Shamsher And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR

CRM-M-32157-202 4 (O&M) -1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CRM M-M No.32157 of 2024 (O&M) Date of decision: 10.07.2024




 CORAM: HON



        

 

N'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MAN ISHA BATRA

Present:

  
30  



4 5*
!, 




 MANISHA BA



 !.
65

*
!
!7*
/ /1  **** ATRA, J. (Oral) 



 
  
 
'

 
0 


 





 




 
 


!

"
89
 
1
6
 
: 


 *
:


#$%

&'

'
 
(


  
 

( )*
(
$
 
  + +
!
!



  


 1
:

*
:


0 0  1




  
1 




 

  

%  
,


  

- 

  , 


  






#$%
; &'
 
(


0


  




 
   
( )*
( (


$
 
 
   

0
  
1
   
 
 
, 
. 
 
( & &

&
    


 

/



0  1

 




 
0


 
1


- 

 
*
, 
 
 

)

 

%8 +
 -2-

%!828&

&*
 . 

 







 

%
+
65
0 
0
  


 5
 
<

  

 

  *
0
0 
0 
5 0





 *



 

  

 
  1
 




%
+
6 5

 1



  





 
0 
1
 
1
 

. 
  

 
1
 

;
(

 


  


  
 , 
  ' &


 

 1


" 
 %
+
65
 

(
$


  
1
  
 




   


  




  *
0 

 


 

#$%
;
&'*

0
  1

,, 

 
 



# #$%
;
( +
 

* *
  
  
('&*
(& *
(+* + 
(

$ $
 
  +


!
!
/


  
 

2  
: *
3 
$

   






* 

 
 1
  *
0 

 

 *
 

0 
0  

 
1
  
0 


 1

 *
   *
 1  





 
/0 , *






 , 
 
, 

 
 
 


   

 1*
   *
 1
,
 


 

 
/  *
 1
,  



!

" 
8
= =
8(9
 

  
 
: 


 *
:





  1
 
 


 
1
 
   , 1

,

  /0 , *
1




 *
 
 



,


  


-3-  
  





  

 






 


  
  *
 
0

 









  


, 


 
*
0 

  1





*  


 
 1



 
1




, 
 0*



 

  
 . 


1 


 > 
 1



. 

 
 
   

 
*
  




 1
  
  







  , 


 0 
 



 



 
  

+
 
!.
65

*
!
!7 7*
/1 *
0

,

  *



 

 

  8 
 

  


1
 

 

 
 
 
 

/



 




  








  0
0
 

*
 


 *
&)(




 *



 


 


   
: 


 *
:

 
*





  
 
  
0 



 ,




 

 
 
0 
1
 
1
01
   1*
    *
 1






  1
  1
  

 
 
 



,, 
 
  

  
 
! 
*

  



 

  ,

 0 

$
 ,
 
  
  

 


0 

  
  
 
  
 
,


 

 
 1

)
$

-4-



 

 


 
1
   

  

 

 
  
 
( )
 
0 

(

$






# $%
;
&'
 
(

*

  
 
  
( )*
(

$
 +


!
!
  
  1
:

*
2  
:


 1

   






  

  


1 

 


 
0  
 
1

 

$





 

 
 
0 

 
1
 
*
, 
 
 

)

*
. 

 





 
0
  




% %
+
65

 






 

 
 






 
  1

  
; 
!





 *

 
1
  
: 


 *
:

*
 , 








1


*


  


 


*
0   
 
   


0








 
  
 1
1
 ,





 





   
 
 
 
 
0


  
 
 
 
 
0  

 

  
0 

   
 
1
 


 

 

*
   *







  ,


0 

'
- 
 ,



 
 


 1



 *
 
 
0
 5

  

  


*
0 
  , 

  

 


    0?


 !  
 
  
   
   

              

-5-









 

 


     !        


  

 

 

  





    
  
  
  
  " !  
    
 
    

  
  

 # 
 

 
 


 



   


  

   
  
     

       
 
    
 



    

       &
<




 
  
 ,  




 1 


1

 





 1
 


 
  @ 
 
01

1
 
0


   



1
 



 
0 

 
  




   

  
 

 


 



*





     

 

 


 
0 0 




 



 



  




 


*

 
 

. 
/0 , *



 
 *
 
 



 


 
  ;
1
 

 
0 
 
,


1 1




 








  

 

*
0 , *
0

 
  
   


0
 




  
 1*


 
  

 

. 

 

 
  




 
 1
  

 






 
 



  *
 


 .

 

1 

1


1
5

 , 
  
 , 

 

  
 
  
 
 





0  



 






1 

0A
$


   


-6-


 
*

 0 
 
 
 





 ,

 , 

 


 

 1

 


1 1








 


 




, 
 
 
 





1



0
,
 
 
0 


 





 



     1
  









 
0 

 
1
 
*






 , 

 



  5



 
 

  
$

 
 *
 

    

 
 1
  

 !%  &'

$

"

# $ *
0 0 


0
 , 

   ?



 


0

, 




 



   

  


, 



1 

  


, 


0

1
!

   

 
  


, 

  9

  



, 



1

 1
  
 
   
  

, 

  
((


 

  


   

,  
1


, 

  9

 
 
  *
 *


, 
 





 
  

 
 ,  

 
" 

 *
0 
 
  *
1

  


   

  <


, 
  


 
 
+ +
0 
 



 

 



 

 

" 
 

 
1


    
" 

0 

0 
  
$

 "  


 
 


  9*

  

 


 
   
1
 



9



 

   


  


 
.

0 

  

   
 
 *

 0








-7-  
 *


 


, 

 " 

 

 
  

 

 


>


 


 

 
 
0

0 

 1

"  
 

  
  

 
 
4 4 1

 




  




 
 
 

5



  
  

 
 
  1



 



, 1


 
  
$




  1 

, 
  

   

 
  

1

 
 



  
  
0 
,


 



,  
 


 


 , 


 
 
 

  



 
,
 



 1




 


01
< 

  


 

  ,

 


  
() +9

 

(& 9
 
0
,






0

   

 

 



 

 
/




  

  


   


 
 

 
 
 1

0
,


 
0 
0

5 0



1
 

   

 



  


 
  

, 

 9

  

    

 
  

, 

  
CCC$$$*


 

  
  


, 

  9

 . 


, 


() +9
 
(& 9
 1

"

 
1

 
  
 

 

, 
$
1





0



  


 1
1
  
  






  1
 

  


*

 1
  *


1








  
01
 



  


 1
<





 *






   



0 
  
  

   

 


   
 
<



  







-8- , 1
  *





  

 
 
  
01 1





  

  1*
 









  


 1
 




*

1
 

. 
 
9
< <




 *
  1


 1
   
 

 


5



0  

0
   1
  
" 


 

 

  




"

 
 


   
1





 1
 




1


 



01



 
 1

 

1
1 
5 , 


 

  

 
1


 *
 
 1E

% 



 



 
   

D

  9

()*+!, -)*

!

;
'


(*
   
 ( )

(*
0  

 
 , 
, 
 

$

, 0


 

 
, *

0 
 



 
 


$
%&'  
1 
  



: 


 *
:


  
  

  


  1





  


 






 
 





  
 
: 

 *
:



0 



*
2  
: *
3 
 




  8!

! 

10.07.2024 (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE


Yes Whether sp peaking/reasoned Yes Whether re eportable