High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/638/2009disposed of

Cit-1 Chandigarh v. M/S Pb. State Coop. Agricultural Devep. Bank Ltd.

2016-11-11Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan29 pages

!"# $%&&% # $ %(

)*+,-, ./& 0"

, $%! (%

1! 23 # $ %(

+& $5+.

65724* .+ 8-,$* ,8 )9:1+# $6*:

8-,$* 65724* .+ 8-,$* 1**;

,24# 8-1<* &

.&-!& % ((# !# ! .,0= 2&# ,% !#

.2%0 . .(# !# .+ % ; # !#

.% & # !# & &&&& ???????

,8)9:1+# $6*:

8-,$* %& (%& # = >%( 7& (%& $%&&% @&A %%( &&&& = B 2=

1%!%&% 2 %

'>%( "&% &%& >

F %( >

=& %(%"

/& @A@A@%A G F 67" %( >

/& @A@A@%A >" !%&% '%( &&&G F %( >

&! %"

" '%%=

%(%"

/& @A@A@%A G B F 67" %( >

&%& %"

" %!%= '%%=

%(%"

/& @A@A@%A GH & !% &%& >#

%& &&%= &

,% @A@A@%A & ' !

! "# $ $ @ F # "%( %! &%=# (&& %

& = '

"&% @A# &

"0 !%&%& &%# & &%'%

" &% @A# &&&&

@A & '

"&% @ & '>%(# =

%! &%= ((

% "3%(

"&# (

&=#

> '%&

(%&

" =

%!%%&H B !%>

"' %%&

&&= & % . ,0= 2&#

&% & %( " '

& &&&&#

,% @A@A@%A " "&%&

((

"3%( > "&%& ((

# >!# &%

&&&&7& = "&%& "&

> & "3%(

F !

&&&&7& "&

"%( ((

&# '#

! %= &"%& %( & ((

"3%( > F %

%%( %& % "'

I &&=# '#

> &

'%& >

+! "3%(

&% % "&%& 7& > %

= "&

&&&&7& "&

.&-!& % ((#

& %( " '

+! %

%& %

(%!

& "'

"' !

&& & "3%(

&&=# '# '%&=

% > (!

&& % "'

% %# >%

&&= ' > &%

"' %%& &&&&7& &&&& =&

C %& &&&& = B# % = %&

% ((

"3%(

%& !% $@A

& %&& &% "

%= '% %(& (

$@A = >

&&&&7&

6>!# %& "0 # $@A

'! &&&&

= =

$@A

5 &%'%

&&&&%( &!

E% & &H "3%(

,% @A@A@%A F > ' > &%

& %(& %( &&&& =& % %

%&% &

I @A .&1 (( %

"3%( "' &

&&# %

%(& BB

& &&&& =

, '%&= %

'>%( ( & $@A

E 6>!# !%

/ /

(

I K B# > % %&& & %!! > &# $ @&A

((

' %&%( '

/& @A@A@%A ( 23

%(=

/& @A@A@%A "%( "&

(

&%%

&&&&%( 5''% ((

"3%(

1# (

"& %' &H @2A ( $@A

& &

"3%(

!%(

"' $@A & &&&& = B & ( ! & "' $@A

%&&

& $@A &&&& = B & %&& & &%

(

@$A F &

(

= %'

> $@A "&%& > &

(

' '

= ! %'

"&%&

F &

(

& # &

D %!=# %

%& "3%(

( !%"

"' $@A

% (

% = & &&&& =

@1A %(%

# >!# !%"

(

% = =

%( "3%(

% %&# '# %"

,% @A @A@%A

%(% (

&&&&%( 5''%

%( 23%( &

,% %% =&

%( 23%(

% "

,% @A@A@%A "

&&&&%( 5''%

& 67" '>%( , $

&&&&%( 5''% >&# '# &%'%

>%( % +&#I#I# / @&

,% @A@A@%A

&&&&%( 5''% &%'%

&&&&%( +&B# #I#B

E5 , &H 23%(

,% @A@A@%AH @*A >&# '# &&=

& & "

"' $@A & &&&& = !%"

( $@A

& & "

& '&# '# = ! '!

% "

= "3%(

@:A % ' %%& (%& .&1 ((7& %

"3%( & &# %%( &&&& = B# ># % (

% " '

E % %

/& @A@A@%A#

%& "'

&# & @%A & =& L +&C# # I /# @%%A & &! L +&# # B#B/# @%%%A & & "& L +&I# C# C/# @%!A &

&% L +&I#B#B # / J @%!A 1%&> !%&% '%( &&& @A L +& #CI# C / I &

+! %(%" %

/& @A@A@%A " &

%( "3%(

1+ %

&&&&%( 5''%

23%( +( % #

& !

