High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21402/2014allowed

Ram Kumar v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ORS.

2015-08-27Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

"#$%#"&'($&)'*"("(

+,),)(+& +&'%'

()(+&&),&- *"(.)/"&*"(.,*+&'

+'0(.+(,'

1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2

3 1

3 1 &+'+(,

&+'+(,

1& $"%&*"(. )(/5" .67",+&,*+0+,),)(+& 1& $"0)5$"88"& .67",+9),* 1&

"6:, )(/* .67",+&,*+&+'0(.+(,'

;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< 5")#,*+0+,),)(+&&"55,#+(,"=%)5,%0=,* 9"' &+:+7,+. 6).+ &.+& .",+. 0"''+. =- ,*+ ',",+

)7+& ()(+&&),&- *"(.)/"&* &+'0(.+(, 00+"5 0&++&&+.=-,*+0+,),)(+&"/")(',,*+&.+&&+:+7,)(*"'=++( .)'#)''+.=-,*+*)+.#)()',&",& &+'0(.+(, 6).+&.+& .",+.> ?

6+("&+6)')(0+,),)()5+.=-,*+0+,),)(+& *"' =++( .)'#)''+. =- ,*+ .6)'& , ,*+ .#)()',&",&2 &+'0(.+(, )(,*+5)/*,&.+&.",+.> *+)(',"(,9&),0+,),)(*"'=++()5+.)#0%/()(/,*+ "&+2(,)7+.,*&++&.+&'"(."00+(.+."'((+@%&+' "(. ?&+'0+7,)6+5-

+,),)(+&)'',",+.,*"6+=++(+(/"/+.)("'#"55 ,)#+ 8)&-"(" =%')(+'' )( ,*+ +*&) 1"&8+, +7,& 2 *"(.)/"&*')(7+ >A3'

+9"')''%+.""(."&,)7+(7+ BCDE>!=+"&)(/&+/)',&",)( "(.9"'"55,,+.'),+

?!)():9"&"+*&)1"&8+, +7,&2 *"(.)/"&*)(,*+ -+"&>A *+*"(.)/"&*.#)()',&",)(&"#+."'7*+#+& '+,,5+#+(,"(.&+*"=)5),",)(+*&)9&8+&'"(.,*+'"#+,8 "&#"5'*"0+)(,+&#'%5+'*"6)(/=++(&"#+.7"55+.,*+ F55,#+(,G&"('+&=%)5,%0=,*')("(- +7,&(5+"'+G*)&+ 0%&7*"'+ ="')' )( *"(.)/"&* %5+' >> B*+&+)(",+& , =+ &++&&+."'F>>%5+'HC (+7+#=+& "0%=5)7(,)7+9"'

/, 0%=5)'*+. )(6),)(/ "005)7",)(' &# &+/)',+&+. "(. "&, )7+(7+ *5.+&' +*&) 1"&8+, +7,& 2 *"(.)/"&* & "55,#+(,=%)5,%0=,*'(7(7+'')("5&",+' *+0+,),)(+& '%=#),,+. "( "005)7",)( "5(/ 9),* ,*+ &+I%)'),+ '%00&,)(/ .7%#+(,'

9+6+& 75")#,*+0+,),)(+&*"'=++(&+:+7,+. 6).+)#0%/(+.&.+&.",+. 0"''+.=-&+'0(.+(, ((+@%&+ %7*&.+&*"'=++(")&#+.=-,*+"00+55",+"(. &+6)')("5"%,*&),)+'

+*"6+*+"&.5+"&(+.7%('+5&,*+0"&,)+' *+="')'&+:+7,)(,*+75")#,*+0+,),)(+&& "55,#+(,"=%)5,%0=,*)'.)'7+&()=5+&#,*+)#0%/(+. &.+&.",+. ((+@%&+ 9*+&+)(),*"'=++(='+&6+. ,*",,*+'),+,*+"005)7"(,9"'/,)('0+7,+.,*&%/*+*')5."& BC ( !

