← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14435/2018allowed

Ram Parvesh Yadav v. Central Administrative Tribunal, Chd And ORS

2025-08-06Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri9 pages



        

 

!"#$%#  " &"'  "()! "#*"+'

(,$ -"$. $ $"  /   

  1   " &"' 2"$ 3/(3'/ $"  /      



      

  

 "  "$"4$5(,)#"$/ "  

")$$ 5(,)# "$/ " 6



 "01 6 

"7$( "7$"!,)# ""/  6 

 ""/ 6 6



88888 

    !"#$  .9$"",55"/ ,(5$$$#+ !  +#,"+ --$"+$$/  #(# $ ! :'   (5   !("  1  $ /"  / , $(( -   "" 

;

<'"   / +9 $

  "( )! "# *"+'

(, $ -"$ . $ 

;

<'" 

& $ !/'-  "", $  "( )! "# ($:'$$( !+9$ (59$/ 7  (" 1 /"   /'"'   $ #"!  



<'") ,/95$$/(-;

$ //"+=  >"= #  ,"+ -"5 "!  

 "     + !   " $ "" //" $' $   .9 $ #"!   



<'" ) , 5$$ 5 "'( +9 $ # ( "

( ", 6"$"

(59, )!+(,  $ )!+( # , $ $ "=  -"?@-$" "=$/, /'9 $ "(  -", 7" /, @-$" "=$/, "=  -"? 2(=, -"", (59 (! *"+'

(, $ -"$, 5" = $ $ (-+(  5"= - '

"$+#!  ,5$$#$"( !   $ )!+(# "'

"$ "($/"'("#  //(9 "$5/7("1 /",5$$5"+(( "!$- "(-"9*$(-+(9  5"!   $ #"!  ( *$ / " $" , !(9 ! "#$ %#5$55"= -)!+(# 5(($"/  6  2"$  3/( 3'/, 5$ 5 5"= -  @-$" "=$/, 5$$ ( ! '

" $ )!+( # , //( " $ /  :'  2/ #5$"!$#"! ,$(

' 5     5"     $ "' 9  )

'(   ( "  5((  "# ""  $  5$//( " $ /   :'  )"  ' - $  /",  !" ( 5 /"/"+9$( '$"95$" , !"#$%#$# - '"

 !"= 5 /(  7"( 6    $ !" (  "/ 2"$ 3/(3'/,5/(7"(6;5$ A !"=

2/ -   #5 $ !" ( /"/", !!(9 $"'/ ,$/5"(('/+9//  -5/" "!$ !"( (' -$/ " !"#$%# ; )"/"//"<!(95 9"$( , $"/ ( "- ()//( )$(( - -$ (  /" " $ /   :'    // !   $ / " $"    $ -"'

 $ $ (  /" $ +  '   #(   $   ' +9 $ (59 ." 

AA;

<'") ,5$"$/("1 /" $+  "(B,$/$+(('

5  (9$ !/(95"= -@-$""=$/5"+"(-+(

.9$!/'- ""

;,$/"9" $"/ +"$*"+'

(5/ $(  $5  (' -$/ " $/ :' 5  $!"5"! +=""$// ! "!$ (-+(    /" $ (59 ."   

AA;

<'" ) , 5$$  '

" $(( -   $ /"  /  A *$( ($"#5/ 5$$(

 !+!

<'" ,5$$""$( + !/'-  $/" /  C"

'

(//" - +$($0  1  "-' $ 5$( / - $ !/'-  "" 

;, $ ($!" 5(($:' (!  /"#'

"$)! "#*"+'

(),A "$"DA )E /" -+"$*"+'

(  9  --"#  C"

 '

( " $ / " ! "#$ %# '+!$ $"/ 5--"#- $"! $#"! 

,$'($#$(( -$! 5$   /"    9"  $ '   $! 5$", # 5$  $ "- ( )//(  5 (   $ 9"

 , $  #"!  $  +  $(( - F , 5$' $" + -  $(( -$"!#"! ,$( ! $+ $ "!       $ #"!  '(  $# +    $"/"!"$ $"9"$'  $#"!  C"

 '

( //" -   +$(  $ / " ! "#$ %# '"$" '+! $ $ (  ( 5$$ $ + !/'- 5' $! $6#!+"

,$'-$5" -(9 !  

 $"- ()//( ,$!'($# ( +  !/'-  5$   /"    9" =/ -   #5 $ (! /"5$$5  +9$"/   C"

 '

( " $ / " "-' $ 5$' " -5$$""- ()//( (+9"/

( //( 55$ $(! /"#'

"7 A ),$"($+ -" 5$$5+9 $4'" $ ( C"

 '

( " $ / " '"$" "-' $ $ 

AA;$+ !//(+('/ $)!+( # ,5$"$5/7("1 /"< 5"+(('/ $ -$! ""$$/5$$ < $)!+(# 5"5$((9"/"((9 "(B   (( $ !  (9 "! $ !/(9 5$ " 5"= -  $ @-$" "=$/C"

 '

( "$/ "'+! $$ @-$""=$/(/"$)!+(#  $/ " ! "#$ %# 5( 5"= $ )!+( #    $ /5$$5"+(('/5"( $)!+(# F , - " -$$( $/ " ! "#$%#5 ""  ""9$ ""  C"

 '

