Lt Col Ashok Bembey v. Punjab State Electricity Regulatory Commission And Another
!
"#!
$%"& '()'* !!!
' + +",'- .$!
/,01) 2 1 '
#'3 -+3+ * '4/#1 "-* "((+$$+", 1,5 1," %'- !!!
'$6",5', $ '$'-7'5 ",8 !
!
-","/,3'5 ",8 !
!
6#"15'5 ",8 !
!
8 9
!
2
!"#
$$$$$$$
:
!
# %%&'%%( ) * + , -.
&/0 %&1+
2
+" + 2# +3 45 ;
, 7 +#2 8 " * 2 ) 9
: .(; %;
..(
! , * < 82#
<
)
.'%
%---/0
1 "# 70 ) ! ! = "# + > + +2
! 2 ! / ? 1 +
)
%4 -% %--%/0 %1 >
" 2 -@ -;
%--%
++ -;
-;
@ >
-;
-;
@/0 @1 +
# 20 # 0
%;
-
..%/0 A1#2
"#+ "#)8< ** >
2+2 #
< 2++"#2
-.
&/0 %&1 ? +
;
> +
# + 2#2
) -@ -;
%--% -;
-;
@ %2 +
* "#< 70 < .4%#2 "# -% -%
.4%/0
1 70 #28 + 2 B
CD 2 2 #2<(
.
"#)8</ B)8<C1+<(
( 2 #B 2 2 2 CD<;
% )8< +
2 -2 , + + ) -@ -;
%--% -;
-;
@ > #
2 )8 < + %;
-
..%/0<
'.1#2
"# %2#2 <+ " #2)
!" #2? C#8 )
"
#
# $%%
% @
> # 2 ;-
%--4#2 # +
A42 ? + ) -;
-;
@
2 # 2
#2 &;2 E+ # %@
%-%A ? "#872 < 2) /
8) 7 21 < %- %-A
%/0 %(1 +#2+ 2 2+ -A2 &;2# + 2<&
&) 2 2+ # 2+ %2 2 D #+ ..2#
-
-% &/0
(1 >%- 2 +F#2 2+2 # ;--2 ;-
%--4 *2%- ;
0 * ;42/%( -% ; -A -@ ;1<4
;;
= )8< =+ ) %2 #2 2# 2 4-2
#
"# 8 72 < 2 ) + 2# 2 8 ( 72< 2 ) .44++# #272%--;
#
)
+ #2 "#
? + %A -
%-- #2D !
) %;
-.
%--%
4@
2 .;
+ *# ' +
>
# 2 #
2 > +
"#870 ) 2# 2 2 #2
%4 -% %--%/0 %1
+2 2+ + # 2 * + #2 >
2 +0 2 -@ -;
%--( ,
&
D # -@ -;
%
( -% % 0 #2 + 2 )= ;;@4 % %;
-% %
) + + + # 0 2 -@ -;
2
) 0 2 -A -;
%/0<
'%1 8#,2
( -% %+"
.
-@ %/0<
';1 ? + + + %;
-%
#2) ++ # -4 -A
(
> & -A %/0<
'@1
+ 0 -%2 # #2 2 ( -A %/0<
'A1 2 + 0 + 2 -@ -;
@ 62 ++)= ;;@4 % #2 %4 -A %/0<
'&1 -;
-;
@ /0<
'(1
)
! 2
! / 81 # +
-A -;
@ 0 < 4----'
2+ +! +# 2# 2+ # + >
# +
$ & "'(() *+
! " #$% %%%&'
(
( (
) * ( +
( , -&./0
( ( (
( 1
D %@
A
8
< + ++ +
) 2+ #
< &/1 # 2 # #2 &A2 8 2&A 2 # %@
.
D 2 + 0 # # 2+#2*2 +#2
> %;
-
..% #+ 2 %--% - ? +0 2 + 2 0 >8 #%- - 2+ # 0 2
) /#1 %;
-
..% >
+ G/#1 %;
-
..%# +2 +
) 2 # 2'0
> ,
"# 2 #2 + # # 2+ /0 <
'
- 21
-
8 + + + 2
/H71"#H6 >
)+
+ 2 #
) -@ -
& /0<
'
%1 ? ++ +, 2 + -22#
C 2 -&
2 + 2
? ;-
%--4+
A4 2 * -
-% & /0<
'
;1 #
2 + %@
( /0 <
'
@1 ! + "# %;
-
..%
# <
)
"#
(/0<
'
A1 2
2 2 ++ + .
