 6#/$*%+ 5#9% #3+& 6%/.+%( 6#6%/ 4&&:
=%33 *A6.1,%( =#/(
2 6#++%( 3%#/,%( #$*#3#-
?- '$%/ #/1.*,1 +&A% $*A%2 3%#/,%( )&.,+%3 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, )&,'*,%+ 6/#<%/ &,3< /%1#/( %,5#,)%A%,$ #=#/(%( #$*#3#2 +.4A*$$*,1 #=#/(%( /*4.,#3 $&& A%#1/%-
- , &$5%/ 5#,(2 3%#/,%( )&.,+%3
&66&+%( 6/#<%/ %,5#,)%A%,$ +.4A*$$*,1 #=#/(%( 8.+$*'*%( #))&/(*,13<2 6/#<%/
(*+A*++#3 6%$*$*&, A#(%-
- &,C43% B.6/%A% )#+% 9%:; < 9
"
B ?
2 5%3( &/ !
"
1
1
1
8
"
= "
"
%
&'(
!
) *" >
&-
!
? %
&'(
!
) *"
"
%
"
3%@%
B ) "3&0064-%>>+4"
"
>
"
!
"
"
"
C#
, )#+% *
D
"
)>
< E %
2
B.6/%A% #+%+ 2 #4&9%+$#$%( 9*%= #''*/A%(- $ 5%3( /%*,+$#$%A%,$ /.3%2 *$ (%6%,(+ .6&, 9#/*&.+ )*/).A+$#,)%+2 3*:% ,#$./% =&/:2 A#,,%/ A%$5&( #66&*,$A%,$2 3%,1$5 +%/9*)% %$)- , 9*%= /#$*& 8.(1A%,$+2 /%'%//%( #4&9%2 1/#,$ *,+$%#( /%*,+$#$%A%,$ 6/&6%/ /%A%(<-
- &,C43% 6%@ 63%$5&/# )#+%+ (*/%)$%( 3*%.
/%*,+$#$%A%,$-
%'%/%,)% )#, 4% A#(% 2
) :
"E
@3&00$4+%>>'.'"% 2
:(
!
@3&00$4'%>>.'"
E)** A @3&00$4-%>>&6+ -
#:*,1 ,&$% '#)$ #66&*,$%(
&/%A#, 5% =&/:%( '/&A
--
--
)&,$*,.&.+3< 3#+$ (/#=, +#3#/< #$
$*A% $%/A*,#$*&,
+- 2 6%/ A&,$5 +%/9*)%+ 5#( $%/A*,#$%( 9*&3#$*&, 6/&9*+*&,+ B%)$*&,+
?
)$2 )&.63%( '#)$
3#*( #,< )5#33%,1% #'&/%+#*( =#/(
#3+& )&,+*(%/*,1 3*$*1#$*,1 /%+6&,(%,$
+*,)% <%#/
D $5%/%'&/%2 #A &6*,*&, #=#/(%( &, 3&=%/ +*(%-
- ))&/(*,13<2 )&,+*(%/*,1 $&$#3*$< )*/).A+$#,)%+2 A< )&,+*(%/%( 9*%=2 *,$%/%+$ 8.+$*)% =&.3( 4% A%$ *'
#=#/(%( 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, %,5#,)%( '/&A
+-
2
+- 22-
%+6&,(%,$+
#/% (*/%)$%( 6#< %,5#,)%( #A&.,$ 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, =*$5*, 6%/*&( $5/%% A&,$5+ '/&A (#$% /%)%*6$ )%/$*'*%( )&6< $5*+ &/(%/-
, )#+%2 ,&,6#<A%,$ #A&.,$ 6%$*$*&,%/ =&/:A#, =*$5*, +$*6.3#$%( 6%/*&(2 +5#33 4% %,$*$3%( )3#*A +*A63% *,$%/%+$ #$ /#$%
E 6%/ #,,.A $*33 +.)5 $*A% 6#<A%,$
A#(%-
- 6%$*$*&, (*+6&+%( #'&/%+$#$%( $%/A+- 6%,(*,1 #663*)#$*&, +2 *'
#,<2 +5#33 +$#,( )3&+%(-
-
+8:+ 5%$5%/ +6%#:*,1/%#+&,%(
"%+
& 5%$5%/ /%6&/$#43% "%+
&