Kunal Bansal v. Punjab Public Service Commission And ANR
!"#" $%#& ' (
$ )* +# #& %#&
*, -
* %
".%/ $%#& '
"
0/.! $%#& '
!
&0! $%#& '
0
.#&" $%#& '
'+ 12'
333
4%4
! " #
$% $& ' ()*+* ,+(-% " ./0#
$% $& ' (*1,2 ,+(-% " "
#
$% $& ' (321)4(-3)( ,+(-% "
##
$% & ' (1+-* ,+(-5
$% "' 6(*1 ,+(- & ' ()*+* ,+(- "' 6()* ,+(- & ' (*1,2 ,+(- " # #
#
/ $%7
"
.8
" / 0 #
" .#
"' 613691+ ,+(- & ' ()*+* ,+(- "
/0#
"' (+13( ,+(- & ' ()*+* ,+(- " # #
' 3 (( & ' (321) ,+(- " ;. #
' (- ,( & ' (321) ,+(- <<<< 335 ' 6!" $%#& ".%/ $%#&7 ' * 6".56.06#.0 $%#& !"#" $%#&
$%
=
$% >
$%
$% ( -
=
$% #
0
$%
0
4"4
. 0 '33 ( 7
=
> .
& ' ()*+* ,+(- !
"!
# $% %!& '#& ((&&
,
0 '
+) +3 ,+(- 9: 4#
9: 4% =
?
' 63 .
9#
:
@A
9#
B
=
=
0 "
;
=
(- (+ ,+(2 9: 4.
+) +3 ,+(-= ?
' 63
=
= ' ( = 0
* #0
' (9
,6 (( ,+(1 4 0 3)3 A
#
/ #
'
,- +) ,+(2 4%
' (
:
=
+6 +2 ,+(2
4!4 )
C
=
)
@#B@B@B@ B # C
=
= 0 0 C
' (7
?
.
@#B 4"0=
= .
4!
=
'
+6 +2 ,+(2 40
=
0 C
=
.
:
= 0 0=
=
)
+6 +2 ,+(2 (* +2 ,+(2 #0=
'
= 3 8
=
=
= ?
' 63 ?
.
@#B
=
= C
8
@B@B
@ B = ?
' 63 A
.
= ?
' 63
DE '
(- (+ ,+(2$ F1%= =
= ?
' 63=
= 8
@B
= ?
' 63 = .
@#B$ 92%= ?
' 63 0 = =
@B @B= = !9
404 )*
&
!!
+&, & ( &
-%!
./ ( ( 1
/ 1 & ,, & %&
!
&,
1 1 & % %& +
& ( & -(1 / ( (
&
& /&
5!!
% # 1 ' ( "
;
(- (+ ,+(2=
0 "
' ,3- (-*.
= ,11
/
0
= G
0
A
#
= .
=
0& ' ,33+, ,+(25% # # $% %!& '#& ((&&
= =
=
= = C
=
B ' (
=
=?
' 63 .
@#B 0 C.
A
&
' ,33+, ,+(2=
,+ +) ,+(- 46 A
0=
"
"' )*22926 ,+(-
= 2
0 '
=
4.4 +) +3 ,+(- 4#=
=
B ?
' 63 .
@#B =
= = .
4 0
=
?
' 63 .
@#B
=
= B & ' ,33+, ,+(2=
= 0
0
B =
=C
= .
= +) +3 ,+(- 4%
== 0 0
"
' ,3-== "
' ,-6 .(-*
= 0 =0 =
= 0
. = =
-
0 B
0
8
@ B ?
' 63
DE
7 ' ( =
= C
= 0
8
@ B ?
' 63
D( $ ;
(< = = =
D#E= 8
D = .
(- (+ ,+(2 = ?
' 63=0 8
@B
' (7
4/4
= 0
:
.
= .
= .
=
0 = = C
0 =
=C
0
:
0
$ %
H
/ =
(3 +* ,+(2 ?
' 3+3,12-1 ,
= =
#0
8 "
8 ;
=
=
&
0
0
+( +3 ,+(- 4%
=
0
0
=
= = .
+6 +2 ,+(2
0
:
C
=
= 0
=
0
= 0
C
=
=
=0 =
= C
=*.
= =.
.
6 I
=
4&4
?
' 63 (+
' (,=
=
(4,*+ +2 ,+(-=
=
09
:
0 = #
= .
=
A
H:
,
0
0
=
=
=
=
= = ,= =
= C
A
#
= 0
!
6-1
8 1 & %&9
!
#! & (&
1 1
!
#! &
%&
(1
!&
-%! & ( (
1 1 2 & :;
+ &
!
#! &
!
&, #!
9
-
1 1 & 1 1!2 %& 11
&(! 6-1
7
& % +&!!
(
1 %
& % ! & ;
%$ & & 11 %2 '1(
$,(
& + &
(12 &
9 (12
!!
464 & ( ( %&
!
&,
1 1 2 '1(
!
&
+&!!
%
"&
& '
&
&
& &
&
( & '
&
& !&
! %&
&, /
&< = &
! % +&
+3 #
=
B
=
@B@B
&
' ,33+, ,+(2= 0 ?
' 63
.
@#B 0
?
=
= C
0
& H:
' ,
= 8
@B
C
=
=
F$%
0 ((
= @
B C
0
= 0 !
> ' !!
+
(
:2 %&
% ;
&
= & 11
! ,
& #
!!
& '&
-1
!2 : % ;
%
+
& 9
1&
= &
! % +&
+9
2
& & !
-1
1&& % ( &!#
6# & (
-1 2
&
%
2+ 9 %
#2
%$
-1
-1 : % ;
: % ;
&!!
1& ?
%
% = &&9 +
&
& (!!
%
%&, % &
(2
#
(
4#4
& ?