-
4/0<
'
&1
I # ;-
.A- 2 "#A42+ ;-
%--% > 2# 2-&2-4 %&2 ;-
%--4#
)
2 < + + ##2 J #2 )=
;4 ( &# ) ++
-( &/0 %A1+
#2 2
+"#2 -.
&/0 %&1 +
<% @/1 )8<2 +
2 #2 2
+ D< ;
% )8 < , 2 # #
+
2 2+ # 2 8 +
-2 # A42 2 2# 2. 2
?
+#
70 + ) 9
* 2 %;
..( 8#,2
2 +
! 2 ! / ? 1
)
%4 -% %--%/0 %1 > 2
++-;
-;
@ ++
# #2 0 @ > 2
#2 # 2+
;
* 2 # # #2 2 # '
*+ # 2 #) 2 2
# :G ? C#8 )
,"
-
. # /0 ( -%23%%4$%$%
+
23 4 5 / 7
,
#
*
(# *
*#5(
# ## 6 ( & .1 *"
55( * (( &"
*
.
(
"5
5" 7
( #
*
8 .
0
.
1 .
"#
5 * 5(6
& " **
(
& 5( *1 *) /
( /7
1 / 1
@
9 + + #2 # 2
#2 * + 2
,2 2 ## 2 2 #
2 # #2 2 2 /1#
/#1##,2F/1,
# )2 #2 2 # # + , F
# +
2
0 # 2 > * 2+ 2+
2 2#
I 2
) + # #2
2 # " #2+ :G ? C#8 ) 9 ") &
", *
( ", *'*
90 ('55 (- 2 $%$% %& -( %-%@ + : ++
89) / :
( 5( 5 * *(
#"(&)
5# ("
(1 ( * #:
<
4.
(
( 1
> +
+
%4 -% %--%/0 %1+ +
2# - 2 > # +
. ;# *
+ + <
' 5=
#;
2%%23%%3
+ + <
5 >
' ' ?#/
((&
5 " & (
55 # 5(&
#5 & "&1 ** #
"
&
# (
+. + <
5=
:
)
55 * 0
# 1
&
D #2 )8<
? + )8<+ #2
2 +
# ) )=
;4 ( &+
-( &/0 %A1+ 2
#2 )8< 2
# > +
0 ( (>
+ + <
5>
( . ? # / ?
# / * 2@@$5 8%223%%$. # )
/ . #
8)1
*(
)
;(* *
& .(
&0##
"5 "
0 ( 1 * (& 5* *" : (
( *!'3A (
) >( (
1 / 1
(
> "#872 < 2) /
8) 7 21 < %- %/0 %(1# + 2
G2 2 2
62 "# "#872 < 2) /
8) 7 21
= < %- A %@
A/0<
'
41++ #
# #2 ) /1
) @ +
2 /1
) 2 2# 2 #
# 2 # # +
) 2)& 2 &A2
+ + ? +
##2, 2 #
> #2 , ##2 %;
-
..%/0<
'.1+ # #2
+ 2# 2
)
"# * %@
( /0<
'
@1 + ## %;
-
..%/0<
'.1 > %@
( /0<
'
@1 # +
: -
+
B3$C@2'4::&$A2
38%22@@3 . *>D 1
.
#2
) 2 +2 # /0<
'
;1
#2 "# :
)8<
#
); <&
&) 2 #
2 2 <(
. 2
0 2+2
+
+ 0 2 #
2 C
# #"#+2 +2 # ++
2+ 2 I2<;
% + #2 + D 2 < ;
% # +
823) - ,
( ;E E) -
.E:
#5(&# #
1 "
5# ) E)
- ) !
( E), (
,
( ( ( F , ',
( 1
/0 %1
#2+
2 2 D <;
% + 2+ +, 2 + ##2
#+ #
#
2 2# #2 # 2
82 +++ + 2 2+ #2
>0 + 0 # 2#2 2 #2
2 2# +
#
> > + 2 # -2 2
%%
*+ # 2
) 2
%;
>
/1 2
@
-% -% %-%& = ' J'
= # J'