← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7316/2011allowed

Parveen Mehra v. Haryana Power Generation Corpn. Ltd. Etc.

2024-02-27Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri13 pages



  

    





  





 !

"#$ %& $'()(%* ++  





 

 !  #!"  

 ,- + .

 .

.

 

$  #% &'( ) *"+ 

 ,  ,  ( *"+ !  ) " % .( *"+ !" ///// .

.

 

+/"0!



! ! -&"

" *+&   '3 +    3 " ""

 5 

 

1- -+ !  & '3 ! 7+  8&++& 833 + 9!:(



0-(  ""

  ;

< !!"

! * 83 --+ !"    ! 7:"

- -"

=!=

)!+-+ +"  :!"

:

"

( 

+ +"

"+"

+:! 

* :!"

:

" !1

- ++- & +:!&  + && :"

 33

 - '

- "

-+

2 

!

&"

 !-: +&"

 ! ::

:



 - +:!& ++- & 3( -&3 4 "

- "

!  +



&&+ + + "

+!  &3  >5?

!  :

 ."

!  ;

< 0-( " ""

<

<(  ! "!:  + 9!:(

 -&&

"

 * : .3 --+ !"!(  : :!"

& *- !(

!"+! "

 +  + -

!

&"

&( +:!&"



 &1& - "

 +



*&&+ + "

!( -&"

!& 0-( ;

""

< 

" !"

"+3 "! :  #;(@(5<A &3  > 5?

!  :



" 

< *3 -"

"( !-"

!!& 1- :(

   ! 7:"( +'

& 5 -  ( !!&& 

"+"

+ + "

!

!

 '"

# ( 5( A

!

:  &3  >5?

!  : 0-( -&"

+"

!!&( +&&33

+ !"! 1

"+"

- "

:  # ( 5( A &3  > 5?

!  :

: ":"



@  #% &'( ) *"+( 1:"

+ !"! !3 :!

3"

"  ;



&&

1 ( 3 +"

3 : +" &- 3  + "

 3"

& -3 : +" &( 1:"

!+-+&&

!""

B

  :

"

+ +"

"+"

+:! 

  1:"

& 3   !+-+ " !"

+:! 

 3"

+"

"+"

: -+

"

 5

<  5

< 3"3 " +"

 !+-+&&

"

" - # @(

A ! !+!

  "



&

"

"+"

&

" + &&

" - !"

!



 -"

+   !

&"

 !

<



 - +:!& ++- & &

"- & : && &1& - "

 +

!

&&+

 1:"

&3 ( +:!&"

  5

<  + 9!: <

<



- ! :  

 --+ !"! -   &

&

 1:"



!&

-&"

!"!(  3 33 "- 

!   '

 

0-( + &

-"

" (

 5

<  5

< &

" ! : + 3"3 

+ !

&"

""

+:!& 

 -  + !& !

&&+  - ""

!

  1:"

- "

"+"

- "

1+'

+ &&

3 +"

&& &-

 7"

) -"

   :&

#. % : ".(  3"

.1 '"

- "

:  

*""& )+ (

)8C( +'

& & 3A&( 0)(

)8C( !(  -+ :" + 13 B ;

AA;<8

+ ""

@

<5;< &"

"  !

1&+ !(  +"

+-+A++&  + !(  -+"

. & ) :( 

3D  !

1&+ !( 1.+ - '     1&+ 3& !"

  1:"

: 2"= &( #. % : ".( -+"

1+  "+ :!&:"

 ) 8&++

C"

+ 3  3D  -+"

1.+ - 3:  - 1"

7"

)   1:"

!    <  3 ! "!: &-  + 9!: -  &&

+"

 + "

""

<5;< :"

 -"

;

  1:"

-   ."

"!: +(

( ++"( :

 3 : 

( + &

3 "!:

 <  0- !

! 1 "

&"

" &-&&"

& 3 -3 !"

+"

+ ( 1:"

"

!

!   !     1&+ 3&

 !  + "

! 3

"!: && " - !

! &- 3 &-&&"

  1:"

 "!"

 ) 8&++

C"( - "

: & 

+ 

-+"

- + !"B3:

1

  1:"

 + : "

  ( + A- "

 "

+ "+ :

"

!"! + :    "   ;

 5

  "( &"

!!3 1&- !"! 1:"

+ ++!"

