Union Of India And Others v. Surinderpal Singh And Another





    
       

  !"#"$$% 


  

 


  

   &%  '(&  )
)

) *

  '(&  )
( *
    ! "#$%#%#& #'$'

(% )
 "#*  %& *+# ( , ---- )

) *

 +, (-   , % %  %  #  .  &  %    %

# (% # (%  # /010/1,2345,6 # #  %'# 7 + #'++ &.% %     .#  #  %  (  (    ((&  %  ( +7  % #' '7*5#5* #'  

!

.

/ !012.$3 /

 ,.#'' %7 1/1,,808 # .# +%# (7*+.(9,1,/11,$:%

+%#   (7  %  *+&  %     .#  #  (''.

#' (#' .%% 

 

     

 9 % (' &(% #'++

#%(% #(((# # ) (( #' '7(7/1;<1; %# #

'+#.##''. *   # /010/1,2345,6 % #* #(%#

 4#+ %#(
  

 

    

                 

       

  

   ! 

               "

   



# "$ %

&

'( = '  #

*  (7 %  #(   &  %  5
( #%#(' %# #%#.  ).45"##"$#  /

2$ 3!.$# / 2 7

"

"$ 2# < %&%'# +'(% 5
 ( #(% 36(*#>

7 % ?' 4$&.% &  

       

    

 (%7%#*.( %4 '#('#.7# %&%'#  #'++

%'

%#*+ % #(##% (% # @ #'' &#(+: 7#  ## # % <# @(%* +   % ?' 4$+# ' #



  !



"#$%!
&  '  '   (

) *(

(+, - 

' .

 /$ ",& + ,912/112 %# ## # %<# @ +74#+ %#( !



      $     )     

 &       '  &     



" $   '*   

 

     +   $    

     

  $    ,             

        

) -                 $                   

 $         $  

 .

        

   /   

     .          

         -  $$

       

 

         

 0   

  1    $    

    

              

0

$   "

 1  23

      1     

 

  

    
4 

 4

     1 

   

    2  3   

   )

       

  4

      $       

 

             $ 



   $   



 

 (

 0 # ( ## # %<(%* +3 #6+'#'

 +%(#+%#+## +'#7% %*+( '# # '#+%&%'7#' #((+ %#

*  (#'  %:#%#7  '&'# '  # 75(4# (  #    &  % &  %  # '#   +'#7&  #%  %# +7 # %.# >+ &%&: #''. &.% #(%#%##(  +  #  (% # % #((' (%.  2 %# +# ## # %@%(&% 4$

+'# %#% %$.#>(  +%'#( ##( +* #  (,@ ## %#.%  8 %# *.#'#

#%#*#++  # >

7# 



 0 0!



"#$% !

&  1& (

$,

- ) *(

( +, 2(3 ((   0 %'*# ## # %.%(# 4#+ %#( 5 

 







    $



  $ ,    





 *  

 ( ( 

   (

,  / ,
##(43,

/  3, , 3, 3#(" ( 

   ( #,    23    

  

    $ 

    

  

              $  

  

    

 



    23     

    

 

      #  " 

   (53( ",  /, (    ,   + , 

  $  

  

    6     

     

   

   23 

  

    

  

     

   ).45"##"$#  /

2$ 3!.$# / 2 2 #7$3 $  ,1 %%%# &%'# +'(%  7%#%#(# >

7##

'+#'%# +#&  #  %  77  (  %  (+  +7##  #'%7  .# #'# + (% #'  # %#% .7( %#

(%+% %7#A ( 36((&% .'

' '#>(#'+#  ,, 

(%# 7&% '#+ '#+#% B

  C+%  >

7  #    %  ?'   4  $&   /118/1,@&+#' # 8"$3 2)"$169# $"$ 
$3"

 $3

2#&.%+% "8"/77

/::; ; #   % '*# ## # %(%# * +#4#+ %#(
      *   7

" /   # -  3     *"895  



1

        554    

$        



)  )

          

    

$           



  

     + 

         

                    

        

         :

  ;6

 

     

           

          

 554  9

 

)  )

        $  

 +            

    $ 

554<5   

   

     8  (
$ $!

