Abhishek Jain v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR
!"#$%&#'()($* +
,-
"
%+
./0
1
+ ..
2
. .
"
1 .3
1
"
0
"
44444
+
+
(5)
6
789 !
" #$%&
'()') "
*
"
(';-( 5<$5;'=
+
+
+
"
" ) :
'5' )')( 0 "
"0 +
$
! "
#
$
% #
& '
& (
& & " )*+ ,-.
/ 00-+0+) 1 & ?
"
+
> / -
+
' ' )') )(
(5)
10
2
>
& "
)'
') 6
72&
89 "
0'' )')(
1 " + 0 0
'' )'
')(?
= 10
> + 1
@ @
( 2&
=
+
1 "
<
(
1 " 1< +
> -/ =
+
+
(5)
+ "
"
#$%0 " '( )') 2& &
$
0
+
"
> + + +
#$% " '' )') )( !
@ + "
0
+
'
' ' )')(
(5)
10 2& &
" "
0 '' )') )(
1 " +
0'' )')( ; #, ,#-!*""!"."# /#/!0!"(1!!2!0(3.0 0!3)/!!*/("!
*,*
2 2
&(
( 3
,-.4+ ,-)53 6 #
,-. # #
7 # (# 6 ' #
(
#
( " "
+0+.
%"
& +0+.2 "
7
#
%"
& + +! & +0+.
%"
& +0!
& +0+.
8 /( "
& + ! & +0+. 2 #
+9!
! & +0+.
& 7:78 2;< 82="
8="7"72 +0+. 4 )> +0+.5 ( ( " "
+0+.
# (
#
#
" $
#
& & & #
/
(
& &
/
0
,-.
#
'(
2
(
#
#
2 #
( + ?
/ (
#
7 #
( #( / 6
( ( # (
(
( #
( (
'
&
#( /
# ( 2
@
. 6 #
2
(
# #
(
) <#
A"
& "
"
& B "
& B
"
& ( A
(/
@ (
<#
# #
# &
( /
9 2 # &#
,-.
2# (
#
#
" $ # & & & #
/ @ #& ( (
#
& #
&(
2 -(
#
&#
( & &
&(<#
"
"
(
&
( (
(&6
#
(
&
> (
( ( " "
+0+. %"
& +0+.
!
$
( "
7
&
& 0 # & +0 0+.
&(
# & &( <#
& &
%"
&
&(
#& &(<#
-
6 6
# #
4 *
# # &#&/#1 #'"($*2&
/45
( ( &
( "
" "
+0+. 4+5666 666 666 666 6 4.5 2
1 <#
( &( C
< @
) ') ))')( >. >A 1 :5(56B9
!
"
! +.?
?& ( +0+) #$#% &$2 6 &(&$ 4.5 ( " "
+0+.4) > +0+.5
<#
&( 2 ( D ( + +0+)
# # "
6 # (
0>4+5 ( ( ( ( "
+0+.
?"
E? F.F+0+.$D
$G ="7 D"(1 "782 8= #'"($* 2&
$ '
'' ( )
*
* *
+,+-
.(/ 45
( ( ( "
+0+.
& # '
#
4+5
(
& # '
# & &/
(
&
# '
(
#'"($*42&
5 0- 1
( 2 3(/45
,-.4 4+ ,-)5&(
4+5
$ 5
( & "
( (
'( ( #
'
( #
&
(&
#
,- -. 4+ ,-)5
( &
4
5 "
H 4&5
&
# &(
/
&
"
(&
"
&
# ( #& &
# "
H 45
(
#
& #& # # "
( (&
"
4.5 I
6 &
"
"
&
&
(
&
&
"
&(
(
&( "
#
"
6 1 /# /!0!"(1! 1!1! !
!*/("! 6
72& 89
)
+ 2
%
*.)2
6 #
( 2
6 ( %
#
#
C
2
*>0 2 2
#
7 #
6
' #
(
( # (
#
@
( (
( "
+0+.