"3%(

23%( +( % #

$ 1+# "0& = '%%=

= "&%& &%

,% @A@A@%A %&&%" &&&&

,# >!# & ' '&

%& # = & (%! =&# "&#

&%&

&! &# & &%

%!%= # '# &&&&%( 5''% &%'%

=%( %

/& @A @A@%A &%

%&H 6

' "

((

"3%(

"3%(# % >

! ! " %&

!# >

! " &&= +! ! %&

5 =# >

! "

" '

+! # "'

%''% %(% !%( "

& %

"3%(

%''% % %

= "3%(

$@A > !

"!# % %!%

= %

&&%&

% %&&

$&% %( '&

% && &# > >

'! %%( =# +! &&&&# !%(

%& &&%

& "!%

% & %&& '! "&%& ((

# '#

&% &&=

&&&&7& % "&%& & ((

"3%(

% "

((

"3%(

((

"3%( '# 0

%&# .&1 ((

! & ( % & '%

&&"0%&

%& "%&&% > '

,% @CA

5 M4# + $ $%!%

'>&

"'() $ *+&$ $$$$$ $$$$$ $$$$$ $$$$$

@CA ,! >%&

# !%&%& $ $%!%

A# %( & 6%( $ & # ' = "# = &

&%H ,-.

("' $ $$$$$$$ $$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$

'**$

"012 "

) )"

"'$!@ = & # ( = !

# = =

= & & '% (%& % "> & = %&& ( ! " '! N

= & 3 = && "0%

! 3 >= #

"0% $ >% % &

&!% % %

= '%

%( # >% % % $ = & '% >

& ((%!

(

(%& "&

# '% && "0% &

& ' "&

'% %(# >% & &

%&% = '% ''%%

%&% %#

# %&# > = # '! & 3*4 12"

# "

'"1') 5, && "0% & '

!%&%&

# & ' = '

# & = @A 5%

@BA F # = = &

"0%# %(% >

%&%&&

' # "0% & '%

= ! &&

' % %& %3& '%# @IA !%&%& %( & %( && & # & ' = %"# = "0%

B .2&7& %

'>%( "&!%&

( , $

# @

,$$ BI > '

( & # #

(

'>&

*&$ , ' % # 4> $%&&% &

@ A &&= E>H & '% && "0% (%& !& '% %( >

%( '% &&"0%& (%!

"%(= '% && "0%& > = >

E=H

& !%&% '%%( &&"0%& (%& '% = "%( !%&% *6$ & %& 4> $%&&% '

, 5"0&

+&& =

'>&

E+

% &

C (%!& >

%&% %( & & '%& %(

'%& %& = (

(%& %N

%( 3%( = &&"0%

& %( ! 3 >= '%& & &

( ( # >!# D %& & %'%% " & &

(

(%& % F =

"%(

& '% &&"0% & '% !& % >% &

%&% > = = '! H @ &%& % .30# 8 "&!

@ BIA $F I @& E

+ 5

%%& >H @%

! "

B .

BB .

BC @:2A

%'%

E% >

% > %&

C '% &&"0%& ! > & &

&%( '% %(& (%& % "> & = %&& ( ! " '! H &%% !%> &&

- 2 ># 8 # $

. II '

C # "%(= '% &&"0% (%& !& '% %( % = >

& '% &&"0%& !%># %% &&

.30# 8 $ 6%( $ " '

1%!%&% 2 %& "

87& @& A

!%> &&

-2 ># 8 0 ;

7& @& A . = & 6%( $ ' ( &%% '

C F

& ' # >%

'%%( &&"0%& 3 !& '%

" &&

(%& & # & &%%(

> $

%&%&&

(%&

' && & '%%( &&"0%# '

C = %

= > &# > &

)3 +7& @& A . & :

$ "

0%7& @& A $ = %'%

( > ' H

I &&&&7& &( '% (%& %&& > ((

"3%(

# >

&&=

% %&& '

"&%&

'# '# %( %&&

&% %# &% D %%( '% &&"0%& ' & % %&& &

$ ( = = ! " &&

&%= > $ '! =

%'' "&%&

%&# # >

& &

"%&&%# '# %

%& % "& && "0%& & 0

F ! % ((

"3%( %

&% >

' $&% %( %(& ! "

= &&= &%

%% !% F '%# '#

% %&&

% &

C %& "%(&

&% % &%& > %

"&%& ((

' &%& > % ' & & = & !