"(. ?

"(. ,*+ &+0&, *". =++( '%=#),,+.,*",",,*+,)#+'%7*)('0+7,)('+6+(,*%/*,*+

'*09"'%(.0+( =%,,*+0+,),)(+& ("#+5- "#$%#"&9"' (,%(.0&+'+(,"(. (,*+,*+&*"(. (+":$%#"& )(/5"

9"'%(.0&+'+(,",,*+'),+"(.9*)7* )(,%&( *"'7&+",+." 3.%=,3,*",,*+'),+*"'=++(/)6+((&+(,,'%7*0+&'() + ":

$%#"& )(/5"

5(/ 9),* ,*+ &+05- )5+. ( =+*"5 ,*+ &+'0(.+(, &+0&,,*+ +*')5."&BC.",+.E

*"'

=++("00+(.+."'((+@%&+!

+&%'"5'%7*&+0&,9%5.

'*9,*",,*++*')5."&*".#".+,9'%&0&)'+)('0+7,)(') + ( !

"(.?

9*+&+%0(,*+0&+'+(,0+,),)(+&*".

(,=++(%(.0&+'+(,",'),+ ?! +*&)1"&8+, 9*+&+"'(+ ":$%#"& )(/5"9"'%(.",,*+'),+ ,9"'%&,*+&&+0&,+.

,*",1& ":$%#"& )(/5"9"'"5'"5)7+('++,*+'"#++*&) 1"&8+,"(.*"."5&+".-=++("55,,+."=%)5,%0=,*)( +7,& 2 *"(.)/"&*)(5)+%*)'"(."&,)7+(7+ ,)'.))7%5,&%',"77+0,,*+&+"'()(/".0,+.=- &+'0(.+(, ?9*+&+=-#+&+5-("77%(,(+":$%#"&

)(/5" *"6)(/ =++( %(. 0&+'+(, ( ,*+ '),+ "55,,+. , ,*+ 0+,),)(+& "7(75%')(*"'=++(.&"9(,*",,*+'),+*"'=++( /)6+((&+(,,*)#) + ":$%#"& )(/5"

("0)(,+.I%+&- *"6)(/ =++( 0%, , ,*+ 5+"&(+. 7%('+5 "00+"&)(/ & ,*+ &+'0(.+(,' ),*"'=++(7(7+.+.,*",+6+(,*%/*":$%#"&

)(/5" *". =++( %(. 0&+'+(, .%&)(/ ,*+ ,9 '%&0&)'+ )('0+7,)(' -+,*)'',",+#+(,9"'(,&+7&.+. ,*"'"5'/(+ %(7(,&6+&,+. ,*", ,*+ +*')5."& .%&)(/ ,*+ 7%&'+ '%7* '%&0&)'+ )('0+7,)(' *"' 7*'+( (, , +6+( &+7&. ,*+ ',",+#+(,',*+".:)()(/'),+*5.+&'

6+(,*+7#0+,+(, "%,*&),-) + ,*+ ',",+ )7+& ()(+&&),&- *"(.)/"&**"'

%(.+.,*+)#0%/(+.&+:+7,)(&.+&#+&+5-("3.%=,3,*", ,*+ '),+ )( I%+',)( *"' =++( /)6+( ( &+(, , 1& ": $%#"&

)(/5"

+9%5.*"6+(*+'),",)()(*5.)(/,*",,*+&+"'()(/ ".0,+.)'9*)#')7"5 *+&+0&,'%=#),,+.=-,*++*')5."&",+&7(.%7,)(/ '%&0&)'+)('0+7,)('*".75+"&5-',",+.,*",1& ":$%#"& )(/5"

*". "5&+".- =++( "55,,+. " =%)5, %0 =,* )( +7,& *"(.)/"&* +'0(.+(, ? *"' 7*'+( , )/(&+ '%7* #",+&)"5"7,9*)5++(,+&,")()(/,*+3.%=,3,*",":$%#"& )(/5"