%"
& +0+.
.
"
7
#
%"
& +! & +0+.
%"
& +0!
& +0+.
8 /( "
& + ! & +0+. 2 #
+9!
! & +0+.
& 7:78 2;;; ;"72 +0+.4)9 +0+.5 ( ( ( ( "
+0+.
#
/
( *.)
%
%
&
(6
/
6
&
2 +
#
<#
C
&(
2
*>0
(
. <#
6
( ( # 6
(
#
<#
6
#
(
# ( /
( # (
#
@
&( @ )2
&(
2
#
2 2 #
( # (
" #& # " #&
2
# ( &
#
# &
&
&## #
#
# ( ( (
( 2
&
# #
& & (
9 (
( ( ( ( "
+ +0+.
% "
& +0+.
! $
("
7
&
& 0 # & +0+.
&(
#& & &(<#
&
%"
&
&(
#& &(<#
>
6 6
# #
-
# # &#&/#1 #'"($*2&
"
$45
( (&
( ( ( "
+0+. 4+5 2
<#
( &(
C
< @
(& # "
4.5 666 666 666
6 4)5 666 666 666 495 666 666 666
) ') ))')( >. >A 1 :5@'6B9
!
"
! +.?
?& ( +0+) #0,% &/2 6 &(&$ 4+5 (
( ( "
+0+.4)9 +0+.5
<#
&( ( D ( +0+) #
"
6# &$ 4+5 0>
E? F.F+0+.$D
$G 82 8="7 D"(1 "78 #'"($*42&
-0# 1
( 2 3(/%& 2
4)9 *>0 05 &(
4+5
&$ 4 5
$ 5#
( ( H 4&5
( # &
& ( '
45
(
(
(
H 45
( # ( (
(
(
H 45
( # (
(
(
( (
( (&
(
(
(& &
4.5
(
(
& #&
#
"
4)5
&$ 4+5
& /
> <
*,-40 *,-5
1 /#$&#$%0(7(*!,0$'
'#&.0# 6+ #'"($*
< C$ '
'' ( )
4
.(545
4)9 *>05
& # '
#
4+5
( (
& # '
#
& &/
(
&
# '
(
#'"($*
< C$#$ 1
( 2 3( (J45
*,*49 *,*5 &(
4+5
J J 5
(&
(
'( #
'
( #
&
(&
#
*, ,* 49 *,*5
( &
4
5 K
# #( ( '( LB222
&
# H 4&5
& &
&
/
&
"
C
(&
& # ( #& & &
# H 45
(
# C
& #& # #
( ( &
H 45 # C
( (
#( 8
.>. 4.5I&
C 6 &
&
&
(
&
&
&(
(
& &( 1 #
6 /# #*#0!,,!.)#)'" 6+ 6
'' '
1 JI I
( E
G G 8
(
&
$ 4 5##
(
6
H 4&5 #
(
( ( H 45
( # # & & ( '
(
H 45
(
(
(
(
H 45
( #
(
( # &
& (
(
( #
(
(&
(
(
( &
8
& E /#$*)"("."($*$%*&(! 0"(',# $%/#$*)"("."( ($*$%*&(!0#!&)!).*� 0$"#'"($*(*0#)8#'"$% %'$*-('"($*%$0$%%#*'#) 45
& #
( 6 #
&&/
(
# &
4+5
&
4.5
(
&
& & 1 %1
?
0 +
"
69
0 $ 1 " A D
+ / "
2
) 3
2( '
9
*
4
(7 80- % & -8$
, 6 ( & & +0
( #
M6
N
"
&
&(
M
N & &
&(
& &(
6
(
&/
&(
(
#
(
( & # #1
$$
1 " A D
+ / "
'
2( ):) 4*
7 866 % & +,6
"9.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx **
&&(
(
&/ #
( A # 6
:
+>5 # ( 20
# x. &#&( ,9."
# "8
6 &/ &( (
# #2
( A 4#
(
@ 4#
(
1
( $$$ 1 " A D
+ / "
;
) < "
= *
; )* ( 9
2( 1)* * )(
/> .
