High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14372/2018allowed

Satya Narayan And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

2026-03-24Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil8 pages

!"# #$%&&'

( )*+ & , +, ++ * **** !" # !" ,-%# . $/#0"12 &

3-4 3 $%&

() " *) + !, ) "- ../0..1 * )

) " ) "2)

3 ) 45 .5%1$ 6)/& - -3- "%/ .5%7$ 6)7&! 3 .8 .5%/ $ 6) 4& "

09: "! --" 2) -+

-!56 $.&

+ ;'+ #-" <"$'#&+- 3 3 9 -:)$9:&" )---3+-

$9:&3 !" " .5%4;%= 3) 3 - ) + .7.>4448 4/ -! 0-3+-- $ 6);%& ?

) ) ;: ) , 3 ! "" -9 -:)'-" ' ) @:

- 2 - + 3 ") )- 9 -:)*$9)A B & 58 .5%5 3 " + - :) 3 - '-" ""

C3 *) :- + - 3 ?

$*& 18=8 .5%% )- - "

"-"" 39:"

" ! 3:* )- 3 -3+",-3 "

<" C! :- C3 *) ! ()3 .8 .5%8 2)

3 ;

3 " +)+ ")- "! "

- $4&

C " $%5 %5"$%$758 . 5"5"$% 36 $=&

D ") -

)3 )

!" ! 6" -- ) /%91 :"68 # "

! 3 ! 6 3 ;-) +- !- 3 - ! 6"-- , " <" C- " ) : - ' 3.8 .5%/ - ") 3)- 9! ! 6 ! 9! ) 3 - "! - - 6() 6 + - $8&

# -" 3 - " ()3 *)

! ""# *)

- 3 - " 9! - - + !+)")- + - + ) -" "" )" " ")- + ) +") "")

" + " - - " -3 ! 2) -

- "") )- 2)-" +)+-

6.$%# %56)!$/%5 3 $/&

" ) ") ! )- " + : - *

- ./ .5%1 ,

$9:& 3 !" " .5%4;%= "- ABE ! ! ! " : ..5%%0%0.5%=;@ $:& %= %% .5%= ")- + ")-- !" :* " ! $1&

+ 3) )3 B ) + :* " "- 3 ")- " "---: '

$7&

D ") - ) ) ") )- 9 -:)*$9)A B & )

6 3 ") )- ! " - 9 - :) '-" ' ) @: 58 .5%5 -- 3 !- + :- C3 *)+" 9:" '-" " ' " '- $ "- & " "

-- 3 3

- 4 -

30" + *)+ 57 .5%4 3 '"

"-*" 39:" ) :* " ! 39: " "

"-"" "")-" " + - ) -.8 .5%1 -

- 3 :* "" + ()"- " -3 ) -+ " $>&

" !" " .5%.;%4 " :* " - .5 5= .5%. -- ) 1% !" "

$9:& F " %%5" -- F !" " " 2) + 3 .5%.;%4 ? 3 : .8 .5%/ "3"- - - 9! ! ) 3 "- " -" 3 " , -"! 6 " "- " -" 3 33 " !-" -"!

$%5&

C- ") -

Analysis $%%&

2) ()" + *) ! 3 + :* !" " .5%4;%= - ./ .5%1 - -

- 5 - 3 !" " " 2) -6 -3 : '

$%.&

) -3+- F " !" ".5%4;%= :* )- -" ! ) 2)-- ) - - 3 :* .5%4;%= +)+- +) +") "

- "

! 3 3 -3 3 3

30 3 " + " "" B3! " 3 " +) "") 3 -- ) ! ()"-" 3 " + " - $%4&

B - " %= %% .5%= ! - 3 - 3 - )+ 2) + -" '

%= %% .5%=

) +", - : ' ; - ! ""-)++ 3!" " "- +" F " -! - 3 - ) ! )- ! 3 G")- H '

) 3 ) 3 "" F " ! 3 () - 3 "

! )-:* "- + "-) - ?

"-) - - - ) ) +-

- 6 - " "- + "! )-- +", 3 "

$%=&

C! ) - ) 3 !")" " --3 " )"-3+- - " ! 3:* )- + - -F 3 " ") !" - "3 F " - ! !- "- %= %/ ) - -F !- 6 -! -" " " )" $%8&

$" $ )& *)" " + )- ! +) - -- +") -" " " )" ! +

) " - - ")- + ) )) "")

" 3 -- 2) - + + ! 3 +) " " )" )-

!+ '

" )3 3 " 6-" " 3) + "-

- 2)-- ) - " 3 -3 )- - ) ! 33 " "

$%/&

! )+ 2) "-" -,: ..5%%040.5%4;@ $:& .8 .5%/ )3

) " 6

-;"!" 3 "- " -" 3 " -" 9! "

- 7 - + 3 3 - " 2) - 6 " ) '

""--" - " 9! ! + 6 --"

3 ! -) 3 -"! +3 - () -6 + - ?

- ")- 6 "--- -;"! "3 ) - 3 "-

)- + 3 - ! - + ) - - "") - 2) "

$%1&

B 3 %= %% .5%= - + - " - G")- H

) 3)-- - "" " - - ) -, '

- "- )- ! 3 G")- H +) 3 "- 3 + ) ")6" 3() " 3 3 - ! 3 " 3 ! "-- () !")--+ ( 3 3 -)

" "-: 5> 5= %>>/ .8 .5%/ "-) "- - 6 - 6

)

- 8 - $%7&

! ")

-- )3 "

) " 45 .5%1 %/ .5%7 + B"- ("2)

" ! 3+ -- ,

$9:&3 !" " .5%4;%= "

() 6 -- - ) "-")- 3 ! 3 -+ +

6" - 6 !

-- + " -

"" $%>&

3-" "" 3- &&'

,-%# . $/#0"1

/#0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No