&&&&7& =&# &! %!&

&&&&# & !

&%& &&&&

& %&&

%&> !%&% '%( &&& @A

.7 $*

& '

%&> !%&% '%( &&& @A # %

& = ! "%( '

& ((

"3%(

& %&

,% @A@A@%A &&&&7& "&

O &% %&# '# &>

(%& %&' % "&

= "%( ((

.8 $9":

.&1 ((7& "%&&%& & > &%& > > &&%= &

F# '#

(

& %!& &! &

%&>

% "&%&

&&&&7&

3 "3& %

$@A >

% (

%!&

%&%( %!%= %"

" &&&&7& "&

E%"

"H ,% @A@A@%A

= &%

%%=

( %

( ,% 2

7& %

" %!&

%%P '%&

%%P% &

B &

+&IB &

&%& !% "3&

%& &

&% "3& & & !%> &

% & (

&&&&7& "& $@A# >!# >

%&% %"

" &&&&7& "&

I .&1 (( "%

%&%

I # , $

( # & '(

) * #

@ ,$$ , "%

( !& '! +!

&# & $%! $ ,%=

& 3

&%=

%!&

&%& "3&

<! & %%& %&

&% "' , $ > >

%'=

&% @A@A@%A

$ =

& "3

&%&

& %%&

( &

(

6;$ &# % % & %( %( & &#

%(%"

,% @A@A@A %!

F & (

,% I %&%( %!&

&%&

& %%&

&&&&@&A 3&

> & %& > %

% &# >

% D %

% %= &&# %!&

&%'%

& %%& &% "'

%&Q >

&%&/& %%&# &%= &3%( & "&7 #

,% G !%># >

(= E & &H# # >

,% I # %( =

&&&&%( ''% 6+$ %# > = =& ,% %& &% & $ )# > % #

& E1

%& & % %&H ,% %& &%

%& & %! &%%& ,% @ A# % %# && > (&& %! &%= %

& = &%'%

%!%%&# &

(&& " ,%= %# %"

" = &%'%

%!%%& ,% @A # >

%(%"

% >

E%H "

,% @BA@A %

'%&

(%& %& "&% % &%! !%&% % %

&%'%= E"

'%&H %

'%%% >

E%H '# > D %

(%! %&

%( > E'%&

(%& &%&&H %

,% @A 6<$ & &# &

"!# ,%= ( = %!&& % %= D %

&& & %!&&# '# ' >% % %( &&% E'%&

(%& &%&&H , &%

& %"

" %!%%& ,%=# =# 3%( (%

"& F ,%= & "&# & % & &

"!# &#

%%(%"

,% @A@

& %!

"& &# > =

& D %

% %= &&&&@&A &&

! " = %!&

&%'%

& %%& E%!&H 6%$ :

# &

"!# &&&&@&A 3& (%

"& %& & = && E%

H =" "&# >

" ( # %!&

&%&/& %%& , # %

,%=# %"%%=

& > " & %"%%= &% '# # &%

" % %!%= %

,% @A@A@A ,% @A @A@A '# 3%( '&

% && &# > !%> &&&&%( ''% %( %( %# %

"!#

,% I *&$ "

(& > %

" '

&&&&@&A % & %! > % & !%&%& ,% F '%

% " &

(& %

> && %( %! "3&

,%= "3%( &%&& F '%%(

( '& & & &= & !

% %"%%= ,% >

" & >

(%! >%( ( > E > '%&

(%& &%&&H %"

" %!%%& &%'%

,% @A@A *6$ % % % > E > '%&

(%& &%&&H &%& &

% & ( &% %

& &%= % &# !% & >& ,%= & D %

&& (%! % % '# '&

% && &# !%># '& (= E5 %H " %( =

,% I H

( &%

&& > %!&

&&&&7& 3

&&&&

( %& % %= D %

% %= D %

& %

& %!

> & %

6>!# &%

% %= D %

& = ! & & % %= D %

& >

= >

!& %%& &

&%( & "&

"%( !