( 86$ % & + +06
. 666666666666666666666666 6 2
( &
( ( # ( ( ( (
( #
( #&
1
(&&
(&
$,
A" / "
* (
3
( 2( '
'
7 8??
@+#
- ? 2
#
#
#
(
(
(&( &'
6 #
& &( ( 2 28 ,9- " 9)0 &( "
(
&
( &(
A #6 (&( ( A
&# #
& ?
#(/
(
#
( ( 6 ( &( ( # > <
*,-
( # #
& $ 6 #
&'
( #
# &
( & 66666666666666666666666 6666666666666666666666666666666666 666 * 2 " )*)
( &$ ( (
&
C
#& & C # > # &(# <
# &$ 4+5 " )*)
'2
&
(
(
'( # (
&
# C
2 #
4 5 &$ 4+5 # C ( # ( &
& # C ( #
#
& (
( &
C
#
&
66666666666666666661 666666666666666666 , 1 " A D
+ / "
> > :
9 *
2( );
;; ) *
(7 8 80?
% &
0$,
4 +.?
&#
( K 45
(
(&
&(
(
&
45
&
&
# 45
#
4#5
#
6
( ( &
(6 #/ & # & &(
#
&(
#
4#5 #
&
(
( & &( &'
#6 (&( ( 1
,$ A 8
+
/ "
4 4 1 2( '
' .
7 8?6 #0
- 2
& A A # #
4 5 &$ 4+5 " )*)
(
A
A 2
2( ( A A
'
(& 2
&(
&
& A A
4 5 "
)*) ,-.
#
" ).9 " # &
A #
4 5 (
5 & # &
" D
'
7 " ) ).* I
&( " D
(
(& ( (
&(
&(
#&( 3
3
51 ,$$ # 2 A 8
A" / "
@ @
) @
)
( 9(
)
7 8 8#$ @ #- -8
'
&( !# K I M N
4 5 &$ 4+ +5 " )*) ,-.
O 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 666 *
(
' ?
'
#
M N
4 5 &$ 4+5 " )*) ,-.
1 ,$$$ >
) '
1 A@ ) '
1
69 #1 "2 A
8
+ / "
'
)( '
4 2( @9
:()) 8?8%+& -$
< >.
( (# &
145
( # 2
'#
'
(
#
(
( ( &(
#
&(
&# #
#
& ( &
+
#
# (
&/
( 1
&
# 2 &
( &(
$ @ &
& #
'
& 69 $ / "
>A A 8
+
()
@ 2( @
) +,,?%-& ?,,
+,< 8 1
&
(
&
' 2
/ %
# # # #
#
M
# N N #
# &
1 $F "* B( ) '
1 ( '
) '
1
69 1 " 2 A 8
+
/ "
) * @ @ 9( '
(
880 66
< 4++52 :
& 9*) 4B5 P
( & PM7( N 49*)5.8 - Q
4&(
&
5 & I + I
# . I (
)
/
(
"
#
K
&
(
#
(H
#
#
# #
N
( & & N1 P R ( % (8 *,* % M7( N
#
<
N *,*9- 9->4L
K (%
(
& (
#
#
& 1 2 +*> 2
( &
#&( (
& M
M
( N 4*,*5 + +* .9 4I5 ( 4B5N 2 P S
!
4L5:
7
&($ " '
# &
2 #
( & '
( & ( #
(
#
( & 1 & 69 A 8
+
/ "
;
;
)3.
2(
'
80?