*".=++()(.%7,+."'",+("(,=-,*+0+,),)(+&(,*+'),+)( I%+',)( *+ &.+&' 0"''+. =- ,*+ "00+55",+ "(. &+6)')("5 "%,*&),)+''%+&&#,*+'"#+6+&-)()&#),-"(.*"6+=++( 0"''+.)("&%,)(+"(.#+7*"()7"5"'*)(

6+(,*+&9)'+ ,*++5)/)=)5),-""(."&,)7+(7+ *5.+&&0%&0'+'"55,#+(,"=%)5,%0=,*)'/6+&(+. %(.+&%5+!>>%5+'"(.,*+'"#+&+".'"'559'

5)/)=)5),-

5)/)=)5),- 2*+7#0+,+(,"%,*&),-#"-"55,"

=%)5,%0=,*)(,*+#"&8+,)("(-'+7,&,"0+&'( ) "C + *5.' " 6"5). *"(. 7"&, 5)7+(7+ "' 9+55 "' " .&)6)(/5)7+(7+"(.9('"*"(.7"&,(,*+.",+ )''%+ ,*+ (,))7",)( & ,*+ .",+ "' #"- =+ 0&+'7&)=+.&,*+0%&0'+'

=C+.+'(,9("7##+&7)"5'),+G'*0)(()( +&&),&-*"(.)/"&* 1*"5)& "(7*8%5")(*)'9( ("#+&)(,*+("#+"(- #+#=+&*)'"#)5- .+0+(.+(,%0(*)#"(.,*+,,"5"#)5-)(7#+&#

"55 '%&7+' .+' (, +@7++. J!G2 0+& #+('%# B%0++' +6+(,*%'"(."(.)6+*%(.&+.(5-C& 9*)7* *+ '*"55 *"6+ , %&()'* "( ")."6), .%5- ",,+',+.=-,*+ @+7%,)6+1"/)',&",+ *"(.)/"&*, ,*)'++7, 7C+.+'(,'%+&&#"(-7(,"/)%'.)'+"'+& 9*)7**+'*"55%&()'*"#+.)7"57+&,))7",+),(+'' H +)(.,*",)(,*+)#0%/(+.&.+&' ((+@%&+' , ?"'"5')(,*+9&),,+(',",+#+(, ()''%+*"'=++(&")'+."' &+/"&.' ,*+ 0+,),)(+& =+)(/ (, +5)/)=5+ *+ =:+7,)6+ "(.

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

+& ,*+ 55,#+(,G&"('+&=%)5,%0=,*')("(- +7,&(5+"'+G*)&+ 0%&7*"'+="')')(*"(.)/"&*%5+' >>"(.",,*+7(7+'')("5 &",+ +I%)'),+&.+&')('%7*&+/"&.=+)''%+.9),*)("0+&). %&9++8'&#,*+.",+&+7+)0,"7+&,))+.70-,*)' &.+& ,)' *9+6+& #".+75+"&,*",,*+=+(+),,*)'&.

'*"55 +(%&+ , ,*+ 0+,),)(+& (5- %0( *)# %&()'*)(/ "( %(.+&,"8)(/,*",,*+=%)5,%0=,*'"55,,+.9%5.=+%,)5)K+. =- *)# & 7"&&-)(/ ( ,*+ 8)&-"(" =%')(+'' & "(- ,*+& 0+&#)'')=5+/+(+&"5,&".+"(.*+9%5.(,)(.%7,"(-,+("(,)( ,*+0&+#)'+'

+,),)()'"559+.)(,*+"&+'").,+&#'

4C B

4C B C B C B C B C

*+,*+&&++&&+.,+0&,+&LB +'G C *+,*+&&++&&+.,+0&,+&LB +'G C *+,*+&&++&&+.,+0&,+&LB +'G C *+,*+&&++&&+.,+0&,+&LB +'G C