&&&&7& %!&

"3& %!&& D = &%

" &&&&7& "&

&# & &&&&7&

%!& "& %

% "3& C

( 1%!%&% 2 $

* # (**- ' ! ./ $ ' 0 1 )# @B & !%>

&# $%! : %

& &%

%% "&

# '>%( &% > > %&

1%!%&% 2 &>

& '>&

EF '&

% &&

> 67" !& % "3& "%( %"

" %!%= &&&&# %'%&

/& @A @A@%A # %(%( '&

% & & !

&%=

= % "3& ' '%

&%&

&!%( "3& &GH EB " '

! %!

% "3& !

,% @A @A@%A

+% "

( 67" , $ )("

"#="' =0-$#$$$ $/*&6&39;4 *;

&%& <! & %%&

$%! ,%=

%!%%& ,%= !%

,% I "%( & &

& &%

( %

( 67" , $ %

" '

! #

! !( > %

> %

%&#

&# !

'! !

( 67" , $

$= !%> &% I !%> "!# '>%(

( 67" , $ )("

"#="'=0-$"

"4# >

% &% '! !

> H 2=

# , $ (

! (%&

( %%@&A ,% 4! @$%!%A @&A CBI/

( = &=

F "

(

& '> (

( , $ &%!

F # = !# &'

( %% 1%!%&% 2 (7& & !%> &

( < 0 6%( $ 2"

* 2* '

* #

3 $# @ A

B 1+ @< 0A

%= & > 2"

* 2* *! >"&% < 0 6%( $ %& >( % ( < 0 6%( $ # > !%'%

%(% %(& = & > E "

* 4 '( )- . - 2 - 6

5 &%& EF '&

% && &# &%'%

+& # B#IC /

&%&

& @A@A@%A GH

$%! ,%= (%&

< 0 $%! ,%%& #

&%& &%

&& , 23 % !%> ( %'

'%%%&

, 23 %

,% @A@A@%A $ %(&

,% 0

!%> "

&%& > "3& & 3

%! 3%(

&% (

&%& %&%( &&&&7& "& 1%!%&% 2 < 0 6%( $ '

(& '

.2& "'

1%!%&% 2

,% @A@A@%A

( , $ (7& @& A

'>&

&# %! &%= ((

"3%( "&# >

&% > '%&

(%& %"

" = %!%%& , $

@& A &# > % (%!%( %& %( > E'%&

(%& &%&&H %

&% @A # "&!

( = %!&

% %= D %

!%> %!&&# '# ' >% % %( &&% E'%&

(%& &%&&H

" %!%%& &%=# =# 3%( (%

> E > '%&

(%& &%&&H &%& &

% & ( &% %

& &%= "&!

% &# !% & >

&&&&&%=

> D %

& (%! % % '# '&

% && &# !%> # '& (= E5 %H

%( = "

&% I

%% # &%= ((

"&# %!&& "3&

& ' = (%& %

&% @A@A

@& A# %( = "%

& & #

%( > 3% %!%%&

=" >

" (

%!&

&%&/& %%&N

% %!&

&%& <! & %%& %& > &&

%&% ;3 6%( $ !

, $ > %

'# &%= "%( ((

"&# %!

&%&

& %%& %"

" 0"

3%( (%

& "& %& %&# '# !%> "!

%&% &%

= %!&& % %

& & % %= D %

&& , $

%!&&# ' >% % %( &&% E'%&

(%& &%&&H

" %!%%&

&%=# =# 3%( (%

> &%= & "&# & % & % %= D %

" %!&

&%'%

& %%& E%!&H %%(%"

&% @A@A@%A : "! &&# &'

& ( !%> 3 ;3 6%( $

!" @& A

%&% , $

@& A &%

& &% % %!

3%( (%

= &&

%!&

&%/& %=

%&% '%

'& &%

> = >

B &# %( %%& %

, $

@& A# &%= ((

"&# %!&& "3&

& ' >% % = (%& %

&% @A@A

I 5 " '

# % "

"= > 2=>&# &

% *(%&

'( H "0& &%= &

2=>&

@ ( %'# &'& ''%%=

% (& &%=N @A % &!%(& (& "&N @A (%! &" & > &% %&&N

@BA =

%!%%& %!%( "0& &%= &# "0& &%=

%!& %!

"& &' 2=> # =

& '&

"0& &%= &# "0 &%=

&% @A@A@%A

& %

%&%& > % "3%( = %% # &% % =

& = = "3%( &%&&# &%

%&%& >

%" '& & &H

@ &%& % F %= (

( < 0 6%( $ &%= "&!%

( , $ &%

= %!&& & %

> ="

( & %& & % %= D %

&& F

(

( = % >

7& = (

% "&%& ((

&& = %% > >

"'% ! "%(

& ((

"3%(

%&& >

.2& %

( & 6%( $ '

* #

' 2"

)

+ I @A

(

%&%( %& "

&# & &&&& $%!