#  6"#.2  ,/ % %&*' +##  '#  7#  % #

* .% #+%#'' +# # +'   #

 %++ &% &%# (# '#  77#A %#7% %*+( '# # '#+% .*&% 4+ %#* + '&#' % %* ++ % 4$+#' #) *(

(+, - .

 / $ ",!

#  &# +#' #$,

- ) *(

( +, !

#  &2%#& % (+ '++ &+7

0 ' 5(4#( *5#5*%7&.%#(%  %#%# + ' (#  (% #(7%

#((' (%  ,9 C%##7# &#(%4+ *% # 4#+ ## # %&#++%* +3 #6   % 4$&%4&%#+## (#' %+7 * %#

* &% &%# *7(# (#'  %%#

* &%.'

('#+ #+ +#  (  #+  *5#5*  %  #

*   '#' &  %   %

'#  # (#+'#7&%.'

##+%#%%# ('7#% #    *+( '# # '#+% .'

((+*' (+##7' '+A# #% # ( %('''(%#

* ,=  7 .%%%+#(#+.%+%#++

*5#5*%  %.##+ #+ +#(#+ ( 7 .%%#%* + & # (#' %* %  &% & +# #7 %(#+7%#&%'*#+#(#+ #++ %  & &%7#A (#* + %

?' 4$+#' #'

$"$ 
$3"

9#

58

2?&   ) $/"$ <;& + ,1,//1,=&.%& # +'##7# %4&%#%(( ((& #%  %#    +7   .    %  ++   %  '*#

## # %#++%* +3 #6#4#+ %#(

  7-       & '       $



  

  

 

        

  



       $     $     .

    & '             

    3

 8 &'05<0=&>.3'  

      ?      = @$     

    A     

      $          "   /

>  $     $    

     "   /  >      $ !+ $          4+     ) & '

  & '              .

   

   

   <  

    , 23



    

             

  ,< %(&+%#  (#' %+#7*

%  & &%7#A (%* + % 4 $&+#' # '

$"$ 
$3"

9#

58

2,#.72 -  :'&% +'##('#.7# %* +3 #6&.%  #((+* %+7 . *5#5*%++ &% *  '#' &% .7(%#  %&*5#5*% ++ &  %  +7  %  +  (  %  %(7

6

7 &  .%%    7   :'  %  #%  %    # #+'#7&# &# 7%.% ,@

+  %  * +  3 #6  +#7  +   ,1,//1,=# % # 7(%# * +&%# 7(% #'++ &% #/1,2 % %&%  7(%* +3 #6 ## 7 7  #+%&# #7' #(# '# (# 9D  #  #A '#+  .*&  .%  %    .7  7# % *5#5*%  &##'' +( # (#'   %  :#  %7  %(&  .%  %   (#'   % * %  #%% %* +3 #6 ++7#'  #'  +(  #  +  #  +  +#  ( #+ :# %     '#'  #' %  # (#' %+#7* %  ( % A :#%#

 (( 7# %(#* ,0

*  %.  +  %  +'##  (  '#.  7#    * +3 #67#A%# +'###4 '#('#.

7&% &%4 '#('#.7&#7# * + 3 #6#'7#A%% +( (*5#5*%

(+  '  ++ &  &    

&  #'  '  % ++ &%## 7A% # (% .7# 7# % &# %#&%(''+7 '7&# ' % &  +*(%#( '# # '#+%

 

"$ / 23 2  6"#.2  ,2 #(7#%&%$( 7%.  #  .%  %  *#  #(# &  %  #7    7   % 7    7## # #((7  ,8

+%7#+#'(%# + &%&#''%

 #

'+#36&(# &#'# 36   (     ,)

) *

-  ,( *
-   A#* % 6

2#7

0"$1=2

#$ % #= 6

22 72

4/

% #=