( " $ / " ! "#$ %# '"$""-'$$ 

AA;

<'") $ + !//(+(5$'$"+ - 9#  ""$$ /7("1 /"5"@-$""=$/  $)!+(# F ,$!/'- ""5$$$+ / +9$*"+'

(5$' 9+$($$5/#" +( -@-$""=$/ (9 )!+(#    C"

'

(//" - +$($"/ //(  '+! $ " $ (    $ /   :' , $ !/(95"/@-$""=$/,$ ,$+ $ $ / <  @-$" "=$/ F , $   

AA;$"-$(9+ !//(+(+9$*"+'

(

, $(  "! $+=""$(  (9 :'$!/(95$$//("!$@-$""=$/ $#$"("

'

("$/" $#-  $"'-$$""5$$"+(  ;  ""  /   //(  ( +" $ *"+'

(, "$+  5$$",$!/"!+(+( =/ #5$' " $//( " )/" 7 A ),$"- ()//(   (9+(+" $"+'

(5$ /" 9"$' "' -  !/(95$/(-"# -  91 $/" ,$ #"!  5 ' +9 $ (59 ."   

 *$ + - , $  #"!  '( $# +  $(( - '/ 

  (9 *$ "/  6 //(  / $# - = 5(-,   "  9 -"#  -  $  #"!  5$ $(! /") $" +",# 5$(( -$ "- ()//( ,$#"! 

$ #"+ !/'-  >'"$", $ ( (   /'"'   $ #"!  

5/"/"

*$"/ //(  ((  9-"# :'$((5$ /"  9"# "!$F ,$-"# + -"+9$ "/ //( 5"":'"+4'-5$$" $!/"!+(=/ #57 A ) A C"

'

("$"/ //( $( $5$'"$$*"+'

(# $5$( ((5 -$/($"/ //( 

-

*$+ -, $-"# "+9$"/  6 //(  5  (9 +9   /"    9", $ ! '( $#+ #  " +9$*"+'

(=/ #5$ (! /"#'

"7 A ),$ , " - $ "- ( )//(  ( +9 $ "/  6 //(    $ 9"

  5$$ /"  !'$ +9   /"  (!     9"/"#'

"$),$"- ()//( 5(+(+ ! $-"'

(! (

 ) $ -, ("

 '

( " $ "/  6 //(  '+! $ $ !  = 5 +' $   

AA; (9 $9"



G# ,'!"$="-'! $$ "-'!   '((9 "", $  ( $ '( $#  (9 ( $ "- (//( +"$"+'

(( -5$ //( = -      (9 5$$ 5 #"   F , $ "- ( )//( 5/"!+9 $/"(!  #- '

"7 $) $"- ()//( '( $# +  " +9"+'

( !"

 )/" "! $,     4'  $ +     !",$'"":'"(= 5$$",$(!" +9 $ "/  6 //(  5 !  +( #   /" $ 

AA;" 

 1!9+ $$-"# "+9$"/  6 //( 5$5$"$"1 /"$+ 5$((9" /"((9  "(B $  $ (   $  /   +  ' '

 5 +9 /( - "(  '/    

+

AA; + -=/ ' 9("+95$$,$/ 5$$ 5" #"  (9 +( -  $ @-$" "=$/, ("

 '

("$"/ //( $($5 9'$#  +"'-$ "">'"$",$#"! 5$$+( , !=("$$/5")!+(#  @-$" "=$/ ) !   "(", $ @-$" "=$/ ( ! '

" $ )!+( #  F ,   $ / 5"  )!+( #  $!5"'(+"#"',

+ $$/5$$5"#"B5"@-$""=$/ (9    $ )!+( #  '

" 5$$,  (9 $ (  ,  $ / " ! "#$ %#  5((  $ "/  6 //(  5" 5"= - $' //" - $  ,$ 

AA;$+ !//(+(+9$ (, 5$$   "" 6   - $ +  "" $ $ #"! 

"($/@-$""=$/    $ )!+( #  $",  +" " -  $ #"! 

("$$/7(" /"5$)!+(#  $@-$""=$/  (9

C"

'

("$"/ //(   $$#"!  :'  $5$$/5"$ @-$" "=$/    )!+( #  >'"$",  !9 +

 $ (( $ #"!     + -  ""9  $ 

AA;,$( 5$$5! /'"'  $#"! 



+)+"/"'( $!/'- ""/5'($5$$#"! 

.

$ + ,"$"," 5-# != "$( '

"$!#"!  ,$+ $($ $#"! 

"($/7(" /"   )!+( #    5"   @-$" "=$/, $ ( //"$""(9"$$ (' $ $ (  5 +   5 #" +9 $   

AA;2/ #5$+#,$""/+9$*"+' ( 

;

<'"    /"#"  $  +"'-$  ""  5((   $ /"#   $ )   $ , 

 + '     " -(9,  *$ ( / " ! "#$ %# 5(( + "   #( (    $   "'! $

*$5"/ "" -(9((5

; ) $ -, ("

 '

( " $ "/  6 //( '+!$ $( $+ $(+#(  (9 /5(( $ /$ + (('/,(+"9 +-# #(//"/""!9(!$ / $ //( (-+((!/"$!""!  $#(9 $((

""" -(9

A )/$/9$""+/( $

(  

   $     

$    $$"/= -?"  % 6 $$" /"+( % 6