%&
: % ;
,
!!
&
/
& &
' (2
= & & = & 11 /
& ( %
& 2
= & 9
' 1
#
(1 & & ( ,
&
(&&, )) = & ' 1 & %
$ &
:!!
& ; 6# &
& (2 !
( %
(2
# < +
+
= & 9 %
&
& %
&
= & 9
= &
% 11
<
$ &
!!
& '
% (2 & %
1 '
< +!, 81 1 & ?
;%! 0&,
(2 !
% 1!
11 &
' !!
+ = & 11
1
,
-1 %
-(& & &
& %
%2
+
-1 9 & & &
11
9 %
( : % ;
(2 1& @
& ( 9
%
! & ' &
= & ?
9
!
(1 & & & &
:(&&, = &
!2;9 + &
& =!!2 &
!!
& 3
' (
B
=
=
(, A
0
0 0 ?
' 63
0
##
0 " ' 6(*1 ,+(- & ' ()*+* ,+(-
44 +) +3 ,+(- (* C
=
=
! ;
;
;
: >(< :<)3 ) ??**
;(* ;
,
@( ?(A*
( ;
)( --(
*$
;
B:
* 58;);;(*<
$ : -
< (?<@:
:*4 ) ) <C ;
??** * $( --
-D( -7 ;
;
;
*(-, ;(*<
) ) C(,, - ;
$() * $ ;*)(* D ()
' (7
#
#
*(3
A #
*,+
5
= .
0
.
> 0 :
=
=
= = =
:
=
= = =
= 0
= =
=
= :
4%4
(3 #
' (7
09
:
0 =
= .
=
A
B
0 H:
' , 8
@B
C
=
=
9
.
0
= ?
@
B C
0
=
= ?
' 630 0
.
(1 0 0
& ' (+*+6 ,+(,
A& ( # 02 %!& '#& ((&& 3 &
9 '? &
=!9 J I
= :
=
=
:
4"4
:
=
/ = C
:
:
:
=
0
7
7
0
#
=
0
:
#
*,+
=
= = #
0
= 0 7 0
0
=
7 #
7
4!4
=
7
:
:
A 0
=
=
=
7
=
A 0
= = =
=
0
:
> 0
=
= 7
=
=
=
404
.
=
= J
= = #
0 = 0 7 0
C
' $ %
' (7 =
C
= 0
(2 C
=
=
7=
= 0 ?
' 63
A 0 0?
' 63 =
,
H:
0 ,
H:
9,0
$%
&
( & 9
5 ?
0
?
' 63
=
=
= 0
= = =
=
=
' ( A
=
@B@B = 0
4.4
&
' ,33+, ,+(20 ?
' 63
.
@#B 0
?
H:
9, = =
@
B C
0
A =
=H:
8
0 0 C
0
0
C
=
0
0
@ B 0
= >
C
0
.
(-
= = 0
0#0 7
=
A B C1
B 5 ( C1
9
)>) ' ) K = 0 0 0
=
"
"
0
B !9 .
! & & ( %2
((&& & #& %2 -1
#&,
& !
-1&
&,
(& =!&& & &
& & &!9 1 %&,
-1& &
& !
%$ 9
! % !
+
& +&
1&& -1 %2
4/4 -1 !
!!, &
(!& ,&
( /
+ ! (!!2 % 1
!#
&&
(& (
-1 +
( (&!& +&
1 %!(
2
,!!2 %3 A B!1
5% '
!<
B "' $
))
' * K #
: =!9 /
& !
(1 &
&
&
&
11!
#
&&
'! & ((&
&&D
! &# (&
&
& & &
1 & !
% & %2
!2
& '! & ((&
+ &
-1 &
%$ ?
-1 & ?
&&
'! & ((&
% & +&
!2
!&(& , 9
&!!,!&
1
( &!
&,!& &
& &
((&
& 1 #& & &,
! & 9
1 # (! & &,
! & /
&
&1
&
1
@&#&
&
((&
&
(1!& +&
!#
?
((&
&
-1 &
!
& , &,
,
!!
!#
( &!
% & / &
&, & 11!
#
! &
( &
&, &
&
,
!!
(1 &# (&
& %2
0&,
+
+ , - & $&& & 3 A
# 0 .?&! + E(
# '
@
356&.!32 !&/5
0
# 0 . '%%
# 5
%!& '#& ((&& 9
4&4 02%3 6. -;( (- *;"/&
0 0
= #
,,1
A
0 =
0 :
(6 A 0
= =
0 A 0
0
0
= = ?
' 63 ?
.
@#B= 0= = 8
@B=
0
= =
@#B
A
@#B
A
$
% = 8
@#B
@ B
@ B
@ B=
= 8
C
C
.
@ 0C
B= C
' (7
=
0
:
.
0
' (7 = .
= .
=$+,%
464
=
C
0
,+ > 0
= .
=
= C
0
A
=
:
=
0 =
A
:
(++C
C
. = 0
.
0 8 C
=
0
. = . = & C
0 0
0 = =
= C
> =
0 .
*++. 0 .
C
,62.
C
0
4%#4
. A
=
.
=
= = =
=0
. = = =
.=
.
,(
=
' (7
=
:
C ?
' 63 C
=
' $
%
= 0 .
0C
' 63
0
=
=
A
= =
0 * ".%/5!"#"50!/!&0! $%#& 1-*?** -1 .#&" $%#&
E (;:;(,( ( -
;
*F *:*3 (
$ : >(<( -
;
*==
.
0 "7
=
+) +3 ,+(-
(- (+ ,+(2=
+) +3 ,+(- =
= =
4%4
= =
= .#&" $%#&
1-*?** -(*
, ** -1 $%
7
0
$% $% :@:* #5%#& 33