B ,%= ((

"3%(

&&&&& > "0 ( %& +&! 23 % #

23%( +( % #

1%!%&% 2

%&%( %&

( , $ (7& @& A (

, $

%( %( %! "3&

& "%( &%

"&%& "3%( &&&&7& %

.2& %

( ;3 6%( $ # "

' ) * (

+ - 7 (!- # "

I II BBC @;3A

&# &&&&$%! ,%=

&%& "3&

&!%(& "3 &

"3& &

&% > %"

" "&

1%!%&% 2

'>&

E '# >

E%"

" H %= % &&% %!

F ! (%& >

(%! &%

%(# = !

&&% %!

&&% E%"

" H "%( %# &%

&&%

(%& > ! = %

( %& & &

&%&&

$%! ,%= "&# & '%&

(%& "&

%# %'

I % %= D %

"&# = 3 &%

&% "3 & %&# &%

" '%&

(%& =

&%= = & %( %

'%&

(%& %"

" %!%= "3%( %! &%=

(&&

> > 3

( $ ./& (& $%! , ,%= # % # , $

%( > &&&&$%! ,%=# "&# & 3%( (%

(> "&

& &% % %!

3%( (%

= &&

=" >

" ( # %!&

&%/& %=

, %

&&&&,%= %"%%=

& > " & %"%%= &%

'# # &%

" % %!%= %

,% @A@A@%A

,% @A @A@%%%A

' '& &%

&# $

&&&&%( ''% %( %( %

,% I

= = '%%( &%

( '& &

' # , $ =%(

> = >

%& &# %!&

"3&

= "&

%"%%=

& > %"%%= %

' '%&

(%&# % %= D %

= "&# > 3&

' =

= "3 & %&

" "3%(

' %"

& ,% @

' &%% !%> 3 & 6%( $ >>== >!,/ # $

== ?@-$/

3*&664*&&,>**&A6*

!%> # &&

%%&

=%( "'%

% '&%

& &%" > %(= "= & &%

"&% &% > &>

(%& !

6# > && '>%( #

$ %

%&%%

1%!%&% 2 &&=

(

" "3%( # '# %"

,% @A@A@%A

& %%# > ! &%

> %& "3%(

&"%&

%& "3%( & =

%''

= ! && %(

(

%&%( %& " ( # > >

%&( & !%>

(& > ! = '

"&%& %% (7& &

= !# > &

" ( "&!%& , $ (7& @& A

> = >

: & &#

( ;3 6%( $ '( ) * (

+ - 7 ::- . #

I I @;3A

C &&%& & &&&& B & % &&# &%&

'! +!

(%& &&&&

( (

& &%

.8 $6.!

I >

"'% ,% @A@A@%A &

!& =& = %'

=& ' >% % "% E"&H &%

F % ! "%(

%& "3%( =

%'' ! %'

=& > ! ' &&&&7& =& &%

E"&H

;% '( ' ; 0 ) '

* #

C ,$ ICB# , $ &% %( % (%

,% @A@A@%A

E &&% E"&H

,% %! &%= &"%&

!%&%& > , 4(%& ( # &&% E"&H &% @A@A@%A &# '# &

!%&%& >

, 4(%&

%! &%= %%( % " '

%&# '# &&= & &&% E"&H &% @A@A@%A %(

'%%% &&% %

&% @A $%! ,%%& H C F &# '#

!%&%& 0"

$%! ,%%& #

> > %' # %& &&&&

,% @(A 0"

$%! ,%%& # '>&

E*$ @(A E"&H & & 0%%( %% (%&% %! &%=

& %

"& % ' (%&% # &

"=>&

& %

&&% "

<! > "&%"& & % &%=H

'%%%

& %

% &&# &%

& &>

'! +!

(%& &&&& & % &&# & &% &%& >

= "&%& ((

% '& = &% >

& ((

"3%(

! '% "%( (%& &&&&# >

%&& & "'

&# = !

6>!# ! '% ((

"3%(# &

% > "&%& %

"'% ,% @A@A@%A

= !%&% & %& "0

%(=

%&&

B=$$?C D =

!"#

B @=-D & &

F & /&3%( K&

F " K&