% )1 )& 6+#
>Q ' &
1
&
( #
(
( ( 6
" 0/ : ,
&
#
( ( (
6
&/ H % K45I
&
H4+5I
#H4.5I (
H
4)5
(1 7( N
&(
) * @ 2 '
800/+ 6,-
16-- #
(& &
(
6
# QQ1
>6 6 09 5
0 "
0 > )'
')(
> 2
> & "
)') = 2
> &> >
)')
2
> >
> > )') "
/ $
11
> >
0
+
/ 0 "
0 + $
+ 0 0 > $
0 1 0
+
0 0
" 0
+ $
>
+ "
H
+
$ > "
+ > 0 0 ><1 0 + 0
"
0> >+ 1
G
1
> 1
1
G+
+
" 0 0 1 "
" 1>
1> "A01 + "0
+ 0 0"
"
0 " 1 "
" +
+ 1
"
"
"
$ "1 "0 > "
"
1
> > > "
"
"= + + "
1 "
"
0 0 0 "
*
" / / "
1
" "
> 0
+
"
0?
00" "0 > + 10 > +
"
0
6 > >
"9 1 0 $ 0"1
/
+/ 5 2&
6 9
0 ' ' )')( 1
) '))')(
!
0
> 2&
++
+ 0
+
0
>
>
+ + 6 9 2&
"0 @ 2& &
1 > > $ +
+
>
> 0 $ 0
+
>
0+
>+
"
G+ G
+1 1 > + + "
1 "
@ 2&
> @ 2&
0
>
++ - ++ +
- - !
>- 1 "
+ '';)')(
> + " I + "0 /
+ +1 >
++ - ++ +
- - !
>- 1 "
'' )') )(
> /
+ +1 2&
+
> + ( 2&
0 > +
2& 1 "
- !
-
0 0 "
"
+1 2&
+1
< 6)9 9
(
2&
C
(
E 1 "
- !
-
0 0 0 " C # E 0
# 1
>
+1 2&
< ( 2&
$ 0
+ +
- 0
2&
+
0 2&
0 '
'' )')( /
> +
" " 0
+
5)
00 >>0 >
5 5 0
G 1> >
"
(2&
( # @ 2&
( (5( :
0 >+
< 0
" + 0
" " >
+ 5 5 1 "2 A 8
+ .3.7!0 0 1*# 6 + 9
+
1
"
>+
+ #
1 "2 A 8
+ #7$* 9&., :!0(7 7 !;( !1!9 6 + 9
>
0
+ +
0
+
0 ++> >
> "
> + 1>
> ++>
>
1 1
" > 1"
0
>
# +1 (
@ 2&
=0
" / "
2 2 A 8
A" !7#1!)(* *2/ 6 + 9= 1
"
> +
" + "
+
0
0
!
+ "
2&
" "1
+
0 +1 2&
# #1
" 2 A 8
+
> :
9
* 6 + 9
1
" + +
> > !
+1 G+> > >
5 )'69
$ +
+ 1
> G+ 1
0 1"
"
+ + + 0 +
>"
"
0"
1
0
$
> >0
+ +1
+
)'
'+ > 1 -
0
A 8
+ 1
"2 / "
2
) 3 6 + 9 >
+
"
(
" > + +
+
$ 0 )'69
$
>+
' + 5( "
> "
2&
>
+
00 2& +1
1
0$
0
+ + "
+ 1
++
0
> +
+ 1 0
0
1
" + & &+ 1 "
> + A > "
" +
+ "
> > 0
+
"
+ "
+
0 + @56)969 2& 0 G+> +1
+ $
> "
+1 " "
>0 !
$ I
@56)969 2& 0 G+> +1
> +
" >
$
$ + A01 1
+1 1
> "- - +
>
G+ 1 "69+1
@ 6)92&
5@ +
> ++> "
J % % $
+
( ? % $
+
1
"2 A 8
+ @9
:( )) 6 + 9
+ +
+
+1 "
0+
"
"
# A 8
+ @
) 6 + + 9
J % $
+
!
"1 " 0
"
> 1> "
1
5;
2&
+ >
:/
%
> "
2&
C2 # &#
,-.