  !+-+ !""

."

! * 83  1 "

: +" -  + 

++! : +" &

 1:"

!

 + &( :&-



+ :&-  1 "

- "

+ "

!!&& 

 # ( 5( A &3





  1:"

- +!"

 ++"( : !!&+1&  -+ -  3"

1- :&

#. % : ". ++"( 3"

.1  - ! ++"( :&-  +

 ) 8&++

C"

+ 3 "!: - 1- 3"

#. % : ". !!&+1& ! !

 1:"

-

 ++"

 +& + !

&

:

"

 + +"

"+"

+   !+-+ " "

+3 +3 !"(

" 1&3 "

!"!

- 

 +:!&"

 1:"

 " & 



!

&"

&( "A+:!&"

- &3 ++!"

&3

:

  &1& - "

:   "

&"

!  +

&"

!  !!"

* 83 !""!: ++!"

1"

! + +"

;

+!"

 &-

 B

 +" !

&"

 !"

+"

"$



          



    

 



          

!"

                 

#     

!

     $        

 

 

        



   



!

     

      $   

 

      



  %                

!          

  



 "

  

   &           

  



   

        "

      '

()  



   & 

!      *       



   +,-* ,! 

      .

  0-( 

!

 + +" B

+ 

 9!:  9!: +(

( <

<



!& '

&"

) 

!

&"

 1& -6"

 1"

! + & : ! ! : 1 &"

! "

3

"3  &

" 3"3 - -6"

: !"

!

+ &- 1&   + &&

"3  !

! +&+ & 

 : "3 "

 ! - !"

*++"3 !(  +:!&"

 5

<

<

:  

 + ! :  

 - +:!& 3( ""

&

+" &

2   & 3 &   3"

1-  !" 3 --+ &

( !"

1& +:!&

- +:!& 

 & 

(  +:!&"

 * ! & !&

-&"

!"



!   3 33 !&

3 : "

&"

!"!  :

+ & : ! 3

* ! & -"

  & 3 !""

:

"

1.+ """

+ "+"

+"

+:! 

"+"

" &

! - ! 3 4  -

B3 1 3 +"

!"   + &&

"3 &

+ &"

!"

+

(   

1& 3  + &"

!" +!

+

"

  "-- ! +!"

&

+

:" 1.+ + "+"

+"

1& 

"3 &

"  -"

! !"! -

13 +"

"3 6+ " !"! 1&     3 "

!&

-&"

!"! 3"3 : 0-( ! -"

+:!&"

 5

<

<

<

:  

 -

+  : -" < *! 1   ! &    !"+!  &"

:!&:"

"

:" !!&+1& :  ! & 3 "-- -+

& ! "

!"! -3 !"

+"

"$ /#  

   



    0 

12-#    !     ,! 

3

  4 567-7-582 



 78 77 58    



 

 /9      "





!

-             "

      

 :

  

,! " * ,! "

 &  ,! ;< 

     "

:      

 

 

$        

!

 

          

 .

@ * ! &   "

5;<  3"

+ &' : : -+"

 . &( )





3D

 !

1&+ !

2 ! 3D &-  "!: +

( +!"

1.+ - '     1&+ 3& !"

2  "( & 1.+ "

  & !

1&+ ! .  !

1&+ ! "!:(  & +  14  !  1&+ !"

2 ! ."

"!: &-

<

< + &

3 "!:  < 

0-(

1.+ "

&-&&" & 1"

+

+& &3 3

"

&-  !""

- '     1&+ " ! +

: -+  -  !( ."

"!: +(

( :

:



 :'

"--+ 1+  + &

3 "!:  < && " +:!&"

&

1&+

 :3&

:  +:!&"

1 ;



* 6!& 3

&"

!"+! & -3 

!&



!!&

&

 3 &"

& 3D  3 !! +&  &    !!&+1&( :++"

0 3 !"

+"

1 !! : 2 

+&&

+"

+ 1+  &-  9!: +  && 3 1 ;

  2  -+ :+ ! +(   ! &&"

:!

3"

"   ;



 1

 "

2 &"

!"! + + :  # ( 5( A &3  !

(  &&  " +

.

.

  !

  ++



 !'3A"

$

FAB

 !1&

$

FAB