2# (
#
#
" $ # & & & & #
/ @ #& ( (
#
& #
&(
-( #
&#
( &
&
&( <#
"
(
& &
( (
(&6
#
(
& & 1 = +1 2&
" "
A> 8 % $
+
6 > 0 .% % $
+
9=
+ >
A 8
+
) * @ 6
+ 9
;
)3.
6 + 9
69 "
>
2&
0
0"
"
/
"1
5
>
2&
(
@ G+
>
> + ;
;J
5 0 0
>
+ "- - 1 "+1
2 2&
>G+
++ > ;J
5 C
E $
0
> " 2&
" "
1
+
; J
5
+ >$ +
@ 2&
!
1
"
( >
"> + 0
> 2&
" 1"
0 ++>
$ $
0
'' )')( 0 0
+ " G+ ++ ++
+ >
@ 6)96 9 2&
+
> <
@ 6)92& &
> + > 1 " 0
E #
"
+ ++
J
5
2& K6> > 0 > @56(9L
+
2&
0
" @ "
1
"
!
1 55
+
" 8 % ( 10 "
"
1
@ 2 2&
% / !
"
"
" +
+
1 1
> "
1
% ? >= 0 %
+
=
0
0 !
1 0
"
1
" 0
+
1
"1
1 "
>
"
1
( (
@ 2&
I
+ ++> " % ?
? >
>
+ ' % ? > > &
+
0 0 + 0 5 >
0 1
@ 6)96 9 2&
+
>
++ - ++ +
- - !
>- 1 "
0
>
0
= +
6
> 9
0 +1 A A01 C# E +1 A 8
+ =0 "0 0
1 "
" +1 (5( 6 + " +1 @ 2&
9= 4 41 6 + 9
0 0 C E
(5( 0 0 C# 1 0# > " + / "
4 4 1 6 + # 2
A" @
) @
) 6 + 9
0C E ( (5( 0 0+ + C
1 0 0
1 >
+1 ( ( 2&
@ 2&
I (
(5(
A A =
/ "
+ ++> + 1 2&
0
0
=C E
C E
" >
+ 69>1 + #
A"
C
1 > C 1A 1<
"> @ 2&
0
++> C 1 0 1
C
E 6
> +
.
"
9 C# 1
C E0
02& &
'' )'
')( +
6 > 9
0 +1 $ 0 +1 @ 2&
++> C# C 1 C C
E 6
> +
.
"
90 1"
> >
++> C
F
F '( # E @ 2 2&
!
1 1<
0 0 " + + " $
+ 0 '' )') )(:H F ++ ++
1 +
'' )') )( $$ +1 (
@ 2&
)')
> >
0
>
++ - ++ +
-1 -+ - -
!
> 1 "
' ' )')( !
+
>9
0
+1
$ 0=
>
++ - ++
-1 -+
'' )')( !
-
+1 2&
)') $$$ > ++ - ++
-1 -+
'' )') )(
+1 <
I 0 1 -/ A01
>
++ - ++ +
-1 -+ + '';)')(
+1
0 >=
>
++ - ++ +
-1 -+ + '';)')(
6% %" > /
+
9
-1
'' )')(
++ - ++ +
-1 -+ 1 1 > -
'' )')( (
0
<
$,
@ 2&
++> # 1
C
1 6
> > +
.
"
9 0 1"
>
++> >
F
F '( # 1 @ @ 2&
>6 6 9 ' +
+
(5)!
"#$%&
'()'
') "
(';-( 5<$ $5;'
*
"
=
+
+ "
" + 0 >
' ' )')
)( 0 + 69 0 +
> %" >
+ 0 '(' )')(+ " !
" #$% +
+ "
" 10 +1
(5 5)
+ 0 0'' )')( 1
+
<
I I 1 /
3
+ + > +
(5)
"
$ 01 1
1
+
$ "0
> "
+
>
+++
+
1 " +1 2&
+ 0
> ) / ( <
=
)')( * + "- M * + M